I love how people argue over which one is more "accurate" lol, 5 vs 144 frets? Accuracy is kind of thrown out the window here, people... What's important is which chart is more fun, and that goes to guitar hero.
GH is more accurate atleast during the main riff.. its played by one guitar, really. and the lower note is constantly played, aka the green note. RB has it the opposite way and doesnt really make sense
What I'm noticing in this video is that the GH chart tends to be a little more towards what a Rhythm guitarist would play in this song, rather then what the lead is actually playing.
Also, GH clearly just took the tab from a Guitar Pro file and incorporated it into a video game.
I think RB has a more fun and accurate chart.
PS: This song is so much fun to play on a 'real' guitar. It's really simple too.
RB chart makes me feel more connected with the audio. GH is harder for me, not only because of chart but also because the GH note arrangement feels awkward for the song.
GH needs more skill but RB seems more comfortable and fun for me.
the thruth is that GH is mostly for amusement of idiots that play thousands of combinations when its mostly likely an 3 chord song thats why RB always seens to be better and more accurate to reallity
@Guiii41 This is wrong. Rockband does tend to be more accurate (not anymore) as it goes with the amount of notes played at any given time, but both of them are inaccurate simply because it is necessary for the game to be played.
90% of all pull-offs and hammer-ons are not pull-offs or hammer-ons at all. This is one of the biggest features of both games, and lots of songs require this, on both games.
Rockband and Guitar Hero are 90% the same game, with different graphics.
@TheIncognitusMe yeah it's really true I've been playing more those 2 games and man the problem now is more about the track list than which one is mostly accurate, buy I still like them and hope for more good tracks on the retail game because I really hate to pay for more musics
from 4:17 just shows how advace rock band is compared to guitar hero and it that section i dont hear hold/long notes
just proves activision buy's something from other ppl and either keeps it that same and dont change a thing or manages to fluck things up....mmmmm sounds like EA's Twin Brother to me lol
@S9anky1982 It's called backup guitar. There is a guitar playing a held note there (and through a lot of the song). It was a choice; to play the 16-some notes being played by the lead, or the held note being played by the backup. They both juggle these choices in lots of songs, and both of them do the same things.
Nothing about this shows Rockband is more advanced.
Granted, Rockband is usually more accurate.
But both of them are inaccurate in all of the important ways, so what does it matter?
um....i think the music's off around the middle part of the song you can tell. you should especially look @ the solo part and on. i wonder why nobody's commented on this yet.....??
@favorflavor101 It's actually just that the GH chart and RB chart focus on different parts. The RB version seems to focus on the more audible part though.
@GotParody If I remember correctly, Rockband was created by members of the original Guitar Hero team that quit, or something of that sort. That's probably why Rockband was at the same level (I like to think Rockband's less hard-core charts and tighter required accuracy for note hits made for, I suppose, more interesting gameplay. definitely made me much more accurate) as Guitar Hero when #3 came out. They knew what they were doing.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
rb juz adds radom notes b\c dey wanna make it harder den gh but no gh is harder ok n rb sometimes has less notes den gh so gh is gud on guitar but i hate singin on gh it sucks its more fun on rb and the graphics are gud to on rb
so dey r both gud games so if u lik playin the bass or da guitar go to gh and if u like singin or the drums go to rb its more fun
Your profile says you're 17, so I suggest you learn to communicate like a seventeen-year old.
Your comment was indiscernible because of your horrible grammar and spelling.
Text is the primary means of communication on the internet and if you want people to take you seriously and consider your opinion, you need to stop typing like an autistic kid trying to sound like a gangster.
first of all i got speech problems so laugh all you want i dont care and second im a kid this is my sisters profile and i use it b\c she barely goes on. My bad for my spelling i was in a hurry.
wats up with 3:24 - 3:40 on the GHWT chart...they arent even charting the guitar...they are just charting the echoing noise of the song lol...RB is actually charting the guitar...
im SICK of comments like rockband stole gh idea or rock band perfected the gh series or wathever....HELLO-O ROCKBAND DEVS ARE THE OLD GH DEVS !!! WAKE UP FROM UNDER THE ROCK !!!
oh....and btw rockband devs are all real musicians...so go figure
Someone told me it was a keyboard, someone told me it was a synthesizer. I wouldn't know what it is. Go on Wiki or something. They might have it there.
Guitar Hero puts too many notes where they dont need to b and doesnt put enough where it needs em. Rockband is waaay better. even though guitar hero came 1st, rockband perfected what they were tryin to do.
@shartdartfart Just to give an example, sometimes, when the notes should be ascending, they descend. Makes you feel like you're playing the bass part, but you're guitar...
guitar hero combines the lead and rhythm guitars into notechart, rock band from the start was supposed to be a full band so no need to combine the guitars, so less notes. Both add notes where none are needed, guitar hero just does it a tad more. Rock Band actually undercharts their stuff a lot from what i've seen
Hey guys did you know Harmonix are real music creaters this is my oppinon guitar hero just listened to the song at the solo OMFG thats nor right and what the fuck is wrong with the long notes its going way off the song Why are we arguing over a game i said it that the thing so shut up and just play the game omg people its a game stop whining Rock Band 2 chart is better
I want to say rock band is like 75% right and guitar hero has the other 25% and at points they both are the same just different colors. But im gonna say RB wins this chart
to get this straight, harmonix made guitar hero 1,guitar hero 2,rock band, and rock band 2. Harmonix gave guitar hero rights to activision. so activision made guitar hero 3 and guitar hero 4. nobody STOLE anything!!guitar hero 4 is super awesome and so is rock band 2.they are both worth buying so stop fighting!
I won't say which one is better,but i've got rock band and i've got to say that the chart is way harder on rock band,and seems more real then gh,i can't see this by the notes comin' off,i mean in gh seem just 3 strums,but the real one(and rock band)has more strummin.(Of course i prefere rock band,but i own gh3 and i really like it as a game)
I(unlike the majority of you) will actually think about this...by the way when i say that i mean the people arguing about which is better...
I agree with il4wlz... but there are other parts that look the other way around... I have to say that i like RB's better even though i like guitar hero more...
Wow people who cares! The problem I have with these comparisson videos is that everyone who owns guitar hero will say guitar hero is better and everyone who owns rockband will say rockband is better. Cant we just say theyre both great games with different pro's and con's and get on with our lives?
are you kidding?... that part at 1:19 is an effect making it chopped up and RB actually put it as individual notes?.... wow... I don't how that makes it "WAYY BETTER"..
If you know anything about playing guitar, that is not an effect but a type of picking called "Tremolo picking." Here's the definition: "A regular and rapid repetition of a single note, which is scored as a single note." It's a single note on a sheet of paper when reading music, but you pick very fast and it sounds like many notes. So rock band wins. You lose.
You can tell it's edited though can't you? I play real guitar and can easily tell that something effect related happens there. And I definitely already agreed that rock band wins... so that doesn't make me lose.. way to fail..
Both have mistakes, but GH's errors are much more apparent and awful. The RB chart has fast-strumming sections, while the GH chart has them as sustained notes. In the solo, RB's fast chords are three-note chords at a slow pace on GH's chart. How is that more accurate?
As a real guitarist, I can honestly tell you that the GH:WT chart is completely accurate, and the RB chart is almost an embarrassment. And I like Rock Band. But WT just seems to have better charting this generation.
how are you gonna call the rock band chart an embarrassment if you are a "real guitarist". It is obviously more accurate. Maybe the timing of this video throws it off. the held notes do go up, so good job ghwt, but the rock band chart is just overall better.
LOL your an idiot its a game and your telling me that you played this song exactly the same way as these charts are and got this song....... NO YOU DIDNT. so to me it seems like your sucken GH's D$%K. Cause these notes are just placed on the screen, so you can play to a song that has been recorded already....by a real GUITARIST.
Bitches, I didn't understand one point you were trying to make, at all. Second, all the uber strumming in the Rock Band chart IS A DELAY EFFECT, NOT STRUMMING.
But some in the RB2 community already complain about how boring this song is. I dunno. But they don't know until they've seen the GHWT chart. Snooore.
I can play this song on actual guitar, and Rock Band definitely wins on the accuracy to the actual song, but GH wins on gameplay. I would rather play the GH version because it is generally harder ( I said generally I didn't say GH was more difficult ) In the end which game is better depends on your preference.
ummmmmm WRONG!!! haha, no seriously its not. in guitar hero they make you play parts when the guitar isnt even present. i dont feel like looking for the time, but they even make you play some bass parts. very innacurate. i can also play it in real life and rock band 2 wins it.
It would make sense to have them as strummed notes but I can play this on actual guitar and it is something you do with a whammy bar so it actually isn't really strummed.
ok i just compraed the charts with the real guitar tab and GH has the most accurate one, rb in some parts needs more notes and then it overcharts for some reason.. Winner: GH
each side appears to have faults, but it definately appears that RB is right in the really fast chord sections when GH has a long note or something (like at 2:00)
I'd just like to say this about Harmonix's charting theory- they take into account all of the layered guitar tracks in a song, even if they're played by the same person in the recording. The way they chart it is realistic in terms of chord changes and distinguishing single notes from chords (Neversoft can't seem to do this). They do mix the tracks up to keep the chart fun to play- by mix I mean instead of playing the same verse over and over again, you play something from the other guitar track.
Its staggering how people think they're right by leaving an unjustified case in ever so little words. ONE, Silversun Pickups has 1 Guitar, count em' Brian Aubert, 1! TWO, the Rock Band charting is terrible, absolutely awful in terms of actually tabbing. They act like two guitars are playing and at some points the guitar swings into Nikki's and Joe's "thing". Guitar Hero's chart beats Rock Band in realism without a doubt. Pathetic!
I'm sorry but Rockband 2's charts look alot more fun then Guitar hero's. and it seems like Guitar couldn't really follow the song correctly(and no its not the keyboard parts i'm talking about
its not neversoft its redoctane that does the whole game ns just sponsors it and at 4:17 rb2 uses the keybord for a guitar rocband uses guitar only rb just sucks period
HMX's outlook on their company... Musicians first games second. Look at the setlists and how the two play. HMX is more about the music where as GH seems to be more on the money and game aspect.
I would say Guitar Hero is more focused on the content of the song that fits to the gameplay. If GH was focused on money then they wouldn't have a song like TTatF on GH3.
... Then please do explain why they're milking the franchise name to death?
This isn't even Guitar Hero.
HMX has secured rights to the Beatles... they announced a Beatles game coming next year. But they clearly said "IT WILL NOT USE THE ROCK BAND NAME! And a couple sources cite it using the RB engine and Platform" Proof HMX doesn't need to milk a franchise
God Neversoft are useless at charting. If they're not overcharting they're undercharting, they stick with the same boring riff through the majority of the song and they actively chose to have you play said boring rhythm riff instead of the different and better lead.
There is no rythym, there is just lead, the other sounds you are hearing are keyboards and bass. There is only one guitarist in Silversun Pickups, and that's the lead singer. Personally I think the guitar hero chart is overcharted, but the rock band 2 chart is pretty undercharted.
Check the personnel for the album Lazy Eye is from (their deut album Carnavas), the only guitar listed is Brian Aubert the lead singer. There is only one guitarist, the rest of the sounds are keyboards and bass.
it pisses me off how gh thinks that by putting rhythm guitar parts over easy lead guitar parts that it makes the game more fun. when u play u totally miss out on important parts of the song.
I love how people argue over which one is more "accurate" lol, 5 vs 144 frets? Accuracy is kind of thrown out the window here, people... What's important is which chart is more fun, and that goes to guitar hero.
CthulhuDarkLord 1 month ago
GH is more accurate atleast during the main riff.. its played by one guitar, really. and the lower note is constantly played, aka the green note. RB has it the opposite way and doesnt really make sense
johnnyfree 1 month ago
gh looks more challenging but rock band realy captured the essence of the song
maximillionbergeron 4 months ago
What I'm noticing in this video is that the GH chart tends to be a little more towards what a Rhythm guitarist would play in this song, rather then what the lead is actually playing.
Also, GH clearly just took the tab from a Guitar Pro file and incorporated it into a video game.
I think RB has a more fun and accurate chart.
PS: This song is so much fun to play on a 'real' guitar. It's really simple too.
Dankscarver 6 months ago
Real Guitar wins
4demon9 6 months ago 3
rb has better chart, just a crappy engine imo
IxOVERKILLxI 7 months ago
they are both close and have differences through out but i'm stickin with GH!
pinkmommyx2 10 months ago
Guitar Hero is much more fun
starleov 1 year ago 4
FUCK RB
Igoryocheck 1 year ago
i saw the whole video before reading the comments and im glad it wasnt only me who thinks RB kicks GH´s ass by way to much
yeah GH seems harder, but RB feels more natural
KaEeRUu 1 year ago
@KaEeRUu That's the thing- Harmonix is dedicated to a more accurate approach while Guitar Hero goes for a more arcade-y approach, if you will.
Think of it as Rock band is to Madden as Guitar Hero is to NFL Blitz. That's the way I look at it.
somedude12233 1 year ago
RB chart makes me feel more connected with the audio. GH is harder for me, not only because of chart but also because the GH note arrangement feels awkward for the song.
GH needs more skill but RB seems more comfortable and fun for me.
remmaps123321 1 year ago
WTF...That is a man singing.
peperonyandchease 1 year ago
@peperonyandchease yes yes there is
mistermeekl12 1 year ago
@mistermeekl12 he sounds like a woman, he might be a gay
peperonyandchease 1 year ago
@peperonyandchease u sure? check the music video or how similar his voice is to billy corgan
mistermeekl12 1 year ago
Rock Band is much easier...
Lacee860917 1 year ago
Guitar Hero.
accquizzer 1 year ago
the thruth is that GH is mostly for amusement of idiots that play thousands of combinations when its mostly likely an 3 chord song thats why RB always seens to be better and more accurate to reallity
Guiii41 1 year ago
@Guiii41 This is wrong. Rockband does tend to be more accurate (not anymore) as it goes with the amount of notes played at any given time, but both of them are inaccurate simply because it is necessary for the game to be played.
90% of all pull-offs and hammer-ons are not pull-offs or hammer-ons at all. This is one of the biggest features of both games, and lots of songs require this, on both games.
Rockband and Guitar Hero are 90% the same game, with different graphics.
Love them both.
TheIncognitusMe 1 year ago
@TheIncognitusMe yeah it's really true I've been playing more those 2 games and man the problem now is more about the track list than which one is mostly accurate, buy I still like them and hope for more good tracks on the retail game because I really hate to pay for more musics
Guiii41 1 year ago
At least Guitar Hero can make a good guitar.
TaborlinTheGreat 1 year ago
from 4:17 just shows how advace rock band is compared to guitar hero and it that section i dont hear hold/long notes
just proves activision buy's something from other ppl and either keeps it that same and dont change a thing or manages to fluck things up....mmmmm sounds like EA's Twin Brother to me lol
S9anky1982 1 year ago
@S9anky1982 on gh i always wanted to play the na na na nana na na
mistermeekl12 1 year ago
@S9anky1982 It's called backup guitar. There is a guitar playing a held note there (and through a lot of the song). It was a choice; to play the 16-some notes being played by the lead, or the held note being played by the backup. They both juggle these choices in lots of songs, and both of them do the same things.
Nothing about this shows Rockband is more advanced.
Granted, Rockband is usually more accurate.
But both of them are inaccurate in all of the important ways, so what does it matter?
TheIncognitusMe 1 year ago
Rock Band has all the notes more correct than guitar hero, is better RB
thebesst95 1 year ago
rock band is for pussies as always
Jonscomin2 1 year ago
um....i think the music's off around the middle part of the song you can tell. you should especially look @ the solo part and on. i wonder why nobody's commented on this yet.....??
favorflavor101 1 year ago
@favorflavor101 It's actually just that the GH chart and RB chart focus on different parts. The RB version seems to focus on the more audible part though.
SubzeroRay 1 year ago
gh wt wins
lakaicrewLL 1 year ago
@lakaicrewLL I LOL'D...
SubzeroRay 1 year ago
These games were made by the same people.... I think Activision
GotParody 1 year ago
@GotParody Activision is merely the publisher. They dont actually MAKE any games.
SubzeroRay 1 year ago
@GotParody If I remember correctly, Rockband was created by members of the original Guitar Hero team that quit, or something of that sort. That's probably why Rockband was at the same level (I like to think Rockband's less hard-core charts and tighter required accuracy for note hits made for, I suppose, more interesting gameplay. definitely made me much more accurate) as Guitar Hero when #3 came out. They knew what they were doing.
TheIncognitusMe 1 year ago
This song is terrible (JK)...
greenorange75 1 year ago
no wonder Brian Aubert always says those songs kill him when he tries playing them on GH and RB2
silversundash 1 year ago
Just saw these guys opening for muse. They were great.
DML897 1 year ago
theres actually another guitar played in the song lazy eye... Each game only plays 1 guitar for some parts of the song
punkx52 2 years ago
Guitar Hero has the rhythm parts nailed. Rock Band has the lead parts nailed.
TheNethero 2 years ago
Comment removed
PWN3DKn1fer 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
rb juz adds radom notes b\c dey wanna make it harder den gh but no gh is harder ok n rb sometimes has less notes den gh so gh is gud on guitar but i hate singin on gh it sucks its more fun on rb and the graphics are gud to on rb
so dey r both gud games so if u lik playin the bass or da guitar go to gh and if u like singin or the drums go to rb its more fun
so stop arguing they r bouth gud games
xxsghnrbfanxxs 2 years ago
Uh, good grammar please?
KolaDannySH2 2 years ago 3
Your profile says you're 17, so I suggest you learn to communicate like a seventeen-year old.
Your comment was indiscernible because of your horrible grammar and spelling.
Text is the primary means of communication on the internet and if you want people to take you seriously and consider your opinion, you need to stop typing like an autistic kid trying to sound like a gangster.
clk22 1 year ago
first of all i got speech problems so laugh all you want i dont care and second im a kid this is my sisters profile and i use it b\c she barely goes on. My bad for my spelling i was in a hurry.
xxsghnrbfanxxs 1 year ago
@xxsghnrbfanxxs Thats some of the worst spelling iv'e ever seen
rbrocks1 1 year ago
bad timing for music and notes
NFSfan1123 2 years ago
RB plays notes that are done by a keyboard. Wtf?
Emiester1130 2 years ago
rb actualy charts notes correctly
tekdekman 2 years ago 2
wats up with 3:24 - 3:40 on the GHWT chart...they arent even charting the guitar...they are just charting the echoing noise of the song lol...RB is actually charting the guitar...
mycoolgoodvideos 2 years ago 2
GH cuts out notes in this and charts inaccurately...RB wins
mycoolgoodvideos 2 years ago 15
RB Does win
KolaDannySH2 2 years ago 8
@KolaDannySH2 why? is there a reason why they win? or they just win because "y'know it's harmonix.there awesome n stuff"
shartdartfart 1 year ago
yes guitar hero cool
geraxxito 1 year ago
@mycoolgoodvideos or rockband overcharted
mistermeekl12 1 year ago
@mycoolgoodvideos like were? rock band made it too fucking hard to complete
mistermeekl12 1 year ago
Guitar Hero is BEST !
j0st1 3 years ago
idiot rockband is easy dumb loser.
pker902 3 years ago
im SICK of comments like rockband stole gh idea or rock band perfected the gh series or wathever....HELLO-O ROCKBAND DEVS ARE THE OLD GH DEVS !!! WAKE UP FROM UNDER THE ROCK !!!
oh....and btw rockband devs are all real musicians...so go figure
p.s.of course rockband is the better game
solidsnakejt 3 years ago
could some one please tell me the name of the guitar effect that kicks in at about 2:16 of the song? it'd be very helpful
thanks
CheeZiEGEeZuH 3 years ago
Someone told me it was a keyboard, someone told me it was a synthesizer. I wouldn't know what it is. Go on Wiki or something. They might have it there.
CLRangeCombat 3 years ago
Okay, thanks. It does sound like a keyboard, but I just assumed it was guitar since it's charted on the game. I'll guess I'll start hunting.
CheeZiEGEeZuH 3 years ago
i like gh4 cuz its bit more difficult than rb2
and the notes are more fun to play
bluedude05 3 years ago
Gh.s Layout is better to
Back0nTrack 3 years ago
RB2 design is better Gh:Wt Lays Out all the Notes
Back0nTrack 3 years ago
guitar hero 1 and 2 were awesome, harmonix left before guitar hero 3 to make rock band, guitar hero 3 sucked....wonder why......rubs chin....
ItOnlyTakes4 3 years ago
rubs chin? stfu
mikehawk16 3 years ago
no u
ItOnlyTakes4 3 years ago
Guitar Hero puts too many notes where they dont need to b and doesnt put enough where it needs em. Rockband is waaay better. even though guitar hero came 1st, rockband perfected what they were tryin to do.
brianxkri 3 years ago 3
not too mention this vid is out of snyc a little
Volcomdude412x 3 years ago
@brianxkri GH's chart seems fine to me
shartdartfart 1 year ago
@shartdartfart The chart is awkward. If you're educated in music theory, you'd look at the chart with disgust. It makes no sense at all.
SubzeroRay 1 year ago
@SubzeroRay to you,how does it look awkward?
shartdartfart 1 year ago
@shartdartfart Just to give an example, sometimes, when the notes should be ascending, they descend. Makes you feel like you're playing the bass part, but you're guitar...
SubzeroRay 1 year ago
@SubzeroRay hmm yeah
shartdartfart 1 year ago
@SubzeroRay chart? sorry im no expert, so what's the chart?
favorflavor101 1 year ago
@favorflavor101 It's basically the notes. The chart is the visual that tells you what to hit.
SubzeroRay 1 year ago
RB is better. More realistic. Guitar Hero just gives you a bunch of notes to play and RB actually gives you notes from the lead guitar...
jmxbox 3 years ago
guitar hero combines the lead and rhythm guitars into notechart, rock band from the start was supposed to be a full band so no need to combine the guitars, so less notes. Both add notes where none are needed, guitar hero just does it a tad more. Rock Band actually undercharts their stuff a lot from what i've seen
Volcomdude412x 3 years ago
Hey guys did you know Harmonix are real music creaters this is my oppinon guitar hero just listened to the song at the solo OMFG thats nor right and what the fuck is wrong with the long notes its going way off the song Why are we arguing over a game i said it that the thing so shut up and just play the game omg people its a game stop whining Rock Band 2 chart is better
NiNjaAssassin99 3 years ago
Comment removed
LASSESboy 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@NiNjaAssassin99 Punctuation much? No one understands a thing you're saying, buddy...
LASSESboy 1 year ago
I want to say rock band is like 75% right and guitar hero has the other 25% and at points they both are the same just different colors. But im gonna say RB wins this chart
degonite 3 years ago 3
gosh why don't u people learn this on regular guitar? its very easy. one of the easiest i kno
munkeyman321 3 years ago
i agree. you can probobly play this song with one finger.
acezospad3s 3 years ago
close. only two lol
munkeyman321 3 years ago
the main part with one finger. learn that, and you basically know 80 percent of the song
acezospad3s 3 years ago
i know. the solo is actually easy compared to some stuff i know
munkeyman321 3 years ago
@acezospad3s I know that from looking at tabs
1000yeroldslep 2 years ago
i had my TV volume on max when i played the ending of this and my neighbor woke up
hillzmage209 3 years ago
I think guitar hero is more accurate
but Rock band is more fun 2 play here
im2cow4u 3 years ago
UGGGGH!!!
i wish the notes in the RB chart at 4:36 to 4:39 were in the guitar hero chart
obkinder 3 years ago
to get this straight, harmonix made guitar hero 1,guitar hero 2,rock band, and rock band 2. Harmonix gave guitar hero rights to activision. so activision made guitar hero 3 and guitar hero 4. nobody STOLE anything!!guitar hero 4 is super awesome and so is rock band 2.they are both worth buying so stop fighting!
whathesaid321 3 years ago
i gotta say rock band chart is better ...
dhekdnlt 3 years ago 2
I won't say which one is better,but i've got rock band and i've got to say that the chart is way harder on rock band,and seems more real then gh,i can't see this by the notes comin' off,i mean in gh seem just 3 strums,but the real one(and rock band)has more strummin.(Of course i prefere rock band,but i own gh3 and i really like it as a game)
lestatvalo666 3 years ago
hmmmm
I(unlike the majority of you) will actually think about this...by the way when i say that i mean the people arguing about which is better...
I agree with il4wlz... but there are other parts that look the other way around... I have to say that i like RB's better even though i like guitar hero more...
obkinder 3 years ago
Wow people who cares! The problem I have with these comparisson videos is that everyone who owns guitar hero will say guitar hero is better and everyone who owns rockband will say rockband is better. Cant we just say theyre both great games with different pro's and con's and get on with our lives?
wackyluke444 3 years ago 2
AS A GH PLAYER RB'S CHART IS WAYY BETTER
KidSon704 3 years ago
are you kidding?... that part at 1:19 is an effect making it chopped up and RB actually put it as individual notes?.... wow... I don't how that makes it "WAYY BETTER"..
kevincaz07 3 years ago
If you know anything about playing guitar, that is not an effect but a type of picking called "Tremolo picking." Here's the definition: "A regular and rapid repetition of a single note, which is scored as a single note." It's a single note on a sheet of paper when reading music, but you pick very fast and it sounds like many notes. So rock band wins. You lose.
Berzerker204 3 years ago 3
You can tell it's edited though can't you? I play real guitar and can easily tell that something effect related happens there. And I definitely already agreed that rock band wins... so that doesn't make me lose.. way to fail..
kevincaz07 3 years ago
You fail for thinking that it's edited. It's clearly not.
Berzerker204 3 years ago
well, as I see the end however, RB takes the win... Guitar Hero was being really weird with their chart, lol. But I like GH's beginning anyway. =P
kevincaz07 3 years ago
Guitar Hero is STUPID!
it has some parts way F--k'n off
ROCK BAND IS THE BEST!
Zombie92891 3 years ago
Guitar Hero is a joke..
maskedkane26 3 years ago 2
Around 4:45 Rb is playing the bass when Gh is playing the lead. WTF?
iL4wlz 3 years ago
i noticed that too
ericm1551 3 years ago
Wow what a craptastic job Neversoft did on that chart. RB2 FTW!
skullpit77 3 years ago 8
Dang people, do some rescearch before saying anything!
UnUsualGreature 3 years ago
Both have mistakes, but GH's errors are much more apparent and awful. The RB chart has fast-strumming sections, while the GH chart has them as sustained notes. In the solo, RB's fast chords are three-note chords at a slow pace on GH's chart. How is that more accurate?
cookupshit 3 years ago 5
rockband is a lot easier i find. therefore, i like guitar hero better.
eatmyshitplz 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Guitar Hero World Tour Chart: Realistic
Rock Band 2 Chart: Fun
You Decide =0
Noobowner094 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Guitar Hero
candysell 3 years ago
i think GHWT its much better
ampliwar 3 years ago
you know what?
who cares which is better
theyre both hella fun to play and its an awesome song on two awesome games.
if you want 100% song accuracy, buy a real guitar.
oh, and do ghwt & rb2 have the same song list?
ericm1551 3 years ago
no but alot of songs are the same
Soul1of1Sauron 3 years ago
thanks
ericm1551 3 years ago
GH all the way
natefly5 3 years ago
GH chart wins. Wtf is with the Chord hammer-ons?
sonknuck23 3 years ago
It's more or less emulating sliding on a real guitar.
cwhitneySH 3 years ago 2
i swear, if GH came out with a band kit b4 RB, everyone would be dick-riding the shit out of GH just as much as most people are doing to RB.
xpumpkinh3adx 3 years ago
guitar hero is harder! YAHHHHH!
THExDEAFLESSxRECORD 3 years ago
As a real guitarist, I can honestly tell you that the GH:WT chart is completely accurate, and the RB chart is almost an embarrassment. And I like Rock Band. But WT just seems to have better charting this generation.
xXSpellcasterXx 3 years ago
Most definitely. RB2 makes you play the bass notes during the solo. What the hell? GHWT is really on the mark, at least with this song.
billiumbean 3 years ago
how are you gonna call the rock band chart an embarrassment if you are a "real guitarist". It is obviously more accurate. Maybe the timing of this video throws it off. the held notes do go up, so good job ghwt, but the rock band chart is just overall better.
Doritos4Life 3 years ago 2
LOL your an idiot its a game and your telling me that you played this song exactly the same way as these charts are and got this song....... NO YOU DIDNT. so to me it seems like your sucken GH's D$%K. Cause these notes are just placed on the screen, so you can play to a song that has been recorded already....by a real GUITARIST.
Bitchesgivehigh5s 3 years ago
Bitches, I didn't understand one point you were trying to make, at all. Second, all the uber strumming in the Rock Band chart IS A DELAY EFFECT, NOT STRUMMING.
xXSpellcasterXx 3 years ago
The RB2 chart is certainly more fun to play.
But some in the RB2 community already complain about how boring this song is. I dunno. But they don't know until they've seen the GHWT chart. Snooore.
IJCRO 3 years ago 3
I can play this song on actual guitar, and Rock Band definitely wins on the accuracy to the actual song, but GH wins on gameplay. I would rather play the GH version because it is generally harder ( I said generally I didn't say GH was more difficult ) In the end which game is better depends on your preference.
BCarey2293 3 years ago
GH is more accurate, but those fast parts in RB are awesome
junkieslayer667 3 years ago
ummmmmm WRONG!!! haha, no seriously its not. in guitar hero they make you play parts when the guitar isnt even present. i dont feel like looking for the time, but they even make you play some bass parts. very innacurate. i can also play it in real life and rock band 2 wins it.
bloc22 3 years ago 2
If you look between about 1:10 and 1:20, those are def fast strummed parts becuse of the twang the noted makes, and GH just has held notes....LAME!
cspang21 3 years ago
It would make sense to have them as strummed notes but I can play this on actual guitar and it is something you do with a whammy bar so it actually isn't really strummed.
BCarey2293 3 years ago
ok i just compraed the charts with the real guitar tab and GH has the most accurate one, rb in some parts needs more notes and then it overcharts for some reason.. Winner: GH
CrazyNights14 3 years ago
and in the solo--i have never seen the real tabs, but it definately sounds like fast chords when GH just has 3 chords
j8son814 3 years ago
each side appears to have faults, but it definately appears that RB is right in the really fast chord sections when GH has a long note or something (like at 2:00)
j8son814 3 years ago
If Rockband 'ripped off' Guitarhero, who the hell cares cuz Rockband does a way better job in all aspects.
carsoniar 3 years ago
actually activision ripped gh from harmonix so harmonix mabe rb and now activision is stealing their idea again
thetylerisamazing 3 years ago
I think Guitar Hero: World Failure just got PWNED. I hope for the Neversoft fanboys that they chart the rest of their setlist better.
Was the GH:WT side on Hard or something? lol
dariussongblade 3 years ago
I'd just like to say this about Harmonix's charting theory- they take into account all of the layered guitar tracks in a song, even if they're played by the same person in the recording. The way they chart it is realistic in terms of chord changes and distinguishing single notes from chords (Neversoft can't seem to do this). They do mix the tracks up to keep the chart fun to play- by mix I mean instead of playing the same verse over and over again, you play something from the other guitar track.
dkbatman06 3 years ago
Its staggering how people think they're right by leaving an unjustified case in ever so little words. ONE, Silversun Pickups has 1 Guitar, count em' Brian Aubert, 1! TWO, the Rock Band charting is terrible, absolutely awful in terms of actually tabbing. They act like two guitars are playing and at some points the guitar swings into Nikki's and Joe's "thing". Guitar Hero's chart beats Rock Band in realism without a doubt. Pathetic!
HerbalAbuze 3 years ago
I'm sorry but Rockband 2's charts look alot more fun then Guitar hero's. and it seems like Guitar couldn't really follow the song correctly(and no its not the keyboard parts i'm talking about
irpie 3 years ago
its not neversoft its redoctane that does the whole game ns just sponsors it and at 4:17 rb2 uses the keybord for a guitar rocband uses guitar only rb just sucks period
EmoRockstar777 3 years ago
Failed troll.
DeadMrFred 3 years ago
RB ripped off GH
PH3N0M3N0M07 3 years ago
wasnt RB2 out first?
esl2k7 3 years ago
I'd love to hear you explain how they ripped off GH.
What an awful GH chart. Way to chart the song completely wrong. It helps to be musicians AND developers, Neversoft.
cookupshit 3 years ago
HMX's outlook on their company... Musicians first games second. Look at the setlists and how the two play. HMX is more about the music where as GH seems to be more on the money and game aspect.
Zeleii 3 years ago
I would say Guitar Hero is more focused on the content of the song that fits to the gameplay. If GH was focused on money then they wouldn't have a song like TTatF on GH3.
BCarey2293 3 years ago
... Then please do explain why they're milking the franchise name to death?
This isn't even Guitar Hero.
HMX has secured rights to the Beatles... they announced a Beatles game coming next year. But they clearly said "IT WILL NOT USE THE ROCK BAND NAME! And a couple sources cite it using the RB engine and Platform" Proof HMX doesn't need to milk a franchise
Zeleii 3 years ago
I guess because they need every chance they can get to show off the guitar hero name.
BCarey2293 3 years ago
ROCK BANDS > GUITAR HEROS.
stop being dillusional, people.
MaliceNMyHeart 3 years ago
Wow neversoft. Horrible job. Seriously
Strykerx77 3 years ago
Rock Band 2 wins
WisconsinCheese1 3 years ago
God Neversoft are useless at charting. If they're not overcharting they're undercharting, they stick with the same boring riff through the majority of the song and they actively chose to have you play said boring rhythm riff instead of the different and better lead.
InaudibleWhisper 3 years ago
There is no rythym, there is just lead, the other sounds you are hearing are keyboards and bass. There is only one guitarist in Silversun Pickups, and that's the lead singer. Personally I think the guitar hero chart is overcharted, but the rock band 2 chart is pretty undercharted.
GoldenJokered 3 years ago
silversun pickups had two guitarists, and personally, i think RB2 has this chart nailed perfectly
acezospad3s 3 years ago 8
Check the personnel for the album Lazy Eye is from (their deut album Carnavas), the only guitar listed is Brian Aubert the lead singer. There is only one guitarist, the rest of the sounds are keyboards and bass.
GoldenJokered 3 years ago
The chart is fine...but check again. 1 Singer/Guitarist, 1 Bassist, 1 drummer, and 1 keyboardist
Berzerker204 3 years ago
they had 2 guitarists, but one got kicked because he lit the singer's jacket on fire
acezospad3s 3 years ago
no amount of overcharting can bring back gh in this fight. maybe in the solo area but thats it
Raid3n1609 3 years ago
RB2 Wins. End.
I can't believe how Neversoft screwed the chart for my favorite song of GHWT. That's, like, the WORST CHART EVER.
bhsoothsayer 3 years ago
Wow, the GH one kinda screws you up with that guitar solo.
Trubadboyplaya 3 years ago
it pisses me off how gh thinks that by putting rhythm guitar parts over easy lead guitar parts that it makes the game more fun. when u play u totally miss out on important parts of the song.
vikingfan1494 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Guitar Hero wins there is no point to the Hammer on of 2 notes
Highway226 3 years ago
of course there is~ the hammer-on chords are an edge that RB has.
I can't believe how undercharted the GH:WT chart is~ RB's chart is more fun
jayou521 3 years ago
Considering you can hammer-on/pull-off chords in real life, RB2 wins that.
Donovan121 3 years ago
Rock band 2 wins this IMO. Much more accurate in the solo.
DHM078 3 years ago 3
GHWT wins. Fatality.
NibWoddle 3 years ago
hou much is the mic for gh;wt
AMDKING63 3 years ago
ghwt wins this time
surtails 3 years ago
rock band 2 chart looks better
Z4ckK10 3 years ago
At gh:wt cares about the bass part
joltingfire5 3 years ago