If only they had released this before `Love Spreads` upon their return, they could of kept up the momentum from the first album into Second Coming. I think for some the hard-edged Zepplin sound of Love Spreads was too much of a departure from their earlier stuff. If they had released this first it would of eased the fairweather fans into the new album without so much trauma..
Lets hope Squire goes back on his plans to bury the Roses for good..
You have to remember this was what 5, 6 years after their debut album?The scene had moved on,Oasis were rocking it with Defintely Maybe...Love Spreads was an amazing comeback tune...Certainly not as hard as Zeppelin..The Second Coming, for the most part, was pretty mellow..
i love the roses,but its really fucked how they really screwed over reni it took over two minutes before they showed a two second clip of him??I know things were really bad between him and squire but that still fucked up,the band was not the same after reni left
Reni left the band before they filmed the video. Thats actually Mani just wearing a hat. So they didn't really screw him. Bottom line though is Reni was pretty much the best drummer of his era and is definitely on a short list for best ever!
exactly, iv felt the same shit. stone roses best shit to listen to when ur trippin. thats how i first got into them now i fuckin love them hahah! you know the score! haha
John Squire's guitar work in this is the equal of the best of Johnny Marr - and that is the highest praise you can give a guitarist. Great song also, this album is almost the equal of their first one.
I think this video is retarded,they were trying to reach a really wide audience (can't blame them) but it's just not them...can't knock the song though!
It's such a great song and you're totally right about the Geffen influence.If they'd kept the momentum back in 1990,they could've been the most important British band since the Sex Pistols...actually I think they were anyway.
this is a fucking great song one of the best off the second coming , although 'tears' is proberbly my fave. the clostest thing to creating there debut magic. " i built this thing for you" superb.
oasis dont even come close,they are living on their first 2 albums,the rest after that have been bollocks,the second coming is supposedly not that good to some people,but for me its still better than anything oasis have done,thats my opinion,oh and definetely maybe is a classic.
"oasis dont even come close,they are living on their first 2 albums"?? the roses were finished with their second album...too fast!! and Oasis are still making classic albums 14 years later like Dig out your soul...stop saying bullshit..
Second Coming was a quality album. It was panned at the time because the expectation was just so impossibly high after the brilliance of the first album. But if you listen to it now, it's still a great album in it's own right....imo anyway :-)
Underrated? The Stone Roses have a MASSIVE fanbase kidder... I'd go for more underplayed these days man, with all the shite thats on the box on the music channels these fuckin days... its a pathetic cry for attention and money more than anything else, yes i'm talking to you Keane, Snow Patrol, Pigeon Detectives, Coldplay, Embrace... I could go on but wont coz i'm lazy... i hate them all, where have all the good bands gone?
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I must say; that Noel is obviously an amazing individual 2 feel this way 4 someone & put it down so beautifully in a song; i've been writing songs since 15 yrs old; written many songs i'm proud of; but writing about love; deep passionate giving 2 another is in it's own league in my mind cos i've never been able 2 do it ... but i finally know why & i'm praying 4 the day i get 2 dance with the man that has the magic 2 make me write something like this; the passion shared in living what the lyrics
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I've never liked Oasis or Noel till this moment in time; cos someone amazing sent this video to me...this is a gorgeous song; but what is most incredible is someone saying these things to me; someone i had no idea would; someone who blows my mind (no offence Noel; but thanks for writing this so someone magnificent could send it to me)
this is the most beautiful song ever written. the stone roses are the best band that has ever put it together. no one can match them. its a pity they hated one another. go on the mancs. from a glasgow boy.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
its 1:24 actually,he hated SQURE at this point in time,that cunt john had already left the band at this time but wanted 2 tour HIS ALBUM 2ND COMING,fuckin shit'ouse sittin there lookin at his wtch,the time was FUCK OFF 2 4,,,,,SEAHORSES "HE HATES ROSES" SO CLEVER ,I BET HE THOUGHT NO1 WUD GUESS,PRICK.WANNA LINE ,BIG FAT ONE OVER @ OASIS JOHN,so off u went n they fuckt u off afta knebworth,u were that embaressing,but i bet u'd sniffed so much u couldn't give them any respect either,u r a twat
What are you on about John Squire got told to fuck off from Oasis? He never was in the band in anyway.. Oasis had alot of respect for John which you can tell by the way liam acts during the champagne supernova video.. i wish John was lead player for Oasis.. he's awesome! No disrespect to noel intended btw.
The Stone Roses were a different class, never saw them live which is a huge regret. Sad that they were cut short in their prime, still sound good to this day though.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Like the NME's first assessment of Stone Roses (7/10?!?) the roses band waggon roles on. Brown cannot sing, Squire is, at best, a compitant guitar player. The real drive behind the roses is Mani and Reni........
This is a recent repost, the unofficially uploaded one before this (that was presumably taken down to make way for the official record company upload/version) had a few hundred thousand views.
is the video about coming down off heroin or summat? i know the roses neva touched the stuff but thats wat it looks like 2 me
fleming140 2 years ago
my favourite stones roses song!
martybhoycfc 2 years ago
I loved Second Coming and still have it on my Ipod now... Quality album, dont take my word for it go and listen for yourself.
milly100 2 years ago 3
This is a proper song, hear too much rubbish these days
goldreserve 2 years ago 6
First song at our wedding ! Second Coming vastly underated !
vimolt 2 years ago 10
i loove this song..but i dont understand the video? what its about?
milkmonztr 2 years ago 2
Something on the lines of religeon, which was the meaning behind a lot of Roses songs. U see Brownie doing a few Jesus poses in the vid too.
stoneroses22 2 years ago 2
Oasis took Champagne Supernova video from this one!What good musical tastes they've got!
Archicrameur 2 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Geesh, these guys made the worst videos ever!
hendrixgreengilmour 2 years ago
Maybe so, but who cares about the videos?! If anything, this one was one of their better efforts anyway.
potshotwilly 2 years ago
Stone Roses 4 Ever
NuQ8 2 years ago 2
Pure class, nuff said
ointment72 2 years ago
I will never get over Roses. Ever.
Tommy4Liverpool 2 years ago
the hairs on your neck stand up
mattandhiscat 2 years ago
If only they had released this before `Love Spreads` upon their return, they could of kept up the momentum from the first album into Second Coming. I think for some the hard-edged Zepplin sound of Love Spreads was too much of a departure from their earlier stuff. If they had released this first it would of eased the fairweather fans into the new album without so much trauma..
Lets hope Squire goes back on his plans to bury the Roses for good..
gabbygall 2 years ago
You have to remember this was what 5, 6 years after their debut album?The scene had moved on,Oasis were rocking it with Defintely Maybe...Love Spreads was an amazing comeback tune...Certainly not as hard as Zeppelin..The Second Coming, for the most part, was pretty mellow..
kevindoo2007 2 years ago
totally agree
stevieb8006 2 years ago
Una joya mas de mi generacion, la generacion "X"
dsantako 2 years ago
This is my favourite song by the Roses, I love it even more than Waterfall.
MarqueeMoon95 2 years ago
champagne supernova!
LiamGallagherTheBest 2 years ago
champagne super-uglycunt!...
One band in Manchester.
THE STONE ROSES.
mersyparadise 2 years ago 6
dico che il video degli Oasis di Champagne supernova è ripreso palesemente da questo!
non ho detto che sono meglio gli Oasis! anche se è vero..
LiamGallagherTheBest 2 years ago
second coming is like be here now
but shunned by critics because they didnt exceed the humungous expectations for them, but both were brilliant albums
oaSisFANatiC1000 2 years ago 5
One of the greatest love songs of our lifetime.
hillman39 2 years ago 7
this son is amazing,, I can`t describe how
evenness 2 years ago 5
in a secret whisper; i think this song is one of the most beautiful ever! the video is beautiful too!
Louiseskybunker 2 years ago 6
This has been flagged as spam show
1. copy and paste
2. send this to 2 other videos.
3. hold your breath for 10 seconds
4. press refresh twice
3. LOOK AT YOUR BACKGROUND
jax631610 2 years ago
If there ever was a better band i'd like to here them
dthorn616 2 years ago 6
89 to 94 was a long 5 years. F the record labels
bigshotbaby17 2 years ago 6
btw the video director's name is 'Sophie Muller' not Miller....
Great, Classic Song/Video all the same :=)
1977musiclover 3 years ago
i love the roses,but its really fucked how they really screwed over reni it took over two minutes before they showed a two second clip of him??I know things were really bad between him and squire but that still fucked up,the band was not the same after reni left
whipit4me 3 years ago
It's not even reni, it's a guy with a mask of his face covering his own. Says so on wikipedia.
oce1989 3 years ago
you are right. that's not even reni wtf????
whipit4me 3 years ago
Reni left the band after recording the song, so he wasn't available for the making of the video.
oce1989 3 years ago
Reni left the band before they filmed the video. Thats actually Mani just wearing a hat. So they didn't really screw him. Bottom line though is Reni was pretty much the best drummer of his era and is definitely on a short list for best ever!
Mozzer232 3 years ago 5
Too true, Roger Daltery at one of the first main stream Roses gigs said that Reni was a more gifted drumer than Keith Moon. IMHO, he wern't wrong!
agghtee 2 years ago
Esta canción quiero que la toquen el dia que me case!
marcogalvezcampos 3 years ago 2
my favorite of all the stone roses songs!
truly brilliant!
fantastic!
leedsman513 3 years ago
Brill song. It's my girlfriend and I's song.
AnimalNitrateInMind 3 years ago 5
interesting visuals to a glorious song....glad to see it posted....one of my fav "contemporary" tunes relatively....wonderful lyrics
tsodeur 3 years ago
my favorite love song of all time...god bless Manchester
zanewlevitt 3 years ago 7
Great video, but haha I just realized where Oasis got the concept for the Champagne Supernova video from! ;)
adhfan75 3 years ago 2
truly amazing band.......
bradlittle2007 3 years ago 3
Immaculate song!!
Hicksie52 3 years ago 3
Magical.
One of my all time best songs, although it breaks my heart.
TheSharkPool 3 years ago 5
i well know what they was thinkin when thay made this video..
madeofstone316 3 years ago
lol! yea, when is this acid goin to wear off?!
NorthernSoulLeon 3 years ago
exactly, iv felt the same shit. stone roses best shit to listen to when ur trippin. thats how i first got into them now i fuckin love them hahah! you know the score! haha
madeofstone316 3 years ago
genius,just forgot how much genius it is
stam1415 3 years ago 2
Is it true that Mani's trying to get them to reform just gotta talk ian brown into it
shuffs231 3 years ago
yeah its ture but ian brown needs to talk to john squire and john squire got to give up his art
brincat93 3 years ago 2
No, he's got to talk Reni into it too I thought.
AnimalNitrateInMind 3 years ago
john squires guitar work is the nuts .....
150superscoot 3 years ago
Prefer the music though! ;-)
NorthernSoulLeon 3 years ago
John Squire's guitar work in this is the equal of the best of Johnny Marr - and that is the highest praise you can give a guitarist. Great song also, this album is almost the equal of their first one.
panacea999 3 years ago
LOL! not even in the same league! Squire is a guitar god!
Thr names shouldn't even appear in the same sentence!
Lol! just kiddin, yea marr's good! but squire is a god!
NorthernSoulLeon 3 years ago
Nice song - I can image kirsty McCall would have done a good cover of this - can you?
salvadormarley 3 years ago 2
This is an awesome song, but the video itself is truly awesome.
MyFavouriteBanjo 3 years ago
This video reminds me of taking trips when i was 13.
Linguist29 3 years ago
13? omg
jcassidy98 3 years ago
a truly majestical piece of music and first song at my wedding! will they ever play on the same stage again? if only the dream would happen!
vimolt 3 years ago
well the specials are touring,get your finger out john and ian.
hoppybhoy 3 years ago
I think this video is retarded,they were trying to reach a really wide audience (can't blame them) but it's just not them...can't knock the song though!
ucla4eva 3 years ago
Your not wrong mate...The video is so Americanised its cringeworthy!! You can see Geffen's influence!!
The song is still the bollox thou agreed
Myerzi 3 years ago
It's such a great song and you're totally right about the Geffen influence.If they'd kept the momentum back in 1990,they could've been the most important British band since the Sex Pistols...actually I think they were anyway.
ucla4eva 3 years ago
liam is defo rippin ian brown and tim from charlatans ??bamm its out there
natnat94 3 years ago
these boys put oasis to shame, go home ye idiots. Reunite the roses!!!!!
johnnyrediculous11 3 years ago 4
best ever stone roses tune man
matmcfc 3 years ago
both great bands stop arguing
sth246 3 years ago
Oasis are still making classic tunes!! Open your ears!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
bentheled 3 years ago
this is a fucking great song one of the best off the second coming , although 'tears' is proberbly my fave. the clostest thing to creating there debut magic. " i built this thing for you" superb.
jdsmith250981 3 years ago
well said matty it's gettin like the whole 2pac biggie thing just appreciate both an if prefer one or other fine don't harp about it..
wakeo29 3 years ago
why argue about who's better?
stone roses and oasis are both quality bands
mattylightspeed 3 years ago
oasis dont even come close,fuckin hell,cmon,
one of the best songs ever written
squire needs brown,and vice versa
hoppybhoy 3 years ago
"oasis dont even come close"?... idiot
cricken 3 years ago
oasis dont even come close,they are living on their first 2 albums,the rest after that have been bollocks,the second coming is supposedly not that good to some people,but for me its still better than anything oasis have done,thats my opinion,oh and definetely maybe is a classic.
hoppybhoy 3 years ago
"oasis dont even come close,they are living on their first 2 albums"?? the roses were finished with their second album...too fast!! and Oasis are still making classic albums 14 years later like Dig out your soul...stop saying bullshit..
cricken2 3 years ago
DIG OUT YOUR SOUL IS BOLLOCKS.
hoppybhoy 3 years ago
the greatest band ever,fucking who else now,could even come close to this,the roses.
get your act together ian and john and show them how its done.
best british band ever since the beatles,actually better
hoppybhoy 3 years ago
Love this video! And obviously a great song!
Second Coming was a quality album. It was panned at the time because the expectation was just so impossibly high after the brilliance of the first album. But if you listen to it now, it's still a great album in it's own right....imo anyway :-)
GSTAR24SEVEN 3 years ago
couldn't agree more,you read lots o shite on here,no one has a fookin clue usaly. bit a g star threads too.
fissplaps911 3 years ago
i don't see why everyone hates second coming. i think its a great album, but its just that the first one is way better
theocean1973 3 years ago
This truly is a great song by an underrated band.
furmountain21 3 years ago 3
Underrated? The Stone Roses have a MASSIVE fanbase kidder... I'd go for more underplayed these days man, with all the shite thats on the box on the music channels these fuckin days... its a pathetic cry for attention and money more than anything else, yes i'm talking to you Keane, Snow Patrol, Pigeon Detectives, Coldplay, Embrace... I could go on but wont coz i'm lazy... i hate them all, where have all the good bands gone?
toothchipbeebop1986 3 years ago 2
The Greatest Band in the World! Bar none.
ronantv 3 years ago
why did they brakeup???
xautomaticeyesx 3 years ago
Watch blood on the turntable, parts 1-6! Documentry that explains everything!
But if your looking for the answer in short,
Gareth Evans and cocaine!
Glenntre 3 years ago
This video's like some mad sort of trip man
1991noel 3 years ago
the best love song from the best album ever made wish reni did notleave at that point
brincat93 3 years ago
One of the most beautiful songs ever written...
Hicksie52 3 years ago
最高です!
rockinscooters 3 years ago
Brilliant song=D
mikgreig17 3 years ago
FKIN LEGENDS!!!!!!!
hibeedude08 3 years ago
Bloody love this song and the Stone Roses. Roses for ever x
theclaxtons 3 years ago 2
***** ¡¡¡ʇoɥ ʇıɥs
crucko1 3 years ago
Haha Ian Brown looks chipmunked out his dial!
iornbrew 3 years ago
Brilliant tune,the vid proves why drugs are illegal....
CBRSIXPACK 3 years ago
noel gallagher didn't write this..its not by oasis !!!
this is the stone roses!!!
written by ian brown and john squire!!
Darkrin1975 3 years ago 2
Oops; i am SUCH a Gomer Pile sometimes...i thought it was Noel Galliger...thanks so much for the enlightenment; Geezuz gotta love my moron moments
Lidowyte 3 years ago
Squire!!!!! it was squires album! the only songs brown had anything to do with on it were daybreak and begging you!
Bit of useless info' for you! lol
Glenntre 3 years ago
And 'Straight To The Man'
crawleytillidie 3 years ago
I stand corrected! lol!
Glenntre 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I must say; that Noel is obviously an amazing individual 2 feel this way 4 someone & put it down so beautifully in a song; i've been writing songs since 15 yrs old; written many songs i'm proud of; but writing about love; deep passionate giving 2 another is in it's own league in my mind cos i've never been able 2 do it ... but i finally know why & i'm praying 4 the day i get 2 dance with the man that has the magic 2 make me write something like this; the passion shared in living what the lyrics
Lidowyte 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I've never liked Oasis or Noel till this moment in time; cos someone amazing sent this video to me...this is a gorgeous song; but what is most incredible is someone saying these things to me; someone i had no idea would; someone who blows my mind (no offence Noel; but thanks for writing this so someone magnificent could send it to me)
Lidowyte 3 years ago
***** ¡¡¡ʇoɥ ʇıɥs
Glenntre 3 years ago
Classic song!!!
prodigalson56 3 years ago
FCKN TUNE !
Ordsall66 3 years ago
this is the most beautiful song ever written. the stone roses are the best band that has ever put it together. no one can match them. its a pity they hated one another. go on the mancs. from a glasgow boy.
daveleela2008 3 years ago 4
Great song!
70Mack 3 years ago
well sed hjstrole cunt of put it better myself absolute classic pisses all ova any oasis ballad
cuthy82 3 years ago
This song should have been huge. Too bad it was all falling apart for these guys at that point.
hjstrole 3 years ago 4
fuckin top class tune, love it.
hermaldill 3 years ago
aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaahhhh!!! Ian where are your beautiful and soooooooft hair???????????
TheBrownEyedLady 3 years ago
liam rips off this video in champagne supernova video
KIDAmnesiacBends 3 years ago 3
Liam Gets his whole style from Ian Brown, he even said that if there was no Stone Roses that there would be no Oasis...
prodigalson56 3 years ago 2
I reckon there would, they would just be even more Beatles influenced.
mufc0607 3 years ago
ian browns cover of Michael Jacksons thriller is another classic.. check it out...
batmanriddlemethis 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
its 1:24 actually,he hated SQURE at this point in time,that cunt john had already left the band at this time but wanted 2 tour HIS ALBUM 2ND COMING,fuckin shit'ouse sittin there lookin at his wtch,the time was FUCK OFF 2 4,,,,,SEAHORSES "HE HATES ROSES" SO CLEVER ,I BET HE THOUGHT NO1 WUD GUESS,PRICK.WANNA LINE ,BIG FAT ONE OVER @ OASIS JOHN,so off u went n they fuckt u off afta knebworth,u were that embaressing,but i bet u'd sniffed so much u couldn't give them any respect either,u r a twat
NAH1HODGE 3 years ago
What are you on about John Squire got told to fuck off from Oasis? He never was in the band in anyway.. Oasis had alot of respect for John which you can tell by the way liam acts during the champagne supernova video.. i wish John was lead player for Oasis.. he's awesome! No disrespect to noel intended btw.
GasPanic08 3 years ago
and noel writes oasis's songs remember, well most of them
theold2007 3 years ago
All the good ones any way! LOL!
Glenntre 3 years ago 2
john and mani watching tv and who comes on only reni 1.23
joydivision808 3 years ago
Actually its an extra with a cardboard cut out of Reni's face in this video... Reni left the band before this video was made!
Bk25 3 years ago 2
It's a millisecond of Reni playing drums at 1.23/24 on the TV. The cardboard cut out is later.
EdFallingLeaves 3 years ago
its not him!
Glenntre 3 years ago
Reni packed in the band just b4 the vid was made. so they had to use a mask as stand in!
lilopeep 3 years ago
Only a band as stunning as this could get away with writing something so gay but totally get away with it. God, it's just too good.
borishawthorn 3 years ago
The Stone Roses were a different class, never saw them live which is a huge regret. Sad that they were cut short in their prime, still sound good to this day though.
chelseafc36 3 years ago
closed captioned?
rupman27 3 years ago
love it x
hubbardsbubbas 3 years ago
The cribs are a pretty good band.
MWHutchy 3 years ago
Have to agree fab tune, Stone Roses were fab, bring them times back, Manchester rocked the North :0)
Hornymam 3 years ago
absolute amazing song! long live the roses
steviecarr06 3 years ago
Not their best work like, but i good tune (Y)
They should really get back together
coxyna 3 years ago
the best band in the days of indie music and one of the best songs but i am the resurrection the best of all songs ever
cerysmac 3 years ago 2
love it all
iliketolivealone 3 years ago
Best song ever!
Birtles20 3 years ago
love this one!!! Stone Roses thankyou for writing such top tunes!: )
Rainbowrdr 3 years ago
SHITE???????
This is music at its finest....listen to the lyrics.....
leemanc1234 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Top band but this song is shite I'm afraid. A song for indie wannabe's who are a couple of steps down the line after buying a coldplay album
VoodooBlue90210 3 years ago
One of the best guitar solos ever! Top tune, cheers for uploading dude
hanifkureishi4 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Who's this knob?
euanhosie 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Like the NME's first assessment of Stone Roses (7/10?!?) the roses band waggon roles on. Brown cannot sing, Squire is, at best, a compitant guitar player. The real drive behind the roses is Mani and Reni........
georeff23 3 years ago
Short hair suits him
Verve20 3 years ago
greatest love song ever
k02066 3 years ago
well said jogger1976
nathanhanley 3 years ago 3
Classic song..just so amazing. Both myself & my husband are Roses fans so it seemed like the perfect choice for our first dance at our wedding.
catymacca 3 years ago 4
This song is so good it hurts! John and Ian, for the love of God, bury the hatchet!
jogger1976 3 years ago 11
what did happen
JevonJonesisahomo 3 years ago
a fuckin men
gazoasis2007 3 years ago
Nada más falto esa en el concierto de México
Pinche culero
orlandord 3 years ago
vinieron a mexico ??
timekillerinhere 3 years ago
Vino Ian Brown al DF hace como 2 años en el salón 21 , estuvo bien chingón, canto temas claves de los Stone Roses y solo falto esta rola
orlandord 3 years ago
ROSES Forever!!!
sorenotes 3 years ago 5
When your heart is black and broken
And you need a helping hand
When you're so much in love
You don't know just how much you can stand
When your questions go unanswered
And the silence is killing you
Take my hand baby, I'm your man
I got love enough for two
Need we say more? No we don't.
Just fucking brilliant.
chemysery 3 years ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
Great tune. Check out my acoustic cover if you like.
desy2478 3 years ago
tune
iank67 3 years ago 3
rENI MAYBE.
saintmirrentilIdie 3 years ago
I wonder who was wearing the Reni mask?
Verve20 3 years ago
This is the classic we had as our 1st dance at our wedding.
catymacca 3 years ago
Best song about being hopelessly in love.
VCK9009 3 years ago
the other vid was removed it had 70k views
dommo808 3 years ago
Yeah I had it favourited too!
desy2478 3 years ago
bring back the stone roses.mint!!!!!!
123noush 3 years ago 6
what a tune man!!!!!
20joshc08 3 years ago 6
I love this song, just want to pick up my pint of beer and sing it LOUD!
MONOKA 3 years ago 7
everyone probably already knows this, but THE SEAHORSES is an anagram for HE HATES ROSES! i'm SURE it's just a happy coincidence! = )
learue8 3 years ago
How the fuck has this classic only got something like 9,000 views??
rockeee 3 years ago 5
This is a recent repost, the unofficially uploaded one before this (that was presumably taken down to make way for the official record company upload/version) had a few hundred thousand views.
The 9000 view counter isn't representative.
uniallu 3 years ago
Ah I see! I totally agree about the 9,000 views not being representative also. :)
rockeee 3 years ago
shit i love this song man, makes me override my love pains
jpmaster53 3 years ago 3
Brilliant!
rocker4577 3 years ago 3
iam 14 i love the roses this and sugar spun sister is amazing *****
mufc956 3 years ago