As a foreign national, there is no explicit right of any kind for you in China, only curtsy. US can wiretap or put surveillance on foreign citizens without due course. Why not China. I seem to remember that they shot at a few Al Jazeera reporters during the Iraq invasion. I think an objective person would ask himself if he wanted to actually affect change (even slightly) to their SYSTEM of government. If the answer is yes, then you are not a journalist but an agent - BBC blurs that line on china
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
John Sweeney displays the over inflated self important attitude that makes us ashamed to be British. He acts as though he has some God given right to go where he pleases and do what he sees fit in a foreign country. His aim was clearly to paint as poor a picture of the Chinese as he could find. It would hardly be surprising if he were not allowed to return. Indeed, I may very well write to the Chinese suggesting that he gives the rest of us a bad name and he should be banned.
Give me a break. What most of this is, is corrupt LOCAL authorities who are not even obeying the laws of the central government and intimidating journalists both from outside AND inside China. And it's their OWN people they are screwing up, not foreigners. When your child is killed because a corrupt official has taken a kickback and you can't even talk about it or attend official memorials for the dead, it ain't about nationality.
Why would the West be jealous of China,Sweeney never said anything bad about China until this silly young Chinese reporter came in and started making unfounded acquisations on how the interview would be perceived, i`m all for a peaceful and understanding world but at this stage i would say the Chinese authorities are not capable of accepting any form of democracy.certainly nothing to be jealous of!!
The BBC have nothing good to say about China because the rise of China in the 21st century really making the west jealous especially after the return of Hong Kong to China.The west only happy to see a poor and weak China but they won't see that anymore because in the 21st century China will only get more and more powerful and nothing the west can do about it so BBC keep talking and fool the british public.
If you would stop thinking the West are saying things merely because they're jealous every time they don't say something good then you will get a more sober view of China
It's an inevitable fact and people have already come to terms. So grow up and read the facts about China.
Its easy to cast doubt on Chinas intentions or look for flaws in their systems. Remember that If I were to wear a T-shirt supporting Kurdish seperatists in Parliament square in London, I could be arrested and held for over a month without charge.
yes, we all have democracy issues - we always did. that is in the nature of democracy. but your kurdish t-shirt example dramatically over-states your case (which i would have agreed with, otherwise)
People have been taken to court in this country for T-Shirt slogans, thats a fact. We have recently tried People and Jailed them for " Thinking about doing something " i.e Thought Crime. We have had Brits in Guantanamo who are released with No Charge after 5 years.
well, if u can give me the details of the case of a person who was arrested and held for a month without charge for a month, for wearing a t-shirt which supported Kurdish separatists, then maybe we could talk about it, but am guessing that you made it up.
You will have to explain the "thinking about doing something" comment. Do you mean "preparing to do something"? But this forum is really about China, so maybe not.
I quote from multiple cases, the mish-mash of anti terrorism legislation imposed on the British People under this totalitarian " Government". What has happened so far is just arrest, interogation, printed and DNA samples taken then release under caution for possesion of offensive material ( The PKK shirt ) but the potential to detain has been imposed. As for my "thinking about doing something" quote The jury seems to agree with me.
Oh dear, this is getting more vague + unconvincing. So the the t-shirt was offensive, rather than politically sensitive? Seems reasonable for this person to be cautioned then. What jury? What case? When? Where?
Why have you put "Governemnt" in quotes? You don't think the British government is real?! As for "authoritarian", wasn't it voted in? We are taking up space on a page which should be about China. I live in China, if you want to see what REAL authoritarian government is like, come visit!
The BBC are fair,they also praise china where it deserves it in this program,that chinese lady at 1 min 38 secs spoke english like the queen,i must say !
john sweeny probably raised his voice...again in this episode. but BBC always talk about China's bad points, even though in britain there is more crime and democracy is slowly breaking - look at labour for example, or 'who on earth voted boris into power?' it's messed up!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
i can't help notice bbc really hates china. all news are about pollution, trailer park people, exposing olympic politics, disaster people who just lost love ones (and natural either blame god or government). old story done 1000 times, so to speak. Boring
john sweeney "lost his head" because he was being harrased by scientologists no one brain washed him instead of telling me what to search in youtube wyh dont you because there is alot of videos defending him that are true.
western propaganda
milltiaryman001 10 months ago
i don't mind being followed by this british guy
cookie246m 1 year ago
stupid human beings, we r really sinful creatures
asdjfh55 2 years ago
hatred will lead to WORLD WAR 3, it is guaranteed. Please think calmly and objectively despite the f**ing media bias!
asdjfh55 2 years ago
bust'em sweeeeeneeeeeey
pinusstrikesback 2 years ago
As a foreign national, there is no explicit right of any kind for you in China, only curtsy. US can wiretap or put surveillance on foreign citizens without due course. Why not China. I seem to remember that they shot at a few Al Jazeera reporters during the Iraq invasion. I think an objective person would ask himself if he wanted to actually affect change (even slightly) to their SYSTEM of government. If the answer is yes, then you are not a journalist but an agent - BBC blurs that line on china
peacemonger64 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
John Sweeney displays the over inflated self important attitude that makes us ashamed to be British. He acts as though he has some God given right to go where he pleases and do what he sees fit in a foreign country. His aim was clearly to paint as poor a picture of the Chinese as he could find. It would hardly be surprising if he were not allowed to return. Indeed, I may very well write to the Chinese suggesting that he gives the rest of us a bad name and he should be banned.
michael1608 3 years ago
Yes i agree, so many people in the West cannot accept cultural differences. We do not have real freedom ourselfs.
thefayed 3 years ago
Give me a break. What most of this is, is corrupt LOCAL authorities who are not even obeying the laws of the central government and intimidating journalists both from outside AND inside China. And it's their OWN people they are screwing up, not foreigners. When your child is killed because a corrupt official has taken a kickback and you can't even talk about it or attend official memorials for the dead, it ain't about nationality.
garyp2727 2 years ago
John Sweeney? Being followed? I think I'm starting to see a theme here.
TehPogo 3 years ago
Why would the West be jealous of China,Sweeney never said anything bad about China until this silly young Chinese reporter came in and started making unfounded acquisations on how the interview would be perceived, i`m all for a peaceful and understanding world but at this stage i would say the Chinese authorities are not capable of accepting any form of democracy.certainly nothing to be jealous of!!
scoobywho17 3 years ago 2
The BBC have nothing good to say about China because the rise of China in the 21st century really making the west jealous especially after the return of Hong Kong to China.The west only happy to see a poor and weak China but they won't see that anymore because in the 21st century China will only get more and more powerful and nothing the west can do about it so BBC keep talking and fool the british public.
26589580 3 years ago
If you would stop thinking the West are saying things merely because they're jealous every time they don't say something good then you will get a more sober view of China
It's an inevitable fact and people have already come to terms. So grow up and read the facts about China.
vinniechan 3 years ago 2
Its easy to cast doubt on Chinas intentions or look for flaws in their systems. Remember that If I were to wear a T-shirt supporting Kurdish seperatists in Parliament square in London, I could be arrested and held for over a month without charge.
We've all got democracy Issues now.
Markdorman 3 years ago 5
yes, we all have democracy issues - we always did. that is in the nature of democracy. but your kurdish t-shirt example dramatically over-states your case (which i would have agreed with, otherwise)
pintpot 3 years ago
People have been taken to court in this country for T-Shirt slogans, thats a fact. We have recently tried People and Jailed them for " Thinking about doing something " i.e Thought Crime. We have had Brits in Guantanamo who are released with No Charge after 5 years.
I honestly dont see how I've overstated anything.
Markdorman 3 years ago
well, if u can give me the details of the case of a person who was arrested and held for a month without charge for a month, for wearing a t-shirt which supported Kurdish separatists, then maybe we could talk about it, but am guessing that you made it up.
You will have to explain the "thinking about doing something" comment. Do you mean "preparing to do something"? But this forum is really about China, so maybe not.
Guantanamo is a disgrace, but is not in UK.
pintpot 3 years ago
I quote from multiple cases, the mish-mash of anti terrorism legislation imposed on the British People under this totalitarian " Government". What has happened so far is just arrest, interogation, printed and DNA samples taken then release under caution for possesion of offensive material ( The PKK shirt ) but the potential to detain has been imposed. As for my "thinking about doing something" quote The jury seems to agree with me.
Markdorman 3 years ago
Oh dear, this is getting more vague + unconvincing. So the the t-shirt was offensive, rather than politically sensitive? Seems reasonable for this person to be cautioned then. What jury? What case? When? Where?
Why have you put "Governemnt" in quotes? You don't think the British government is real?! As for "authoritarian", wasn't it voted in? We are taking up space on a page which should be about China. I live in China, if you want to see what REAL authoritarian government is like, come visit!
pintpot 3 years ago
The BBC are fair,they also praise china where it deserves it in this program,that chinese lady at 1 min 38 secs spoke english like the queen,i must say !
liverpooltv 3 years ago 2
john sweeny probably raised his voice...again in this episode. but BBC always talk about China's bad points, even though in britain there is more crime and democracy is slowly breaking - look at labour for example, or 'who on earth voted boris into power?' it's messed up!
PianoKwanMan 3 years ago
having the olympics in china is a joke
dalglishtheking1 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i can't help notice bbc really hates china. all news are about pollution, trailer park people, exposing olympic politics, disaster people who just lost love ones (and natural either blame god or government). old story done 1000 times, so to speak. Boring
bg24955 3 years ago
You are 100% right!
26589580 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
What a dipstick. Another Chinese bashing programme from the BBC. Yawn.
quietman18 3 years ago
lol he's always being followed whether it be by scientologists or by chinese.
He's my hero
dl615 3 years ago 10
lol its funny when he talks to people that follow him
vejaji2 3 years ago 4
John Sweeney... isn't he the guy who lost his head when being *cough* brainwashed *cough*... i mean interviewed by that scientology bloke...
MATTPARS0NS 3 years ago
no he didnt
vejaji2 3 years ago
Yeh he did, type john sweeny scientology on youtube and it comes up :-)
MATTPARS0NS 3 years ago
john sweeney "lost his head" because he was being harrased by scientologists no one brain washed him instead of telling me what to search in youtube wyh dont you because there is alot of videos defending him that are true.
vejaji2 3 years ago
John Sweeney is great.
doggie101171 3 years ago