you should do another red dead redemtion walkthrough, but this time without any golden medals,
because yours golden medals walkthroughs is so boring, you always using that dead eye, you skip cutscenes and all stuff like that, thats why your RDR walkthrough aren't so popular
@Dommy521 Because they still saw him as a member of the Dutch's Gang. Ross' mission was to take down the entire gang, and he just tricked John into doing his dirty work before taking him out.
It's interesting but if this game had any intentions of having a "good" ending... Just take cover and kill them with dead eye. From what I saw the first time I played this, it was definetly not the hardest situation John has been -_-
When John leaves the barn he should have gone out with the evans repeater. 22 shots. Could have taken them all out. Then because he was in dead eye he would be immune to gun fire. Spam a few medicines for good measure. Sorted.
@KoRnIbanez123 Well if he did that then he would be more in danger because the goverment would be so far up his you know what because he was in a gang. The goverment in the game would be like bounty hunters because they would chase you down try to kill you in the worst way. But he did the right thing even tho he could of just ran like a coward he dint he protected his famliy thats what was best.
This is a pretty epic mission, but it's sad that they killed off John. I have a save before this mission though so I can continue playing as him. Only problem is I can't change outfits.
@alleyoop33 u have to replay the entire game though if u wanna keep John Save the game after the mission “And The Truth Will Set You Free“ & continue from there as John & if ur wondering why after that mission is so u can change outfits because after u trigger the 1st abigail mission u cannot change outfits hope this helps
@ospelbos I've been running around the map as Jack and half done stuff like the Funny Man is still lying there for completion out at the mine. The gunfighter at Fort Mercer is still open for me, and all the bounties and treasure hunts are still there. Hope this helps. Remember these games cost a bomb, so you paid for all this stuff.
John knew he could notredeem himself, so he decided to redeem his family by sacrificing himself for them. But John died for nothing, because Jack killed Ross, and became the very thing his Father died to keep him from becoming: a murderer.
@iPlayGamez4Life The main goal of Ross' was to eliminate Dutch's gang. John rode in that gang, so he was still a part of it. they just took advantage of him and made him do their dirty work, before killing him like a dog.
I don't feel sad when someone dies by how sad everyone is or how awesome the character is...I get sad when someone dies because of what you had to go through with them.
@PrivationProductions Before they shoot you, you can pull out the gun and use Dead Eye to kill the American Army Captain. He's a possible character to kill.
@PrivationProductions you cant kill any of the main characters outside the barn - i shot that other agents several times in the head but he was in the cutscene afterwards alive
if ya dont want to play as jack simply when you return home after you see some horses with unc and he is chillaxing after that mission is the barn when you play as jack dont do it but i did it it was boring it wasnt nature
@dand0708 This is the 2nd last mission. The one before this, you're gonna save Jack from a bear. And after this mission you're gonna play as Jack as an almost grown up (around 17-18 I think) and take revenge on Agent Ross. You're gonna meet him in Mexico in a shoot-out. If you kill him, You've completed the whole story and you're gonna play as Jack forever.
actually it does but in a very perculiar way, undead nightmare take place sometime around the time when john came back home from killind dutch van whatever. but happens before the his death in "the last enemy that shall be destroyed". so it does fit in with the orginal story. look it up if you dont believe. its called google.
This was such a fantastic (first) ending and Marston needed to die. It gave a lot of gravity to the speeches Dutch and the Bureau gave about change; that Marston (and Ross) would eventually pay for what they have done. I'd strongly recommend giving the Red Dead wikia page a gander reddead.wikia.com/wiki/Edgar_Ross as the story is fantastically well written and you can see the characters' foreshadowing of what they would do.
@Ettoize john marston used to be an outlaw so the US marshalls pretty much just used him to kill bill williamson. they didnt need him anymore so they came to kill him.
@Ettoize Because they tricked Marston into killing his old gang. But the Army want Marston's ENTIRE gang dead. And, well, Marston's WAS in the gang...so...
@dmansam45 hes actually not, red harlow was born in 1880's , and if i aint wrong, from the 1880's to 1911 is no more than 25+ years or so. Uncle was born in 1835.
thats not the last misson the last mission u end up finding edgar ross hunting in mexico and u draw with him and kill him thats the last mission but i think the game should have ended with replayable missions with your son and wife
@StraightBound in some ways i do agree with you that it should have ended like that. but once i thought it over the government would want to "cut all ties" with john marston including killing his family and his former gang. not surprised that the government would use someone like that as a tool
When I saw Red Dead Redemption first advertised I thought it was a sequel to GUN. I LOVE GUN but Red Dead Redemption is awesome too. Sadly, I can see this happening to Colton White (The main character from GUN that you play as)
Glad you skipped the cutscenes they're painful! I knew we all liked John but reality was he was in fact a criminal who had to pay for his crimes, he even committed some while we controlled him, people like that shouldn't walk among the rest of us abiding citizens in society. Even if they do change they have to pay for their mistakes. And John knew that, he knew the last enemy to be destroyed was death. To give his family freedom.
Marston was a likeable chraracter you grew to care for though.
He got shot the hell up, abandoned by his clan, his family got snatched up and then he was FORCED to commit more crimes in order to bring in his old gang, and got shot the hell up AGAIN. And all he wanted to do was live the rest of his days law abiding and raising up a law abiding son with his wife. How is that worthy of a bloody death by some self-serving and backstabbing hypocrite who despite HIS misdeeds goes down a hero in history while John just dies another outlaw?
@metaXzero That's right. You got too attached to him though, and don't see the reality of it. We didn't want him to get shot up. I didn't. But that the creators is trying to get through to us is that his past caught up to him, what goes around comes around. That's life, bud.
My point is that Marston already suffered enough. This wasn't life teaching a lesson. This was life showing how absolutely and unnecessarily cruel it can be. It also showed how life can go without karmic retribution for some who deserve it more. A man trying to mend his ways gets shot like a dog and remembered as scum while everything he tried to do goes down in darkness while another who is genuine scum and lovin it dies a "hero". Its life. And life sucks.
@metaXzero Yepp you got the point now, life can be cruel. Though John was a bad person in his past and tried mending it, he was still killing innocent people even in side missions that didn't need to die and he knew it, he knew he was still doing wrong. But John did get redemption, after his death when Jack murdered Edgar Ross, so the karmic balance is there. I agree with ya, but John shot the first bullet and they shot back. The point was to get attached to John. Excellent writing here.
Side missions are just that; side missions. They are an optional part of the story. Just like its optional to go around and shoot up towns. I wouldn't count them along John's journey. Though I don't remember any part of the story side or otherwise where he was killing innoccents.
What balance? John dies and history recognizes him only for his past, his wife dies shortly afterwards, his son is driven down the path that he worked so hard to steer him clear of--
Ross takes the credit of John's good actions, goes down in history a hero of the proto-FBI and America in general, his skewed form of justice stays with him even in death, and his death is forever a pyrrhic victory for the Marstons. I don't see any form of justice being served besides Edgar's bastardized and hypocritic form of justice. Like I said, I just see life not being fair.
another question: Im not bothered to play the boring farm missions and i want to know why edgar ross kills john, He did do all his dirty work? Please tell
@SpockHD there is no definitive reason, but the best reason was that John Marston is still a mercenary in the law's eyes, even though he decided to fled that life. Edgar Ross took this opportunity to take down John Marston as a big "bounty" to get the medals and fame he wanted. that fat pig will burn.......
I remember thinking in this mission, "Why not just get to the top of the barn and throw down some of that dynamite?". Guess that would be kind of a cop out though. The ending is sad, but it's supposed to be, it's fittingly bittersweet. I played a couple times to see if I could pick Archer and Ross out of the crowd, I think I got archer, not sure though...
Its too bad that John ended up getting killed... He was much cooler and more likeable than Jack.
ashlee19881000 13 hours ago
how does john come back in read dead redemtion undead night mare LOL he already was zombie maby
2002alien 6 days ago
6:49
u killed ross!
hahahaha
MrSdefrgh 1 week ago
well 6:49 was a fail
Reid1Reid1 1 month ago
you should do another red dead redemtion walkthrough, but this time without any golden medals,
because yours golden medals walkthroughs is so boring, you always using that dead eye, you skip cutscenes and all stuff like that, thats why your RDR walkthrough aren't so popular
Yaroslav1122 1 month ago 7
:(
DaniKasteddu 1 month ago
john should of climb up the ladder in the barn and thrown out sticks of dynamite :D
CrazyDude862 2 months ago
why did the government kill john? didnt he do what they ask? smh plz respond
Dommy521 2 months ago
@Dommy521 Because they still saw him as a member of the Dutch's Gang. Ross' mission was to take down the entire gang, and he just tricked John into doing his dirty work before taking him out.
christbl58 2 months ago
@christbl58 thanx
Dommy521 2 months ago
oh c'mon don't skip the videos !! thats the only minus in your videos... it's kind of anoyng that you skip the videos !! :P ;dd
pompeja100 2 months ago
It's interesting but if this game had any intentions of having a "good" ending... Just take cover and kill them with dead eye. From what I saw the first time I played this, it was definetly not the hardest situation John has been -_-
punktheman 2 months ago
@punktheman He could have killed them, but if he escaped, the army and the fbi would still pursue him and his family.
rinofang 2 months ago
@rinofang But why didn't he take his family to mexico, where he knew the president and had a house with a machine gun on top of it.
Mullahgrrl 2 months ago
R.I.P John :(
MrJiggmin1234 2 months ago
Dudee Lay of the dead eye !
WorshipGamer 3 months ago
I did shit in this mission :P
diamondring62 4 months ago
When John leaves the barn he should have gone out with the evans repeater. 22 shots. Could have taken them all out. Then because he was in dead eye he would be immune to gun fire. Spam a few medicines for good measure. Sorted.
KoRnIbanez123 4 months ago
@KoRnIbanez123 Well if he did that then he would be more in danger because the goverment would be so far up his you know what because he was in a gang. The goverment in the game would be like bounty hunters because they would chase you down try to kill you in the worst way. But he did the right thing even tho he could of just ran like a coward he dint he protected his famliy thats what was best.
WWETripleG 2 months ago
How I also complete this game 100% I beat this game now and have only 76%?
StuntTeamST 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Gst0359 me too
thatannoyingkid12 4 months ago
@gst0359 me too
thatannoyingkid12 4 months ago
not uncle
2tacosrgood 4 months ago
it was so shcking from rockstar games to kill the hero of the game and that's not the final missin remember my family stranger task is mission #58
WiseOsamianAlien 5 months ago
This is a pretty epic mission, but it's sad that they killed off John. I have a save before this mission though so I can continue playing as him. Only problem is I can't change outfits.
Gst0395 5 months ago
@alleyoop33 u have to replay the entire game though if u wanna keep John Save the game after the mission “And The Truth Will Set You Free“ & continue from there as John & if ur wondering why after that mission is so u can change outfits because after u trigger the 1st abigail mission u cannot change outfits hope this helps
rollercoasterCEO10 5 months ago
John Died Because of FBI Agent Edgar Ross
Killed Him, So Jack Had Been Your Player
65Prototype 5 months ago
marston never should have died is there a way to keep him as a character
alleyoop23 5 months ago
i finished this game once ,now im playing it for the 2nd time and im nott gonna do this mission cuz i will keep playing with john
ximacaua22 6 months ago
im doing this mission irght now time to complete this game !
iMuss963 6 months ago
so after he dies can u complete the stranger side-mission u started but didn't finish? and can you finish the ambient challenges and stuff?
ospelbos 6 months ago
@ospelbos I think so im not 100% sure
Rasmusboy100 6 months ago
@Rasmusboy100 you can
mommieslittlekiller 6 months ago
@ospelbos I've been running around the map as Jack and half done stuff like the Funny Man is still lying there for completion out at the mine. The gunfighter at Fort Mercer is still open for me, and all the bounties and treasure hunts are still there. Hope this helps. Remember these games cost a bomb, so you paid for all this stuff.
Kelly14UK 5 months ago
@Kelly14UK thanks, that helps a lot
ospelbos 5 months ago
why did abigail died anyway?
BlackBox1270 6 months ago
@BlackBox1270 Some kind of desease or depression, I think.
goldblaze93 6 months ago
John knew he could notredeem himself, so he decided to redeem his family by sacrificing himself for them. But John died for nothing, because Jack killed Ross, and became the very thing his Father died to keep him from becoming: a murderer.
pacers2015 7 months ago 16
@pacers2015 John did not do for nothing he died for his family and he died for who he is
Comicking45 4 months ago
@Comicking45 indeed. but he also died so jack could have a normal life, and jack ruined it by killing ross in that duel on the san luis river
pacers2015 4 months ago
Could you try not using dead eye every fucking second?
Comicking45 4 months ago
@pacers2015 Remember John's Words: Murdering And Killing Are Different Things.
rinofang 2 months ago
I THINK JACK SUCKS HES ANOYING HE RUINS THE RDR FEEL
rob99eli 7 months ago
720p + full screen is just like playing it on your computer!
xXRecklessviperXx 7 months ago
@iPlayGamez4Life The main goal of Ross' was to eliminate Dutch's gang. John rode in that gang, so he was still a part of it. they just took advantage of him and made him do their dirty work, before killing him like a dog.
loweydude220 7 months ago
Beecher's hope has a hope
robotvernieteger 7 months ago
I wanted to flank them by the barnby a wall open the door and in cover and SHOOTING! THAT BITCH EDAGRR ROSS!!!
robotvernieteger 7 months ago
@iPlayGamez4Life I think that the government thought that John was a big threat, so...
finlandiapoika 7 months ago
I hate Edgar Ross
extend 7 months ago
1:40 i did the exact same thing with the rifle and the dead eye
RandomPeopleLikeMe 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Try this:
"The Demise Of Barbara And The Return Of Joe"
Play it at 2:55 when John open the doors... EPIC EPIC EPIC
PABLERL 7 months ago
PLIS RDR SECOND PART!!!!
kingtiguer88 8 months ago
@66manning This was before he died and at the end he dies but is a zombie who do you think is on the cover of the game?
demonic41700 8 months ago
I don't feel sad when someone dies by how sad everyone is or how awesome the character is...I get sad when someone dies because of what you had to go through with them.
demonic41700 8 months ago
thats the stupidest ending he john should be able to kill them all with dead or some shit like that cuz that would be bad ass and i like john
idancewithdadevil 8 months ago
@idancewithdadevil Yea he meant to die actually for his family but his dead eye is REALLY low so he doesn't have enough time.
demonic41700 8 months ago
7:21 lol isn't martson supposed to be dead
uglybugushan2364 8 months ago
@uglybugushan2364 thats jack
zachman163 8 months ago
@zachman163 ok
uglybugushan2364 8 months ago
@uglybugushan2364 Lol isn't that his son -_-
demonic41700 8 months ago
i just played the game yesterday and its freaking AWESOME
uglybugushan2364 8 months ago
It took like 50 guys to kill John Marston. It took only one guy to Kill Agent Ross you do the math John was 50 times the man Ross was.
Zain844 9 months ago 2
One of the best video game endings I've ever seen.
I really love it.
Jack is awesome and in my opinion he's a bit better than John.
Would like to have a DLC with him but there will never be one :(
TheFeshOne95 9 months ago
@TheFeshOne95 isn't red dead Redemption undead nightmare a DLC
busen2 9 months ago
@busen2 Do you play Jack in it ? No.
TheFeshOne95 9 months ago
@TheFeshOne95 i dont know because i just tried the game
busen2 9 months ago
@busen2 I got the game yesterday and it's awsome.
StarSeeker94 9 months ago
but i know that it is coming to pc 2011
busen2 9 months ago
ISNT ANYBODY CURIOUS ABOUT KILLING EVERYONE OUTSIDE THE BARN. IM TIRED OF HEARING IT CANT BE DONE, JUST FUCKING GET THE GERMAN PISTOL AND TRY IT
PrivationProductions 9 months ago
@PrivationProductions You can't because there aren't enough bullets to kill them all, and the story couldn't progress unless they killed you.
P0tatoPotato 9 months ago
@PrivationProductions Before they shoot you, you can pull out the gun and use Dead Eye to kill the American Army Captain. He's a possible character to kill.
StarSeeker94 9 months ago
@StarSeeker94 can you explain to me why you told me that from what i said originally
PrivationProductions 9 months ago
@PrivationProductions I just said that the american army captain is a possible character to kill once you get outside that barn
StarSeeker94 9 months ago
@StarSeeker94 that is so not related to what I asked
PrivationProductions 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@PrivationProductions what do you want me to say?
StarSeeker94 9 months ago
@PrivationProductions you cant kill any of the main characters outside the barn - i shot that other agents several times in the head but he was in the cutscene afterwards alive
TalonMercenary 8 months ago
if ya dont want to play as jack simply when you return home after you see some horses with unc and he is chillaxing after that mission is the barn when you play as jack dont do it but i did it it was boring it wasnt nature
mastaroni6 9 months ago
how lame no body knows jack man i spent tons of time make john famous so everyone knew him ugh wat a waste
310266762 10 months ago
Can someone tell me what mission is before the last, I really don't want to play as Jack.
dand0708 10 months ago
@dand0708 its a mission that you save jack, a bear was attacking he
Hyefer 9 months ago
@dand0708 This is the 2nd last mission. The one before this, you're gonna save Jack from a bear. And after this mission you're gonna play as Jack as an almost grown up (around 17-18 I think) and take revenge on Agent Ross. You're gonna meet him in Mexico in a shoot-out. If you kill him, You've completed the whole story and you're gonna play as Jack forever.
StarSeeker94 9 months ago
go to the attic...wait for every last one to climb up the ladder and shoot there heads off!!!!!!!!!!!!
mike826 10 months ago
can u kill all of them without dying if u use dead eye on a gun with loads of ammo
xxxcodboyzxxx 10 months ago
I just fucking laughed my ass off when he shoots Edgar Ross first.
Thats fucking hilarious.
But yeah, I was so fucking shocked when I saw him die.
videoman223 10 months ago 18
@videoman223 no he shot archer
puplover99 8 months ago
Comment removed
rucajuda 7 months ago
@videoman223 wait...if you shoot edgar first what about the mission with jack? three years after?
Coughranbranden 5 months ago
6:48
John: bang!
Army: BANG BANG BANG RATATATATA BOOOM BANG BANG BANG
TommyVercetti214 10 months ago 2
at 4:13 that is just sad like he thinks he will win
codyer121 11 months ago
Is there a possibility to end this mission alive ?
MiczuPolak 11 months ago
@MiczuPolak nope you die everytime
MrDvan812 10 months ago
I think he killed Archer. Thumbs up!
AddamHusayin 11 months ago
What's the name of the soundtrack that can be heard during this video?
It's not one the list of 19-soundtracks.
Please, that's the best soundtrack in the whole game!
RunkkaajaApina 11 months ago
@RunkkaajaApina It's called 'Triggernometry', and it is the best!
OrangesofSymmetry 10 months ago
Comment removed
sessionalJET21 11 months ago
i was like wtf i kill like 50 of them and i lose haha XD
Danieldx22 1 year ago
R.I.P John Marston
TurKeY2304 1 year ago 4
@chase00agent113 you die XD
lordgirino2010 1 year ago
at 6:42 i'd be like....okay back inside the barn!
mrhammertime85 1 year ago 3
cool wife
TheAlex12008 1 year ago
the enemies are very persistent. sending a 100 guys on you and still they want to mess around with you even though they arel ike 20 left
Alexander907able 1 year ago
when i did this mission it was cloudy and raining the whole time
NuggetStudios 1 year ago
You probably could have killed all the guys at the end with an evens repeater
RandomLightbulbs 1 year ago
@RandomLightbulbs Thats what i always thought :/
xmewx18 1 year ago
worst videogame ending ever!!
WikedAssPlayar 1 year ago
@WikedAssPlayar more like the saddest one..... i liked it
kfrontera83 1 year ago
@kfrontera83 I think its both: sad and bad.
But tell me the truth didin't u get pissed off when
Marston died.
He is a badass!
WikedAssPlayar 1 year ago 26
you shouldnt always use dead eye
sasakexumi 1 year ago
Archer fordham is one of the group who kills you i think he is in the middle
kutuzzle 1 year ago
@kutuzzle yh but if u read the in-games newspaper, he isnt mentioned or given any credit 4 Johns' death
Hoitech 1 year ago
@Hoitech yh i know if you dont kill him you should be able to do an extended edition of ' remember my family'
kutuzzle 1 year ago
i can never resist to skip the cut scenes its just a key part of the mission
cnacios 1 year ago
eshot effects like the wanted hahahah
QUEPORRAHEESSAVLOGLA 1 year ago
57 missions very short
mastaroni6 1 year ago
0:00 it says the mission is done by jack marston :S
kutuzzle 1 year ago
did someone tryed to kill that ROSS bitch standing between all those guys ??? idk im going to try it out now
ChiLLaKiLLa1000 1 year ago
MrSenneboy yeahhh lol i was comantig her and like 20 min i went n played and i figured out the last stranger task is what i wanted looool
ChiLLaKiLLa1000 1 year ago
aspire he didnt why would they make undead nightmare?
connerh37 1 year ago
uppsssss lol i just found out he is going to haha man im an idiot lmfao
ChiLLaKiLLa1000 1 year ago
i hate this sad ending . i just wished there were a last mission where jack goes and kills that stupid son of a bitch ROSS . that would made me happy
ChiLLaKiLLa1000 1 year ago
@ChiLLaKiLLa1000 there is a minnigame where jack goes kill edgar ross in Mexico? dont you now that?
MrSenneboy 1 year ago
@ChiLLaKiLLa1000 there is
donedealD 1 year ago
@ChiLLaKiLLa1000 theres is its called remember my family and its a stranger mission.
disruptfam 10 months ago
@ChiLLaKiLLa1000 There is. After john dies and your playing as jack, Go to blackwater. Side mission: Remember My Family.
You kill Ross On it. As Jack. But it dont always show up. Just look all over blackwater and if it aint there save the game and look again.
Hitmanfan12222 9 months ago
holy fuck you suck at the end shoot out try marking targets in deadeye dumbass
burnndogg 1 year ago
3:51 lol 360
juhotheonehanded 1 year ago
A sad ending
SuperJK321 1 year ago
If you look with the sniper on the graves you wil see john abagil or something and uncle and why doesnt have uncle a name?
SuperJK321 1 year ago
This game can win it without using the child tries to find a suit that you raise the dead eye and buys a gun with 15 bullets pull dead eye
Joel007com 1 year ago
what if u kill all those soldiers with the Dead Eye?
B3nga1 1 year ago
@B3nga1 It wont work etheir way he Still dies ):
DUBSTEP1667 1 year ago
@B3nga1 its impossible you have catleman oon that situation and when u have shot all your ammo you will die
juhotheonehanded 1 year ago
@MrMullig1 NO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!thts so sad cause u didnt even fire at them!
dingchavez9902 1 year ago
i can't make this mission happen for some reason
ThomasRowsell 1 year ago
you most familially fired your son LOL
sekahkiller 1 year ago
rumour has it that God or Death or whoever it is from 'Do I know you?' is in the background in the final scene (6:40) ish onwards
I cant see him but baaah weird times none the less in the stranger mission..
solardan 1 year ago
actually it does but in a very perculiar way, undead nightmare take place sometime around the time when john came back home from killind dutch van whatever. but happens before the his death in "the last enemy that shall be destroyed". so it does fit in with the orginal story. look it up if you dont believe. its called google.
xplayboards7 1 year ago
what happens if u dont shoot at the end?
dingchavez9902 1 year ago
Jack should have been the star in Undead Nightmare.
And at the end when the Undead come back,John would come out of the grave.
They should let you keep playing as Jack and have him kill John,Then Seth for taking the mask from the catacombs.
Write a comment on what you think of this.
vekussj5 1 year ago
@vekussj5 Suck, in my opinion.
Bubblefinno14 1 month ago
This was such a fantastic (first) ending and Marston needed to die. It gave a lot of gravity to the speeches Dutch and the Bureau gave about change; that Marston (and Ross) would eventually pay for what they have done. I'd strongly recommend giving the Red Dead wikia page a gander reddead.wikia.com/wiki/Edgar_Ross as the story is fantastically well written and you can see the characters' foreshadowing of what they would do.
jaykhunter 1 year ago
why did you skip the cutscenes
timelessthee 1 year ago
oke, one question... the us army killed john marston, but in undead nightmare he's still alive, soo i don't get it
gekkeie1997 1 year ago
@gekkeie1997 alternate story or something like that.
BlooDragon009 10 months ago
i don't get it, why did they attacked him? why did they killed him??
Ettoize 1 year ago
@Ettoize john marston used to be an outlaw so the US marshalls pretty much just used him to kill bill williamson. they didnt need him anymore so they came to kill him.
testnumberone1 1 year ago
@testnumberone1 ok, thank you
Ettoize 1 year ago
@Ettoize Because they tricked Marston into killing his old gang. But the Army want Marston's ENTIRE gang dead. And, well, Marston's WAS in the gang...so...
RabidWolverineVision 1 year ago
What's this gold medal crap? I want to watch the cutscenes.
127gggwtf 1 year ago
why didnt fucken Rickets come help!!!!
LCRUZ93 1 year ago
@LCRUZ93 Hes old
TeamTraxxas37614 1 year ago
Uncle is Red Harlow just sayin
dmansam45 1 year ago
@dmansam45 hes actually not, red harlow was born in 1880's , and if i aint wrong, from the 1880's to 1911 is no more than 25+ years or so. Uncle was born in 1835.
Pied.
Kalamando 1 year ago
thats not the last misson the last mission u end up finding edgar ross hunting in mexico and u draw with him and kill him thats the last mission but i think the game should have ended with replayable missions with your son and wife
StraightBound 1 year ago
@StraightBound i wanted to bring jack to hunt that bear the fucker was so keen to get...sad days...
dtr125er 1 year ago
@StraightBound in some ways i do agree with you that it should have ended like that. but once i thought it over the government would want to "cut all ties" with john marston including killing his family and his former gang. not surprised that the government would use someone like that as a tool
g4tviscool 1 year ago
When I saw Red Dead Redemption first advertised I thought it was a sequel to GUN. I LOVE GUN but Red Dead Redemption is awesome too. Sadly, I can see this happening to Colton White (The main character from GUN that you play as)
donaldlolwut 1 year ago
I think Jack at the end kinda looks like Johnny Depp in pirates of the carabean:S
BettyBoo123477 1 year ago
Lol during this part, I accidently turned off dead eye, so John looked like an idiot.
v_v
Remaanahk 1 year ago
Glad you skipped the cutscenes they're painful! I knew we all liked John but reality was he was in fact a criminal who had to pay for his crimes, he even committed some while we controlled him, people like that shouldn't walk among the rest of us abiding citizens in society. Even if they do change they have to pay for their mistakes. And John knew that, he knew the last enemy to be destroyed was death. To give his family freedom.
Marston was a likeable chraracter you grew to care for though.
holyfuck444 1 year ago
@holyfuck444
He got shot the hell up, abandoned by his clan, his family got snatched up and then he was FORCED to commit more crimes in order to bring in his old gang, and got shot the hell up AGAIN. And all he wanted to do was live the rest of his days law abiding and raising up a law abiding son with his wife. How is that worthy of a bloody death by some self-serving and backstabbing hypocrite who despite HIS misdeeds goes down a hero in history while John just dies another outlaw?
metaXzero 1 year ago
@metaXzero That's right. You got too attached to him though, and don't see the reality of it. We didn't want him to get shot up. I didn't. But that the creators is trying to get through to us is that his past caught up to him, what goes around comes around. That's life, bud.
holyfuck444 1 year ago
@holyfuck444
My point is that Marston already suffered enough. This wasn't life teaching a lesson. This was life showing how absolutely and unnecessarily cruel it can be. It also showed how life can go without karmic retribution for some who deserve it more. A man trying to mend his ways gets shot like a dog and remembered as scum while everything he tried to do goes down in darkness while another who is genuine scum and lovin it dies a "hero". Its life. And life sucks.
metaXzero 1 year ago
@metaXzero Yepp you got the point now, life can be cruel. Though John was a bad person in his past and tried mending it, he was still killing innocent people even in side missions that didn't need to die and he knew it, he knew he was still doing wrong. But John did get redemption, after his death when Jack murdered Edgar Ross, so the karmic balance is there. I agree with ya, but John shot the first bullet and they shot back. The point was to get attached to John. Excellent writing here.
holyfuck444 1 year ago
@holyfuck444
Side missions are just that; side missions. They are an optional part of the story. Just like its optional to go around and shoot up towns. I wouldn't count them along John's journey. Though I don't remember any part of the story side or otherwise where he was killing innoccents.
What balance? John dies and history recognizes him only for his past, his wife dies shortly afterwards, his son is driven down the path that he worked so hard to steer him clear of--
metaXzero 1 year ago
@holyfuck444
Ross takes the credit of John's good actions, goes down in history a hero of the proto-FBI and America in general, his skewed form of justice stays with him even in death, and his death is forever a pyrrhic victory for the Marstons. I don't see any form of justice being served besides Edgar's bastardized and hypocritic form of justice. Like I said, I just see life not being fair.
metaXzero 1 year ago
another question: Im not bothered to play the boring farm missions and i want to know why edgar ross kills john, He did do all his dirty work? Please tell
SpockHD 1 year ago
@SpockHD there is no definitive reason, but the best reason was that John Marston is still a mercenary in the law's eyes, even though he decided to fled that life. Edgar Ross took this opportunity to take down John Marston as a big "bounty" to get the medals and fame he wanted. that fat pig will burn.......
supersonicx123456789 1 year ago
2:38 THIS BIRD IS A SPY! 3:48 ASSSHOT 6:48 mind of soldier: this man is dangerous, lets shoot is a break!.......(edgar ross dead)......now!
HeikenCazen 1 year ago
Thanks mate.
padzsi 1 year ago
well, at least at the end Jack almost looks like John
Ettoize 1 year ago
I remember thinking in this mission, "Why not just get to the top of the barn and throw down some of that dynamite?". Guess that would be kind of a cop out though. The ending is sad, but it's supposed to be, it's fittingly bittersweet. I played a couple times to see if I could pick Archer and Ross out of the crowd, I think I got archer, not sure though...
sumanoskae 1 year ago