Jennifer Hudson Vs Fantasia, I like Them Both

[lilseaxydee]

FANTASIA ALL DAY

[roxybadalutei]

jaclyn victor..

[mjfan4life94]

I choose Fantasia. I can just relate to Fantasia and feel the soul from her, Jennifer is too commercial for me.

[MsKateRoberts]

@mjfan4life94 Too commercial? More like too classy for you. Please you are in denial Jennifer is clearly better than that manly sounding Fantasia with her manly vocals.

[spierce100]

Imma have to go with...hmmm JHUD!

[hotboip24]

more power and range, jennifer.....more control, and technique...fantasia

[lilseaxydee]

I MUST SAY FANTASIA WILL BLOW JENNIFER HUDSON OUT THE WATER BUT JENNIFER HUDSON WILL OUT SELL FANTASIA ANY DAY JENNIFER HUDSON IS A CROSS OVER ARIST AND FANTASIA FANS WONT EVEN BUY HER ABLUM SUCH A SHAME FANTASIA FANS NEED TO STEP UP TO HELP HER OUT BECAUSE SHE HAS THE MUSIC ITS JUST FANTASIA FANS SLACKING BUY A COPY OF HER NEW ABLUM BACK TO ME IF YOU HAVENT AND U CALL YOURSELF A FAN

[16ondablack]

@lilseaxydee fantasias albumn is great and its doing well on the other hand i didnt like jenn's 1st album i thought it was wack fantasias 2nd album was a flop but i luv free urself and this new album FIRE u cn litterally listen all the way through but its really dosnt say anything about them bcuz neither 1 of them write theire music btw im 4 tasia all day but i really do lov jenn

[tdbrown88tdb]

i luv em both they're both gifted

[meldiesel1]

WELL THIS IS AN UNSTOPPABLE ARGRUMENT...IN MY OPINION IT DOESNT MATTER WHO CAN SING BETER...ONE IS CLEARLY MORE SUCCESSFUL AND THATS WHO WINS !!!

[lilseaxydee]

I SAY FANTASIA

[gangstachcolate]

i think they are both good honestly . Jenifer has that strong but sweet voice and tasia has that light sweet raspy voice i think there both good

[sjerome11]

i am going to go with Jennifer Hudson on this one . i like Fantasia but sometime she just screams and JENNIFER HUDSON is the best !

[tdbrown88tdb]

shit they both can sang jennifer got that soulful voice and fantasia got that southern soulful grits voice

[jayromeb]

I love fantasia!!!!!!!!

[2554432]

cant choose, but if i reaallly reaalllly had to, i would pic jen

[darrelwood]

I feel like these audio samples are a little biased. I've heard Fantasia sing way better than in the songs chosen, like her performance for Patti LaBelle at UNCF

They both have incredible, but very different voices. The best two singers to come out of American Idol by far.

[ajnatheiconoclast]

you had to make this even more difficult didn't you....this is wrong. I would have to split the award right down the middle. They are both superb vocalists!

[deontasia]

I lke both but i have 2 give it 2 FANTASIA!!!!

[getmeacheezecakeplz]

One of THE hardest vocal decisions

[MsMadie3]

They can blow, only diff is Fantasia is raspy and Jennifer isnt raspy AT ALL!

[jaderrw]

Love em both.

[Chillumpot]

JHUD!!!!

[moesalim88]

Jen is amazing

[nikkidabest812]

well both jenn and fantasias voices are so powerful. fantasias voice is unique, but jenn has a smoother tone. honestly i really dont care, cause if there albums came out on the same day i will buy both, as long as the singles are good

[WazUpN04]

Fantasia has one of the best voices of this generation. Jennifer Hudson would be good if she'd learn how to build up a song.

[MosaicMaiden]

I understand you! They are both brilliant singers I would not not compare they have 2 different tones. its up to the individual as to whether they like a deeper or a higher voice.

Both of them have bought me to tears, bless their talent!

Thank you for sharing!

[ladyjmk20]

no way i can choice

[japrphilly]

they both can sing their asses off but i love them both for other reasons

[xhotgyalx1]

both of them are gd singers

[larrissa74]

Both can blow I like both of them but Fantasia can sing mary had alittle lamb and make wanna run down the asile like you in church. Watch the video of Im his Only Woman ,Jennifer cant mess with Tasia live sorry!!! I But I love Jennifers Spotlight song.

[twistalookalike]

i love hudson but its easy to compare her to people. fantasia dosent sound like no one but her self.

[Eric407851]

jennifer has a more powerful voice than tasia. but tasia has stage presence n she puts emotion into everything she sings. both of them can sing but jennifer isn't gud with hiting low notes but wen it comes to hight notes the girl can blow. but tasia can go from high notes n low notes jus like that without takin in breaths like jennifer to get to the next note. i've watch both of them perform n i say dat fantasia has it.

[blkbeautie19]

BOTH

[brooklyntrail]

I like both singers but I have to go with Fantasia. She is unique and her stage presence is unique.

[XShanyLiyahJenniferX]

Fantasia has control over her voice. I love Jhud's tone more though.

[blackbeautyanddiva]

jennifer guuurrrlllll!!!!! i love you and all, but fantasia wins this won. to be a great singer, not only do you have to know how to sing but the stage presence needs to be there. the emotions need to be there. the desire needs to be there. the showmanship needs to be there. fantasia has all of the above and listening to jennifer is cool, BUT watching her perform is like watching gum slide down a wall, DULL and BORING

[justcrystalle]

i cant stand neither one of they hollerin asses

[jaaja477]

Hello why are you watching their video?are you jealous that you cant sing?

[inodeathflower888]

watch?v=Ika9pM-Shf4

Jennifer doesn't scream all the time, she screams when she loses control, for a while now, she hasn't lost her control because she's been working on her control, now she's much surperior too Tasia

[acirema82]

I love them both but honestly Jennifer leaves Fantiasia in the dust when it comes to singing and acting!!! Jennifer hudson peekin at Fantiasia in her rear veiw mirror LOL

[NorthernStar2187]

I love Fanny sooo much! She has the tendency to scream, BUT she almost NEVER falls of key and it works with the framework of the songs. When Jennifer screams, she loses her pitch! FANTASIA WINS FOR ME.. .Jennifer has a good voice tho.

[Shello16one]

Are you guys tone deaf? How the f*ck can you say Fantasia is better than Jennifer? Fantasia is like a squeeking guinea pig. J-hud is The Voice.

[jaaja477]

ya mother

[Mehrunissah93]

Fantasia wins. Jennifer's voice is so common. Both of them scream a bit much though.

Vocals: Fantasia by FARRRR

Acting: Jennifer Hudson

Lyrics: Tie

[belvedeeralize]

jenifer duhhhhh

[malcolmjs1993]

jennifer won but it was tough call

[mylast1stkiss]

Im kinda feelin that jennifer hudson song before when i see you....where can i find it?

[Isaiahinger]

it"s call stand up

[lilseaxydee]

fantasia killing jeniffer

[jaaja477]

hell yea

[csasbaby]

fantasisa two natinal anthum

[MissSabrinaD]

Tasia is just too much for the RECORD EXECS sometimes.. shes a crowd pleaser... Jen is a perfect mix of both... she has a crowd pleasing voice while still maintaining that professional voice...

[MzRidikuluz]

Fantasia Duh!

[belvedeeralize]

jennifer wins this one so0o0ry

[blksung]

I refuse to get into this debate. THEY ARE FRIENDS, so it doesnt matter. But I'm responding because I NEED to know whats the name of that song at 1:20. Its not onJHuds album. Just that little snippet sounds great.

[belvedeeralize]

its called stand up

[G5R9E2G7]

JHUD

[cstewar2]

Tasia is a better performer, and I have never seen her give a live performance where she was offbeat, out tune, or missed a note....That is the true test of Great singer! While J-hud does have the POTENTIAL to be great, she is not using her voice to make herself Great! I have seen some of J-hud's live performances, and: they are boring, unemotional, and it sometimes she doesn't project to me and probably the audience that she really loves singing. They seems like contrived Broadway performances.

[inodeathflower888]

Oh, I'm sorry. You like daffy duck, right? She screeches and screams, has no range whatsoever? The only thing Tasia has beat on Jennifer is soul/emotion. They both put soo much soul into her voice.

[cstewar2]

Fantasia is the Best! She didn't win A.I. for nothing. I like J-Hud but she doesn't compare to Aretha nor Patti, who have both admire Fantasia as a performer. I think she could stand to learn a thing or two from Tasia. When J-hud did that tribute to Aretha, Aretha didn't even crack a smile, but when Fantasia got up there, Aretha was nodding and smiling.....So you tell me who's better? The Queen herself gave props to Tasia!

[dfjkslsdfjkl]

Fantasia, she has such an evocative tone of voice reminiscent of past eras and yet it retains a contemporary tastefulness. She has the innate ability to turn whatever song she touches into heart-wrenching, soul-searing greatness. Her vocal stylings and artistry are untouchable and she's in a league of her own. Sorry Jenn fans. I love her but she's no Fantasia....it's not all about belting out notes....

[Alona2178]

Jennifer Hudson

[Lgh45]

Fantasia

[aikalo87]

JENNIFER HUDSON is WAAAY better... FANTASIA sings out of her nose and it's annoying.....

[sniperjeggae]

you dont know nothing about singing fantasia sing from the heart and she sings with passion

[prentoe]

i have 2 agree, jennifer hudson is better, and she cums out with more music.

[DAlmond123]

J-HuD!! All the WAY!!

[nosugref117]

I would have to say FANTASIA!! Fantasia's range has grown and she does have better showmanship..

[dangelomister]

fantaisa beat jennifer hudson on american idol that enough we already know who is best lol fantaisa i dont know if you knew tha but its true taisa all ready beat jennifer hudson

[crownrecords15]

F A N T A S I A!!!!!!!!

[artsumet]

i like jennifer hudson. I want to ask some question.

Who know the name of the last song of this video ? tell me please. thank you very much

[Isaiahinger]

it call to love somebody

[welovesjs]

Fantasia

[creamytu]

definitivamente me kedo con JENNIFER HUDSON es la mejor

[deechild908]

I think they are both awesome talents, but Fantasia has an edge. When she sings, it doesn't just sound good...it feels good. This one goes to Tasia!

[larriale]

jennifer hudson!

[dfjkslsdfjkl]

Fantasia hands down. Jennifer can sing but she can't touch the audience on an emotional level like Fantasia can.

[inodeathflower888]

Oh really? Well, I guess that's why they choose Jennifer over Fantasia in dream girls.

[dfjkslsdfjkl]

i believe jennifer was chosen because she is more befitting to the character of effie both physically and vocally. I'm not trying to demean jenn in any way, but tasia is the better performer...

[MsKateRoberts]

@dfjkslsdfjkl You must be deaf and dumb. Jennifer Hudson is a way better singer than Fantasia. What is wrong with you? Fantasia cannot hit them notes like Jennifer. You are so delusional. Better make an appointment to see the ear doctor because you might be losing your hearing.

[mujaahid123456]

darkchilddiva u a stupid hoe i wonder wut u stupid ass look like u probrably look a pitbull walkin backwards hoe

[belvedeeralize]

r u talkin bout me

[belvedeeralize]

jennifer has the full package

[terrenceakatko]

You know DarkChildDiva, or what ever the fuck you wanna be called, I'M SICK OF YOU AND YO MOUTH !!! Fantasia has was majority of the music industry nowa days lack, SOUL !!! When ever she opens her mouth to sing, she touches another heart. She could make a whole church and the church down the street shout. So you go rethink your statements because they make no sense. Apparently you're just a hater who has too much time on his or her time. Go be a dumb ass and buy more cds you know you'll hate.

[terrenceakatko]

CLEARLY you must be the deaf one !!! Fantasia Monique Barrino is the SHIT !! True enough Jennifer Hudson has a powerful voice, but a powerful voice is NOTHING without soul. Whoever made this video put all the good parts of Jennifer Hudson's song on here, but put the not so good parts of Fantasia's song on here. If you need, i will GRATEFULLY make a better version.

[ateeino]

Obviously you know nothing about music and vocals so I am not even going to go there with you. If she couldn't sing then she would not have been chosen by Oprah Winfrey to be in a broadway musical in case you haven't notice you have to be able to sing to be on broadway! Matter fact let's hear you sing some of her songs. Just ignorant!

[frenchhornguy123]

she can sing but range is not her friend and she lost her job on BROADWAY!!!

[ateeino]

She has a big enough range and she also can do a lot with her voice. She had to leave Broadwway because she got sick with a tumor on her throat. While she was performing she could feel blood oozing from her throat so she had to have surgery. When she left Broadway so did the sales and that's why they ended the Color Purple sooner than expected.

[frenchhornguy123]

no she was fired for missing alot of dates!!! If that was true they would of worked with her not ended her contract!!! I didnt say she can sing she just doesent due what i think she can and should np point in being able to do somethig if you anit gonna do it

[GirlSoCrazy]

You really need to stop relying on internet articles for your information, because fantasia was not fired from broadway. Her contract ended. Do you know the difference between being fired from leaving on your own because the amount of time you signed to do a show has ended???

Fantasia renewed her contract to january because it originally ended in October 07. the demand for her was so high that Oprah offered her an extened stay until jan 08.

[fiestymike]

frenchhorndud, she was not fired. Her contract ended Jan 6, 2008. I was at that show. The play ended, as was said, when Chaka and BeBe Winans couldn't pull in the crowds after she left. You really need to get out more and stay away from the blogs as your source of news. You sound ignorant to those who know the facts. Base your dislike on something else. Tasia has range. Watch the Patti LaBelle tribute in Jan. Educate yourself.

[fiestymike]

ateeino, they discovered the tumor after her Broadway contract ended. She honored her contracted time. Soon after that, after Clive Davis' Pre-Grammy show they found it, she had the operation and was ordered not speak for six wks.

[welovesjs]

OK.... if you know she lost her job on broadway why was she selected to do the color purple film based on broadway? I don't even have to say you're dumb.

[LoveMalique]

jenifer hudson beet fantasia in dreamgirls and jamie foxx was madd but jen hands down...and prayers to her familey esppecially the baby boy

[QueenEgypt718]

fantasia screams and has an annoying voice but performs better, jennifer sounds better but, I dont think she is that versitle, she needs to do a gospel CD and stick to acting.

[bladeworm]

Fantasia is a better performer. I have seen her in "In the Color Purple" and have seen her in concert twice and she does not disappoint. I think both ladies are talented but, Fantasia just out performs Jennifer. Both have amazing voices.

[legalhustla2009]

Yeah Jennifer has amazing power behind her voice but I'm not sure if she knows how to connect her feelings into the song. Fantasia will make you cry... so for that reason, she's the better singer.

[shojo95]

Is there really a competition. Jennifer is amazing! That girl's voice is all her own, she's absolutely amazing.

[muzikbox420]

I love them both, but if I was to choose, I would pick Fantasia becaus I loved her since day 1 and that voice is just outstanding!!!!

I wish them both the best of luck because they're both talented as hell!!!!!!!

[belvedeeralize]

wow r u serious jenifer hands down but fantasia just yells da hole tyme r u serious

[ateeino]

FANTASIA, FANTASIA, FANTASIA, and did I say FANTASIA!!!!!!!!!

[belvedeeralize]

bes erious jennifer wuld blow her out da wata any day cum on

[freakyblkboi]

Fantasia anyday, fantasia is the best

[dusroots]

Fantasia all the way!! She is jus is a better singer and I would luv 2 hear her sing "And I am telling u" I bet she would've put all kinds of stank on that song. I like Jen's power though

[drphd5]

Are Yall serious about this one? Fantasia is on course to be a legend(both Aretha and Patti agreed). Jennifer is good but she is terrible in a live concert. I seen her twice in concert and was absolutely disappointed.

[Blakmajik78]

Both of those girls are bad as hell, Jennifer has more range and powerful but Fantasia voice is versatile and her voice is unique. Fantasia also has more showmanship on the stage..thats why she beat Jennifer on American Idol. Jennifer can clearly outsing her on ballads, but Fantasia can outsing her on uptempo songs. Like I say...it depends on the day lol cuz both of them wainches can sing...they've both outsang each other b4...I love em both! Both of em need shoes thrown at em! Its a draw!

[kenzosin]

Hahaha! Agree with you, mate! Both are fantastic in their own ways. Fantasia has superb stage presence. Jennifer Hudson pierced you right through your heart with her rendition of any songs with all her heart and soul. Both are champions! Just dont throw shoes at them please. You can throw all your properties to them though. Hahaha!

[lexilex96]

Blakmajik you are killing me bad cuz you are sooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­ooooooooooooooo right! Not sure about the range thing tho. Jen just likes to demonstrate hers more. Fan makes me cry! She has soooo much emotion and soul I cry dam near every time she sings and Jen I just wanna shout but never cry. Sorry but Ms Barrino has something NO ONE else has. She has Soul Magic!

[lastnite07]

i love fantasia..... but jhud is talented as hell. i wish both of them the best.

[csasbaby]

fantasia make you say damn jenny make u say go head on so i dont know jen got some range over her but fanny kill her wit dem run s i but yall need to stop tryna play jenny like she caint sing cause she still a beast & one of the coldest in da game but dis aint no easy battle

[SingerStaceyDodson]

its a tie to me sorry

[DAlmond123]

Fantasia because Jen has a tendency to oversing her songs sometimes she just puts to much emotion in it. JHud we know you can sing and you have a powerful voice and dont have to use that every time you sing a simple song.

[tyr421e1]

Both

[bushnellboi26]

i like them both, but i would listen 2 J Hudson over Fantasia any day

[turion1668]

Both of these women sound absolutely beautiful. Neither have to compete with each other.

[drphd5]

ARE YALL SERIOUS? Fantasia hands down. Fantasia will be a legend one day.

[JTB4004]

fantasia rules, she is a better vocalist she beat jennifer on idol, go tasia, when i seee uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu

[tgreene7739]

I like Fantasia...but Jennifer's voice sounds so much better on a record! Stand Up crushes any record Fanny has ever done (sorry folks), just gotta be honest.

[xxCrossedxx]

Jennifer by far!!!

[prettyeyes]

I like both of them.

[it39563]

jenny come on you kno she better becuz jennifer beat fantasia out of dreamgirls

[JTCRHS]

FANTASIA WON AMERICAN IDOL AND SHE WINS AGIAN HERe.DOES 65 MILLION VOTES MEAN ANYTHING!

[daravens]

FANTASIAAAAA she did it in A.I she did it again.

[tgreene7739]

Jennifer Hudson....ALL THE WAY, her voice is much better and less whiny.

[temptation422232003]

Fantasia!!!!!

[chiquitaluvs2]

jennifer rock that shit