陳奕迅 2003 Concert Part 18 - 不再問究竟

[harrycheng1]

呢D先係歌手...即使唔係原唱.一樣能完美演繹~

[alextang1030]

陳百強唱既時候比我既感覺係 柔弱既感嘆

陳奕迅唱既時候比我既感覺係 激動既感慨

[ken717w]

陳奕迅係紅得有道理

[janeaquifer]

@ken717w eason is impressive.i love his song pretty much!:-)

[yt6054]

miss you 林振強

[lingvic]

Danny唱呢首歌既心情等同佢當時既心情, 當我諗到呢一點, danny版本更觸動我心

[mickey0418]

danny, miss you so much

[kc168100]

更正；Eason版，應該寫作Eason翻唱。Danny版本，­應該寫作原唱者Danny仔。

[kc168100]

原來呢首“不再問究竟”嘅Eason版，有咁多人羅黎比較！我覺­得成長於唔同年代嘅人，會有唔同嘅感覺。正所謂蘿蔔青菜，各有所­愛！「而我本人，每次聽Danny仔嘅版本，都會有一種好蒼涼嘅­感覺。」

[jeremynghk]

希望各位不要再去比較了, 你喜歡誰就誰.........自己好好去欣賞



[chiudaiha]

eason不是不好,但還是較喜歡陳百強版本,無疑eason係­好有感情,但陳百強把聲太有character,聽佢唱第一句,­就立即代入歌中畫面,好似睇到danny好失落站在燈下落淚,

畫面太強,令人難忘

[7165971659]

聽一次就喜歡了a_a

[LuHuWei]

這個更有流行曲味道~

陳百強的很經典，EASON唱也是別番味道

[lpy031504]

我比較喜歡陳百強的板本~eason有d位太硬,唔夠放鬆,,,­

[bbsarajane]

我相信danny在天之靈聽到d人硬要將佢同唔同年代既Easo­n比較, 都一定會好難過.有心人阿臣亦唔會為此而覺得驕傲.

[bbsarajane]

我反而係聽到eason live既版本才記起danny有呢首遺忘既好歌.

點解要比較?一個係studio錄音,一個係live performance,既然工作/專業與音樂有關既, 仲應該會更明白兩者更難相比.

要比都唔洗講出口,因為有品有sense又懂得欣賞美好事物既人­係去appreciate而唔係硬去比較.

[marco2004112]

可能我唔係果個年代, 我覺得EASON唱得好D

不過陳百強都好聽~

好鐘意呢首歌!!

[nonojojo123]

陳百強唱既歌，往往都能夠好成功做到「感情融入歌聲中」既境界，­係一位好難得既歌手

[unpayb]

陳百強好D，無他，先入為主。

[jholivehk]

Danny ' s the original version is much more touching ...

[resteffi2]

why every cover song needs to be compared???

what a waste of time. just listen, and that's it.

[annie780]

Eason唱得一般咋喎,有d部分似朗讀多過似唱,唔相信竟然有­人覺得佢唱得好過原唱,有d問題喎,肯定係佢自己d fans黎,情人眼裏出西施!

[hkghelmet]

我覺得陳百強版本仲似朗讀@annie780

[tan022090]

各有千秋、各有各的感性!不同的時代造就不同的英オ!前、後两位­歌者都演澤得非常好!!!正如以往陳百強在“維他紅星傾過界”電­視節目上表白過:゛本身毎個歌星、影星都有他的偶像!總之迷上ー­個人係無得解釋嘅!"各花入各眼………

[Bolingdc]

不知道所謂最佳評論是怎樣得出的?! 為何要批評誰唱得好些,還說自己是音樂劇演員,那又如何?! 陳百強是香港難得一見的歌手,聲音與外型同樣非常有魅力的,陳奕­迅也很欣賞他,很多現在仍在樂壇的歌手都很喜歡他,包括楊仟樺,­梁漢文,張智霖,張敬軒.....而我覺得陳奕迅率真的性情與陳­百強最為接近.  我很喜歡他唱陳百強的歌,但請不要比較誰唱得比誰的好,只要好好­欣賞就夠了.

[ledo11148]

@Bolingdc 批評？言論自由？WTF？

[thedarkstarrr]

@Bolingdc 那不是批評,那只是提出自己的想法不是嗎?

[edwincyy]

eason 講故事, danny 抒發傷感的感情

[Orz1205]

uh ha~

e到聽到好sad=(

[ttcsuck2]

I think both versions are good. The only problem is that this cover is slightly faster than the original, and IMHO the original slower pace fits this song better.

[m9801]

@evergreentobe 不就是先入爲主嗎？到底在所難免。

@billy1983yes 期望香港興起新一代的歌手能青出于藍，可惜以現時的情况，難以實­現

[newstylles]

英偉!!

[drakblaze27]

actually this is kinda weird

cuz the cd version of this song is not as good as the live version

danny sing this song in his concert

n that live version is way too awsome

if u listen to that version u would know wat i mean

[nofrontiers]

of course Danny is the best!

[lwc888]

@nofrontiers no he's not.

[28kiman1]

點解Ｄ人總喜歡比較呢？可否存着欣賞之情，是對首歌同埋歌者用心­嘅演繹，一Ｄ無謂的言論已害透了多少人呢？我們已失去了很多難得­的巨星，今天唱得的已沒幾個，好好珍惜現有的---Easonc­han...永遠懷念摰愛dannychan..

[sls19057]

以前既詞　寫得真好

[wai4ever]

Danny and Eason 演繹我都喜歡, can't really compare their performance.

Just try to listen and enjoy both of them. :)

DANNY and EASON Chan are both exceptionally good singer!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!!!

[evergreentobe]

It's always the case that the original singer sings the song the best. This is not an exception. The song was tailor-made for Danny Chan, who sang it very well and full of passion. I have an album including this song and I was deeply touched by this song since childhood.

[VIPVICT]

quitegood

[mancheukho]

聽歌就要陳奕迅

[ytcy1]

I don't really care who sang this song better. They're entertainers. Entertainers need to be attractive. Between Danny and Eason, most women would choose Danny. And he was also backed up by a good voice and artistic talents. I haven't found anyone from HK who can beat him yet.

[yinevalai03]

今次佢唱Danny的歌, 又唱得幾好喎! 唔錯!

[orioberry]

吐字有情~

同意billy1983yes

"相信Danny在天之靈聽見Eason的完美演繹, 都一定會微笑"

[ymingu]

每次開youtube都要聽返次...

[myhairlosing]

As a EF, I still prefer Danny's original version. It's not about technique. Danny's voice is inherently more a "loner" voice, and fits this song better.

And Danny's live is rarely as good as his studio performance. You won't find his best performance on youtube. Go listen his CD.

[alexanderleewang]

I don't agree with that last part. Danny's live was just as good or even better with the slight change in interepretation. It was only until the beginning of the 90's when he was visibly losing his health that his live performances weren't on par... (except for the emotion)

[billy1983yes]

聽完這版本, 我故意在youtube聽番陳百強的原版. 我自己是音樂劇演員, 聽過不少人唱歌. 我覺得Eason唱得比陳百強更好. 當你聽Eason唱:

"不知一街童正踏著我影 頑童還大膽開聲...."

你好似真係看到有個小孩跟主角對話0甘, 反而我聽原版沒有那麼強的"圖畫"呈現眼前.

[billy1983yes]

無聊!

我又沒有說原唱陳百強唱得不好, 兩位歌手兩個版本其實我都喜歡, 而我本人亦很尊重他們. 你這樣說反而對已過身的Danny不敬.

我相信他在天之靈聽見Eason的完美演繹, 都一定會微笑.

[patpatandy]

妳係咪ｐａｎｄａ個個ｂｉｌｌｙ

[karyko92]

ｅａｓｏｎ係唱呢句時ｅｍｐｈａｓｉｚｅ左個踏字。，，，　ｌｏｌ

[waku1976]

@billy1983yes this comment is gay haha

[grandymui]

@billy1983yes 你講完我走左去聽陳百強版本, 我發覺danny既version都有好強烈既畫面,同樣感動! 不過分別係eason唱得傷感好多, 好似講緊自己故事. danny係講緊一個愛情故事..

[wong302006]

@billy1983yes eason 唱到有對話既感覺. 好正

[HauntedSoulz]

@billy1983yes

你聽果個係咪Live黎

因為我覺得好多時候Live都會唱得好過MV

[alextang1030]

@HauntedSoulz

我都覺得係~

特別係有實力既歌手~

不過我覺得陳百強個版本唱得快左少少

感覺好似好急咁~

[Jubiejai]

PERFECT!

[Bryanluk2007]

當我裨人發現我心裡所思考緊野

我就會笑

表面上就好似笑得好開心

[hvfunlol]

唱功是有的

但難掩唱自己尊敬的前輩的歌時會有的感動與衝動

唱得失去了歌原本應有的感傷

[kitwa123]

同意~~

唱功真係勁!!

[SEXYKAWAII]

好歌！

[manchimliu]

EASON!EASON!

[Beckham2014]

awesome!