@celinethegreat1025 isa kang MALAKING GAGO!!!! ISANG BESES LANG NAGCONCERT DITO SI MARIAH!!! PUTANG INA MO!!! MAGRESEARCH KA MUNA BAGO KA MAGREPLY!!! AND it took you 2 years to reply just to give me that crap???? napakabobo mo!!!!
@xeth86 hi xeth ,,,, were you there when she had a concert?i don't think so coz you're such a poor jerk...i was in the front row when CELine dion had a concert in dubai.......and i don't care if she made a concert twice in the philippines choosing her is a suicide...poor IDIOT...
@celinethegreat1025 of course you wouldnt even care if mariah had her concert here ONCE, just so you know i was in the front row too along with Richard Gomez, Nina, Charlene and Aga Muhlach, Ben Chan Of Bench and many Philippine Artists, that means I GOT MEANS, hindi ako poor na kagaya mo!, if i know DH ka jan sa Dubai hahahaha, and PLEASE icheck mo naman yung grammar mo, gosh!!! suicide ka jan, eh bobo ka naman!
@celinethegreat1025 that was none other than NOV 2003, charmbracelet tour held at the fort open field, taguig city, tama si xeth86, hindi naman lahat ng filipino maka mariah, hindi naman kasalanan ang tumanggap ng pagkakamali eh.
@leoviefernandez i might be wrong about it....but kahit dun pa sya tumira wala akong pakiaalam ...di naman ako galit sa kanya.....but i hate to hear that mariah is better than celine in vocal abilities..kasi proof na yung DIVAS LIVE 1998 ..di nya kayang sumabay ng boses kila aretha at mariah nung last number nila...
@leoviefernandez i might be wrong about it....but kahit dun pa sya tumira wala akong pakiaalam ...di naman ako galit sa kanya.....but i hate to hear that mariah is better than celine in vocal abilities..kasi proof na yung DIVAS LIVE 1998 ..di nya kayang sumabay ng boses kila aretha at CELINE nung last number nila...
@celinethegreat1025 during those times mariah was just giving way to aretha for outstaging her fellow divas, while celine couldn't bare that she was being shadowed vocally, so she screamed her heart out making her funny, barking like a dog, while mariah kept her composure, acting like a REAL diva, there's no comparison really with her and celine, its just that you gotta be equipped with knowledge, which you are lacking, so sad, again you gotta listen to xeth86
@leoviefernandez who are you to tell me what to do.......I just love celine dion and everything about her,now if you and xeth will fight against the real DIVA...both of you are loser!Celine proves she can compete with anyone,and its clearly shows,1000 + award,including grammy and oscars....over 200 million of album sales...great LIFE better than your BITCH....
@celinethegreat1025 you're really not gettin it, do you? youre out of context, kagaya ng sinabi ko sa yo, hindi pinatatalunan dito si celine at si mariah... ang kabobohan mo ang point namin dito bwahahaha
@celinethegreat1025 maayos ka lang magenglish but its doesn't prove you're smart enough ,tandaan mo english ang linguahe ng mga americano,simpleng abbreviation di mo ALAm?
@celinethegreat1025 baka ibig mong sabihin fight for mariah, hindi "now if you and xeth will fight against the real DIVA", hahahaha nakakatawa ka! sinabi na kasing wag nang magenglish eh, napakatrying hard mo!!!
@celinethegreat1025 so you proved yourself WRONG hahaha, the next time you comment on any pages make sure you know everything, but then again improve your grammar!
@xeth86 mas gugustuhin ko nang maging BOBO pero MAYAMAN kaysa naman sa TARANTADONG KATULAD mo.....TANDAAN mo some successful chinese businessmen in the philippines had never went into college but now employing a degree holder like you!
@celinethegreat1025 i didnt say im rich, but im living a better life, nagmumura ka na huh, pikon ka na ba? Kung talagang mayaman ka you couldve went back to school and learn how to deal with people properly, sige na ikaw na mayaman, hahaha dream on!
@xeth86 did i say you're RICH , hahhahah... ikaw kaya tong nagmura ng todong todo sa simula pa..!hhahahhahh... and .yes In fact now I'm studying photography in UP.........I already got what i dreamed of.......
@xeth86 hahhahhahha!ang ikli naman?damihan mo naman!ganyan lang kasi boses ni mariah eh...maikli din... di na kaya yung matagalat mahabng note....hahhhaha..magsama kayo both loser
@celinethegreat1025 who cursed first?im just giving you what you dearly deserved! alipustahin, murahin, isumpa! cause people like you who couldn't stand on their grounds and arguments, should be hang upside down, youre worthless of my time
@celinethegreat1025@celinethegreat1025 isa kang MALAKING GAGO!!!! ISANG BESES LANG NAGCONCERT DITO SI MARIAH!!! PUTANG INA MO!!! MAGRESEARCH KA MUNA BAGO KA MAGREPLY!!! AND it took you 2 years to reply just to give me that crap???? napakabobo mo!!!!
I love Mariah Carey so much, & vocally she is superior to Celine. Don't get me wrong I like Celine & she is very talented, but Mariah's voice is so much more versatile & has a strong resonance to it. As Celine gets higher her voice gets more nasally & thins out. Both very talented women though.
I love Mariah Carey so much, & vocally she is superior to Celine. Don't get me wrong I like Celine & she is very talented, but Mariah's voice is so much more versatile & has a strong resonance to it. As Celine gets higher her voice gets more nasally & thins out. Both very talented women though.
Vocally, they're both good. Hands down. But overall, i'd choose mariah..
mariah sings with more emotion.. it's not like she's showing off her voice, but the song itself. i've seen n heard it just by the beginning of the vid.. endless love is sang with much love within it. mariah sings like a water flowing naturally as it should be.. she knows when to belt and when not to.. of course mariah has this style if singing with variety and not just hitting the song straight..
i love celine's stamina in her voice and its beauty...mariah..i love how she create her songs...she doesn't use her whistle for show off..but to make her music more beautiful..and i love her MELISMAS..:p
They are both amazing songstresses, my favorism for Mariah comes from her & the ability to display her voice in so many different ways & she's shown thus over the course of her career. Her voice is one that has not & will not be matched by any other. Though her voice has deteriorated, with her age & the course of the time; she can still outsing many of these acts that are out now. And she will retain her title as the #1 Best Selling Female Artist of All Time.
For a fair comparison, listen to the same song by both. Celine far superior, no doubt about it. No one would invest 95 millions in Vegas for M. Carey as they did for Celine. And she is coming back!! Vive Céline!!
mariah carey voice is so much sweeter and her songs are better.. mariah could take celine dion any day in a vocal battle!!!!!!!!!!! (bring it on celine)
this is a REALLY hard one to compare... as much as I LOVE Celine when push comes to shove I think it would be Mariah......Celine is very adult contemporary while Mariah is much more main stream and gets more air play.
It's pretty clear that Mariah has the better voice. I mean when someone mentions her name the first thing you think of is her voice. Celine isn't nearly as noted for her voice. She's noted for titanic... A sinking ship... Lol
for me i think 90's and 2000's would be mariahs decade, she would have surpass the BEATTLES, leveled up with MJ, a lot famous than MADONNA...
just think of how she still amazes people with that "struggling voice", how much more if she's still like before?
as to CELINE she's lucky enough to maintain her voice, but how far did she go of that?...she haven't made a big edge from mariah whose voice is deteriorating...
No no no, I think y'all got it mixed up now. Mimis got everything! Low register, high falseto whistle notes, belt, breath, long notes, changes in speed, EVERYTHING! Mariah wins hands down. N one of you said b4 the Celine wad the best female artist of all time??? Yeahi don't think so, look at mariahs records on the Internet b4 u write that.
@Jeffieboi «Mariah sounds like an air conditioner» HAHAHAHA!!! I have to say Mariah sounds very breathy yes, we can hear the air «rubbing» her vocal cords, so much that it covers her actual singing at times......
ANNOYING!!!!!!!!!!!! She was able to reach to the director of Sony, the highest placed in the music industry, and made him marry her. Without him, I think (in facts, I KNOW) she wouldn`t even be close to where she is now in terms of success..
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
IM SORRY BUT MARIAH WINS ANYTIME BECAUSE LOOK.. HOW VERSATILE MARIAH VOICE REALLY IS AND HOW MARIAH CAREY CHANGE WITH THE DECADES!!.. BUT CELINE... IS GOOD BUT ALL SHE CAN DO IS BELT AND HOLD NOTES..!!.. MARIAH HAS SO MUCH MORE TO HER!!.
MARIAH CAREY is a legend. No singer has sold more than her, she has an amazing voice and an incomparable acute, is rich, is beautiful, her compositions are unsurpassed, with songs deep, ever had the pleasure of watching it closely and can say with certainty she is very nice, the way she treats the fans is very nice to see. It has more songs on top of any other artist, so I can say that she is the greatest singer of ALL TIME.
haha(: there is no need to comparing both artist they are both great ! even though im more of a mariah carey lamb im just gonna leave it like that cause i dont want people attacking her ! both beautiful and gifted artist's they are !
Celine Dion is not only the Best Female Singer of ALL TIME. She is a LEGEND. A Goddess, A Donator of millions of dollars to poor people. She is he Voice of the people, and that's why she is so successful. She has so much influence on youung people and music and inspiration. And she is the BEST mom in the WORLD!
Celine is the best singer of all times. She is so elegant and her voice can be sweet and pure but it also can be poweful and touching. She is simply the Ultimate DIVA.
Mariah is one of the most wonderful singers of the world but I prefer Celine :D
check this link on youtube v/BdpAAh5aKPQ celine dion great a performance even its hard to change the note because of older woman!shes really fantastic,and see if mariah has a new live performance showing her vocal ability!
@parachuteboi - HAHAHA bconSHIT couldn't get any more original with names? Since we started calling him "bconSHIT" he's now find it convenient to do the same thing by calling you "shitboi." OMG! LMFAO! Could this fool get any dumber than he is now? I guess so! Well, I must admit that was kind of expected.
no doubt mariah had amazing voice especially her unbelievable diff. kinds of notes.. just add her beauty and talents too.. So amazing!.. celine is nothing compare to mariah thats a fact!.
Mariah has better tone, quality, melismas, range, and strains a lot less than Celine. But we can't blame Celine for being nasally as that usually comes natural to many French singers.
I can't deny Mariah is a great vocalist, but I don't really like her sound/style/personality from what I know of her... Celine will always be my favorite singer!
@bconSHITT - Yeah, whatever shrew! When I accused you, you call it mocking but when you accused others, you insult them. You're freakin hilarious!! You're so pathetic & it's too funny!! LMFAO!! Next time try harder, ok? And check your spelling!! Sycophant isn't spelled with 2 h's dumbass!!
@bconsitt - Hey bitch, you complain about others using your comeback but here you are using mine but that's fine by me coz I really don't expect much from some feeble, termagant, low-life shew like you. Adios sycophant! I'm done with you!!
@parachuteboi - True! True! Bconshit will stop when a single soul starts listening to what he has to say but for now, he has to keep on going coz NO single soul is an idiotic sycophant shrew like bconshit. Exactly, HAHAHA!!
@bconsitt - Back shit up with what? All you've been postings are nothing but nonsense. All the stuff you said about Celine are so irrelevant. You actually have a list of things about Celine? Oh wow, aren't you accomplished! I'm glad I got your attention with my dictionary post. HAHAHA!! You're just another sycophant. Adios feeble shrew!!
Thats a little harsh... Celine is still the top selling female vocalist in the history of the US... Whitney falls as number 2. Her song My Heart Will Go On is the most popular song sung by a female vocalist, And I will Always Love You falls as number 2 again. Statistics show very much that Celine has contributed...dont denounce facts because you dont like her-which is of course your valid opinion
If all you can do are runs & whistles that doesn't make you a great singer coz it doesn't cut it to become a great artist and who wants to listen to that crap? That's all Mariah can do nowadays!! MC can't hit any of her high notes & can't hold on long enough like she's supposed to. Her voice has changed a whole lot & not for good either. She sounds too scratchy & coarse it's like sand paper on the wall. She depends a lot on her whistles & it's just annoying & overused.
btdtlol7 - yeah,it is just tiresome to argue and explain to haters.
It doesnt make any sense at all.
I dont know why some people keep saying that they dont listen to Celine Dion's "sappy" music but every time she makes a show,it's always been jam packed!LOL.
@tinceline - Oh I agree with you without a doubt! How else can these haters know about Celine if they don't listen to her music? I think it's incredibly amazing that Celine's latest tour were jammed packed & sold out right after her 5-year Vegas gig. Honestly, how many artists do you know who can accomplish the same or even come close? It's an absolute proof that her millions & millions of fans around the world still want to listen & watch her perform after 25 years in the business.
And?bconshitt,Time magazine labeled Celine as a Global Diva,others call her the queen of pop,Mottola said she's the Ultimate Diva,for David Foster Celine's the Undiva Diva,Randy Jackson said she's "untouchable".She is known as the World's Best selling female artist and the Ultimate Performer of the last decade...haayyy...tsk tsk thanks for giving her so much attention!
@tinceline Not to take anything away from Celine, but the same people have made flattering comments about M. When David Foster heard M was breaking the Elvis record and he wasn't involved in any of it creatively he said he wanted to call her up to collaborate. Randy Jackson stated that out of the big three (Whitney, Celine,Mariah) MC is the only one who writes, arranges, and produces her own material. He also stated there will never be another artist like her again. Tommy? We wont go there.
@RJJ12 I also think that David Foster said Celine has the most beautiful voice tone and talent for singing he had ever heard before. If writing her own songs makes Mariah a better artist, then ok, she is! But Celine`s the best singer along with Whitney in my opinion:P
@tusenslemarais I'm sure he did. He helped create her. Something kind of told me that you would say that Celine is the better singer...you wouldn't be a Celine fan if thought differently. Just like I believe Mariah and Whitney are the best singers of our time, but just my opinion!
@RJJ12 The thing is, David Foster is subjective, as he worked with all these divas Celine Whitney Mariah Babra just to name a few, and by his experience and professional judgement he declared Celine has the most beautiful voice ever, and yes, I agree with him.
@RJJ12 it is bcoz the big three have their own talents and capabilities.Mariah is more of an artist and Celine is more of a performer/vocalist and she entertains a lot of people so I go for her.
I've been watching your posts for some time going back and forth between other posters and I must say you are definitely in the top ten "biggest pieces of shit posters" that ever posted on you tube. Your posts are perpetually laced with lies, absurdities and just plain old stinking honking bullshit. Congratulations. It must take a lot of effort to achieve such a record.
Quit talking about Celine Dion. She is one of the most talented, gifted and generous human beings on this planet. Go do something productive with your life and quit wasting it. You are never going to get anywhere by posting bullshit on here.
no one takes Celine seriously> i guess thats why Caesars Palace decided to build her a $100 million coleseum to perform in for a $200 million contract. and i guess thats why she pulled Las Vegas out of an economic slump by generating MILLIONS of dollars thru incoming business to the area because of her show. and i guess thats why she gave thousands of family's in the area employment for 5 years!
Yes bconshitt Britney and Rihanna have wide audience as well and Mariah is a serious JOKE. that's why u're in a case of "sour grapes"---less surprising for a lamb.
"In Celine Dion's earnings of $747.9 million, $522.2 million came in from concerts and $225.7 million from album sales during the decade. She has sold more than 200 million albums so far. The best-selling female artist of all time."
i like mariah before, in fact i got her giant poster in my room but now not anymore... i love celine and i was so impressed with her las vegas concert...
@march742503 - Yup, same here!! What's amazing about Celine is that she has maintained her voice until now. That shows dedication, determination, & lots of discipline.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
MARIAH has more vocal range and vocal flexibility, not to mention waaaayy better songs. I like Celine too but I i only like maybe 3 of her songs.... MIMI wins <3
dont get me wrong I have tons of respect for Celine but even with Mariah's belting being gone she still manages to have new #1 singles that pop up and tons of record sales.
@psych006 - Well, if she has tons of record sales, then how come Celine is the Best-Selling Female Artist with over 200 millions sold? Celine is up there with Madonna.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
well they say Mariah Carey is the #1 selling female artist of all time too with over 200 mil sold as well, especially recently since shes still doing CDs im sure shes passed Celine since celine is doing that vegas thing, all the power to her cause I love her.
@psych006 - What vocal range & flexibility? Everytime she performs, she has a difficult time hitting the notes & she always changes the melody of the song. That's why I can't stand watching her perform anymore coz it's so disappointing!! It's such a shame!! Celine on the other hand, can still sing Power of Love, All by myself, To love you more perfectly & she never fails with hitting the notes.
Mariah a Melhor
janamimi100 1 month ago
celine is the best
shane2007able 4 months ago
Celine é MUITO boa. Mariah proxima a PERFEIÇÃO
MPauloRicardo 5 months ago
I LOVE THEM BOTH SOO MUCH! Two of the best voices to ever exist <3
EveryDayMe43 6 months ago
Mariah all the wayy i love celine soo much but mariah is wayy and i mean wayy better!
piscesgirl98 6 months ago
my heart beat now vs love takes time (plutot can't let go ) #UFAIL
sweetheartattitude 6 months ago
Celine is the best!
Agostinacolorina 7 months ago 2
Mariah is way better
Scotty2650 7 months ago 2
Celine, and Celine... and Celine again :-)
Nikostgc 7 months ago
mAriah carey is real boring boy celine is the best
iamrhebesify 8 months ago
@iamrhebesify think carefully before speaking, loser
babylovemeonemoretim 7 months ago
@xeth86 tanga pangalawa na yun!
celinethegreat1025 8 months ago
@celinethegreat1025 isa kang MALAKING GAGO!!!! ISANG BESES LANG NAGCONCERT DITO SI MARIAH!!! PUTANG INA MO!!! MAGRESEARCH KA MUNA BAGO KA MAGREPLY!!! AND it took you 2 years to reply just to give me that crap???? napakabobo mo!!!!
xeth86 8 months ago
@xeth86 hi xeth ,,,, were you there when she had a concert?i don't think so coz you're such a poor jerk...i was in the front row when CELine dion had a concert in dubai.......and i don't care if she made a concert twice in the philippines choosing her is a suicide...poor IDIOT...
celinethegreat1025 8 months ago
@celinethegreat1025 of course you wouldnt even care if mariah had her concert here ONCE, just so you know i was in the front row too along with Richard Gomez, Nina, Charlene and Aga Muhlach, Ben Chan Of Bench and many Philippine Artists, that means I GOT MEANS, hindi ako poor na kagaya mo!, if i know DH ka jan sa Dubai hahahaha, and PLEASE icheck mo naman yung grammar mo, gosh!!! suicide ka jan, eh bobo ka naman!
xeth86 8 months ago
@celinethegreat1025 that was none other than NOV 2003, charmbracelet tour held at the fort open field, taguig city, tama si xeth86, hindi naman lahat ng filipino maka mariah, hindi naman kasalanan ang tumanggap ng pagkakamali eh.
leoviefernandez 8 months ago
@leoviefernandez i might be wrong about it....but kahit dun pa sya tumira wala akong pakiaalam ...di naman ako galit sa kanya.....but i hate to hear that mariah is better than celine in vocal abilities..kasi proof na yung DIVAS LIVE 1998 ..di nya kayang sumabay ng boses kila aretha at mariah nung last number nila...
celinethegreat1025 8 months ago
@leoviefernandez i might be wrong about it....but kahit dun pa sya tumira wala akong pakiaalam ...di naman ako galit sa kanya.....but i hate to hear that mariah is better than celine in vocal abilities..kasi proof na yung DIVAS LIVE 1998 ..di nya kayang sumabay ng boses kila aretha at CELINE nung last number nila...
celinethegreat1025 8 months ago
@celinethegreat1025 during those times mariah was just giving way to aretha for outstaging her fellow divas, while celine couldn't bare that she was being shadowed vocally, so she screamed her heart out making her funny, barking like a dog, while mariah kept her composure, acting like a REAL diva, there's no comparison really with her and celine, its just that you gotta be equipped with knowledge, which you are lacking, so sad, again you gotta listen to xeth86
leoviefernandez 8 months ago
@leoviefernandez who are you to tell me what to do.......I just love celine dion and everything about her,now if you and xeth will fight against the real DIVA...both of you are loser!Celine proves she can compete with anyone,and its clearly shows,1000 + award,including grammy and oscars....over 200 million of album sales...great LIFE better than your BITCH....
celinethegreat1025 8 months ago
@celinethegreat1025 you're really not gettin it, do you? youre out of context, kagaya ng sinabi ko sa yo, hindi pinatatalunan dito si celine at si mariah... ang kabobohan mo ang point namin dito bwahahaha
xeth86 8 months ago
@xeth86 ikaw siguro ang BOBO?hahhahha
!KASI it clearly shows here on this page MARIAH vs. CELINE.....hahhahhahah
o baka naman di mo alam ang ibig sabihin ng 'VS' hahhahhah
celinethegreat1025 8 months ago
@celinethegreat1025 maayos ka lang magenglish but its doesn't prove you're smart enough ,tandaan mo english ang linguahe ng mga americano,simpleng abbreviation di mo ALAm?
celinethegreat1025 8 months ago
@celinethegreat1025 does it mean you're giving up your pride,and accepting your defeat ?poor girl....
celinethegreat1025 8 months ago
@celinethegreat1025 baka ibig mong sabihin fight for mariah, hindi "now if you and xeth will fight against the real DIVA", hahahaha nakakatawa ka! sinabi na kasing wag nang magenglish eh, napakatrying hard mo!!!
xeth86 8 months ago
@xeth86 ha?is she a real diva I'm talking about?hahhahhahh!!!!!matigas talaga ako ......hhahahhahha....
celinethegreat1025 8 months ago
@celinethegreat1025 you know what? tagalugin mo na lang hirap na hirap ka na!
xeth86 8 months ago
@xeth86 baka ikaw ang naghihirap,nagpupuyat at magdamag nanakaheadset!hahhahhahahh
celinethegreat1025 8 months ago
@celinethegreat1025 so you proved yourself WRONG hahaha, the next time you comment on any pages make sure you know everything, but then again improve your grammar!
xeth86 8 months ago
@xeth86so what do you to prove then!hahhahhahha...buy your own laptop para naman makapagreply ka agad!hahhahahha! POOR BEGGAR!
celinethegreat1025 8 months ago
@celinethegreat1025 clearly you're a waste of time!
xeth86 8 months ago
@xeth86 hahhahhahh!then clean the time you wasted !hahhahhahahh
celinethegreat1025 8 months ago
@celinethegreat1025 BOBO!
xeth86 8 months ago
@xeth86 mas gugustuhin ko nang maging BOBO pero MAYAMAN kaysa naman sa TARANTADONG KATULAD mo.....TANDAAN mo some successful chinese businessmen in the philippines had never went into college but now employing a degree holder like you!
celinethegreat1025 8 months ago
@celinethegreat1025 i didnt say im rich, but im living a better life, nagmumura ka na huh, pikon ka na ba? Kung talagang mayaman ka you couldve went back to school and learn how to deal with people properly, sige na ikaw na mayaman, hahaha dream on!
xeth86 8 months ago
@xeth86 did i say you're RICH , hahhahah... ikaw kaya tong nagmura ng todong todo sa simula pa..!hhahahhahh... and .yes In fact now I'm studying photography in UP.........I already got what i dreamed of.......
celinethegreat1025 8 months ago
@celinethegreat1025 dream on..
xeth86 8 months ago
@xeth86 hahhahhahha!ang ikli naman?damihan mo naman!ganyan lang kasi boses ni mariah eh...maikli din... di na kaya yung matagalat mahabng note....hahhhaha..magsama kayo both loser
celinethegreat1025 8 months ago
@xeth86 BUTI NA LANG sa PUBLIC School ako nagaral,GAling mo MAGMURA!
hhahahhahah..maybe you,ve just graduated in a private school but you're living with criminals!aren't you xeth?
celinethegreat1025 8 months ago
Comment removed
xeth86 8 months ago
@celinethegreat1025 who cursed first?im just giving you what you dearly deserved! alipustahin, murahin, isumpa! cause people like you who couldn't stand on their grounds and arguments, should be hang upside down, youre worthless of my time
xeth86 8 months ago
@xeth86 di ba?lumalabas ang tunay na KULAY ng MGA CALLcenter AGENT!hahhahhahahh...at excuse me who told you I'm giving up ?
celinethegreat1025 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@celinethegreat1025 @celinethegreat1025 isa kang MALAKING GAGO!!!! ISANG BESES LANG NAGCONCERT DITO SI MARIAH!!! PUTANG INA MO!!! MAGRESEARCH KA MUNA BAGO KA MAGREPLY!!! AND it took you 2 years to reply just to give me that crap???? napakabobo mo!!!!
xeth86 8 months ago
Go for EmC forever!!!!
louie200353 9 months ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
I love Mariah Carey so much, & vocally she is superior to Celine. Don't get me wrong I like Celine & she is very talented, but Mariah's voice is so much more versatile & has a strong resonance to it. As Celine gets higher her voice gets more nasally & thins out. Both very talented women though.
JimmyJrock 9 months ago
I love Mariah Carey so much, & vocally she is superior to Celine. Don't get me wrong I like Celine & she is very talented, but Mariah's voice is so much more versatile & has a strong resonance to it. As Celine gets higher her voice gets more nasally & thins out. Both very talented women though.
JimmyJrock 9 months ago 3
Comment removed
shutupbllsht4 9 months ago
for my opinion, mariah ;)
shutupbllsht4 9 months ago 6
mariah carey
keppaway09 9 months ago 19
mAriah carey , the queen
freshpears08 9 months ago 28
Vocally, they're both good. Hands down. But overall, i'd choose mariah..
mariah sings with more emotion.. it's not like she's showing off her voice, but the song itself. i've seen n heard it just by the beginning of the vid.. endless love is sang with much love within it. mariah sings like a water flowing naturally as it should be.. she knows when to belt and when not to.. of course mariah has this style if singing with variety and not just hitting the song straight..
anjelwta08 9 months ago 5
i love celine's stamina in her voice and its beauty...mariah..i love how she create her songs...she doesn't use her whistle for show off..but to make her music more beautiful..and i love her MELISMAS..:p
MrDjoleen 9 months ago 3
They are both amazing songstresses, my favorism for Mariah comes from her & the ability to display her voice in so many different ways & she's shown thus over the course of her career. Her voice is one that has not & will not be matched by any other. Though her voice has deteriorated, with her age & the course of the time; she can still outsing many of these acts that are out now. And she will retain her title as the #1 Best Selling Female Artist of All Time.
JimmyJrock 10 months ago 4
Celine - effortless, emotions, tricky vibrato, perfect control, can achieve beautiful legato lines, balanced resonance, amazing timbre, belts, ... , performing, enthusiasm, artistry, confidence, .... , great personality, humble, funny, ... , succesful, popular, reputable, desired, legend
Mariah - whistle, melisma, a herd of lambs, hit songs, song-writing, ... , success, popular, festive!
This is my SUBJECTIVE description of them. Any objections from the lambs are rejected in advance.
velkyprase 11 months ago 3
MARIAH CAREY ALL THE WAY
LALMCGatorsfan 11 months ago
Mariah by farrrr. Mariah can do way more with her voice than Celine can. Celine just belts. Mariah has a falsetto and whistle register.
MusicLuver093 1 year ago
Mariah wins!
Raoulirshan 1 year ago
Mariah..+..
chisame2009 1 year ago
For a fair comparison, listen to the same song by both. Celine far superior, no doubt about it. No one would invest 95 millions in Vegas for M. Carey as they did for Celine. And she is coming back!! Vive Céline!!
BobbyTubenevsky 1 year ago
Celine is much better, off course!
HewellynThuany 1 year ago 7
Celine
philippines1912 1 year ago 7
Congratulations Mariah! More number 1 albums and more number 1 singles for you!!!!!!
DaoMingChoi 1 year ago
Celine Dion Celine DION
olemra17 1 year ago 2
mariah ♥ mariah ♥mariah ♥mariah ♥mariah ♥mariah ♥mariah ♥mariah ♥mariah ♥mariah ♥mariah ♥mariah ♥mariah ♥mariah ♥mariah ♥mariah ♥mariah ♥mariah ♥mariah ♥mariah ♥
lufemaciel123 1 year ago 2
Off course Celine Dion!!!!
TheBrigm 1 year ago
CELINE DION CELINE DION CELINE DION
keptdude 1 year ago 5
MARIAHS VOICE HAS BEEN BACK LOOK UP " MAKE IT HAPPEN ATLANTIC CITY" THE VOICE NEVER LEFT! EVERY PICK UP MARIAHS NEW XMAS ALBUM !!!
PopCultureVultureTV 1 year ago
Mariah cant sing anymore. Her voice is gone since 10 years ago or more. Since DIva's Live she got slaughtered
muskiskoka 1 year ago 9
mariah carey voice is so much sweeter and her songs are better.. mariah could take celine dion any day in a vocal battle!!!!!!!!!!! (bring it on celine)
travaris18 1 year ago
MARIAH CAREY!!!!
petergriffin9901 1 year ago
mariah and celine ist the best female singers in the hisotry
edsssooonnn 1 year ago
@edsssooonnn if only mariah's voice stayed in such good condition that celine's did. mariah can't even hit C anymore
phatdurg14 1 year ago 3
CELINE DION
MSB2118 1 year ago 5
MARIAH CAREYYY!!!
petergriffin9901 1 year ago
MARIAH CAREY !!!
MrTiaguiar 1 year ago
mariah carey is so pretty and talented!!!!!!!!!!! and celine is pretty as well
travaris18 1 year ago
What happened to Mariah, anyway? Did her voice die?
elphie96 1 year ago
CELINE DION OFCOURSE!
candylozzi 1 year ago
i can't compare either one although mariah is my number 1.. they are amazing singers including withney
rejfinal 1 year ago
Celine>Mariah. Both FIERCE, though.
makinbacon254 1 year ago
@makinbacon254 Mariah > Celine. Both FIERCE though. Lol.
MissJayG 1 year ago
personality+beauty+voice= Celine Dion
Ladykristel09 1 year ago
this is a REALLY hard one to compare... as much as I LOVE Celine when push comes to shove I think it would be Mariah......Celine is very adult contemporary while Mariah is much more main stream and gets more air play.
gaydevil13 1 year ago 2
Celine lipps....... mariah doesn't....... Mariah is the best
applmac2009 1 year ago
@applmac2009 As much as I love Mariah, she most definitely lips. Especially this year..
MissJayG 1 year ago
@applmac2009 celine does not lips synch
candylozzi 1 year ago
@candylozzi yes she does
applmac2009 1 year ago
La mejor voz es de MARIAH CAREY! celine tiene una voz increible pero MC la supera!
Xulo13 1 year ago
It's pretty clear that Mariah has the better voice. I mean when someone mentions her name the first thing you think of is her voice. Celine isn't nearly as noted for her voice. She's noted for titanic... A sinking ship... Lol
MusicLuver093 1 year ago 2
Mariah have a strong voice, but it kind of like a normal POP singer. Celine have a AMAZING voice! She is better!
AsumiShiroNiwa 1 year ago
what if mariah's voice was still like before?...
for me i think 90's and 2000's would be mariahs decade, she would have surpass the BEATTLES, leveled up with MJ, a lot famous than MADONNA...
just think of how she still amazes people with that "struggling voice", how much more if she's still like before?
as to CELINE she's lucky enough to maintain her voice, but how far did she go of that?...she haven't made a big edge from mariah whose voice is deteriorating...
i think mariah deserves to win..
nijzien17 1 year ago
No no no, I think y'all got it mixed up now. Mimis got everything! Low register, high falseto whistle notes, belt, breath, long notes, changes in speed, EVERYTHING! Mariah wins hands down. N one of you said b4 the Celine wad the best female artist of all time??? Yeahi don't think so, look at mariahs records on the Internet b4 u write that.
MissKarls24 1 year ago
Mariah sounds like an air conditioner. Her and Whitney both fucked up their voices.
Jeffieboi 1 year ago 2
@Jeffieboi «Mariah sounds like an air conditioner» HAHAHAHA!!! I have to say Mariah sounds very breathy yes, we can hear the air «rubbing» her vocal cords, so much that it covers her actual singing at times......
ANNOYING!!!!!!!!!!!! She was able to reach to the director of Sony, the highest placed in the music industry, and made him marry her. Without him, I think (in facts, I KNOW) she wouldn`t even be close to where she is now in terms of success..
ohouui 1 year ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
IM SORRY BUT MARIAH WINS ANYTIME BECAUSE LOOK.. HOW VERSATILE MARIAH VOICE REALLY IS AND HOW MARIAH CAREY CHANGE WITH THE DECADES!!.. BUT CELINE... IS GOOD BUT ALL SHE CAN DO IS BELT AND HOLD NOTES..!!.. MARIAH HAS SO MUCH MORE TO HER!!.
mariahpowerful 1 year ago
Celine wins handsdown!!!!
Celine is in a class of her own
italo36 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
MARIAH CAREY is a legend. No singer has sold more than her, she has an amazing voice and an incomparable acute, is rich, is beautiful, her compositions are unsurpassed, with songs deep, ever had the pleasure of watching it closely and can say with certainty she is very nice, the way she treats the fans is very nice to see. It has more songs on top of any other artist, so I can say that she is the greatest singer of ALL TIME.
vinidornellas 1 year ago
haha(: there is no need to comparing both artist they are both great ! even though im more of a mariah carey lamb im just gonna leave it like that cause i dont want people attacking her ! both beautiful and gifted artist's they are !
AndreiiOnline 1 year ago
Celine Dion is not only the Best Female Singer of ALL TIME. She is a LEGEND. A Goddess, A Donator of millions of dollars to poor people. She is he Voice of the people, and that's why she is so successful. She has so much influence on youung people and music and inspiration. And she is the BEST mom in the WORLD!
muskiskoka 1 year ago 3
Celine is the best singer of all times. She is so elegant and her voice can be sweet and pure but it also can be poweful and touching. She is simply the Ultimate DIVA.
Mariah is one of the most wonderful singers of the world but I prefer Celine :D
ICelineDionI 1 year ago 6
Mariah 100 percent ^^
ekiiim 1 year ago
check this link on youtube v/BdpAAh5aKPQ celine dion great a performance even its hard to change the note because of older woman!shes really fantastic,and see if mariah has a new live performance showing her vocal ability!
celinethegreat1025 1 year ago
no live = no beautiful
undala 1 year ago
Mariah is the best !!!
999xander999 1 year ago
Mariah all the way, shes prettier and has the better voice. But celine is still amazing
MissKarls24 1 year ago
the only thing thats useless is you. i really wish you'd come to littlerock. i wander if you could even find your way there? lol
parachuteboi 1 year ago
@parachuteboi - HAHAHA bconSHIT couldn't get any more original with names? Since we started calling him "bconSHIT" he's now find it convenient to do the same thing by calling you "shitboi." OMG! LMFAO! Could this fool get any dumber than he is now? I guess so! Well, I must admit that was kind of expected.
btdtlol7 1 year ago 2
@btdtlol7 , you know he's been commenting on this video for like almost 10 months now LOL
parachuteboi 1 year ago
hey dumbie, movie roles can comprise singing too. barbra s. in funny girl. ever heard it? look into it asshat
parachuteboi 1 year ago
i take it you never saw Celine's movie Celine through the eyes of the World. because if you did you still wouldnt be on here dissing Miss Celine.
parachuteboi 1 year ago
its chimier yawning up the place with his stinking mouth again
parachuteboi 1 year ago
no doubt mariah had amazing voice especially her unbelievable diff. kinds of notes.. just add her beauty and talents too.. So amazing!.. celine is nothing compare to mariah thats a fact!.
neszhey 1 year ago
Mariah has better tone, quality, melismas, range, and strains a lot less than Celine. But we can't blame Celine for being nasally as that usually comes natural to many French singers.
denidowi 1 year ago
I can't deny Mariah is a great vocalist, but I don't really like her sound/style/personality from what I know of her... Celine will always be my favorite singer!
ohouui 1 year ago 4
LOL
tinceline 1 year ago 2
@tinceline - LOL!! Of course, a hater NEVER reveals, right? Hahaha that's freakin hilarious!!
btdtlol7 1 year ago
@bconSHITT - Yeah, whatever shrew! When I accused you, you call it mocking but when you accused others, you insult them. You're freakin hilarious!! You're so pathetic & it's too funny!! LMFAO!! Next time try harder, ok? And check your spelling!! Sycophant isn't spelled with 2 h's dumbass!!
btdtlol7 1 year ago
@bconsitt - Hey bitch, you complain about others using your comeback but here you are using mine but that's fine by me coz I really don't expect much from some feeble, termagant, low-life shew like you. Adios sycophant! I'm done with you!!
btdtlol7 1 year ago
HAHA, i see that pyschotic bitch BCONSHIT is still trying to diss Celine , what an idiot. LMAO
parachuteboi 1 year ago
@parachuteboi - True! True! Bconshit will stop when a single soul starts listening to what he has to say but for now, he has to keep on going coz NO single soul is an idiotic sycophant shrew like bconshit. Exactly, HAHAHA!!
btdtlol7 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Madonna's way better than both
Liebromeistal 1 year ago
@bconsitt - Back shit up with what? All you've been postings are nothing but nonsense. All the stuff you said about Celine are so irrelevant. You actually have a list of things about Celine? Oh wow, aren't you accomplished! I'm glad I got your attention with my dictionary post. HAHAHA!! You're just another sycophant. Adios feeble shrew!!
btdtlol7 1 year ago
Thats a little harsh... Celine is still the top selling female vocalist in the history of the US... Whitney falls as number 2. Her song My Heart Will Go On is the most popular song sung by a female vocalist, And I will Always Love You falls as number 2 again. Statistics show very much that Celine has contributed...dont denounce facts because you dont like her-which is of course your valid opinion
secrecy 1 year ago 6
bconshitt Celine doesnt just have a great selling record.She has exhaustive list of achievements that makes her a great artist.
Btw,I aint care about Stevie Wonder
tinceline 1 year ago 38
I love Mariah Carey and Celine Dion. One of my favorite part of this video when Mariah sing from Love Take Time:
You might say that it's over
You might say that you don't care
You might say you don't miss me
You don't need me
But I know that you do
And I feel that you do
Inside.
MsSCamilo 2 years ago
If all you can do are runs & whistles that doesn't make you a great singer coz it doesn't cut it to become a great artist and who wants to listen to that crap? That's all Mariah can do nowadays!! MC can't hit any of her high notes & can't hold on long enough like she's supposed to. Her voice has changed a whole lot & not for good either. She sounds too scratchy & coarse it's like sand paper on the wall. She depends a lot on her whistles & it's just annoying & overused.
btdtlol7 2 years ago 2
Yah,better throw away ur lists coz they're nothing but non sense.
tinceline 2 years ago 3
@tinceline - Oh wow! bconSHITT actually has a lists of things to say? It just proves that someone really has no social life/skills. How sad!!
btdtlol7 1 year ago
btdtlol7 - yeah,it is just tiresome to argue and explain to haters.
It doesnt make any sense at all.
I dont know why some people keep saying that they dont listen to Celine Dion's "sappy" music but every time she makes a show,it's always been jam packed!LOL.
I bet bconshitt owns her CD!Haha
tinceline 1 year ago 5
@tinceline - Oh I agree with you without a doubt! How else can these haters know about Celine if they don't listen to her music? I think it's incredibly amazing that Celine's latest tour were jammed packed & sold out right after her 5-year Vegas gig. Honestly, how many artists do you know who can accomplish the same or even come close? It's an absolute proof that her millions & millions of fans around the world still want to listen & watch her perform after 25 years in the business.
btdtlol7 1 year ago 2
And?bconshitt,Time magazine labeled Celine as a Global Diva,others call her the queen of pop,Mottola said she's the Ultimate Diva,for David Foster Celine's the Undiva Diva,Randy Jackson said she's "untouchable".She is known as the World's Best selling female artist and the Ultimate Performer of the last decade...haayyy...tsk tsk thanks for giving her so much attention!
tinceline 2 years ago 8
@tinceline Not to take anything away from Celine, but the same people have made flattering comments about M. When David Foster heard M was breaking the Elvis record and he wasn't involved in any of it creatively he said he wanted to call her up to collaborate. Randy Jackson stated that out of the big three (Whitney, Celine,Mariah) MC is the only one who writes, arranges, and produces her own material. He also stated there will never be another artist like her again. Tommy? We wont go there.
RJJ12 1 year ago
@RJJ12 I also think that David Foster said Celine has the most beautiful voice tone and talent for singing he had ever heard before. If writing her own songs makes Mariah a better artist, then ok, she is! But Celine`s the best singer along with Whitney in my opinion:P
tusenslemarais 1 year ago
@tusenslemarais I'm sure he did. He helped create her. Something kind of told me that you would say that Celine is the better singer...you wouldn't be a Celine fan if thought differently. Just like I believe Mariah and Whitney are the best singers of our time, but just my opinion!
RJJ12 1 year ago
@RJJ12 The thing is, David Foster is subjective, as he worked with all these divas Celine Whitney Mariah Babra just to name a few, and by his experience and professional judgement he declared Celine has the most beautiful voice ever, and yes, I agree with him.
tusenslemarais 1 year ago 18
@tusenslemarais Of course his opinion is subjective. Him saying that Celine has the best voice ever is just that, an opinion.
RJJ12 1 year ago
Comment removed
parachuteboi 1 year ago
@tusenslemarais I AGREE WITH YOU HONEY!
celinethegreat1025 8 months ago
@RJJ12 it is bcoz the big three have their own talents and capabilities.Mariah is more of an artist and Celine is more of a performer/vocalist and she entertains a lot of people so I go for her.
tinceline 1 year ago 3
@tinceline and she didnt even made it to the Rolling Stones Top 100 LIST.. PATHETIC
magayonx 1 year ago
@magayonx Who cares about it? No one.Sorry
tinceline 1 year ago 2
@tinceline tin your still around defending the Queen i see ;)
parachuteboi 1 year ago
@parachuteboi Yeah ofcourse! =)
Celine is still amazing..
tinceline 1 year ago
@magayonx rolling stone mean nothing lol
parachuteboi 1 year ago
@parachuteboi yes its true!better change it to 'ROLLING COIN" that would make sense....LOL
celinethegreat1025 8 months ago
@ bconsitt
I've been watching your posts for some time going back and forth between other posters and I must say you are definitely in the top ten "biggest pieces of shit posters" that ever posted on you tube. Your posts are perpetually laced with lies, absurdities and just plain old stinking honking bullshit. Congratulations. It must take a lot of effort to achieve such a record.
muskiskoka 2 years ago 6
Quit talking about Celine Dion. She is one of the most talented, gifted and generous human beings on this planet. Go do something productive with your life and quit wasting it. You are never going to get anywhere by posting bullshit on here.
muskiskoka 2 years ago 6
no one takes Celine seriously> i guess thats why Caesars Palace decided to build her a $100 million coleseum to perform in for a $200 million contract. and i guess thats why she pulled Las Vegas out of an economic slump by generating MILLIONS of dollars thru incoming business to the area because of her show. and i guess thats why she gave thousands of family's in the area employment for 5 years!
parachuteboi 2 years ago 30
@parachuteboi WELL SAID :D
slmala999 1 year ago
my bestfriend gay idol mariah and me,celine dion pls. watch my video ill be there by mariah whengceline and lhandie
Whengceline 2 years ago 3
Yes bconshitt Britney and Rihanna have wide audience as well and Mariah is a serious JOKE. that's why u're in a case of "sour grapes"---less surprising for a lamb.
tinceline 2 years ago 8
@tinceline - HAHAHA!!! LMAO!!! Your comments are the BEST!!!
btdtlol7 2 years ago 3
No one takes Celine seriously?Is this why she has countless audience around the world?
I think you're the one who is delusional and no one takes you seriously.You are the biggest joke here on youtube =)
tinceline 2 years ago 3
@tinceline - Another funny one!! Keep it comin!! Hahaha!! Love your comments coz they're so so true.
btdtlol7 2 years ago 4
I LOVE CELINE AND SHE'S THE BEST
olemra17 2 years ago 4
celine is deffs better the mariah
petlover21 2 years ago 6
"In Celine Dion's earnings of $747.9 million, $522.2 million came in from concerts and $225.7 million from album sales during the decade. She has sold more than 200 million albums so far. The best-selling female artist of all time."
deemama07 2 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I lover Celine's personality more than Mariah's but as an Artist I love Mariah more.
psych006 2 years ago
psych006 when are you going to stop posting the same things over and over. its becoming tired
parachuteboi 2 years ago 5
They both have amazing voices, but Celine... she has THIS! Her voice is INCREDIBLE! Her notes are breathtaking!
Celine Dion - the best female singer EVER!
Googaify 2 years ago 7
i like mariah before, in fact i got her giant poster in my room but now not anymore... i love celine and i was so impressed with her las vegas concert...
march742503 2 years ago 5
@march742503 - Yup, same here!! What's amazing about Celine is that she has maintained her voice until now. That shows dedication, determination, & lots of discipline.
btdtlol7 2 years ago
celine
Georgesarhawi 2 years ago 4
Sorry but what mariah stands for is far more important than any Celine song FOR ME
Jordypoo4 2 years ago
what does mariah stand for, please tell me. oh wait. is it drunkardness, vulgar-ness, hoochie-ness, gee i just don't know,, maybe all the above,
parachuteboi 2 years ago
@parachuteboi - Hahahaha, love your comment. I think it's all of the above!!!
btdtlol7 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
MARIAH has more vocal range and vocal flexibility, not to mention waaaayy better songs. I like Celine too but I i only like maybe 3 of her songs.... MIMI wins <3
psych006 2 years ago
sweetie, this is not 1993. mariah has limited vocal range, sorry to burst ur bubble :)
parachuteboi 2 years ago 3
dont get me wrong I have tons of respect for Celine but even with Mariah's belting being gone she still manages to have new #1 singles that pop up and tons of record sales.
psych006 2 years ago
@psych006 - Well, if she has tons of record sales, then how come Celine is the Best-Selling Female Artist with over 200 millions sold? Celine is up there with Madonna.
btdtlol7 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
well they say Mariah Carey is the #1 selling female artist of all time too with over 200 mil sold as well, especially recently since shes still doing CDs im sure shes passed Celine since celine is doing that vegas thing, all the power to her cause I love her.
psych006 2 years ago
Celine hasn't done that "vegas thing" for over a year and put out a new CD when it was over.
galanie 2 years ago 2
psycho006 - Eventhough Celine did Vegas for 5 years, she still managed to release 3 albums; One Heart, Miracle & Taking Chances.
btdtlol7 2 years ago 2
@psych006 - What vocal range & flexibility? Everytime she performs, she has a difficult time hitting the notes & she always changes the melody of the song. That's why I can't stand watching her perform anymore coz it's so disappointing!! It's such a shame!! Celine on the other hand, can still sing Power of Love, All by myself, To love you more perfectly & she never fails with hitting the notes.
btdtlol7 2 years ago 3