Phew! What a work out. All three of these cats are phenomenal!!!! I see this as three generations in the evolution of this music; bop, post bop/modern and post modern/free. Happily for me, I like all three.
Three generations of master drummers making a joyful noise. I was smiling ear to ear the whole time this played. Thinking? Feeling? All of the above and more from each player, 100%. A magic moment in my never so humble opinion.
These guys are some of the best that have ever been and ever will be. No rock drummer compares to this. We likely will not see guys like Art Blakey or Elvin Jones for a LOOONNNNG time to come.
These guys were at the frontier of modern drumming. If anyone showed up on the scene today playing like Art Blakey, they'd probably get criticized that they have no dynamics and no groove, or that there are "too many fills."
It's sad to say, but drummers are beginning to lose the "feeling" of drums, and it's being replaced by this technical garbage.
This instrument is about feel, not about how fast you can playing your inverse swiss army triplets.
Fills and groove IMO make a good drummer. And this style works just fine for me. Art Blakey, and Elvin Jones had it all. Sonny Murray is quite impressive too. THese three are guys I'm pretty sure I'll never touch as a drummer. These is some of the most complex drumming I've heard to date. Makes Toad and Moby Dick look like pieces of cake, and those are fantastic solos.
@dtegg91 Interesting comment. Solo drums are rarely nice to hear anyway. Drummers become self indulgent quickly. Exceptions are Chico Hamilton's "The 3 faces of Chico" and a few others like Max Roach's "Drums also waltz" or Joe Morello's "Far more drums".
My take on this is that Sonny Murray's free form playing is all emotion without any structure, no thought involved. Art was just showing off- he can be a very interesting player when he's relaxed. But I've never heard Elvin when he wasn't thinking, forming, going somewhere, even if sometimes he didn't make it, he wasn't just trying to make an impression.
Yes, he is obviously feeling a lot. and I'm not saying that he is not an intelligent musician. In his last year or so, John Coltrane played some highly emotional sheets of sound stuff, always pushing the parameters. It was formless, chaotic, and ugly. But it was the entirely logical progression of a man exploring every possible angle.
I disagree. There was always stucture involved and all the musicians knew what was going to happen for the most part. As far as ugly goes, I think coltranes late period was some of the most beautiful music ever released. His sound and his playing was constanly getting better.
E L V I N .
Helslinky 10 months ago
Phew! What a work out. All three of these cats are phenomenal!!!! I see this as three generations in the evolution of this music; bop, post bop/modern and post modern/free. Happily for me, I like all three.
reverendbryan 1 year ago
Pure excellence from all three, love it.
mclovindrumman 1 year ago
I enjoy all three styles, none a favorite over the other.
Bringerofnoodles 1 year ago
what the fuck is sunny doing at the end! atr and elvin are mad into each others shit, and sunny just seems to be out of it!
Bosphorus92 2 years ago
2:34 yea hit it good :D
stokaskas 2 years ago
i wonder whose idea it was to put sunny on this bill. pretty weird.
kwakky 2 years ago
BLAST BEAT!!!!!
FormerlyMrBean667 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
damnit elvin starts always great but ends shitty..
OldSteamer 2 years ago
@OldSteamer he is drunk on this sessions. Art B always Scared Elvin to death!
KOKOYAMS 2 years ago
3 of the best jazz drummers, and 3 that have most influence my playing. Thanks for the video!
normloman 3 years ago 3
Art Blakey has always been a Hero not only as musician but as person too.
Elvin J is awake here . one can have a short glimps of his mastership
KOKOYAMS 3 years ago
I think art blakey is the hero here.
tolvispelvis 3 years ago 2
I realy don't like Sonny that much, elvin is my hero!!!
soduno 3 years ago
I agree. Sunny's performance here is one of the worst I've ever heard IMHO. Maybe I just don't get it. Elvin and Art are as superb as ever!
Gretchluver1 3 years ago
Sonny's style is "something else"
eldorado8888 2 years ago
Three generations of master drummers making a joyful noise. I was smiling ear to ear the whole time this played. Thinking? Feeling? All of the above and more from each player, 100%. A magic moment in my never so humble opinion.
BDWong 3 years ago
You can almost witness a primal,expressionistic descent from Elvin,down to Art,down to Sunny.Lovely.
thirdshift47 3 years ago
Elvin is pure magic here
PeanutButterMan3 4 years ago
These guys are some of the best that have ever been and ever will be. No rock drummer compares to this. We likely will not see guys like Art Blakey or Elvin Jones for a LOOONNNNG time to come.
jetfreak4 4 years ago 3
These guys were at the frontier of modern drumming. If anyone showed up on the scene today playing like Art Blakey, they'd probably get criticized that they have no dynamics and no groove, or that there are "too many fills."
It's sad to say, but drummers are beginning to lose the "feeling" of drums, and it's being replaced by this technical garbage.
This instrument is about feel, not about how fast you can playing your inverse swiss army triplets.
dtegg91 4 years ago 7
Fills and groove IMO make a good drummer. And this style works just fine for me. Art Blakey, and Elvin Jones had it all. Sonny Murray is quite impressive too. THese three are guys I'm pretty sure I'll never touch as a drummer. These is some of the most complex drumming I've heard to date. Makes Toad and Moby Dick look like pieces of cake, and those are fantastic solos.
jetfreak4 4 years ago
@dtegg91 Interesting comment. Solo drums are rarely nice to hear anyway. Drummers become self indulgent quickly. Exceptions are Chico Hamilton's "The 3 faces of Chico" and a few others like Max Roach's "Drums also waltz" or Joe Morello's "Far more drums".
eluxoso 1 year ago
My take on this is that Sonny Murray's free form playing is all emotion without any structure, no thought involved. Art was just showing off- he can be a very interesting player when he's relaxed. But I've never heard Elvin when he wasn't thinking, forming, going somewhere, even if sometimes he didn't make it, he wasn't just trying to make an impression.
davidjnes 4 years ago
no thought involved? He is feeling the rhythm from every possible angle.
edcerc 4 years ago
Yes, he is obviously feeling a lot. and I'm not saying that he is not an intelligent musician. In his last year or so, John Coltrane played some highly emotional sheets of sound stuff, always pushing the parameters. It was formless, chaotic, and ugly. But it was the entirely logical progression of a man exploring every possible angle.
davidjnes 4 years ago
I disagree. There was always stucture involved and all the musicians knew what was going to happen for the most part. As far as ugly goes, I think coltranes late period was some of the most beautiful music ever released. His sound and his playing was constanly getting better.
edcerc 4 years ago
I had no idea Desmond Tutu played the drums
grandpascorpion 4 years ago
dashikis rule
madmexart 4 years ago
all three= BADASS
simasuma 4 years ago
who the first drummer
brownereclues 4 years ago
Elvin's playing was far more musical than murray's or blakey's
rudeass 4 years ago
I don't like Art Blakey's playing at all.
zoomare 4 years ago
how can you not like that? it's monumental!
jackie83413 4 years ago 2
what the hell is sonny murray playing?
I never liked that stuff
madchops82 4 years ago
Saw Sonny play the pyrmid club NYC around 1980- Nice dude-smoked a dube with him after the show-Ha HA
mothermoore 5 years ago