I know he's famous for doing chance type pieces, but after hearing this beautiful song I cannot believe he gave up making this kind of music that "talks" to people for the "action" of chance. I can only wonder what kind of non-controversial masterpieces he would have composed had he not changed his style in 1950
John Cage said: 'If something is boring after 2 minutes, try it for 4. If still boring, then 8. Then 16. Then 32. Eventually one discovers that it is not boring at all.'
@MrPaevo Good one but i didn't come up with that one if you notice there are quotes '' '' at the very top comment meaning i just repeated what Mr. Cage said. Sorry if you find life boring.. Maybe you should try origami or spelunking. All Hail John Cage.
I'm 15 and I love this kind of beautiful piano music. I consider John Cage to be an artist than a musician. On a side note, I have lost all respect for those five people who disliked this mesmerizing music.
@AngryDraftsman I'm not sure if he considered ALL sound music. There are specific instructions in his radio pieces to avoid newscasts. It makes me think that music is not just sound, but sound that does not convey information. i.e. not language, or at least not the language we speak.
@AngryDraftsman I'm not sure if he considered ALL sound music. There are specific instructions in his radio pieces to avoid newscasts. It makes me think that music is not just sound, but sound that we are necessarily detached from. i.e. not language, or at least not the language we speak.
This is a hard and challenging piece to play, but even more difficult to record - there shouldn't be too much ambient reverb. This version sounds truly perfect!
@Huffinearts are you a fucking idiot? just because it doesn't sound pleasant to your ear doesn't mean it's not music. That was the whole point of experimentalism and more spefically indeterminacy in Cage's music. He was challenging accepted cultural norms in music and demonstrating that everything really, even if it doesn't fit into an "acceptable" scale or tonality range, is still musi and contains beauty. Obviously this movement has passed right over your head along with the ignorant masses.
For the last time, everyone, music is art, and therefore has NOTHING TO DO WITH COMPETITION!! John Cage was certainly not trying to out do anyone greater with the apparent profound silence of 4'33''. That piece was but a message for all to enjoy the pleasure of sound without producing any notes, it calls for all to reach out with imagination and appreciate noise. Yet, avant-garde can get over the top, and music still takes skill, as it should.
Sub-sub-footnote to musical history. In the 1980s my sister took part with many other performance piano students at New England Conservatory in a recording of one of Cage's pieces. At one point her stool squeaked. Eek.
Perhaps the five nocturnes, my particular favorites. Probably the closest pieces to this particular style are the danses de travers from Pièces Froides. Check the IMSLP website for the scores. If you can't find them send me a private message.
This song reminds me of a quiet place far from everything and everyone where you can rest forever and ever. A place where you can find the peace that you looked for the entire life...
Misterstudebaker, if that's what you really think, then you maybe should hold off on performing the piece till you better understand it, and better understand John Cage in general. It's not a conservatory piano recital piece, it's music that just happened to be for piano.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I'm learning this right now. It's very poorly written. It's basically a melody, a tone poem - there are very few harmonies or chords in it. He has the sustain pedal throughout (which is cool) but has all these dotted 1/2 notes tied to dotted 1/4 notes, which are impossible to hear, due to the pedal. It makes no sense. I think he wrote it without the pedal, and then played it with the pedal and said "WOW!" and just kept it, rather than re-write it *for* the pedal. I truly love this piece, tho'.
@Emilduvier No, I'd dare say it's far less than music. It is the complete absence of music and art, and should therefore not be appreciated as such. People who keep shoving 4'33 down my throat need to get a grip on how they interpret the garbage that is "modern" art: a slough of uncreative figures trying to wrestle individuality out of their own lack of talent. "I can't paint like DaVinci, so instead I'll convince the world that my splotchy mess is superior."
@DavidEasthope It's not less than music - after all, it is music! We have to remember here that 4:33 isn't silence, as the common misconception suggests.
And if I was to have a painting on my bedroom wall, I'd rather have a so called "splotchy mess" than Da Vinci anyday, simply because it would suit my room more. Geddit?
@DavidEasthope 4'33 calls for one's own imagination, to interpret the ambience which always surrounds us for there never such a thing as silence.
If you don't like this train of thought, you could at least acknowledge it, then discard it, for it doesn't go with what you think music is.
Little insiders tip though, "musical" (music can be very abstract, as some feelings are) understanding doesn't come easy, one has to listen carefully and remove all preconceived notions of what one likes.
@swawandoo yeah...well 4'33 is more conceptual, it's the apogee of his philosophy, (and it was pretty "shocking" too!) but surely it doesn't erases the rest of cage's ideas and composition!
i am still listening to it.. omg.
kawikatube 5 days ago
luv.
thebrokenclaim 2 weeks ago
simply amazing !
yuya7723 3 weeks ago
dat nigga was huge!
samuelgperry 3 weeks ago in playlist Favorite videos
@samuelgperry hahaaha lol!!! I think the piano was small.
SuperVideodave 1 week ago
Like a dream... I usually don't like contemporary classical music but this one is pretty good
sudokuwkroku 1 month ago in playlist Favorite videos
@sudokuwkroku That pretty much says it all...
MrPaevo 1 week ago
Oh my god.
SunZenHeadHomonid 1 month ago
Way ahead of his time.
mybikemybike 2 months ago
this is so beautiful.. :)
MrDNANDA 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Hey everyone check out the probability of chance video on my channel!
Jusstfnsk8 3 months ago
oh shutup
kennobody 3 months ago
433 was for the sounds you might hear. Yourself.
jbearden 3 months ago
Comment removed
jbearden 3 months ago
orgasmatic
kevinleroyable 4 months ago
i like this
joeyshabadu187 4 months ago
This is an amazing piece of music. I am not normally into "classical" or composed or whatever music like this, but this is just amazing.
Lewis1711 5 months ago
@Lewis1711 ....there's a lot more of it.
SuperVideodave 1 week ago
dj shadow......
organisenoise 5 months ago
@organisenoise what about him good sir?
throwingbacktheapple 3 months ago
This masterpiece can open in my mind an "empty space", a palace of peace.
dpiktoria 5 months ago
It's nice. But I prefer Alexei Lubimovs version on ECM Records.
danlanois 5 months ago
This is beautiful. Guess there is more to John Cage than just atonality. Just so ornate and creative.
ARobinsonization 5 months ago
This is so beautiful :)
I'm listening to it in the rain whilst reading Dubliners, it's so perfect...
spockezri 5 months ago 3
I know he's famous for doing chance type pieces, but after hearing this beautiful song I cannot believe he gave up making this kind of music that "talks" to people for the "action" of chance. I can only wonder what kind of non-controversial masterpieces he would have composed had he not changed his style in 1950
toltas13 5 months ago
Amazing timeless piece. If autumn leaves changing color had a sound...this would be it.
Egoguitar1 5 months ago
John Cage said: 'If something is boring after 2 minutes, try it for 4. If still boring, then 8. Then 16. Then 32. Eventually one discovers that it is not boring at all.'
Godamatic 5 months ago 38
@Godamatic or they fall to sleep
jeff551z 4 months ago
@Godamatic Oh my God.
BruisedEyeSockets 3 months ago
@Godamatic Sorry, what's boring after 2 minutes is doubly boring after 4 and so on and so forth...
MrPaevo 1 week ago
@MrPaevo Good one but i didn't come up with that one if you notice there are quotes '' '' at the very top comment meaning i just repeated what Mr. Cage said. Sorry if you find life boring.. Maybe you should try origami or spelunking. All Hail John Cage.
Godamatic 1 week ago
This is just too beautiful for words.
milesdavisistheman 5 months ago
woww john cage was a big man... look at him compared to the size of that piano..
phoneboothLC 6 months ago
@phoneboothLC its cuz that is a toy piano... he wrote a suite for it
VukWolf23 6 months ago
@VukWolf23 oh... really?
huertamj128 5 months ago
very nice
aeronleslie 6 months ago
This is great, and it reminds me of Debussy.
FriendlyShadow1 6 months ago
Thank You.
tigrantahmizean 7 months ago
I'm 15 and I love this kind of beautiful piano music. I consider John Cage to be an artist than a musician. On a side note, I have lost all respect for those five people who disliked this mesmerizing music.
musicman4536 7 months ago 2
Songs without Piano.
What's wrong with kids these days?
seasaltisland 7 months ago 5
One of the most beautiful pieces I've ever heard. Cage is truly unique.
larpusrp 7 months ago 2
I just jizzed out of my ears
SuperMegaPeanut 8 months ago
Bravo! Cheers from Brazil
PiscaCPT 8 months ago
@PiscaCPT Bravo! Cheers from Brazil 2
ImCalebRosengard 8 months ago
I always come back to John Cage…
MargaretHarmer 8 months ago
biutuful
mperezn71 1 year ago
@AngryDraftsman I'm not sure if he considered ALL sound music. There are specific instructions in his radio pieces to avoid newscasts. It makes me think that music is not just sound, but sound that does not convey information. i.e. not language, or at least not the language we speak.
BarrySeroff 1 year ago
@AngryDraftsman I'm not sure if he considered ALL sound music. There are specific instructions in his radio pieces to avoid newscasts. It makes me think that music is not just sound, but sound that we are necessarily detached from. i.e. not language, or at least not the language we speak.
BarrySeroff 1 year ago
素晴らしいです BEAUTIFUL
hobbyoda 1 year ago
This is a hard and challenging piece to play, but even more difficult to record - there shouldn't be too much ambient reverb. This version sounds truly perfect!
ClaesCornelius1 1 year ago
Thank you for putting this on YT: it has quite made my evening. I had no idea that Cage had written such accessible, and beautiful, music.
KeiraForsyth 1 year ago 2
One of my personal favorite songs.
SquidAttackMusic 1 year ago
anybody know where i can get the sheet music i have been searching some websites and blogs but i cant find it
ADailyRitual 1 year ago
I love this.
BasdK95 1 year ago
some of his stuff actually is music TG!
Huffinearts 1 year ago
@Huffinearts
If you follow his philosophy all sound is music or no sound is
AngryDraftsman 1 year ago
@Huffinearts are you a fucking idiot? just because it doesn't sound pleasant to your ear doesn't mean it's not music. That was the whole point of experimentalism and more spefically indeterminacy in Cage's music. He was challenging accepted cultural norms in music and demonstrating that everything really, even if it doesn't fit into an "acceptable" scale or tonality range, is still musi and contains beauty. Obviously this movement has passed right over your head along with the ignorant masses.
Hamgammy 1 year ago
ahhhh...this is sooo amazing. something about it makes me think of a walk through a park during early winter...
daredevillboy1982 1 year ago
i love this sooo much
spainoner 1 year ago
there is a definite almost kind of like a cool structure to this piece. totally
schkent09 1 year ago
John Cage is awesome.
TheComposinator3000 1 year ago
For the last time, everyone, music is art, and therefore has NOTHING TO DO WITH COMPETITION!! John Cage was certainly not trying to out do anyone greater with the apparent profound silence of 4'33''. That piece was but a message for all to enjoy the pleasure of sound without producing any notes, it calls for all to reach out with imagination and appreciate noise. Yet, avant-garde can get over the top, and music still takes skill, as it should.
SoldatSolutrea 1 year ago 26
@SoldatSolutrea Then why do musicians and composers participate in numerous competitions in order to make their respective careers?
MrPaevo 1 week ago
This is a very good piece, like one of those things I could listen to all day long.
randomuserguy 1 year ago
@randomuserguy
yeah, it's one of those....
aperisimo 1 year ago
to the guy who doesn't get 433. if you dont like cage, leave. nobody is shoving anything down your throat. you are actually the one doing this.
nuclearRabbit123 1 year ago
kono kyoku ochitsukuuuuuuuu~
silverapple127 1 year ago
cage y el desierto de sechura
kepuysac 1 year ago
This is amazing music.
jrmcgee1 1 year ago
Sub-sub-footnote to musical history. In the 1980s my sister took part with many other performance piano students at New England Conservatory in a recording of one of Cage's pieces. At one point her stool squeaked. Eek.
shiralunacy 1 year ago
Comment removed
shiralunacy 1 year ago
what is the song with the nails in the piano?
sarahrocksyoursockss 1 year ago
@sarahrocksyoursockss Search for "prepared piano" and you'll find those pieces
NewMusicXX 1 year ago 2
thank you
sarahrocksyoursockss 1 year ago
@NewMusicXX thank you (:
sarahrocksyoursockss 2 months ago
@sarahrocksyoursockss .....lol....cute user name, sarah.
FishingForLobster 2 months ago
so nostalgic It almost makes me not afraid to die the way it deconstructs at the end. i shed a man-tear.
strongmungus 1 year ago
@strongmungus
Everything just got awkward.
oryandymackie95 1 year ago
Might this be the first minimalist piece?
1kirin1 2 years ago
Not by a long shot, that honer may go to Erik Satie who inspired these 2 pieces (including dream) by Cage.
pianiplunker 2 years ago
Would you care to recommend some particularly minimalist pieces by Satie? I'm playing La Fils de l'etoile I'm thinking it might qualify.
1kirin1 1 year ago
Perhaps the five nocturnes, my particular favorites. Probably the closest pieces to this particular style are the danses de travers from Pièces Froides. Check the IMSLP website for the scores. If you can't find them send me a private message.
pianiplunker 1 year ago
here is he speaking
:)
N0TKA 2 years ago
My piano teacher recomended this composer to me. She's right, this music is wonderful.
ToniMaelstrom 2 years ago 2
a genius. eno before eno.
dallexandro 2 years ago 4
aphex before aphex :)
AimmarCair 2 years ago 4
This song reminds me of a quiet place far from everything and everyone where you can rest forever and ever. A place where you can find the peace that you looked for the entire life...
Peace... rest... quiet
andbluesky 2 years ago 2
4分33秒ばっかり聴いてないでこっちも聴いて欲しい(´・ω・`)
隠れた名曲
Margatoroid 2 years ago
descubri a jhon cage en mi clase de historia del arte...me encanta su filosofia, su propuesta musical y visual, ¡gracias por su talento!
ruvagada 2 years ago
Misterstudebaker, if that's what you really think, then you maybe should hold off on performing the piece till you better understand it, and better understand John Cage in general. It's not a conservatory piano recital piece, it's music that just happened to be for piano.
bluephihitman 2 years ago 7
yeah pieces like this one and Dream are truly beautiful they show his beautiful sensitivity to sounds..
thebeatcreeper 2 years ago 3
perfect comment beat creeper
1drummer214 2 years ago
Comment removed
1drummer214 2 years ago
Comment removed
1drummer214 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I'm learning this right now. It's very poorly written. It's basically a melody, a tone poem - there are very few harmonies or chords in it. He has the sustain pedal throughout (which is cool) but has all these dotted 1/2 notes tied to dotted 1/4 notes, which are impossible to hear, due to the pedal. It makes no sense. I think he wrote it without the pedal, and then played it with the pedal and said "WOW!" and just kept it, rather than re-write it *for* the pedal. I truly love this piece, tho'.
misterstudebaker 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
You sound like a fag.
7h1m0 2 years ago
i think that if misterstudbaker truly loves the piece, its fine for him to say that in his opinion its "poorly written"
i don't take offense to it, i don't mind dissecting a piece
songsmadeforyou 2 years ago
heartachingly beautiful !!
howlingsin 2 years ago 3
this is too much
dudarstmein 2 years ago
in a good way or bad?
1drummer214 2 years ago
absolutely good of course LOL
dudarstmein 2 years ago 4
reminds me a paint of Van Gogh
cition 2 years ago
Could Arvo Part have been influenced by this? Probably not - but who knows?? It's not important - thanks so much for posting.
musiloo 2 years ago
genius
nocerotrequarti 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
does johnny cage have something to do with this guy?
i hope he doesnt
really nice piece. im gonna learn piano in order to play something like this
fermixx 2 years ago
i'm guessing john cage was one of harold budd's main influences.
dstdvl 2 years ago
i love cage's music it can be very challenging and also so exquisitely sweet and gentle..
nbv556 2 years ago 2
Comment removed
misssunshineboo 2 years ago
anyone know where I could get sheet music for this?
freshhh1994 2 years ago 2
john cage motherfucking owns
fenetremagique 2 years ago 58
Cage is incredible.
kingbobius 2 years ago 5
awesome!
andressavidigal 2 years ago 2
so clearly, john cage was much more than just 4'33
swawandoo 2 years ago 53
yeah, he's 9:50 also.
bootheavy 2 years ago
Negative commentators, you didn't get it. Swawandoo is right.
stefandetrez 2 years ago 4
@swawandoo But 4'33 is so much more then music!
Emilduvier 1 year ago
@Emilduvier No, I'd dare say it's far less than music. It is the complete absence of music and art, and should therefore not be appreciated as such. People who keep shoving 4'33 down my throat need to get a grip on how they interpret the garbage that is "modern" art: a slough of uncreative figures trying to wrestle individuality out of their own lack of talent. "I can't paint like DaVinci, so instead I'll convince the world that my splotchy mess is superior."
DavidEasthope 1 year ago
@DavidEasthope It's not less than music - after all, it is music! We have to remember here that 4:33 isn't silence, as the common misconception suggests.
And if I was to have a painting on my bedroom wall, I'd rather have a so called "splotchy mess" than Da Vinci anyday, simply because it would suit my room more. Geddit?
theknightmarlowe 1 year ago
@DavidEasthope 4'33 calls for one's own imagination, to interpret the ambience which always surrounds us for there never such a thing as silence.
If you don't like this train of thought, you could at least acknowledge it, then discard it, for it doesn't go with what you think music is.
Little insiders tip though, "musical" (music can be very abstract, as some feelings are) understanding doesn't come easy, one has to listen carefully and remove all preconceived notions of what one likes.
maniacguitar 1 year ago 5
@Emilduvier Is so much less then music.
evanescent25 1 year ago
@swawandoo yeah...well 4'33 is more conceptual, it's the apogee of his philosophy, (and it was pretty "shocking" too!) but surely it doesn't erases the rest of cage's ideas and composition!
RhymeByRhyme 1 year ago
amazing
Link123seabass 2 years ago 4