一无所有-催健

[gk910830]

臧天朔 亮点，一直听这首歌，现场版更屌

[MANGCANG]

一个时代的开始

[wolfyloner]

你爸爸姓崔？

你爸爸叫健！

[XvallorX]

I love "I have nothing" (崔健) - one of my favorite song all the time. Regards from Poland!

[taxuell]

吹笛子的是谁啊？

让我想到窦唯那些经典的笛声。

还吹唢呐啦！

[GoldenCalfChannel]

sky86560 ,這根本是為政治而作的歌曲,為何你反倒不明白為何這麼多人提到­政治與種族

[mycastle199699]

伪摇滚並木有貶意........重點是好聽



[dinnae]

I've been looking for good Chinese music for a while now （I'm from Holland）. I think I've finally found some!

[jackcollection]

臧天朔弹的KEYBOARD



[AgustJinx]

相当好的器乐演奏和编排，喜欢唢呐的运用。现在基本没人有心思去­做这些了。

[sky86560]

相信各位來到這裡是為了再次回味崔健的好歌

但我不明白為何這麼多人提到政治與種族

或許 現在真心只想聽音樂的人 已經沒了

[boywinter]

永远流传的经典

[mycastle199699]

偽搖滾 真箇熱鬧的山歌 ...............但是很好聽

[kenken0893]

@mycastle199699

請問你何為真搖滾?

我睇你都答唔出

崔健呢d風格係獨一無二

[GTItoTTS]

@mycastle199699 哎哟我靠？滚石杂志的senior editor都说自己已经不敢也无法定义摇滚了，你这儿来一个伪­摇滚，你去当滚石的编辑怎么样？

[59421china]

@mycastle199699 华语摇滚在80年代后期到90年代初的大陆和香港

台湾没有摇滚，台湾的才是伪摇滚。 只是拿个吉他 唱着一些谈情说爱的流行歌曲罢了！ 比如伍佰

[roytsui999]

一首聽到2011年都好聽的歌

[Firefly1989J]

听首歌怎么这么多废话？又是国家又是教养的。自己是自己别人是别­人，你自己不是别人有什么权利评论那么多，有点信仰，only god can judge me.

[zhuzhukun]

键盘是臧天朔。



[MegaChibachan]

如果说崔健是中国摇滚的开路人，可能有意见的不多，但要说是教父­，就言过其实了。第一他不是最有成就的，第二他不是最有才华的，­第三也是最重要的一点，他没有一点教父的领袖气质。既没有帮助提­携过后辈，也没有为中国摇滚做过什么前瞻性的计划，更要命的是他­这个人心胸还很狭小。从他和许巍的关系上可以看出来，他这个人做­人很有问题。许巍是出了名的老好人，崔健也曾经是他的偶像，但是­许巍在西山偶遇崔健，也只是请服务员送去一些好茶而本人不去和他­交谈。而到了去年的许久未健上海演唱会，老崔说的许多话简直就可­以用没有教养来形容。



[MegaChibachan]

如果以政治系统论的话，中国的问题可能更多，但是以结果论的话，­现在的中国政府可能是世界上最有成就的政府。

日本はすばらしい国だと思ってきましたが今回の地震津波原発と日­本人の口ばかりの援助を見て日本はもうしまいと再認識しました。­日本人はもうほかの国を評判する資格すらなくなってしまったとい­う自覚がない限り自由とか文明人のことばを言わないほうが適当で­はないでしょうか？

[ousukeryuzouzi]

言葉は分からずとも思いは伝わってくる。いつか中国がこの曲を自­由に歌える国になって欲しい。催健、尊敬。加油。Rock never die.

[MM9915]

かっこいい

[fuyanfu27118177]

这首歌---------经典的历史里程碑！  摇滚的骄傲！

[derikisakiller]

这不是山歌吗？？？

@@

[2010qksisa]

你想講既係龐克吧,不過龐克都係搖滾度生產出來的,所以根本同一­脈

[2010qksisa]

我想沒有人知道呃,搖滾的起源是由聖樂(唱比神聽的曲)轉化的,­起初的音調就是以這種令人喘不過氣的音速為基礎,再變化成重鼓聲­,重彈技的現代搖滾,只要有聽早期的英倫樂隊也會發現這種樣子的­輕急式搖滾,ROCK is feeling not tech.

[z6665836]

@2010qksisa 崔健很多歌都偏FUNK 因为老崔乐队的吉他手艾迪喜欢玩放克 所以把歌编的都偏FUNK

[louby1207]

崔健屌爆了~

[DiabloMercy]

这叫摇滚？

摆着那电吉他装气派？根本一点儿固定的音旋都没有！

简直就是山歌。。

他凭什么叫自己摇滚教父？？ 就因为他拉着那嗓门，弄沙哑的声音？？

我真希望你们能能听听真正的摇滚和重金属音乐！！

[z6665836]

@DiabloMercy 并不说音色重 鼓点狠猛的就是摇滚 Post-punk 就一点都不重 英伦的也是 你多听听崔健别的歌就知道了 其实他歌词很反叛

但是曲子很多首都是FUNK风格的 比如像一把刀子 从头再来 之类的

[ltq19900310]

@DiabloMercy 请教什么叫真正的摇滚和重金属音乐？

[jackie19880811]

@DiabloMercy

你又懂搖滾個屁？搖滾不只是Hard Rock, Metal（metal跟搖滾有很大差別，懂嗎？）

光憑一無所有的中間變奏 間奏和尾奏就很明顯是Punk加一點Aggressive Rock 和 Hard Rock，

Funk有一些但還不太算，Funk通常會有Chorus 的和聲加一些尖叫，動作會在強烈一些～

[yxtooslow]

以下内容与音乐无关，纯属个别意淫之士挑拨。

[yxtooslow]

南朝鲜最大的优点就是自大，最大的另外一个优点就是自卑。自大和­自卑的共同点是，二者都是狭隘的一种体现。

相比来说，北朝鲜要强多了。真正骨头硬的朝鲜人。（某个角度可以­这样说）

[henrychiuhk]

@yxtooslow 如果是你,挑去南韓還是去朝鮮

如果38線大門開了,跑去南韓多還是朝鮮多

假設性問題不多談,領導人,幹部,富商的兒女在歐美國家多,還是­在古巴朝鮮多

這就是用腳去投票

[sourzzon]

@yxtooslow 中国人比较喜欢北朝鲜的根本原因是, 面对北朝鲜人, 中国人不自卑.

[yxtooslow]

我们中华民族，五十六个民族 都是兄弟姐妹。我真没想到这么简单的问题，棒子几句话挑拨一下，­大家都这么激动。

兄弟们不妨胸襟宽广一点，有个别狭隘阴险的走狗在那里狂吠不止，­人是没必要跟它们对叫。

[sniper1227]

堅!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[chiaodelpiero]

終於又看到嗩鈉了呀！讚！



[amaka52]

那个笛子真是出神入化。

[z6665836]

@ganmu2009  窦唯本身就是吹笛子 玩民乐出身的 臧天朔也是乐手 键盘手 。

[jason650329]

@ganmu2009 臧天朔不是键盘手嗎?他不是被抓了嗎?

[ganmu2009]

韩国说崔健是韩国人了吗？

[nameless0shelter]

中国的民族主义太傻逼，崔健是朝鲜族 怎么样？ 是中国人

[Aliciajiang]

看看今天的偶像歌手娘不拉几的样子。。。老崔绝对是条汉子。

[adammyang]

是臧天朔，崔健的乐队里面各个都是好手。 不愧是摇滚第一人，大哥呀

[TheCoolhihi]

听了那么多年才听出来，其实这是首情歌...

[ramaskrik]

This is such an epic song. I do not speak Chinese but I can feel it. Some songs transcend language, this is one of them. Gives me goosebumps.

[nyf1124]

@ramaskrik Totally, this is a big hit. It sorta demonstrated that Chinese rock music is a serious business.

[wltan8888]

we love you CHUI JIAN you are our inspiration!!! regards from ur fans in SINGAPORE!!!!

[shinhiroshinhiro]

@wltan8888 guitar player is from SINGAPORE ! 

[amaka52]

名曲！中国摇滚乐的先驱。在今天拜金主义的中国社会里，多少人还­是一无所有。

[bad700700]

老崔啊...............你好嗎?

[zhuronghua]

键盘手是臧天朔吗？

[StuJ227]

@zhuronghua 是

[nathanalexander1]

@zhuronghua 是阿！

[xiaohufan]

this guy demonstrates what is true manhood. we need some real man icons not pretty sissies.

[LoveForChinaForava]

he sang this song because he loves China. he wanted to give a voice to the new generation

[jiangxingxv]

在流行乐坛死亡和文化管制的2010年 我听到了音乐 听到了真情

[leo82ly]

这么多年后听还是那么有感觉。太经典了

[Selflessable]

I think the first chinese rock and roll is good!

[niceday1507]

爺們

[gungfumasta22]

powerful voice. i like ka kui's version of this song too- except his mandarin is not so good.

[Selflessable]

i agree

[desormi]

我最喜歡的內地男歌手有三個：刀郎、孫楠，還有崔健。

[Runaholism]

No one can sing this song better than him. I have many friends trying to sing this on karaoke...oh my, it's like sky and ground.

[hyuanhan]

笑你一無所有，然後就提倡自己還有的是自由，這個和政治拉上關係­了嗯!!!

[jacda13]

The song reminds of the Talking Heads...

That's what I was thinking about halfway through the song. And then they started doing the running in place move that the Talking Heads do in "Stop Making Sense" and I was like...yeah.

I don't mean to knock on Cui Jian though. I like his music in its own right, and that horn player is bad ass.

[emsctemsct]

@jacda13 Good call. Although rarely mentioned, both Talking Heads and the Clash were the biggest rock influence on Cui. Musically speaking, Cui was a new wave/post-punk musician in his early rock years, and is one of the most successful TH successors, IMHO.

[BStaidu]

震撼！！！真不愧是爺們兒！

[alk647]

所謂：酒越醇越香，歌越老越嗆。

人老，看的有氣魅，聞的有勁味。

歌曲，唱的出懷鄉，聽的到滄桑。

崔健，搖滾的原罪，令人永敬畏。

[kevinrong]

崔健最牛逼的一首歌

[xinghengxingyun]

@kevinrong 呵呵，个人觉得，这不是崔健最牛的歌，这是崔健最好听的歌，但最­牛的是《一块红布》！：）

[baraclude]

爷们 顶啊

[Popeyes00]

lol so what's all the commotion about? Are people saying he should go back to Korea because he is of Korean ethnicity?

[chan808yuen]

相信搖滾可以拯救世界的人不會理會崔健是甚麼人

[Runaholism]

He has a voice that NO ONE can imitate.

[Popeyes00]

i can imitate his voice

[huanmar417714]

bien

[georgechan02]

its a good rock music in china.i like it.

[edmundkhor]

is this song still banned by the chinese commies?

[byronchang]

好听，

这首歌好像没有什么政治的东西

想谈政治的还是去听他的一块红布吧

[likaizhu]

还有 最后一枪

[Astella56]

请勿用六四和棒子来亵渎崔健。谢谢。

[evilcherry]

本來崔健就和以上兩樣相關。

[leung9413]

@Astella56 

[acaftermath]

how old is this song?

[jehswong]

20 years ago... was also sung by those students protesting at Tiananmen Square in 1989...?

[9ks9ks]

Catchy!

[animenagai]

lol I grew up in HK with a British education. I just thought about getting into the chinese metal scene and during my research I learned about this guy and his chinese rock status. I looked for this song for so long, and now that I finally found it, I actually know the song :P.

He doesn't have a bad voice BTW, I like his raw style.

[infinera06]

Goes to show that no matter how ugly your voice is and no matter bad you sing, there will be people paying to listen to you. Sad but true.

[rabbitrun84]

"It's not going to be about how pretty the voice is. It's going to be about believing that the voice is telling the truth."

This is what Sam Cooke said about Bob Dylan. Cui Jian is Dylan of China.

[rabbitrun84]

You could say the same thing to Bob Dylan, Bruce Springsteen, Tom Waits, Kurt Cobain, just to name a few. But unfortunately, these guys are more significant than many "beautiful" voices.

[infinera06]

That's right. All those you mentioned have ugly voices. That's why I said that no matter how ugly your voice is, someone will think it's wonderful. Personally, I listen to music to sooth my ears and my mind. If I want to hear a message of significance, I go somewhere else for that.

[9ks9ks]

"Personally, I listen to music to sooth my ears and my mind."

You god-damn philistine.

[infinera06]

Punk.

[Molislily]

I think good music is far more than a medium for soothing one's ears, it could function like literature and poetry to assist people seeking truth, criticize the government/society, etc. But prefering 'beautiful voice' to sooth the ears is your choice, we should respect that preference : )

[penguinpen10]

That brings back memories! I remember the first time I heard him 20 some years ago. He was awsome. Can't believe it still sounds good. He was really something back then. Where is he now?

[WeiJieD]

Wow.His voice shocked me a bit.

Haha.

Er..Anyone knows what's the name of this concert?

[hkbaby1985]

i wonder eventually the girl in that song goes with him....

[uacconly]

Not girl. This songs is about China.

[jehswong]

The passing of an era...?

[xihangyang]

@uacconly no it about a girl and not china.

this song was related with china because the student protest on tian man square.

the student love the song because of the title nothing to lose.

he also preform on the square.

but the song was release before the protest.

after the protest he did write a lot of song about china.

like piece of red cloth.

also he never turn rich like other china pop artist.

but his music was supported by a lot of foreign cultere charaty group.

[ltq19900310]

@xihangyang bullshit , this song is nothing to do with the tian an men protest

[xihangyang]

@ltq19900310 read it carefully. i say this song got nothing to do with the tian men protest, but he did preform there. people still link this song with the protest but the song was relase before the protest. read. it carefully

[ltq19900310]

@xihangyang wrong ,the only song considered to be related to tian men protest is The last gunshot

[ramaskrik]

@ltq19900310 what is your problem, this person is agreeing with you! learn to read before you post.

[Molislily]

吹笛的人是谁？

[HARIOB]

张元

[CLORIANN]

你说啥呢？

[everrr1980]

he is Chaoxian nationality,

[hellfairyjason]

that means his ethnicity is korean..the same thing..except he doesn't speak korean......u realize chaoxian and korean are the same thing rite?

[everrr1980]

no， i dont think they r the same thing, actually, they r totally different. but i just told the truth

[sourzzon]

actually he dose speak korean language

[c18zyxt]

what?! he is born in beijing OK？and his Nation is korea,it is just a kind of nation in china! but it's does not mean he can speak korean!you are so stupid!

[sourzzon]

go learn more english, please....

nationality means 民族 also means 国籍. CuiJian's nationality is Korean could be mean: 崔健是朝鲜或者韩国人, but also could be translated as崔健是朝鲜族人.

go check out fuking dic, dont play with ur emptiness.

[c18zyxt]

what a mad dog said he can speak korean?did you get my point?go learn more chinese!why don't u come to CA and face to me suk your fuking dic!u said i am chinaman!i do not know why u use this word to describe me !but i take pride in the prosperity of our country and i'm chinese!anyway it is better than you cur!

[sourzzon]

and if he could or not speak korean dosent matter with he is korean or not. please be logical, chinaman...

[maria564114153]

what happen if he speak or not korean language,??!the most important is that he sings in chinese.that's why he is a ithe King of Rock in China...!

[sourzzon]

Who said that important he speaks Korean? Noone said that Korean identity is covering chinese culture inside of him. Dont u think u Chinese too sensitive about this?

[fossilheart83]

FANG NI MA PI

[everrr1980]

你可以查一下崔健的资料，他确实是朝鲜族的，但他是中国人。这不­矛盾

[fossilheart83]

我知道崔健是朝鲜族的。 但是你说nationality" 就不对了。在所有大陆的歌手里面，老崔是最关心中国命运的一位

[sourzzon]

nationality 在英文中有民族的意思,sb

[hkbaby1985]

国籍才對吧?

[sourzzon]

字典到处都是吧,别总问我啊,民族,国籍都是nationali­ty

[c18zyxt]

用那鸟语跟你 解释是以为怕 外人误解，用中文草你丫的 是因为 要操飞你祖宗！改个国籍 出个国，以为自己还真成一等良民了！杂种而已 何来骄奢之气！

[sourzzon]

sb..hhh

[maria564114153]

管他是中国人还是朝鲜的，从他嘴里长出来的是中文而不是朝鲜语就­足够能证明他所关心的国家是中国，还有他的文化也是中国人话~~­~~~~~~~

[nitatyo]

他的国籍是生下来就是中国,他的父母的国籍也是中国.应该说他是­纯纯正正的中国人.



[sgfhk321]

孔子是韓國人也算了... 現在連崔健都是啦?

糟了糟了糟了

哈

[chineseplayer]

cui jian is the best!!! we love zhong guo

[LIMPINGJA]

摇滚先驱崔健不停地号叫"可你却总是笑我一无所有 "

集悲憫無奈於一身。

80年代的我...........

唉,一切并不遥远往事如昨..........

[lily1882]

80年代是个多有理想的年代呀？可惜。

[summerbeat]

你 in the song refers to who?

[pal2011]

ahh that is open to interpretation. the ambiguity is probably one of the reason s why cui jian was banned by the cpc for so long. The most harmless interpretation of course is that someone the author's pursuing.

[ilovelux]

我曾经问个不休你何时跟我走

可你却总是笑我一无所有

我要给你我的追求还有我的自由

可你却总是笑我一无所有

[ytaxc7]

這首歌無論是旋律，感情，都是經典之作。

聽了會勾起無限的傷感。

[syharrymn]

谁有节奏之犬的视频？

[syharrymn]

那时侯的藏天朔还不是黑社会，还是五月天

[syharrymn]

那时侯的崔健还是能蹦起来的！！还是很灵活地！！想着86年看到­他在百名歌手演唱会时吼出了的一无所有时的心情，我哭了~~~~­

[Vbommel]

摇滚先驱

[ccsj1ss]

他用情歌來表達那一年代，我們追求理想時的困境。

今天回首， 我們之中，到底， 有多少人心中還有理想？？

[gongdaweinan]

the number one singer in Chinese history

[washa500]

雖然是老歌~但是歌詞很棒~^^~很喜歡這首歌給人的感覺!!

[goodman528]

Interestingly, I first heard of this song reading a Japanese novel "Battle Royale" in English. There was a translation of the lyrics in English. Since then, this song and CuiJian has grown on me, and this is now my favourite song.

I'm pleasantly surprised by how many English people has heard of CuiJian. Perhaps thanks to "Battle Royale", he is inspiring a new generation.

[MouIchiDouKisu]

one of the good classic songs, this version sounds very smooth, and country songs kinda feel.

[avignon99]

20年后的今天听此歌，别有一番滋味在心头。

崔健是一个时代的代表，是一个时代的帝王。可称前无古人，后无来­者。现在的歌手都在玩什么？

[dickzou]

wow so great,reminds me of the childhood

[OhMymy]

一无所有 means having nothing. If a person is 一无所有, it usually means he has no power, rank, educational attainment, money.

[rukawa911]

his voice kept me up for countless hot summer nights.

his truly a chinese rock star

[ricelake0]

Now your hands are shaking.

Now your tears are flowing.

Could be you're telling me.

You love me for being penniless.

[ricelake0]

I tell you I've waited too long.

I tell you my final demand.

I want to hold your hands tight.

You must go with me now.

[gstlb]

Most important Chinese popular song. Ever. Period.

[togotogototo]

Lyrics continued:

Penniless

The earth under me is moving.

The water beside me is running.

But you always laugh at me.

For being penniless.

Why are you always laughing.

Why do I always dream.

Could be in your mind.

I will always be penniless.

[togotogototo]

Lyrics roughly:

Penniless

I used to ask you day and night.

When you would go with me.

But you always laughed at me.

For being penniless.

I want to give you my dreams.

I want to give you my freedom.

But you always laugh at me.

For being penniless.

[lida15]

sing more fucking songs, cui jian!

[becauseofyousiumui]

他太屌了

[joyofmusic88]

This is a great song! It sounds so moving as if there is a sense of unity is called for? I think the flute sounds like country song! Can anyone tell me the name of this song and the singer??? Even though I don't understand what's he is singing, the sound and combination of instruments make this song interesting!! Peace everyone! Thanks for posting this wonderful song!

[NIRVANAMATE]

singer is 崔健

name song is 一无所有

[lisajason111]

fanhuijue is a nub from jiangsu

[fanhuijue]

couldn't get any better than this

[arielhe]

yeah，I work the road alone。。。

[shinerocky]

我操崔健这个太牛逼了

震撼

[melodeeaus]

这是哪次演唱会的录像？哪儿有完整版吗？谢谢！

[iSoap7]

边儿凉快去

[melodeeaus]

Don't be a moron.