Added: 4 years ago
From: bnlmusic
Views: 19,125
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (36)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Bump #UN#. Check out our 007 License Plate Hide kit for bike&cars tho ;-)

  • Hmm I guess its true, Some of the best stuff comes to you in the bathroom ( =

    I love your Music, Have ever since I was a little Girl

  • The reason I've decided to stick primarily with rhythm guitar! over the past 16 yrs. Love it all Ed! Thanks!

  • Love it man. The album version of this song reminds me of a Phish song: especially the last 50 seconds. Great stuff!

  • I kno how it goes. Thats too bad, My son recently passed away and he was only 1month and 12days old. This song just about made me cry as well.

  • Your song so reminds me of 'My Immortal'. They have the same meaning, but I can tell that yours has so much emotion because it's real.

    Take it easy, Ed. Your fans are here for you :)

  • This song alway makes me want to cry, not only because of your brother and the pain you went through, but also, it reminds me of my dad. He took his own life about 13 years ago, when I was just a litte kid and I've been having dreams about him ever since. I guess that's why you're my favourite artist, you make music from your soul

  • What a great song! can't stop listening to it.

  • <3 Ed! Great song...

  • One of my favorites!

  • Please do a bathroom rendition of "Just a Toy!" It's one of my favorite songs and it's never played!

  • I had no idea Ed! Not like he may read this I dunno. But man I love this song and I'm sorry of the circumstances too. You rock.

  • The concept of this makes me think of the show Rescue Me, with Denis Leary seeing the ghost of his cousin all the time.

  • totally man. i love that show.

  • thanks for that. that is one of my favs.

  • oh, full stars, great, the first time I saw in youtube! and that with 65 votes, great, greaaaat, I want to destroy it perfectness, DESTROY. Joke, man :)

  • This is beautiful..........

  • Great break up song lol

  • This song is even better in acoustic! So sorry about Doug tho, it's hard to lose a family member, I know, but I'm glad u got on with your life.

  • Love this song, sorry about the pain you went through Ed to get inspired for it. I was just kicked out of a park by a cop and this song was playing interesting.  Out of 2300 songs this is the one the ipod was playing coincidence?

  • I think not.

  • Such a beautiful song born from such a tragic event. _Ed you´re incredible...

  • thank you SO much for posting these, Ed. I was at the edmonton show and I cried when you played Brian Wilson! This song is amazing too and like most people I thought it was about a breakup but now that you've explained it it makes more sense! Thank you for everything!

    -Charlotte

  • Never really liked this song... until now. I always figured Am I The Only One was about the unfortunate accident. That one has always brought me to the verge of tears.

  • Never really liked this song... until now. I always figured Am I The Only One was the unfortunate accident song. That one always brought me to the verge of tears.

  • A song recorded in the bathroom? That'll make you a "fixture" on the music scene! Thanks, Ed...that was fun. - Josh G.

  • Ed. You are amazing. I couldn't think how this would sound the same as on the cd, with just one guitar. It's nice to know the meaning and feel your feelings through the lyrics. Your soul shines.

  • Dude. I too always thought it was a breakup song. In a way it is, just a breakup that you can never think of happining.

  • I hope writing this song helped you to sleep a bit better....

  • Amazing. I've always loved this song but love it even more ever since I learned what it was truly about. Excellent job.

    --Ethan

  • You make me want to smash my guitar against a wall!  That was great man, thanks.

  • Wow... thanks for sharing something so deeply personal. I had always had a similar "guess" at the meaning of the song, and overall liked it's general sound, etc... but I guess I had assumed it more of a "breakup" song. Thanks again for sharing another great "new" version of your music!

  • Barenaked Ladies are REAL!

    Barenaked Ladies are People Too...

    Barenaked Ladies are EMO.

    Barenaked Ladies are Down to Earth.

    Barenaked Ladies are ME.

  • I don't see any barenaked ladies.

  • gee, thanks for pointing that out.

  • I frequently skipped over this song for years due to not understanding it. Then you explained it at the Hartford Peep Show back in '03. For me, this song shows how you are so personally passionate while explaining something like the grieving process for us all. In a way, your writing compliments the connection between artist and audience that occurs durring BNL's live shows. Well done once again.

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more