@s1earle Horowitz does not pound, he interprets - needless to say Horowitz's interpretation is so much better than MAH or Ponti that it's a waste of time to compare :-)
@Bret6464 Seems surely that you are really uneducated in good music; Both Horowitz and Cziffra made their respective names with abundant technical accomplishments but both faltered poorly when the music demanded virtuosity - they had to resort to bombastics to get past the difficulties; this has been proven time and time again in their performances. Compare with the dynamics and good sounds coming from Backhaus, Kempff, Wild etc.: Now they and their peers were the performers of note...
@Bret6464 Do you read or just show your ills? - The peers of the pianists I mentioned also include the ones you mentioned - Gilels (and Richter), Moiseiwitsch, the great Alexis, and the list goes on: Kempff is one of the great talents perhaps more sonorous than "poor Hofmann" - best you get your finger out long enough to put your head in your ass, only then might your foul ears be your destiny...
@Bret6464 Yes you're right - if one mixes to a fool then one becomes one , even though one might be an unrespected elder of lacking experience - Yep, I'll take a cold shower and chill out...Sorry to have hit your spark of disrespect and foolishness...
wow! he sure has a way of making the sound so orchestral ... which is probably what rach intended with all those dense harmonies. He totally shreds that 3rd movement!!! ... I wonder if her ever recorded/played the 1st sonata ... it's even more orchestral than this one.
@nathanscoleman Unfortunately he hasn't played the 1st Sonata, or at least it wasn't recorded. I'd love to hear him playing that one, I like that Sonata so much.
Marc andre has real power in his playing. No doubt about it. But the beauty of the slow section especially in building upto a climax is not bettered by Horowitz later version.
I agree with the comment that the first version is much better
ranwanguva 2 weeks ago
I think the first version much better than second.
bende85 2 weeks ago
Tremendous virtuosity and musicianship.What a sonority!Bravissississimo!!
abmsghost1 1 month ago
Kapustin got influenced by this piece im sure! especially at the slower parts starting about 7:15
L4RSLink 2 months ago in playlist Favorite videos
such intensity! a really intense car ride.
FlyingBlackAndWhite 3 months ago
Mirrors the perfect performance by Ponti; and somewhat proves that the pounding of Horowitz was not needed to make an impact.
s1earle 5 months ago
@s1earle Horowitz does not pound, he interprets - needless to say Horowitz's interpretation is so much better than MAH or Ponti that it's a waste of time to compare :-)
Bret6464 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Bret6464 Seems surely that you are really uneducated in good music; Both Horowitz and Cziffra made their respective names with abundant technical accomplishments but both faltered poorly when the music demanded virtuosity - they had to resort to bombastics to get past the difficulties; this has been proven time and time again in their performances. Compare with the dynamics and good sounds coming from Backhaus, Kempff, Wild etc.: Now they and their peers were the performers of note...
s1earle 4 months ago
Comment removed
Bret6464 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Bret6464 Do you read or just show your ills? - The peers of the pianists I mentioned also include the ones you mentioned - Gilels (and Richter), Moiseiwitsch, the great Alexis, and the list goes on: Kempff is one of the great talents perhaps more sonorous than "poor Hofmann" - best you get your finger out long enough to put your head in your ass, only then might your foul ears be your destiny...
s1earle 3 months ago
Comment removed
Bret6464 3 months ago
@Bret6464 Yes you're right - if one mixes to a fool then one becomes one , even though one might be an unrespected elder of lacking experience - Yep, I'll take a cold shower and chill out...Sorry to have hit your spark of disrespect and foolishness...
s1earle 3 months ago
@s1earle Likewise - I am deleting my comments, and my apology to you
Bret6464 3 months ago
Comment removed
rarescores 5 months ago
wow! he sure has a way of making the sound so orchestral ... which is probably what rach intended with all those dense harmonies. He totally shreds that 3rd movement!!! ... I wonder if her ever recorded/played the 1st sonata ... it's even more orchestral than this one.
nathanscoleman 6 months ago
@nathanscoleman Unfortunately he hasn't played the 1st Sonata, or at least it wasn't recorded. I'd love to hear him playing that one, I like that Sonata so much.
madlovba3 6 months ago 3
@madlovba3 me too! It was the first Rach piece I ever spent my own money on ... I still have that Boosey & Hawkes blue copy!
nathanscoleman 6 months ago
@madlovba3 Indeed. The first is so special to me. I wonder why this one is historically more popular?
myfmhighlights 2 months ago
Those last chords sound like an exploding bomb :)
titusbeertsen 6 months ago
Marc andre has real power in his playing. No doubt about it. But the beauty of the slow section especially in building upto a climax is not bettered by Horowitz later version.
gjeacocke 6 months ago
beautiful...
ansonyeung825 6 months ago