Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (1,147)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • ITS 100%%%% LIVE -SHES AMAZING LOVE FOREVER M.

  • There is no way on earth anyone can believe that 1:37 is live.....

  • @jaarnek IMO I dont think all of it was live either. I def feel some parts were lipped.

  • The best rendition ever ! It gives me goosebumps !!!! Mariah no one can compare to you !!!!!

  • Im really impressed by this performance! She's still got it!

  • I like the album version better, she took too many shortcuts in this version avoiding tough notes. Still a brilliant performance though, the bar is just high because she's Mariah Carey

  • It's 100 percent live. She also admitted that the pregnancy made her voice stronger. I guess after a whole 9 month of good sleep, eating healthy food, no smoke nor alcohol recover her voice. Bad life style is the worst enemy for any singer.

  • The better version ever, of this song !

  • Instead of creating such an expensive place on clothes wasting energy electric, media gas ect (and think about all the people who bought new dresses and presents in vas vast consumption....!!!!!) if you ever have this phenomenon called FAITH , you'd all be on the streets and help the POOR instead of having a quick orgasm of pretending faith in this building!!!!

  • Incredible voice !

  • she looks like fiona from shrek.

  • @Mssavagette

    ela se parece com a fiona e voce com o BURRO do shrek....

    KKKKKKKKK !!!!!!

  • @Mssavagette exactly which version of her??

  • @esmaulhusna100 ogre. 

  • @Mssavagette lol , exacly

  • @Mssavagette lmao rude much shes pregnant here.

  • @sentfromupabove :) I know. I;'m such a bitch LOL i love her though, Best singer ever,

  • @Mssavagette loool

  • fuck, now i m in xmas mood again ;)

  • @teom44 loool

  • so proud its all live :) thats my girl up there :)

  • even if she lipped it she still sounds great!

  • nicely done mariah!

    

  • lindo  d mais

  • Diva

  • oh my G... she's a big mama in this video... where are you Mariah ?

  • @rimbaud15 she was pregnant with twins

  • or course this is live...theres no disputing it....please ppl stop being stupid and saying it isnt

  • @LuiZzZz437 she did perform it live....

  • Amerikanischer Schnick-Schnack!

    

  • =DDD OMGG please tell me this is 100% live!!!!!! I love it!!!

  • so beautiful and what excellent praise and worship rendition she knocked it out of the park on this one seems heart and soul were connected on this one just simply loved it!!! can i get an amen somebody!!!

  • @angelwingstravel1 Amen! Totally agree with you, absolutely incredible performance

  • @aregatokek it really doesn't matter we all know she can do anything when she puts her mind to it ! And as for pre-recored vocals. . . Who cares you can't prove it !

  • Hey people, some fans contacted Mariah on twitter, and she decided to watch some of her videos and read what some people are whriting about her. So get ready to talk to her lawyers!

  • it's good that in her pregnant state she can still sing good..good that she still has good breathing dynamics..because in that time the diaphragm is already being pushed by the growing uterus..so some breathing problems should be imminent..:),,still she is great..i love u MC>hahaha

  • @Knotslanding2000 yes that's your opinion and what I said is also true and has been prooven so shut you trap

  • @aregatokek your so incorrect mariah can, do all her belts, live, its all about the amount of rest she gets & FYI , she sang the belt "Through The Rain!" Part live many times like on MTV & her tribute at soul train awards .

  • @mariahpowerful i agree, the "Shining Through The Rain" performance of through the rain is 100% live, but as you can hear, they adjust the key lower. yes, when they adjust the key lower, most likely she will be belting the high parts LIVE. but if she will sing her song in same key as the studio version, she lips them. some belts don't sound the same as the cd version on some of her lip belts because she is so clever to use another version of her pre recorded high belts.

  • @mariahpowerful alot are also fooled that her whistle in live versions of "I wanna know what love is" is live because it doesn't sound the same as the CD version. i will say it again, mariah have bunch of different versions of pre recorded whistles and belts (those that don't sound good to her and did not make into the album) of her songs and that is what they use when she sing live to make it sound live. that's how clever her technicians are. i might even be one of them. who knows, right? lol

  • @aregatokek you have any evidence for what you said

  • @truongphan90 unfortunately i don't have, other than by viewers having keen observation on how to spot a singer lipping no matter how a singer fake her facial expression

  • @aregatokek ok so........................STFU and only come back when you have some sort of corroboration. (:

  • @aregatokek YES SURE SHE WOULD LIPSYNCH 2 METRES AWAY FROM ANNIE LENOX AND MAXWELL. PLEASE GOOGLE WHAT ANNE SAID ABOUT THIS PERFORMANCE AND STOP BEING SO STUPID

  • @aregatokek @aregatokek i totally respect ur opinion.i mean mariah must be such a perfect lypsincer right.i mean to be able to switch from live-singing to a "pre-recorded whistle note" in a matter of a second is totally awesome on her part right.im totally impressed by such minute detailing and research on ur part about mariah's singing career.im sure even her own fans have not gone to such lengths to explain the mysteries behind her great live perfomances.thank u so much for the hard work.

  • @sandyzmz oh snap

  • @xennexdude just being sarcastic to this loser mariah hater

  • THE PROOF THE MARIAH IS NOT MIMING ON THE PERFORMANCE:

    /watch?v=6z_wfI4XqDU

  • Hey haters, watch this vídeo and see how Mariah is mimimg:

    watch?v=6z_wfI4XqDU

  • HATERS: Damn Mariah sure has lost her voice over the years,what a shame! :(

    LAMB: Ummmmm, just watch Mariah sing come all ye faithful (live in Washington) and you'll see she never lost her voice, you just lost faith in her! :)

    HATERS: Cant wait to buy her new CD! -___-

  • Lol who the Fuck is Sandi patty.

  • Omg still so many mimi haters. It's live bitches, get over it. People always try to deny the power of " the voice" they could meet her personally and hear her sing Accapella and still deny it.

  • @elshine Highest belting part is not live : obviously from the studio track => So get a life.

  • @theoneandonly2503 is live mothefucker lol

    

  • @perroelectrocutado Fuck you :)

  • It's fair compare Mariah Carey and Sandi Patty. Sandi Patty wins!

  • @gustavogouveia Who the fuck is Sandi patti and in what miraculous way can that unknown girl win against Mariag fucking Carey??

  • too popy 

  • @LuiZzZz437 umm honey she did lol/

  • omg my mimi.. ur voice is so great..

    love you MC..

  • @LuiZzZz437 actually, she did ^.^

  • Great performance!

  • @LuiZzZz437 copy pasted by a pathetic hand, singing a pathetic single who failed to top any chart from a flop album by a singer who lips her high belts. LOLS

  • @LuiZzZz437 i'm doing a better thing which is making comments here. and i'm talking to a hand now who thinks that finding a big fat dick to play with is a better thing to do. keep dong it by yourself. enjoy! LOL!

  • @LuiZzZz437 oh now im talking to a hand. pathetic hand that is. LOLSS.

  • So good !

    

  • @LuiZzZz437 i dont care if celine or mariah or whitney or whoever is the voice. my point is, MARIAH IS LOOSING HER VOICE AND SHE WILL NEVER EVER SING LIKE SHE USE TO ANYMORE. bleeehhhhh!!!!

  • @aregatokek So what? Her voice is better than 99% of the so called singers these days. It's only natural to lose some of your talent as you age. Mariah is still an amazing song writer and her TONE alone is a killer for those who appreciate beautiful voices.

  • @initochanchan in short, u agree with what i said that mariah is loosing her voice. thank you!

  • @aregatokek Nope. The fact her voice is still brilliant yet not like 20 years ago DOES NOT mean she's losing her voice. Losing her voice means it's getting worse little by little, which i don't believe for a minute. Her voice can remain like this (great) until she retires (hopefully around her 70s jaja)

  • @initochanchan any changes in your timbre such as presence of raspy, airy and cracky sound is a sign of vocal deterioration if your voice doesn't seem to sound that way from the very start. and the fact that she is lipping the high belts of her songs is a sign weakening vocal power. you could say that she is singing her songs 100% live, but take it or leave it, she is no longer capable of singing the high belts live, and she only get thru to them by lipping.

  • @aregatokek AMEN. Finally someone sharing my opinion on Mariah vocal condition and supposedly "live" belts (which are always lipsync since like the end of the 90's)

  • @theoneandonly2503 thank you. mariah stans are harassing me here, accusing me of being a hater. i'm just stating a fact, an observable fact that is. im not saying that she is no longer capable of singing live, but she is incapable of singing a whole song 100% live, especially the high belts. i have no problem if she will lip her high belts and pretend to be singing it live by doing all her fake facial expression, i am just stating it.

  • @aregatokek Exactly, we are just pointing out things, real things that lots of users/lamb/ex-lambs have heard. I don't even talk with them cause I know we are right and I don't have time to lose arguing with someone of bad faith/deaf/delusional. mariah still have great lows and mediums and on some few days good belts, but her belting register is like dead (she never really sang her "belts" in her last Xmas album, for me this is studio engineering, like her belts in CB or TEOM)

  • @theoneandonly2503 what they do in the studio is, she records the belting part separate from the rest of a song instead of recording it as a whole. it's like a puzzle actually. (listen to the cd version of thru the rain and ul notice) she records the song part by part, and connect them all together for the final output coz her vocal energy is incapable in singing an entire song. as a result, when she does them live, she lips the high belts. that's how she gets thru her recording session

  • @aregatokek C'mon. How can you be so sure is uncapable of singing a whole song live? I have watched literally every live concert there is on youtube and Mariah still sings many songs entirely live. Stop being a hater. Plus WE ARE HERE because we love Mariah and we couldn't care less about your opinion. Can't fans of an artist enjoy a beautiful performance by them without some naysayers coming and spoiling the moment?

  • @initochanchan oh anybody who have seen her sing since vision of love days can tell who is the mariah belting live and who is the mariah lipping the belts. as i have said, i am just stating an observation. and it's so funny im not the only one who have observed it. the fact that there are also other users here commenting that she is lipping the high belts is obviously a sign that i am not the only one who have observed it.

  • @aregatokek Okay. If you feel like you have made your point, feel free to let us enjoy Mariah's music.

  • @initochanchan from the very start, who told you to reply on my comments anyway. it just so happen you can't stand with it, so if you don't mind, keep enjoying as much as i do

  • @LuiZzZz437 who told you to reply to my comments in the first place. if u can't stand with my comments, pathetic you. lol

  • From where come those notes???? AMAZING!

  • @LuiZzZ yes your right. celine lipsyncs since 1992, two decades

    mariah vocally, lyricly and as a person more exiting and superior!

    just listen to mariahs first 5-6 albums and compare it to celine lol

    celine sounds allways nasal, thin and o.k, not wooooooow fact!!!

  • Mariah is the best

  • @LuiZzZz437 delusional mariah stan. yes celine is lipping her high belts, and it's so pathetic that mariah is fooling you as well. both of them are lipping the high belts these days. deal with it.

  • @aregatokek sad to hear that you still believe that mariah's high belts are live. mariah is so happy to know that. LOL

  • WOW! THE BEST VOCALIST EVER!

  • @LuiZzZz437 mariah's voice is what? then why can't she sing like she use to? why does her voice lost some of its clarity? and why does she lip the high belts of her live performances? and worse, even lip an entire song. accept it or not, she partially lost her voice. it's sad but yeah, mariah won't be able to sound anymore like she use to.

  • wow

  • mariah is the best ever!

  • @LuiZzZz437 and now ur being paranoid. accusing me of being celine's what? do u have any proof? at least i have tons of proof here in youtube showing that mariah have partially lost her voice u delusional mariah stan.

  • @aregatokek my fave part 2:24-2:37 SHE'S THE GREATEST SINGER EVER!

  • @LuiZzZz437 ur delusional. she lost some of it

  • @hayopnakombo10

    putang ina mo, hayop ka mwahaha

  • @didintei getting better with age? are you sure? her voice is deteriorating as she age. though she sounds better now than her rainbow and glitter era, she is still incapable of singing like her music box and daydream era, which i believe is her vocal prime. i hope her upcoming album would showcase stronger vocals, not like daydream or music box, but at least better than Memoirs.

  • Stop comparing Celine and Mariah, they are both legends.

  • @LuiZzZz437 keep ur comments to yourself! its christmas, have a heart. i love celine btw

  • @LuiZzZz437 yes Celine fans eat you heart out! LOL! MC = Mariah Carey = Merry Christmas! CD= Celine Dion = Christmas Deficit.

  • I LOVE THIS SONG

  • MERRY CHRISTMAS TO YOU!! :D

  • merry christmas from the philippines, mariah and celine should make music together

  • @marklovesGMA that would never happen, because mariah never wanted to do music with celine. why? ask mariah. it has always been proposed when they were still both in the sony family. even doing the whitney song was almost impossible before, coz according to mariah she doesn't want to make music with someone because she is asked to do so. it should be her decision if she wants.

  • @aregatokek

    oh i get it. still i hope they will make music together. i love mariah. she's my fave international diva. of course i have my faves in the philippines. but mariah is the goddess diva

  • TODAY IS A GLORIOUS DAY !!! :3

  • MEY CHISTMAS HAITI!!!

    NO REMORSE

  • well she killed this great carol sorry but errrrr

  • You Go Gurl!, I Still Sing to the Lord, when I was Pregnant!..You want your child to Praise God too..

  • @12maximumride yes she was in the early stages of a very complicated twin pregnancy when this performance was taped last december

  • wow its so amazing i cant feel of what Christmas mean :)

  • is this when she was still prego?

  • Comment removed

  • @12Maximumride

    No this is where she was still CUKOO! lolzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz­zzzzzzzzzzzzzz

    zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz­zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz­zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz­zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz­zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz­zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz­zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz

  • I can't take anymore of Mariah Carey. She doesn't just sing it beatifully, she overdoes it TOTALLY everytime. ooOOOOaaahaahyeeeeyeeee Praaiiihaaihaise The Loooooooord. -.-

  • @Olivere118 if you cant take her, then why the hell are you even watching the video? just click the "X" button.

  • the last note...AMAZING!!!

  • When Mariah first came out as an artist, I loved her every song, but I'm not fond of this new stuff. IMHO, the choir did most of the work in this song. Bring back the Mariah I know and love!

  • Very good performance. She's got the range and gracefulness in her vocals but not so much control, power and breath control like Celine and Whitney. Very impressive though. Mariah, Celine and Whitney need to teach today's singers how to do it. Go the legends!

  • @tomble10th she actually does more technical things..than celine and whitney and she was pregnant..but without control power and breath control she wouldnt have gotten thru this song..mariah is more of a musician....celine and whitney are more singers

  • Beautiful song to our Saviour! and thanks Mariah for your beatiful voice, thanks for this video

  • even mariah carey knows about him.!! Praise the Lord !!

  • Comment removed

  • @RDN91 I agree with you Mariah was so beautiful while she was pregnant with Roc and Roe though all the cmplications she had through her 8 months of pregnancy made her decide not to have oe kids nor were the twins her first pregnancy she had a miscarrage around christmas 2008

  • I watch this everyday. Mariah you slay! This is coming from a Beyonce stan.

  • I have this CD but this performance...WOW! It has restored my faith in her talent. I wish she would do less bubble gum stuff and do more music that makes her talents stand out more.

  • @Stantheman08221975 I totally agree !!

  • waaaaaaawwwwwwwww i'm speechless ....so dazzling <3<3

  • AND YET SHE IS STILL STUNNING

  • Her movement at 1:50 - 2:00 is outstanding!

  • @LuiZzZz437 Annie lennox did too. she said, "say what you want about mariah carey but her voice is unlike anything I've ever heard before". She praised Mariah

  • Now,who says she cant sing anymore??

    eat this one..Haters!!

  • Her voice sounds soooo good here! Her new album will be a killer hopefully

  • LOVE THE vocal range!!!!! Go Mariah!!! She is amazing!!!!! 

  • hahaha, she was pregno last christmas

  • FUCKIN' AMAZING!!! Can't get over this performance!!! My newest favorite of Christmas songs this year!!! And FYI MegaArcox, when you're the soloist you pretty much intertwine with the choir and the orchestra...specially when you're singing adlibs...pretty much the extra notes are embellishments...thanks!!!

  • Comment removed

  • @jazzares2010 And your comments are where, now? BOLUDO! Love this video! Thanks for the upload =)

  • Comment removed

  • Mariah...you have to sing in time with music and choir...please revise your first singing lessons!!

  • MegaArcox please who are you? this woman is a legend,

    and sounds amazing, you cant even sing one note of this.

    

  • i reckon those boobs are bigger than her head.

  • @ Samoht199912 she can..most person sing the carols off her album.She did a wonderful job in this video despite her being pregnant, imagine when she is not pregnant..Go research b4 u talk.ur just jealous.

  • SHE CANT SING CAROLS

  • @DrGliekBeebs Well, I don't know if anyone has asked but as a devoted fan I have to...how did Mariah sounded in person, she sounds beautiful here, I listen to this and it is like Angels singing but how was it in person? pleeeeease...thanks!

  • @Cab2Cab Mariah was about 3.5 or 4 months pregnant with twins when this performance was filmed so she was starting to swell up as most pregnant women do give her a break her and those precious babies almost didn't survive

  • Mariah the best forever time, gospel, soul, r&b, pop, hip-hop.etc.the great voice of the world

  • Mariah is still the best!!!! :)

  • i can feel god's embrace in her voice . "oh come let us adore him " "glory to god" lines brought me goosebumps. mariah is gods gift.

  • gosh, she looks faaaaaaaaaaat, but its understandable, she will thing twice about getting preg again

  • My God! Listen to this voice! Stunning performance!

  • That woman in red dress ate Mariah !!!

  • christianity killed pagan's stole what was their's twisted it around and then your fake jesus was born he was born to man ! the bible is nothing but lie's and is a known fact you idiot's are not supposed to worship false idols and you do so fake all lie's deal with it

  • @royallove23 you are the fake one. JESUS IS REAL AND THE BIBLE IS SACRED. Please be polite

  • @nadyfan better yet the halo you see around your jesus's head is not a christian thing ever wonder why in every picture you see your jesus looks different ?

  • MAJOR CONTRADICTION HERE ! jesus was born in 1 place and called jesus of something else lol jesus was never to be worshiped he is all lie's go to my page for proof christianity is only 4000 years old considered new so your fake jesus never existed to begin with christianity was stolen from pagan religion

  • @royallove23 be gone

  • @nadyfan lol make me your jesus is fake deal with it and the bible is shit just like the assholes who believe in it christianity is only around 4000 years old considered new dont like it to damn bad i know your scared to believe the truth its ok weak one's always are christianity should not even exist since everything you idiots have does not belong to you it all came from paganism eat that dont believe me look under my comment section on my page eat that lol lame ass

  • @nadyfan all you morons are ... are fail's in life your just a bunch of foolish gullible idiots that believe things they are told without even an ounce of knowledge read the story of the real god Zeus airgo je-SUS ever heard the saying may jesus strike you with a thunderbolt ? he doesnt have 1 because it belongs to the real god of the heaven's ZEUS all you christians did was pretty up zeus and called him jesus known fact

  • @nadyfan the letter j was not invented when your so called jesus was said to be born dec 25th is not his birthday you christians made it that way the 3 king's are not people they are stars on Orion's belt that at a certain time align with the brightest star serious your holliday's weddings wedding rings symbol's christmas wreath's and more are all pagan look it up stop being so stupid

  • @nadyfan better yet look at the 2 link's under my about me section on my page

  • @insexmetrust you're a heartless piece of crap Mariah had a very complicated pregnancy and singing while your pregnant is hard because the growing uterus compresses the lungs which makes it harder to breathe which makes it harder to sing. look at shirley Jones while she's singing Till There Was You in the Music Man at 7 months pregnant with her second son Patrick