Considering the best I could probably do on any of these is some like fish flops on the floor lol I am definitely not qualified to judge. However with the way the woman spoke during Komova's floor routine she acted as though Komova would get the difficulty for that spin taken out and execution for it as well... then probably in this scoring system Wieber should have and did win. However to the lay viewer Wieber's mistakes seemed more obvious and gives credence to Komova winning.
In this montage it looks like Komova was robbed but it doesn't include the wobbles in almost half of her skills on beam, her fall of the spin and the low landing in the double pike.
@SuperGymmie Sorry, my english aren't great and I said it wrongly. She did not actually fall, but she had a mistake during on of her spins during her FX in the AA
We will have to wait to the Olympics to see who is the better gymnas! and dont't count Alya Mustafina out! She won Worlds 2011 with higher points! I will put my bet on Vika gold, Alya silver and Wieber brons
ALSO to those who say komova is a WAY better gymnast then wieber consider this she beat komova even with what they called/considered a major mistake on bars. Not saying komova isnt talented because she is but if wieber one its because on that particular day she was better
Komova made mistakes too. You just fail to acknowledge that in this montage. She ran out of her double tuck on floor and her head nearly hit her knees on her double pike. Her turns on beam and floor weren't as good as she can do them. I think, on the day, Wieber was the better gymnast. That isn't saying Komova isn't an amazing gymnast...fix just one of her landings and she would have won.
Just to put in perspective, if they competed with the 10.0 system Jordyn would not of won this title, Yao Jinnin would not have meddled and Viktoria would of just been in the mix.
I don't know why all the komova fans are freaking out about her not wining. Everyone knows the reigning world champ usually never (besides Liliya) wins the olympic all around. Maybe it's God telling Vika good things come to those who wait.. just a thought :)
WHat annoys me is that people all point out jordyns faults because they favour viktoria but they do not point out the faults she made e.g. - connections missed on beam, fauling out of spin on floor, and low under rotated double pike back = low chest on landing also - I LOVE BOTH GYMNASTS it is just annoying when people say how jordyn doesnt deserve it when infact... they both made mistakes!!
@astros1515 - for worlds I was routing more towards wieber because I felt like she would not win the AA in 2012.... I have this hunch she wont win the AA in 2012 so kinda wanted her to get it whilst she could?? - Although im not counting her out completly, she is clearly talented and a threat to others
@cwgcGymnast yeah but with bross coming back aly raisman and her than mustafina comig back it will be so interesting but it sucks thats theres the 2 per country rule because that means one of those 3 wont be allowed to compete
I am undecided who should have won, when an all around is that close they are both fantastic gymnasts. I hate to say this, but this montage is kind of biased against wieber...
@gymnasticsloverxoxo I agree. The montage is amazing, beautiful and breathtaking. But you show none of Komova's mistakes. Nothing personal, but it's just pretty biased. :)
The trainer of wieber and the trainers of USA did a campaign in opposition to komova, precionaron to the judges to be strict with komova and to lower the difficulty, on the other hand they were good with wieber in spite of his serious mistakes, The gentleman gedert and the lady karoli , cannot support that a Russian wounded by the foot ,is better than, the best gymnast of USA Before the eyes of the world, wieber is not the champion sorry, fans of USA, sorry NBC, sorry mister karoly
@concreto20 Komova made mistakes. She gave up. She thought she'd won and by floor it looked like she couldn't be bothered. Apart from a slight form deduction on bars and a step out of the floor (which is only 0.1), Wieber made no mistakes. She fought for the gold. Komova missed connections and didn't complete turns. Get your facts right before you post it for the world to see.
i think jodyn won fair and square. Komova really lacked the fire and determination at this championships. They both made errors but Komova's tiny errors just amounted to more i guess.
i think jordyn deserved to win even though she had those 2 major mistakes.. i feel bad for komova but she made a lot of little mistakes on beam and floor and they just added up
Both girls were amazing but I agree with you and think that Komova should have won but I am happy for Jordyn. She did som great routines, especially her beam but her floor score seemed a little too high as it wasn't a great perfomance. Having said that, she is a fantastic gymnast and it will be great to see her lots more in the future.
i really think wieber deserved it, because she made just about as many (if not less) mistakes than komova, but then her start values were higher so it makes sense to me, granted i don't know much about gymnastics
I understand fully why Wieber won and Komova lost in the end. People are trying to compare the two as if it came down to the mistakes. Komova lost due to her lower start values and lack of a clean performance. The wobbles and sloppy landings stand out. Komova had no major falls but she needs to step up the difficulty on vault and floor. Jordyn made one form break on bars but had way more difficulty. Komova better bring it for 2012
Really people are fussing cos it was toooo close -if either one of them had stuck just one more landing or something there would have been a clear winner, people would be cooler. alot of people thought Komova would win, we wanted her to win, she's more graceful - but in the end she made clear mistakes - we thought the Russians would protest anyway. It's typical gymnastics - on the day. Komova is a bit fragile caught up in the moment hopefully she'll toughen up with this. They are all amazing.:)
I have to agree, I honestly think Komova deserved to win, although Jordyn is very good, Komova has this quality in her gymnastics that is just so supple, light, and graceful! She is a true beauty to watch! And Komova still can improve on vault (2.5TY), bars (she can change the composition around), beam (patterson dismount, connecting her full turn to front arial and sheep jump) and floor (double layout instead of double tuck)! Komova is truly amazing, showdown in London for sure :D
I don't think this is too unfair at all. Besides the fact that it didn't show Komova's second and fourth pass. This videos shows highlights of each event (Wieber had no highlights on bars. SuperGymmie can't help that!) and each pass except for two of Komova's.
Komova will be 100% on 2012, so Russia will have Komova and Mustafina (or Grishina) on the AA final. I won't be surprised if Russia takes gold and silver in London. So, Vika and Aliya for 2012 Olympic medal... it will be a HUGE showdown!
Victoria had more problems than people want to talk about. On Floor: 3 poor tumbling passes, fell out of two (and didn’t finish) spins, had a hop on a slit jump landing. Beam: Didn’t connect a lot of skills, had five balance checks, and didn’t finish a spin. Bars: Hit her feet on the bar during a release move, didn’t hit a handstand, and took a step on landing. Vault: Small hop on landing. We can say Jordyn had a lot of mistakes. But they both did. It was a close raise.
Before it all started I wanted Jordyn to win, but Komova did way better in the final, so in my opinion Komova deserved it more. doesn't make me less happy for Jordyn.
I do think that Viktoria Komova deserved to win but I am still happy for Jordyn even though when I learn't the results I was gob smacked for about 20 minutes and had completely different thoughts and opinions about it.
poor vika :( she was devastated! I still don't know how i feel about this result, its just the way absolutely everyone thought vika had won and then instead of the crowd cheering when the winner was announced it just went silent :( Im happy jordyn won because she is a fantastic gymnast but i definitely would have been happier if she'd done the floor routine of her life! I love her floor but in aa it wasnt her best! I want a komova/wieber/mustafina/bross showdown in 2012!
Plus the only routine Komova had that was more difficult was bars! So 2 errors total with difficult routines beats about 10 smaller errors with simpiler routines
Wont people dont understand is that Jordyn may have had more VISABLE errors. While Komova has several not as noticable errors that add up. Wieber had the mistake on bars and out of bounds on floor, thats it. While Komova struck her foot on the bar, had a missed connection and wobbles on beam, a fall out of the turn on floor, and a low landing double pike. Not to mention Komova has bad twisting form. So when you really think about, Jordyn really did deserve to win!
@gymnasticsfan14 - omg i love you hahaha! No seriously though, you are the first person who has agreed with me! Its like people are blind when it comes to gymnasts they favour!
@cwgcGymnast Thank you! haha(: But yes I agree, people are totally blind when it comes to their favorites! You should go check out my new video on why Jordyn won the all around...its on my channel. I think it explains the all around well for the blind komova fans ;)
@gymnasticsfan14 There's more than that for both gymnasts. You can't go by two mistakes and say who won. You're forgetting Wieber's bobble on her 1/2 turn on beam, Vika's big hop on her double tuck on beam, Jordyn's lack of height on vault, Komova's big hop on her double tuck on floor, et cetera. There's a bunch of stuff and I don't think it's fair to mention only the mistakes by one gymnast. And Jordyn had many more execution errors than Komova... Definately not 2...
@ShawnVikaKomova2012 Yeah its not fair just point out just one person's mistakes. But thats pretty much what this video did. It showed all Jordyn's errors and she edited out all Victorias! I felt like this video was made just to put down Jordyn. Man I hope she dosnt see this! I know they both made mistakes, but Komova clearly made more! I wish people would just stop all this wieber komova stuff. They both deserved what they got!
@gymnasticsfan14 I totally agree. Jordyn won fair. Komova lost credit on a turn on beam and on floor. Yes Jordyn made a form break but that is less tenths than a loss of credit. I am proud of the standings. Anyway 2nd is not bad. Komova made me a little upset in how she reacted it was a little rood.
@gymnasticsfan14 /watch?v=1eBIeKtC8VY the wobble on her half turn comes at 0:49. She wavers one of her arms. And actually her full turn had a hop. And I take it that this video was made as a joke because of the "who really should've won" videos... They don't seem to be too fair.
@ShawnVikaKomova2012 I dont think they made this as a joke. Their obiously a Komova fan and have to create a video to make Jordyn look bad. There trying to say Komova should have won, to bad she had to edit out all Komova's mistakes. And no, there was no wobble there. I dont get what your seeing? Watch her foot, it never tilts to the side or anything. Her arms never waver! There may have been the slightest & i mean very slighest tilt in her body at the end of the turn. But thats not a deduction
@gymnasticsfan14 Well there have been two videos uploaded trying to make Komova look terrible and Wieber excellent. The only edit is her sheep jump landing. Maybe you need to watch it again. Her full turn has a small hop. It's a bit uncontrolled. And her half turn has a very noticeable wobble. It in fact is a deduction.
@ShawnVikaKomova2012 Thats not true, my video as well as the other one I've seen arnt trying to make Komova look bad rather showing why Wieber won. My video shows not only Komova's mistakes, but Jordyns as well. In this video she shows all Wiebers mistakes, and edits the landings of Komova on beam. she wobble on almost every skill. On floor she didnt show Komova falling out of the double turn, or her last pass. She showeed all Jordyn's passes besides the last one where she stuck it.
@gymnasticsfan14 She doesn't show all of Wieber's mistakes in this video. Wieber made many more. All three videos should show all of the mistakes each gymnast made for it to be fair. Not one of the three videos does that. They are all biased which is why on yoliss94's videos, I'm making my own scores for Wieber and Komova. I didn't do Komova's yet. I will try to be as fair as possible.
@ShawnVikaKomova2012 What mistakes does Wieber make that arnt in this video? To me it looks like she included all of them! But this video is the least fair because it shows none of Komova's mistakes. On beam where she had a bunch of wobbles, she cut it out. And on floor she dosnt even show Komova falling out of the double turn, or the her last pass. This video was made to make Wieber look bad, not show why she won. My video is pretty fair. I think I showed both their mistakes, & good things to!
@gymnasticsfan14 I don't think any are fair unless they show every single skill performed and include "-0.1 for bobble on turn" or whatever. I think this video is fair. It shows equal good and bad for both. If SuperGymmie really was against Wieber, they could've included the wobble on her side somi and showed her vault from another angle. Or even not have showed her triple spin and bars dismount which really are the only skills Wieber did that don't require deduction...
@ShawnVikaKomova2012 True, but I did show almost every they did. I honestly just didnt want to take the time to write down where each deduction occured and how much it costs. This was just to give everyone a basic idea. This video basically shows all Jordyn's mistakes. And none of Komova's. & she didnt wobble on her side somi either? You do realize a wobble is when you foot comes off the beam, you body leans forward or backward, you arms are wavering. Your to anal about everything.
@gymnasticsfan14 Not to criticize... But your video was about 4 minutes long... Generally vault is about 8 seconds long, beam 1:30, floor 1:30, and bars 45 seconds so your video would've been 8 minutes if every skill was shown. A wobble isn't necessarily when that stuff occurs. On Wieber's switch leap + back pike on beam, when she raises her arms after the back pike, she leans toward the side. That's a deduction.
@lylaha - i agree!! she didnt show the spin she fell out off = major deductions, double pike = lack of rotation, lack of height, low chest on landing, and went flying = 0.3 out her double tuck back... I LOVE both girls, but I have to agree - only shown here jordyns faults - none of Komovas, unfair?
Komova should have won she was by far the most artistic of the two and had very little major mistakes so for london 2012 im TEAM KOMOVA!!!!! all the way
Oh, this montage shows oob landing very clearly. While I kept the thought that some scores are probably questionalble , it's surely now!! Well, the FX judges need to undergo qualification test! There's been quite a few inquiries on Mitchell's floor for example and here.. I believe that these two gymnasts both deserve to win.But it's heartbreaking margin and somehow it left the feeling of doubt and dissatisfaction on the resuls.
I love both girls, they both had mistakes, wiebers mroe noticable to the eye so no need to state however, komovas double pike was low, under rotated and chest was low on landing as a result of this, she also fell out of a spin... I feel sorry for Komova :/ she is so artisic and graceful and pleasant to watch but at the same time wieber is pleasant to watch due to her explosive power... Both girls amazing in their own ways, and i agree its not right at all to put wieber down just because she won
@cwgcGymnast I think that the people who truely love gymnastics never put others down or being disrespectful. But so many men so many minds. I don't argue Viktoria's score, but is Jordyn FX in this AA final worth 14. 800?! Still congradulations to Jordyn, she worked hard for that , and I really hope Viktoria will shine and be more beautiful than ever in London 2012!!
@lilidaification - 14.8 is a mammoth score not going to lie, but deductions wise i only saw the obvious step out of bounds and hops on landings, and the hops depending on how big range from 0.1 to 0.3 and most of hers were 0.1 hops I am happy for Jordyn she wasn't expecting to win and sometimes a win like that is the best - the reaction, the happy tears, made me want to cry for her - I also hope Komova will shine in 2012 too, she has been recognised world wide as big competition for the future!!
I think Komova really deserved to win this title, she had much more regularity in this competition than Wieber who made some big mistakes.. I mean that Wieber won only thanks to her vault and beam whereas Komova was a true All-Arounder... I'm really disappointed. But I'm sur Komova will shine in 2012 :) !
If this was in 2008, they would have no chance against Shawn Johnson and Nastia.
kbrawn92 1 week ago
@kbrawn92 ...They're better...
ShawnVikaKomova2012 5 days ago
I don't want to be mean but I feel really bad that Mustafina couldn't compete in those worlds. If she had there would be no controversy
xrictinagymnastics 3 weeks ago
Considering the best I could probably do on any of these is some like fish flops on the floor lol I am definitely not qualified to judge. However with the way the woman spoke during Komova's floor routine she acted as though Komova would get the difficulty for that spin taken out and execution for it as well... then probably in this scoring system Wieber should have and did win. However to the lay viewer Wieber's mistakes seemed more obvious and gives credence to Komova winning.
ULibby 1 month ago
i love the rusian girl she had to win! i mean also is about the difference of ages :s
renata12565 1 month ago
how old is Komova?
nerdynordy28 1 month ago
@nerdynordy28 She's 16 :)
GymnasticsFan1144 1 month ago
In this montage it looks like Komova was robbed but it doesn't include the wobbles in almost half of her skills on beam, her fall of the spin and the low landing in the double pike.
xrictinaaa1 1 month ago
@xrictinaaa1 She didnt fall on the spin in AA she fell during Beam finals.
SuperGymmie 1 month ago
@SuperGymmie Sorry, my english aren't great and I said it wrongly. She did not actually fall, but she had a mistake during on of her spins during her FX in the AA
xrictinaaa1 1 month ago
i feel so bad for Komova but I like Shawn the Best
SuperSoup99 2 months ago
We will have to wait to the Olympics to see who is the better gymnas! and dont't count Alya Mustafina out! She won Worlds 2011 with higher points! I will put my bet on Vika gold, Alya silver and Wieber brons
pollewopje112 2 months ago
ALSO to those who say komova is a WAY better gymnast then wieber consider this she beat komova even with what they called/considered a major mistake on bars. Not saying komova isnt talented because she is but if wieber one its because on that particular day she was better
astros1515 2 months ago
@astros1515 Consider Komova started full training in June and was only doing 80% of her full difficulty... And she had many .3 deductions...
ShawnVikaKomova2012 2 months ago
I think they both should win! : )
They so lovely and strong gymnast
Whitelazyfox 3 months ago in playlist Liked videos
Comment removed
Whitelazyfox 3 months ago in playlist Liked videos
komova, the original champions
concreto20 3 months ago 2
Komova made mistakes too. You just fail to acknowledge that in this montage. She ran out of her double tuck on floor and her head nearly hit her knees on her double pike. Her turns on beam and floor weren't as good as she can do them. I think, on the day, Wieber was the better gymnast. That isn't saying Komova isn't an amazing gymnast...fix just one of her landings and she would have won.
phillipadickens 3 months ago 2
Just to put in perspective, if they competed with the 10.0 system Jordyn would not of won this title, Yao Jinnin would not have meddled and Viktoria would of just been in the mix.
liukin95 3 months ago
I don't know why all the komova fans are freaking out about her not wining. Everyone knows the reigning world champ usually never (besides Liliya) wins the olympic all around. Maybe it's God telling Vika good things come to those who wait.. just a thought :)
carriemydear 4 months ago
WHat annoys me is that people all point out jordyns faults because they favour viktoria but they do not point out the faults she made e.g. - connections missed on beam, fauling out of spin on floor, and low under rotated double pike back = low chest on landing also - I LOVE BOTH GYMNASTS it is just annoying when people say how jordyn doesnt deserve it when infact... they both made mistakes!!
cwgcGymnast 4 months ago
@cwgcGymnast completly agree with you 100%. Who were you rooting for to win the AA?
astros1515 2 months ago
@astros1515 - for worlds I was routing more towards wieber because I felt like she would not win the AA in 2012.... I have this hunch she wont win the AA in 2012 so kinda wanted her to get it whilst she could?? - Although im not counting her out completly, she is clearly talented and a threat to others
cwgcGymnast 2 months ago
@cwgcGymnast yeah but with bross coming back aly raisman and her than mustafina comig back it will be so interesting but it sucks thats theres the 2 per country rule because that means one of those 3 wont be allowed to compete
astros1515 2 months ago
@astros1515 - very true... It is going to be an Olympics to remember!!
cwgcGymnast 2 months ago
Viktoriya Komova should have won. Jordin made some mistakes.
GymnasticJam 4 months ago
I am undecided who should have won, when an all around is that close they are both fantastic gymnasts. I hate to say this, but this montage is kind of biased against wieber...
gymnasticsloverxoxo 4 months ago 10
@gymnasticsloverxoxo I agree. The montage is amazing, beautiful and breathtaking. But you show none of Komova's mistakes. Nothing personal, but it's just pretty biased. :)
CopGymnast861 1 month ago
Jordan worked really hard and she deserved that win very much! I am very happy for her!!
jbuglovesgymnastics 4 months ago
It was riged. Komova should have won </3
number1soifongfan 4 months ago
The trainer of wieber and the trainers of USA did a campaign in opposition to komova, precionaron to the judges to be strict with komova and to lower the difficulty, on the other hand they were good with wieber in spite of his serious mistakes, The gentleman gedert and the lady karoli , cannot support that a Russian wounded by the foot ,is better than, the best gymnast of USA Before the eyes of the world, wieber is not the champion sorry, fans of USA, sorry NBC, sorry mister karoly
concreto20 4 months ago
@concreto20 Komova made mistakes. She gave up. She thought she'd won and by floor it looked like she couldn't be bothered. Apart from a slight form deduction on bars and a step out of the floor (which is only 0.1), Wieber made no mistakes. She fought for the gold. Komova missed connections and didn't complete turns. Get your facts right before you post it for the world to see.
phillipadickens 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
komova with 70% of difficulty was in 0033 to win the day this 100% none can beat him. perhaps Iordache and Mustafina.
concreto20 4 months ago
i think jodyn won fair and square. Komova really lacked the fire and determination at this championships. They both made errors but Komova's tiny errors just amounted to more i guess.
KMoney3187 4 months ago in playlist More videos from SuperGymmie
i think jordyn deserved to win even though she had those 2 major mistakes.. i feel bad for komova but she made a lot of little mistakes on beam and floor and they just added up
aaligymnast095 4 months ago
Both girls were amazing but I agree with you and think that Komova should have won but I am happy for Jordyn. She did som great routines, especially her beam but her floor score seemed a little too high as it wasn't a great perfomance. Having said that, she is a fantastic gymnast and it will be great to see her lots more in the future.
flopsyandcottontail 4 months ago
ARE YOU BACK!?!?! i miss your videos :'(
i really think wieber deserved it, because she made just about as many (if not less) mistakes than komova, but then her start values were higher so it makes sense to me, granted i don't know much about gymnastics
rsmistletoe3 4 months ago
I understand fully why Wieber won and Komova lost in the end. People are trying to compare the two as if it came down to the mistakes. Komova lost due to her lower start values and lack of a clean performance. The wobbles and sloppy landings stand out. Komova had no major falls but she needs to step up the difficulty on vault and floor. Jordyn made one form break on bars but had way more difficulty. Komova better bring it for 2012
jevonk 4 months ago
Really people are fussing cos it was toooo close -if either one of them had stuck just one more landing or something there would have been a clear winner, people would be cooler. alot of people thought Komova would win, we wanted her to win, she's more graceful - but in the end she made clear mistakes - we thought the Russians would protest anyway. It's typical gymnastics - on the day. Komova is a bit fragile caught up in the moment hopefully she'll toughen up with this. They are all amazing.:)
Erifilly111 4 months ago
I love this :') thanks so much for making this, it says exactly what needs to be said..great job :)
CopGymnast861 4 months ago
What's the name of the song? It's beautiful!
danielcnsilva 4 months ago
@danielcnsilva the song is called Numb by Barcelona :)
SuperGymmie 4 months ago
Nice video :D
I had prefered that Vika win, but I'm happy for Jordyn. She did a great job to win with her mistake. I hope Komova will do better in London :D
GymnastJohnsonShawn 4 months ago
What editor do you use??
blokflip13 4 months ago
@blokflip13 Ulead Video Studio 11
SuperGymmie 4 months ago
I have to agree, I honestly think Komova deserved to win, although Jordyn is very good, Komova has this quality in her gymnastics that is just so supple, light, and graceful! She is a true beauty to watch! And Komova still can improve on vault (2.5TY), bars (she can change the composition around), beam (patterson dismount, connecting her full turn to front arial and sheep jump) and floor (double layout instead of double tuck)! Komova is truly amazing, showdown in London for sure :D
GymnasticsFan1144 4 months ago 2
I don't think this is too unfair at all. Besides the fact that it didn't show Komova's second and fourth pass. This videos shows highlights of each event (Wieber had no highlights on bars. SuperGymmie can't help that!) and each pass except for two of Komova's.
ShawnVikaKomova2012 4 months ago
Ok. Jordyn won fair and square.. You can have your own opinions, but leave it be that she DID deserve this.
How would she feel if she saw so many people saying that she didn't deserve it? How would you feel?
gymnastjaiderz 4 months ago
Comment removed
GymnasticsFan1144 4 months ago
Komova will be 100% on 2012, so Russia will have Komova and Mustafina (or Grishina) on the AA final. I won't be surprised if Russia takes gold and silver in London. So, Vika and Aliya for 2012 Olympic medal... it will be a HUGE showdown!
brdbarreira 4 months ago 6
Victoria had more problems than people want to talk about. On Floor: 3 poor tumbling passes, fell out of two (and didn’t finish) spins, had a hop on a slit jump landing. Beam: Didn’t connect a lot of skills, had five balance checks, and didn’t finish a spin. Bars: Hit her feet on the bar during a release move, didn’t hit a handstand, and took a step on landing. Vault: Small hop on landing. We can say Jordyn had a lot of mistakes. But they both did. It was a close raise.
lisapizza16 4 months ago
My opinion It should have been Komova..She looked stronger, more consistent...
Dimaolerd1 4 months ago
Before it all started I wanted Jordyn to win, but Komova did way better in the final, so in my opinion Komova deserved it more. doesn't make me less happy for Jordyn.
Kadolino 4 months ago
beautiful montage :) better than the one i made haha.
i love both of them <3
kiwigymnast16 4 months ago
I do think that Viktoria Komova deserved to win but I am still happy for Jordyn even though when I learn't the results I was gob smacked for about 20 minutes and had completely different thoughts and opinions about it.
liukin95 4 months ago
poor vika :( she was devastated! I still don't know how i feel about this result, its just the way absolutely everyone thought vika had won and then instead of the crowd cheering when the winner was announced it just went silent :( Im happy jordyn won because she is a fantastic gymnast but i definitely would have been happier if she'd done the floor routine of her life! I love her floor but in aa it wasnt her best! I want a komova/wieber/mustafina/bross showdown in 2012!
gymnastdory 4 months ago 17
Plus the only routine Komova had that was more difficult was bars! So 2 errors total with difficult routines beats about 10 smaller errors with simpiler routines
gymnasticsfan14 4 months ago
Wont people dont understand is that Jordyn may have had more VISABLE errors. While Komova has several not as noticable errors that add up. Wieber had the mistake on bars and out of bounds on floor, thats it. While Komova struck her foot on the bar, had a missed connection and wobbles on beam, a fall out of the turn on floor, and a low landing double pike. Not to mention Komova has bad twisting form. So when you really think about, Jordyn really did deserve to win!
gymnasticsfan14 4 months ago
@gymnasticsfan14 - omg i love you hahaha! No seriously though, you are the first person who has agreed with me! Its like people are blind when it comes to gymnasts they favour!
cwgcGymnast 4 months ago
@cwgcGymnast Thank you! haha(: But yes I agree, people are totally blind when it comes to their favorites! You should go check out my new video on why Jordyn won the all around...its on my channel. I think it explains the all around well for the blind komova fans ;)
gymnasticsfan14 4 months ago
@gymnasticsfan14 There's more than that for both gymnasts. You can't go by two mistakes and say who won. You're forgetting Wieber's bobble on her 1/2 turn on beam, Vika's big hop on her double tuck on beam, Jordyn's lack of height on vault, Komova's big hop on her double tuck on floor, et cetera. There's a bunch of stuff and I don't think it's fair to mention only the mistakes by one gymnast. And Jordyn had many more execution errors than Komova... Definately not 2...
ShawnVikaKomova2012 4 months ago
@ShawnVikaKomova2012 Yeah its not fair just point out just one person's mistakes. But thats pretty much what this video did. It showed all Jordyn's errors and she edited out all Victorias! I felt like this video was made just to put down Jordyn. Man I hope she dosnt see this! I know they both made mistakes, but Komova clearly made more! I wish people would just stop all this wieber komova stuff. They both deserved what they got!
gymnasticsfan14 4 months ago
@gymnasticsfan14 I totally agree. Jordyn won fair. Komova lost credit on a turn on beam and on floor. Yes Jordyn made a form break but that is less tenths than a loss of credit. I am proud of the standings. Anyway 2nd is not bad. Komova made me a little upset in how she reacted it was a little rood.
ASPaez1965 4 months ago
@ShawnVikaKomova2012 & what do you mean her wobble on the turn on beam? She didnt wobble...her arms didnt even waver????
gymnasticsfan14 4 months ago
@gymnasticsfan14 /watch?v=1eBIeKtC8VY the wobble on her half turn comes at 0:49. She wavers one of her arms. And actually her full turn had a hop. And I take it that this video was made as a joke because of the "who really should've won" videos... They don't seem to be too fair.
ShawnVikaKomova2012 4 months ago
@ShawnVikaKomova2012 I dont think they made this as a joke. Their obiously a Komova fan and have to create a video to make Jordyn look bad. There trying to say Komova should have won, to bad she had to edit out all Komova's mistakes. And no, there was no wobble there. I dont get what your seeing? Watch her foot, it never tilts to the side or anything. Her arms never waver! There may have been the slightest & i mean very slighest tilt in her body at the end of the turn. But thats not a deduction
gymnasticsfan14 4 months ago
@gymnasticsfan14 Well there have been two videos uploaded trying to make Komova look terrible and Wieber excellent. The only edit is her sheep jump landing. Maybe you need to watch it again. Her full turn has a small hop. It's a bit uncontrolled. And her half turn has a very noticeable wobble. It in fact is a deduction.
ShawnVikaKomova2012 4 months ago
@ShawnVikaKomova2012 Thats not true, my video as well as the other one I've seen arnt trying to make Komova look bad rather showing why Wieber won. My video shows not only Komova's mistakes, but Jordyns as well. In this video she shows all Wiebers mistakes, and edits the landings of Komova on beam. she wobble on almost every skill. On floor she didnt show Komova falling out of the double turn, or her last pass. She showeed all Jordyn's passes besides the last one where she stuck it.
gymnasticsfan14 4 months ago
@gymnasticsfan14 She doesn't show all of Wieber's mistakes in this video. Wieber made many more. All three videos should show all of the mistakes each gymnast made for it to be fair. Not one of the three videos does that. They are all biased which is why on yoliss94's videos, I'm making my own scores for Wieber and Komova. I didn't do Komova's yet. I will try to be as fair as possible.
ShawnVikaKomova2012 4 months ago
@ShawnVikaKomova2012 What mistakes does Wieber make that arnt in this video? To me it looks like she included all of them! But this video is the least fair because it shows none of Komova's mistakes. On beam where she had a bunch of wobbles, she cut it out. And on floor she dosnt even show Komova falling out of the double turn, or the her last pass. This video was made to make Wieber look bad, not show why she won. My video is pretty fair. I think I showed both their mistakes, & good things to!
gymnasticsfan14 4 months ago
@gymnasticsfan14 I don't think any are fair unless they show every single skill performed and include "-0.1 for bobble on turn" or whatever. I think this video is fair. It shows equal good and bad for both. If SuperGymmie really was against Wieber, they could've included the wobble on her side somi and showed her vault from another angle. Or even not have showed her triple spin and bars dismount which really are the only skills Wieber did that don't require deduction...
ShawnVikaKomova2012 4 months ago
@ShawnVikaKomova2012 True, but I did show almost every they did. I honestly just didnt want to take the time to write down where each deduction occured and how much it costs. This was just to give everyone a basic idea. This video basically shows all Jordyn's mistakes. And none of Komova's. & she didnt wobble on her side somi either? You do realize a wobble is when you foot comes off the beam, you body leans forward or backward, you arms are wavering. Your to anal about everything.
gymnasticsfan14 4 months ago
@gymnasticsfan14 Not to criticize... But your video was about 4 minutes long... Generally vault is about 8 seconds long, beam 1:30, floor 1:30, and bars 45 seconds so your video would've been 8 minutes if every skill was shown. A wobble isn't necessarily when that stuff occurs. On Wieber's switch leap + back pike on beam, when she raises her arms after the back pike, she leans toward the side. That's a deduction.
ShawnVikaKomova2012 4 months ago
hm you did show all Jordyn her faults, but none of Komova's, you make it look like Komova was perfect :p I don't mean this rude btw.
lylaha 4 months ago
@lylaha - i agree!! she didnt show the spin she fell out off = major deductions, double pike = lack of rotation, lack of height, low chest on landing, and went flying = 0.3 out her double tuck back... I LOVE both girls, but I have to agree - only shown here jordyns faults - none of Komovas, unfair?
cwgcGymnast 4 months ago
victoria aurai du gagner !
manongse 4 months ago
Komova should have won she was by far the most artistic of the two and had very little major mistakes so for london 2012 im TEAM KOMOVA!!!!! all the way
13shifter 4 months ago 2
@13shifter
I seriously hope that between Bross and Weiber, Komova comes in a far away third. Go Team USA!
georgert 4 months ago
@georgert ik its a hard decision for me but im still team Komova maybe Jordyn and Bross will change my mind, im still open to any surprises
13shifter 4 months ago
@georgert Not possible, haha.
ShawnVikaKomova2012 4 months ago
Beautiful montage!! Thank you!!
lilidaification 4 months ago
Oh, this montage shows oob landing very clearly. While I kept the thought that some scores are probably questionalble , it's surely now!! Well, the FX judges need to undergo qualification test! There's been quite a few inquiries on Mitchell's floor for example and here.. I believe that these two gymnasts both deserve to win.But it's heartbreaking margin and somehow it left the feeling of doubt and dissatisfaction on the resuls.
lilidaification 4 months ago
I love both girls, they both had mistakes, wiebers mroe noticable to the eye so no need to state however, komovas double pike was low, under rotated and chest was low on landing as a result of this, she also fell out of a spin... I feel sorry for Komova :/ she is so artisic and graceful and pleasant to watch but at the same time wieber is pleasant to watch due to her explosive power... Both girls amazing in their own ways, and i agree its not right at all to put wieber down just because she won
cwgcGymnast 4 months ago
@cwgcGymnast I think that the people who truely love gymnastics never put others down or being disrespectful. But so many men so many minds. I don't argue Viktoria's score, but is Jordyn FX in this AA final worth 14. 800?! Still congradulations to Jordyn, she worked hard for that , and I really hope Viktoria will shine and be more beautiful than ever in London 2012!!
lilidaification 4 months ago
@lilidaification - 14.8 is a mammoth score not going to lie, but deductions wise i only saw the obvious step out of bounds and hops on landings, and the hops depending on how big range from 0.1 to 0.3 and most of hers were 0.1 hops I am happy for Jordyn she wasn't expecting to win and sometimes a win like that is the best - the reaction, the happy tears, made me want to cry for her - I also hope Komova will shine in 2012 too, she has been recognised world wide as big competition for the future!!
cwgcGymnast 4 months ago
Komova deserved the title. I don't think Wieber deserves to be abused for her win, however.
FallenRose101 4 months ago 3
What effects did you use for the coloring>?? It's lovely!
blokflip13 4 months ago
KOMOVA DESERVED THE WIN!!!!!!
LOVxxE 4 months ago 2
Fabulous montage ;)
They both did wonderfully!
Athlete065 4 months ago
I think Komova really deserved to win this title, she had much more regularity in this competition than Wieber who made some big mistakes.. I mean that Wieber won only thanks to her vault and beam whereas Komova was a true All-Arounder... I'm really disappointed. But I'm sur Komova will shine in 2012 :) !
Lauureette 4 months ago 11
i feel so bad for Komova
dientes025 4 months ago
I think Komova was better but Jordyn done a fantastic job!
TheGymnast1305 4 months ago 2