Red Dead Redemption: PS3 vs 360 Comparison

[RIKONTFS]

PC wins!

[gt362gamer]

anyway ps3 is amazing, but thanks to the lazy devs. i think that ps3 + xbox 360 is the real gen. actually is pretty late, i dont know what 2 do...

[gt362gamer]

and this dont happen only in rdr, my friend have a xbox and gta4, it looks ok, gta 4 in ps3 look horrible, jaggies are annoying, and the game looks like there were oil in the screen.

[FrickinTipsY]

i dont about this miniscule diffrence between graphics im gonna buy xbox360 cause i LIKE it more

[podar124]

xbox 360 has better graphics in this because what i saw is that on the ps3 version it is alot more blured and less shar than in the 360 version

[gt362gamer]

@Szubakable 360 have 1080p UPSCALED

[gt362gamer]

@Szubakable mmm, 256+256=512, same ram, better gpu=xbox, better cpu=ps3, so multi games are usually better in xbox, and exclusive games, ps3.

[littleAE86thatcould]

@gt362gamer Yes finally someone gets it. look at the shadows on xbox, more sharp and bettter rendering.

[gt362gamer]

@littleAE86thatcould im disapointed because the game in ps3, sucks, i cant see nothing, because, if i see grass, there arent nothing, resolution? jaggies all over the place, the shadows draw distance is bullshit, it loads in your head, same with textures, that are blurred too. Then i put uncharted 2 and i say... this look a lot better, why can all games look like u2? (i know why, lazy rockstar and company, im tired of this, im going to buy xbox just for this game and gears!

[gt362gamer]

@Szubakable ram= same (xbox 512, ps3 256+256), cpu way better in ps3, gpu better in xbox.

[gt362gamer]

@jjc032681 in rdr 360 have better graphics, but in exclusives, ps3 wins by far. Example:

Uncharted 3 vs GeOW, Kilzone vs Halo, etc

[gt362gamer]

@potatismos112 yes, im dissappointed with rockstar, they made better graphics in xbox, and ps3 owners (like me) have an inferior game.

[gt362gamer]

@MegaDragonZombie blind

[gt362gamer]

@Uwjake sorry, but battlefield 3 looks better on ps3, AC are tie, crysis 2 bad port, rockstar games pretty bad ports.

[gt362gamer]

@littleAE86thatcould xbox supports 720p and ps3 640p... 1080p? in your dreams xD.

[gt362gamer]

@BudzMcgr33n mmm l.a noire? battlefield 3? final fantasy XIII? Portal 2? Sorry, rdr is way better in xbox, but it isnt better always. have a nice day

[gt362gamer]

@GoulouMalouku PC>>>>>>PS3>XBOX360>>>>>>>>>>>­WII (in graphics)

[arisconstantino]

PS3 BY PURE DOMINATION!

[brizzlestick]

360 uses ATI/AMD.. PS3 uses NVIDIA.. so there you go...

[chromeinox]

I own a xbox 360 but I'm no fanboy. But even watching this video in sd you can see that the 360 has sharper visuals. Want proof? Just look at the ground when the 360 appears after the ps3. It's evident that the 360 has a slight advantage in having MSAA instead of that blurred imitation on the ps3.

[BlackWidowZ93]

To bad i own a 360 and PS3. Both great consoles <3 But Uncharted 3 is immence!

[Xtube25]

Saaame??, botth??

[pavan50tola]

coding a game on ps3 is really very hard..all the 7SPEs have to be utilized; which most of the game programmers fail to. PS3 has nearly 40-45% more processing power which is unused and is called untapped power. If game programmers could utilize(learn to utilize) the untapped power, PS3 will lead the xbox. As of now it seems xbox is better but, it isnt.

[NewLynxS]

@pavan50tola First of all, there is nothing called "untapped power". Second, developers don't use the six SPEs (not seven, as one of them is reserved for XMB) not because they don't know how to, but because it doesn't make financial sense to invest in that on multiplatform games. And finally, every hardware has potentially unused processing power. It's no different for Xenon and desktop CPUs than it is for Cell, you never achieve 100% of the theoretical peak performance.

[peteyjay328]

PS3 is better and i have a 360....

[gt362gamer]

@peteyjay328 are you blind? i wish i have a xbox, it looks a lot better in>head to head> rdr>lens of truth

[fatzmember]

got both

[TheMasterzabo]

I like turtles

[sebu46]

xbox 360 is better

[Cralfinsamhiemnater]

Aside from its slightly lower resolution, the odd issue with the PS3 version is that it it seems to be missing 50% of the grass and foliage from the 360 version. It really makes the landscapes look more barren and less detailed. I'm not sure why Rockstar's games always end up looking better on the Xbox 360...

[apsinthion]

the bit at 00:25 when hes walking to the fort, the 360 sky looks like paint and doesnt look as real as the ps3 version, but thats only real difference in whole vid. can argue forever and people have for years, but end of the day ps3 is the stronger console and has potential too produce the best games, hence 13 1 disk on ps3 3 on xbox with framerate issues, think how many disks mgs4 would be on 360 too.

[dasoldier91]

I'm sorry but you have to be blind not to see the difference. Xbox is better with the textures and other small details. Other than that no matter what console you have it is a great game.

[rushlessons101]

360 looks better sometimes, but really, its almost no difference

[iDontBeTrollin]

I've had both 360 and ps3 but the ps3 looks better

[coolgriff]

I have a PS3 and a Xbox but i got to say xbox..

[AK1000ism]

Almost  the SAME! 360 better

[WWEAttitude266]

ps3 is better

[KemalTheOne]

@WWEAttitude266 no its not



[ReddeadRedemption724]

@WWEAttitude266 You need glasses, mate.

[WWEAttitude266]

@ReddeadRedemption724 nope, all tv's have different settings and my red dead looks much better then this, and just because a game looks lighter it doesn't mean it's actually better

[ReddeadRedemption724]

@WWEAttitude266 Yeah i agree. It actually depends whitch Tv you are using.

[zinx43267]

@WWEAttitude266 actually 360 is because, the big reason is you dont get hacked on 360, or at least not as much as u do on ps3

[WWEAttitude266]

@zinx43267 does't xbox get hacked every day by fraudsters? ahahah fail, and atleast the ps3 has exclusives, better graphics and we don't get rrod! nice try, now go back to you're kinectbix

[zinx43267]

@WWEAttitude266 the exclusives r the only things better on the ps3 than the 360, 360 has better graphicsand better online network, despite having to pay but it is worth it

[WWEAttitude266]

@zinx43267 better graphics? bahahha then why did uncharted 3 win best graphics beating battlefield 3 pc, gtfo

[Jonereator2]

@zinx43267 No ps3 has better graphics, it's more powerful in any way. However it's easier too develop games for xbox that's why games for multiple consoles usually looks better on xbox. Like uncharted is waaaay ahead graphics wise of any xbox game.

[789reishram]

@WWEAttitude266 all platforms have exclusives, so no reason to exclude all the others....just saying..*cough* ps3 ftw *cough*

[littleAE86thatcould]

@WWEAttitude266 you must really know what your talking about.

[UtopianEnrico]

Hard to tell but I think Xbox is just tiny bit better it looks more bright too

[Radiohead4121]

Dat Bass

[mannkiller0786]

360 is better

[Caesarslegion1]

I really don't think there is ever any noticeable difference in these videos-from an xbox player

[dean44100]

my favorite part of this game is when you first go to mexico and de santa completely bullshits you and then yells "welcome to mexico!"

[danilofoxify]

ps3 намного круче сраного xbox360

[triickmaster246]

Thumbs up if you got PS3

[MrRjSalem]

to be honest , i have both consoles and the game for both , graphics are really sucks which means i change the display settings on the ps3 for every 5 minutes from sunshine to sundown , especially when i watch the cut scenes of the game.

XLGT : RJ Salem

PSN ID : KickerGTR

[PetsANDGames98]

I have this game on ps3 it doesnt look like this wtf

[dean44100]

@PetsANDGames98 if youre not using an HDMI cable, it wont have the best picture

[PetsANDGames98]

@dean44100 no i meant that the ps3 looks better than this

[666BrotherofMetal]

They both look the same to me....sept ps3's a lil bit darker.

[CJBombaYe]

i h8 consoles. shame this game isnt on PC

[666BrotherofMetal]

@CJBombaYe Thats the same as a console.

[CJBombaYe]

@666BrotherofMetal

your point is irrelevant. ppl know what I mean including yourself

[666BrotherofMetal]

@CJBombaYe Your life is irrelevant. Cheeky prick.

[lpsided]

@CJBombaYe you hate consoles just because everyone kicks your ass and the only way you are actually good on pc is using hacks

[CJBombaYe]

@lpsided

lol, i h8 consoles coz they're obsolete and i don't use cheats

[triickmaster246]

@CJBombaYe it's so obvious you're a PC gamer by the shit why you type. starting with "lol" saying "coz" and "h8"

Consoles for the win bitch. Try getting this game for PC.

[CJBombaYe]

@triickmaster246

my initial comment was, "shame this game isn't on PC", einstein.

[javiergtaV]

pendejo estupido el PS3 es meor que el xbox 360



[cooby95]

ps3

[IrougeshadowI]

its the same thing godamet

[Alagamerful]

xbox360 wins, flawless victory!!!!

[darthmaul446]

ps3 = heavy rain infamous

xbox 360 = halo unforgetible multiplayer expeience

buy both

[PetsANDGames98]

@ElatedTheGame why is ur comment flagged wtf trolls

[ElatedTheGame]

@PetsANDGames98 Haters gonna hate :)

[plonkgenius72]

EVERYBODY SHUT UP there are no "best consloe"i think there are both awesome thumps up if you argree.

[joker43602]

funny how all these comparison videos have so many dislikes. lol

[coco3423]

Xbox 360 :)

[KnightRider1216]

snake deadly go fuck ur self they are both the same

[snakedeadly]

0:23 SEE SEE! SEE THAT BIRD THERE AT THE XBOX 360 VERSION! that proves that the Xbox 360 is better! THE PS3 IS TOO LAZY TO RENDER AND CREATE A OBJECT!

[Sirwest299]

@snakedeadly You are an idiot. Just because one bird doesn't appear in a cutscene, you assume the PS3 doesn't have birds? I have the PS3 version and it does have birds. It has the exact same detail the Xbox 360 version has. Including birds. Idiot.

[snakedeadly]

@Sirwest299 And your a idiot for thinking that this is true Ever herd of the word, Joke?

[ThatLostNoob94]

they look pretty much the same, the xbox has less jaggies but it also looks like play dough.

[o0Zzzz0o]

I hate GayBox

[slashrules83]

@o0Zzzz0o I Hate Gaystation 3

[MADMADMORDO]

The ps3 is better because they used an HDMI cable

[TheBauernmax]

Ganz Ehrlich xbox 360 ist besser.....aber nur wegen Bestechungsgeldern von Microsoft genau wie bei Skyrim :D

[NonTrollJoke]

I saw it! 360 version has bird

[atalis1]

Xbox is a little more brighter

[XxFletyzzxX]

thumbs up if you got xbox360

[GamesX4XtheXwin]

@XxFletyzzxX ,WOW i thought more people had an xbox 360

[SSTheGamer98]

@XxFletyzzxX Thumbs upif you have xbox 360 AND ps3!!!

btw. the ps3 is the best !!! the only games i play on my xbox is the halo games, alan wake and the gears of war games and fable!!!

[Xtube25]

@XxFletyzzxX *Thumbs down*

[SuperFunnyman001]

the 360 version looks better. it runs at a higher resolution. the end.

[MrXxsnipesXx]

well, the ps3 does look better, because the sky on the xbox 360 version looks painted on

[gt362gamer]

@MrXxsnipesXx i have ps3, but rdr is a pretty bad port of xbox.

[cabercat]

lol xbox uses dvd's while ps3 uses bluray discs i mean really there is no comparison

[SuperFunnyman001]

@cabercat do you even know anything?

[Milomia9]

In a game with such great scenery, the graphics matter so much more. I might get a 360 in a few years (if they werent stupid enough to start the 720 already) since theres a couple exclusives I want.

[Milomia9]

Guys, admit it. Just because you buy a game system doesnt remove all its flaws. besides, look at skyrim. It varies by game.

[Milomia9]

They seem about the same actally. The Ps3 graphics just look more blurred together and the the quality isnt that high, which can make it hard to tell anyway. Isnt that called antistropic-filtering or is that something else?

[lolitsme50]

Xbox looks better, and if Xbox wasn't a scam I would have picked it for that platform instead.

[Diztryx]

360.

[Vladi0951]

I think the 360 is better

[Zanbatoss]

i'm planning to switch to xbox, my ps3 has a pretty bad framerates in some games while 360 delivers smooth FPS, i can't stand it anymore

[gt362gamer]

@Zanbatoss no, buy xbox, but dont sell ps3, im thinking to buy an xbox too, but never sell ps3. uncharted, the last of us, killzone...

[JeppeGutt]

RDR looks better on 360. It's a fact not an opinion.

[undead12335]

@JeppeGutt its true

[horridroadwar]

i just got the xbox because it was cheaper.

[omph98]

Xbox looks way better

[NextGenGameSystem]

Am I seeing double or is it just me?

[marcitos66]

Ps3 looks Better

[parcofantasma]

:yaoming:



[AV3D1]

xbox 360 has better resolution

[frankytap]

from my experience, the ps3 has better shadows then xbox. But on this game ive discovered alot of more bugs and glichtes on the ps3 version then the xbox. But maybe thats fixed now.

[19HajimeSaitou91]

Triggernometry i love this track

[mcgeehe]

Developers makes games for Xbox then port them to the PS3, therefor the game is actually better on Xbox. I have both versions (Orginal on PS3 and GOT Edition on Xbox) and the Xbox is the better version on every level IMHO. The PS3 version is still great though.

Fact

[frankytap]

@mcgeehe whats included in the GOTY? i have the orig but bought undead, and got the lairs and the other dlc

[Robbzzify]

is it only me that knows all you have to do is fuck around with the display colours to make them exactly the same?

[Idontloveyougeenu]

They are the same. Dont get your panties in an knot .

[muffenman1245]

pc for the win

[pablooverlord]

@muffenman1245 this game isn.t available for pc fucking stupid

[blackdreamr]

responding to purely this video and not going into a debate on the consoles themselves, I didn't see a whole lot of difference anyway. The only thing I could point out between them was the colour of the sky at one point.

[TheIrkenBrittany]

Ps3 just looks darker and blurrier...nty I'm happy with my 360. :|

[mark79135]

360 have a 360

[Xav04021996]

Ps3 is have the real color

[pablooverlord]

@Xav04021996 fucking stupid thats is false, because you can adjust the colors .... and the definition of textures is better in xbox 360,the framerate is te best in xbox, because it have 512 mb of ram , and the ps3 have 256 mb only

[strean333]

@pablooverlord retard, console wars are pointless...they're both the same

[elmoskater]

@pablooverlord lol u fool ps3 has better ram it has 2 rams both 256mb each eaqualling to the same as 512mb except ps3s rams better becuase xbox has 512mb of GDDR3 @ 700mhz but ps3 has 256mb of GDDR3 ram at 700mhz and then 256mb of xdr ram @ 3.2ghz which means ps3s has much better and more powerful ram and as for frame rate more ps3 games have 60 frames per second then xbox most xbox games are only 30 frames a second and ps3 has the best texture of the 2 thanks 2 bluray

[dndeee]

@pablooverlord How bout knowing about how stuff works before posting idiotic posts like this? Xbox RAM is misleading since the system RAM and video RAM are shared. The PS3 XDR RAM is also faster and more efficient than the Xbox's. PS3: 3,2 GHz Xbox 700 Mhz.

Fact.

[MegaKiller219]

@Xav04021996 no xbox have the real colour fucking fanboy

[Shenanigans07]

@MegaKiller219 You sound like a fanboy. It has nothing to do with colour. YES the xbox has the better graphics on RDR and most multi-platform games. It doesn't have "real colour" the regression in graphics happens on the PS3 because games are created for the xbox and then ported onto the PS3.

The xbox couldn't handle a game like Uncharted 3, for example. And I'm not a fanboy, That's just fact. I have an Xbox 360 and a PS3.

[iPixelGuns]

@Xav04021996

You is have bad grammar.

[gt362gamer]

@Xav04021996 and xbox the real grass xD.

[dethcon5002]

playing a game for it's graphics is like watching porn for the storyline.

hopefully, in the future, we'll all learn not to give a fuck.

[Gam3rkidz1]

WHO FUCKING CARES ABOUT WHICH SYSTEM'S GRAPHCIS ARE BETTER THERE PRETTY MUCH THE SAME AND WHO CARES I ONLY CARE FOR GAMEPLAY

[11cobu]

I dont hate the xbox 360 i just prefer the ps3

[EmoGrapefruit]

@11cobu its obvious that xbox is extremly better, plus we have halo. you have little big planet, wooptie fuckin doo!

[11cobu]

@EmoGrapefruit why so much hate if i just said i dont hate xbox i just prefer the ps3 i wasnt talking shit

[nathan7687]

@EmoGrapefruit but ps3 has blu ray and xbox doesnt

[elmoskater]

@EmoGrapefruit lol halos shit land we actuallyn have resistance 1 2 n3 which is an alien game but its way better then halo plus we havee god of wars 1 2 3 and killzone 2n3 and metal gear solid 4 and rachet and clanks aswelln as uncharted 1 2 3 and heaps more

[TheHockeygod6666]

Ps3

[Bipolar10001]

better on xbox 360

[pixelsblack]

The PS3 actually looks better here, I guess it depends on the game, some games may have better quality on the PS3 some better on the 360

[gt362gamer]

@pixelsblack this look better in xbox 360, is a port for ps3, so it looks worse.

[ymcmgamer]

Ps3 is better it looks just like a movie xbox it looks like a cartoon tht my opinion

[tasr09]

the ps3 looks like is was recorded with a blurry camera.

[tasr09]

Xbox does look a little better but theres not enough of a difference to really pick a side.

[DeathmetalRK]

IMO Xbox version looks a bit more HQ.

[V4NN1LLANOV4]

at like the end you can jus see that the ground on the xbox has more texture! but EXACTLY THE SAME!!!

[DrGreenThumbNZL]

Xbox RDR = 720p native

Ps3 RDR = 640p native

Xbox wins again

[gt362gamer]

@DrGreenThumbNZL yes, because rockstar didnt work enough in ps3 version.

[LukeDuke9997]

both but i like PS3

[jessex69]

x360

[Caspian922]

Xbox 360 is a lot of better including graphics, shadows, textures... But PS3 is also good.. :D

[Noieter]

i have tried this game in both consoles, fun to play in both with awesome environments but in some areas i think xbox works better, specially the shadows and textures

[ecxlex]

Imho Ps3 Has slightly more Realistic Lighting Not as Warm But its all preference and really the gameplay so yeah BEST OF BOTH WORLDS (jesus that was a terrible song)

[Joshisalobster]

It's funny how just about every comment I see is about how much the Xbox 360 is better or how much the PS3 is better. I have tried both the Xbox 360 and the PS3 and you want to know what I think? They are both the same damn thing. Both have great performance, great graphics, and both support fun games. So. . .who cares? It is honestly not that big of a deal.

[DRAGOON2ONIONKNIGHT]

@Joshisalobster I think all this is. Is a means to start a flame war.

[simwarn]

@Joshisalobster well that is because it increases the size of your penis and makes your balls juiceyer making it fresh and nice to suck. it makes you ass more firm and tight and makes your sack more sreachey and and your penis nicer to smell and contense the maten nae with you sack

[Michaelmifsud017]

@Joshisalobster you ma'am, are wrong

[sperrow478]

@Joshisalobster but but, the graphics is equal, everyone knows, but the both two have games only for the type of console, this is a big shit of the rivals sony and microsoft.

[sgtarmy10]

I don't get it

[johnie1992]

Analy raped fucking fanboys why don't you shove a pen up your dickhole? I own both consoles and I can easily tell that the Xbox version is quite better. But you know that already. Anyway that doesn't mean Xbox is better than the ps3 or anything like that... Just a better port that's all. Now get the pen out of your dick and suck it hard. Fuck you fanboys (of any platform and company). Cheers!

[Joehashungry]

ps3 way better and doesnt even have the hdmi lol

[sshers1]

GTA V should be only on xbox

and ps3 can play COD because there one is free.