He's not Dan and he's not better or worse, just different. and I am digging the differences! Can't wait to hear what they come up with now! I think Dan sounds epic with Skyharbour, I hope that takes off too!
I really liked the original version of this song with Dan's vocals. People are saying that we shouldn't compare the two singers and should judge them on their own merit, but to redo the song with a different vocalist is making a direct comparison. As good as the new singer is, please don't redo the old stuff, make something new with your own touch, I'm sure it will be fantastic. 'One' was my favourite album of 2011 and it was Dan's vocals that made it so amazing.
I actually like Elliots voice alot. The only thing im really worried about are the lyrcis...I feel that Dan had a very mature style of writing with alot of spiritual experience in it, which really drew me to TesseracT in the first place. I hope Elliot doesnt ruin this band with garbage lyrcis since he WAS in Sky Eats Airplanes at one point in time (horrible lyrcis =p)
people are like stop giving elliot shit..i'm not the song in general has changed
it's shortet
no ambient sections
way over complicated and way over produced with effects
to loud
the feel is ruined
the clarity is gone. just my look on it, i guess it's because the original eden means alot to me and reminds me of so many memories... dan's voice is better, elliot is an amazing singer he really is, but i loved dans voices because it intertwined with the melodies better and his screams were emotional
The original version is unbeatable. It's a Dan's song. This one sounds good, but it will never be better that the first Eden. And, also, it's longer; that's a plus point for me.
The more I hear this version, the more I prefer it over Dan's version. Elliot just brings something else to the table. It has soul; His melody sways with the music. I just really really enjoy it. I just wish I could hear the full song. Perhaps one day.
How many of you truly paid very much attention to TesseracT with Dan? It seems that after he left and was replaced by Elliot that the band started to gain more recognition. Dan was a damn good vocalist, but he left. Elliot is a damn good vocalist, and he's the current vocalist. Get used to it already. He's a nice guy and gives it his all on stage, so why can't you give him a chance? There are lineup changes all the time. A band can't suit ALL of your needs, so either accept the band or move on.
some of the words in the lyrics should sang in a powerful (screaming) voice like what Dan's did in the original version... now, it's gone... it's like lossing a feeling for a song..
@jan2xmotionmusic Dan has a really well-developed vocal fry, which Elliot appears not to have. His screams are typically death growl or false chord. In my opinion, it's just best if he sings because his voice is amazing anyway.
What is wrong with change? Why does everyone seem to be afraid of it? People need to stop bitching about Elliot and lighten up a bit. Ye are too attached to Dan.. Ye need to allow for change to happen. I guarantee what they are doing with Elliot at the moment will blow your minds. Just wait.
Both are good. I fucking LOVE Dan's voice so it's hard to hear this with someone else, but Elliot does okay here. I didn't like the new demo though...
tbh, you could show both this and the original to someone who hasnt heard either one and they wouldnt be able to tell which one came first. they are just different. both are pretty great in my opinion, but i do perfer the original.
I think Elliot's voice really suits this song well. But I think for Elliot you need sort of an aquired taste for his kind of vocals, his remind me that of Cedric Zavala from the Mars Volta just a little less extreme. Oh well I like it. It's different.
All I can read is fucking spastics with possibly little or no musical background. Both vocalists were chosen by the other members of the band for a reason; they're both brilliant vocalists. both have their pros and cons, but personal opinions from youtube viewers won't give you your preference 100% of the time. Both singers do an amazing job with the song, as do the other musicians in creating such a good song. Get over the Dan Vs. Elliot shit and respect the music for the music.
@BetweenTheBuriedAndI :P There ARE a lot more of us out there. I think the majority of the time we just sigh at the ignorant comments and move on. No real need to state our opinions about THEIR opinions I reckon.
Damn theres a lot of elliot hate going around. I fell in love with elliots voice from his Zelliack stuff and was introduced to tesseract through him so I'm on the opposite end of the spectrum (not saying Dan isn't amazing) Give Elliot a chance to put out an album before you hate, he's doing his best to cover Dan's stuff. I'm sure the new material will accompany Elliot's vocal style a lot better.
Really? You guys think I don't know anything? I know Dan left to go back to Piano. All I'm saying is Dan is what made them amazing. Elliot just sounds stupid. I know plenty you idiots. I don't make judgments without knowing the full story. Feel free to try and sound all cool by insulting a guy with a different opinion than you
@KsrDragon what you said isn't exactly an opinion, is more like a bunch of insults c: , at the end of the day, Only the guys from TesseracT can choose what they want to do with their music, I loved Dan's voice, but Elliot is great too, and I don't think that he is singing in his ''comfort zone'' in this song
@KsrDragon Dont' be a fucking idiot, don't assume. They didn't get rid of him, so you're wrong. He left, asshole. And I was told this by Acle Kahney himself, so don't even try to fucking argue.
@KsrDragon He left voluntarily...to go do this: /watch?v=BMnBo9ZUftM (how's that for girly?) So you tell me who's the whiney bitch here. (hint: that would be you)
@BetweenTheBuriedAndI I don't mind it either haha (with his voice how could anyone? and I spend more time listening to non-metal than I do listening to metal) I'm just pointing out how silly his "girly sounding singer" argument is. Besides, listen to Immaterial by Haunted Shores and tell me that Elliot Coleman is girly sounding; his growls are pretty sick.
I was sad to learn that Dan was leaving the band, but tbh Elliot really makes this song perfect.. his odd voice just makes it right
Can't wait for a new album containing song actaully made for him ;)
UrbanSpower 5 days ago
TesseracT will be awesome whoever they have as a vocalist, in my opinion elliot does a very good job
thedoomisfresh 1 week ago
He's not Dan and he's not better or worse, just different. and I am digging the differences! Can't wait to hear what they come up with now! I think Dan sounds epic with Skyharbour, I hope that takes off too!
shREDhead44 1 week ago
@shREDhead44 Dan also sings with Piano, beautiful stuff
BetweenTheBuriedAndI 1 week ago
I really liked the original version of this song with Dan's vocals. People are saying that we shouldn't compare the two singers and should judge them on their own merit, but to redo the song with a different vocalist is making a direct comparison. As good as the new singer is, please don't redo the old stuff, make something new with your own touch, I'm sure it will be fantastic. 'One' was my favourite album of 2011 and it was Dan's vocals that made it so amazing.
ademus4 3 weeks ago
I actually like Elliots voice alot. The only thing im really worried about are the lyrcis...I feel that Dan had a very mature style of writing with alot of spiritual experience in it, which really drew me to TesseracT in the first place. I hope Elliot doesnt ruin this band with garbage lyrcis since he WAS in Sky Eats Airplanes at one point in time (horrible lyrcis =p)
Almost5768 3 weeks ago
@Almost5768 Nah, most of the stuff that Elliot writes for his own projects have good lyrics. Check out some OMNOM (Of Man Not Of Machine)
PPPatrickWWW 3 weeks ago
@PPPatrickWWW will do
Almost5768 2 weeks ago
people are like stop giving elliot shit..i'm not the song in general has changed
it's shortet
no ambient sections
way over complicated and way over produced with effects
to loud
the feel is ruined
the clarity is gone. just my look on it, i guess it's because the original eden means alot to me and reminds me of so many memories... dan's voice is better, elliot is an amazing singer he really is, but i loved dans voices because it intertwined with the melodies better and his screams were emotional
UltimateBadAssesUBA 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
The original version is unbeatable. It's a Dan's song. This one sounds good, but it will never be better that the first Eden. And, also, it's longer; that's a plus point for me.
rodrigobreaks 1 month ago
Comment removed
rodrigobreaks 1 month ago
The more I hear this version, the more I prefer it over Dan's version. Elliot just brings something else to the table. It has soul; His melody sways with the music. I just really really enjoy it. I just wish I could hear the full song. Perhaps one day.
ianguitarist4 1 month ago 4
Luke Holland Brought me here
iwillwait 1 month ago 11
@iwillwait Good to know that he still listens to good music now that he drums for Tyler Carter...
BetweenTheBuriedAndI 1 month ago 11
@BetweenTheBuriedAndI hahahahahahhaa
ACDCwarmachine 3 weeks ago
this guy is amazing O.O
Even though I like the old singer, this one does have a amazing voice! Looking forward to hear more! :D
Hauntedundead 1 month ago
I really have nothing against the new singer he just as good as the old one if not better, this version is just too short.
MissterMachine 1 month ago
How many of you truly paid very much attention to TesseracT with Dan? It seems that after he left and was replaced by Elliot that the band started to gain more recognition. Dan was a damn good vocalist, but he left. Elliot is a damn good vocalist, and he's the current vocalist. Get used to it already. He's a nice guy and gives it his all on stage, so why can't you give him a chance? There are lineup changes all the time. A band can't suit ALL of your needs, so either accept the band or move on.
JustinDunwiddie 1 month ago
some of the words in the lyrics should sang in a powerful (screaming) voice like what Dan's did in the original version... now, it's gone... it's like lossing a feeling for a song..
jan2xmotionmusic 1 month ago
@jan2xmotionmusic Dan has a really well-developed vocal fry, which Elliot appears not to have. His screams are typically death growl or false chord. In my opinion, it's just best if he sings because his voice is amazing anyway.
vbsasquatch1 1 month ago
And I heard this version first..
Progg3 1 month ago
Doesnt compare to dans performance. This feels rushed.
Progg3 1 month ago
What is wrong with change? Why does everyone seem to be afraid of it? People need to stop bitching about Elliot and lighten up a bit. Ye are too attached to Dan.. Ye need to allow for change to happen. I guarantee what they are doing with Elliot at the moment will blow your minds. Just wait.
InHolyTravisWeTrust 1 month ago
i didnt think i would like the new singer but i really like this but for the material on one Dans better
phreestylesk8r 2 months ago
Both are good. I fucking LOVE Dan's voice so it's hard to hear this with someone else, but Elliot does okay here. I didn't like the new demo though...
ctuliebs 2 months ago
tbh, you could show both this and the original to someone who hasnt heard either one and they wouldnt be able to tell which one came first. they are just different. both are pretty great in my opinion, but i do perfer the original.
kurukq 2 months ago
I think Elliot's voice really suits this song well. But I think for Elliot you need sort of an aquired taste for his kind of vocals, his remind me that of Cedric Zavala from the Mars Volta just a little less extreme. Oh well I like it. It's different.
mrfreedomthomas 2 months ago
he's ok the new guy. but daniel was amazing. I miss him
fantotzii 2 months ago
All I can read is fucking spastics with possibly little or no musical background. Both vocalists were chosen by the other members of the band for a reason; they're both brilliant vocalists. both have their pros and cons, but personal opinions from youtube viewers won't give you your preference 100% of the time. Both singers do an amazing job with the song, as do the other musicians in creating such a good song. Get over the Dan Vs. Elliot shit and respect the music for the music.
Snippless 2 months ago 33
@Snippless Thank you. You're the first person who see's it the way I do from what I've seen
BetweenTheBuriedAndI 2 months ago 11
@BetweenTheBuriedAndI :P There ARE a lot more of us out there. I think the majority of the time we just sigh at the ignorant comments and move on. No real need to state our opinions about THEIR opinions I reckon.
Brendanlikesthis 2 weeks ago
@Snippless Sick burn
It's not like Tesseract is going to look at these comments and say, "Wow, we need to go get Dan back."
FrakTheGods2011 2 months ago
Everything Elliot's voice touches turns to gold... and this song was already awesome.
gleeoch 2 months ago
its good. i just think the old version had more umph. know what i mean?
Uzielsquibb 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
╭━━━━━━━━━╮╭┓┈┈┏╮
┃┈┈┈┈┈┈┈┈┈┃┃╰╮╭╯┃
┃┈┈┈┈┈┈┈┈┈┃╰━┓┏━╯
┃┈┈┈┈┈-●┈┈┈╰━━╯┃
┣━━━━━━╯┈┈┈┈┈┈┃
╰━━━━━━━━━━━━━╯
poopynuggetmetalteer 3 months ago
Damn theres a lot of elliot hate going around. I fell in love with elliots voice from his Zelliack stuff and was introduced to tesseract through him so I'm on the opposite end of the spectrum (not saying Dan isn't amazing) Give Elliot a chance to put out an album before you hate, he's doing his best to cover Dan's stuff. I'm sure the new material will accompany Elliot's vocal style a lot better.
Babeman12 3 months ago
Really? You guys think I don't know anything? I know Dan left to go back to Piano. All I'm saying is Dan is what made them amazing. Elliot just sounds stupid. I know plenty you idiots. I don't make judgments without knowing the full story. Feel free to try and sound all cool by insulting a guy with a different opinion than you
KsrDragon 3 months ago
@KsrDragon what you said isn't exactly an opinion, is more like a bunch of insults c: , at the end of the day, Only the guys from TesseracT can choose what they want to do with their music, I loved Dan's voice, but Elliot is great too, and I don't think that he is singing in his ''comfort zone'' in this song
gonzachuncho 2 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Dan was better. Screw Elliot. TesseracT used to be my favorite, until they got rid of the best singer. Now they suck with a girly sounding singer.
KsrDragon 3 months ago
@KsrDragon Those are some strong words
BetweenTheBuriedAndI 3 months ago
@BetweenTheBuriedAndI They are also very incorrect words.
Drumtome 3 months ago in playlist Drumtome's favorites
@KsrDragon Dont' be a fucking idiot, don't assume. They didn't get rid of him, so you're wrong. He left, asshole. And I was told this by Acle Kahney himself, so don't even try to fucking argue.
Drumtome 3 months ago in playlist Drumtome's favorites
Comment removed
WrappedInGray 2 months ago
Comment removed
WrappedInGray 2 months ago
@KsrDragon He left voluntarily...to go do this: /watch?v=BMnBo9ZUftM (how's that for girly?) So you tell me who's the whiney bitch here. (hint: that would be you)
WrappedInGray 2 months ago
@WrappedInGray I actually really enjoy Piano aha
BetweenTheBuriedAndI 2 months ago 4
@BetweenTheBuriedAndI I don't mind it either haha (with his voice how could anyone? and I spend more time listening to non-metal than I do listening to metal) I'm just pointing out how silly his "girly sounding singer" argument is. Besides, listen to Immaterial by Haunted Shores and tell me that Elliot Coleman is girly sounding; his growls are pretty sick.
WrappedInGray 2 months ago
@KsrDragon Maybe you should get your vocals up to par and fill his spot.
FrakTheGods2011 2 months ago
@KsrDragon Dan quit
Fingertap2002 1 month ago 3
@KsrDragon Just because he can sing a higher octive than the pevious singer doesnt mean he's girly.
happyjap96 1 month ago
Props on the copyright. And damn, it sounds pretty good! No daniel tompkins, but I'll give him respect for doing it his own way, and doing it well!
Drumtome 3 months ago