Gaga's HBO Monster Ball vs Madonna's Truth or Dare

[xXLazarus23Xx]

I heard Howard Stern talking about this. I don't think its a rip-off, the feel of it, maybe, Madonna was not the first to have a show like that. Gaga is a much better actress though... I believe what she's saying, she always talks about being insecure and prays before each performance. I don't believe it with Madonna. She sounds so bitchy at the start. and I said the same with "strange love" but it's a sample. It's not played all throughout the song, she LOVES that band!

[TheZoRetro]

Madonna has never brought theatrics and Art to her performances like gaga has. Gaga has took performing to an All-time high!

[TheAngelmuse]

DEAR Little Monsters - FYI, and I know u hate hearing this, but the FACT is that Madonna was the first artist to merge both the theatrics presentation of live act with the concert concept. What Gaga did with Monster Ball, we Madonna fans lived it out 20 yrs ago w/ Blond Ambition and we can understand what your feeling for Gaga is now.

But Dont hate Madonna for being the pioneer of what you think is being original today. At least Madonna was up front when she used or re-invent old concepts.

[Monster901023]

So, Madonna invented black and white?

[TheCesarway]

madonna is crap.

[mecastillo96]

madonna seems like she used to be a bitch....GAGA is so humble onstage and off :) love my mother monster <3

[jackharrisonankin]

eugh one of the most blatant things i saw in this video is madonna is just rude.

gaga is crying because she is insecure and wants to be better for her fans, while madonna is complaining about not being happy with 'someone from the industry' being in the audience.

hello you're meant to be a worldclass superstar?

oh and its a tour dvd how many concepts can be done?

[ejecu]

i saw Madonna´s Last Year, and yeah, tottally its a rip off.

i Saw Caca´s 2, ( Not The whole think cuz its suck) and i coudnt take Madonna out of my mind.

[fahd08]

gaga

cheat

dot

blog

spot

dot

com

[lolCen7]

2:56 I was ready to see the balloon

[hiag3]

LOL at those who haven't been at the MONSTER BALL and say GaGa doesn't sing live <3

[tomasduda1979]

@hiag3 This is not about the singing live, btw Madonna singing live always on her tours, it's about big similarity between Madonna's ToD and Gaga's MonsterBall by HBO. I'm Madonna's fan, but I saw monsterball and it was amazing. And Gaga's attitude and ideas are very similar to Madonna's.

[hiag3]

@tomasduda1979 doesn't mean she copied her! superficially they're very similar, but closely they're two different artists.

[momo4likeever1]

madonna invented a mirrar. madonna invented prayers, madonna invented everything! jesus fucking christ i love both madonna and gaga but these comparisons are ridiculous. give gaga a break, seriously they are not the same people. really it's pathetic how practically everyone think artist copy from madonna. madonna didn't invent the whole fucking planet nor did gaga.

[RileyRemix]

@momo4likeever1 They are not comparing the mirror or the prayer itself. It's the identical editing style and gaga's character. It's as if she watched truth or dare over and over and tried to become the character that is Madonna. Quoting the same things that Madonna said word for word like 'inspire everybody in that room'

[fantasysoul5]

You ppl are idiots, i love madonna and gaga but HBO made it! Also madonna had lawsuits for copying, she even had to pay 600,000 bcuz of it, nothing is original...

[BijanCanVlog]

@tiki8761 WTF?!?!? Have you been to the monsterball, SHE SINGS!

[jontur]

duuuh! i don't see the point, because both specials was made by HBO!!!! not by Gaga or Madonna!

anyways! GAGA IS THE NEW QUEEN! SUCK IT UP

[deliz6]

MADONNA INVENTED THE PRAYERS

[imac79]

FULG!

[raulito1589]

lady gaga is so fake, madonna is the queen!

[Smartiepants70]

There's one big difference between the two - Madonna did it all with style and wit, Gaga does it all with her head up her own ass.

[ilsecreepy]

fuck you haters GAGA IS THE NEW QUEEN OF POP paws up !!!

[governmentscheisse]

I love how threatened Hagdonna fans are.

[governmentscheisse]

MADONNA INVENTED BLACK AND WHITE!

[thehorrocruxes]

gaga is copycat lol and is very very very ugly, madonna is beatiful oh my god like lady gaga makes it to be so ugly, is a copy of Madonna but is abortion, this super ugly

[thehorrocruxes]

gaga is copycat lol and is very very very ugly, madonna is beatiful

[thehorrocruxes]

gaga is copycat lol

[gogetamusic]

LADY GAGA WANTS TO FEEL LIKE A MADONNA, BUT NEVER SHE IS A CHEAP COPY AND UUUUUUUUUUGLY TRAVESTY

[MaGoSpears]

I CANT BELIEVE IT! lady gaga is a copycat, can't deny.

[brushpicks23]

Tidbits:

* See that curly haired woman at 2:15?? That's Madonna's makeup employee "Mama Make-up" in T or D.. and Gaga is so obsessed in doing/following all things Madonna that Mama Make-Up is NOW Gaga's makeup artist!!

* See that Gaga rising up the stage part? Yep, can be seen in TOD "promise to try" scene! COPY

* See that silhouette entrance by Gaga at 5:18? A LAME copy of Madonna's EPIC Who's That Girl tour entrance!! (w/ costume copied from M's Hung Up to boot!)

Gaga is muy creepy!!!

[brushpicks23]

Hahaha at lil monsters giving EXCUSES that Gaga did not direct this monster's ball RIP OFF show.. yet when things work out, they'd say it's ALL HER!! LOL

They make Gaga DUMB! LOL

Why do they REFUSE to see what is HUGELY PLAIN TO SEE? That HBO Monsters Ball is a thorough, inch by inch COPY/PLAGIARISM of Truth or Dare???

Monsters, being "inspired" is to take elements of a previous work and make it different and infuse a new point of view.. ALL GAGA DOES HERE IS PLAGIARIZE!

[xianlm]

Wait...you're telling me a mirror scene is a plagiarism? Oh God. I've always thought mirror existed before Madonna.

[steph0318]

@xianlm It's not the exact details but the concept. There's a lot of what Gaga has done that is directly lifted from work Madonna's done. The concept of the two programs are the same. If you can't see that, then you are really delusional.

[xianlm]

@steph0318 Yes, I can see it, but I see inspiration, not a plagiarism. I also see inspiration and not plagiarism in Madonna compared to Nina Hagen, Dietrich, Cher, Debbie Harry or, of course, Monroe. I also see inspiration and not plagiarism in Lady Gaga compared to Madonna, Cyndi Lauper or Bowie. I was just joking with my comment. I think some people are too dramatic with these things.

[steph0318]

@xianlm It's not the exact details but the concept. There's a lot of what Gaga has done that is directly lifted from work Madonna's done. The concept of the two programs are the same. If you can't see that, then you are really delusional.

[lamquangnhat]

@steph0318 lol, dont be ridiculous, dont make me laugh anymore, stupid haters =)) that's what people will always do when have a concert like this ,Please =))

[Ouroboros11eleven]

@xianlm Don't act stupid. You know the concepts are similar.

[XxVirginBabyxX]

Straight Out of the Madonna Playbook... jeez Lady CopyNPaste seriously has no shame... one thing is to pay homage & admire those who inspire ur career & another to just flat out COPY!

Madonna leads where others follow... oh & by the way the "monster" below me is deluded to the point where lies & denial overpower truth & facts... sad:(

Madonna Queen of Pop 4ever!!

[24freemonster]

Its what its But LADY GAGA IS FUCKING ORIGINAL ok!!

[24freemonster]

Fuck you madonna fans lady gaga is original and if gaga whats to do something in black and white well let her Madonna did not creare black and what!! And Madonna Dora not sing that good like gaga she sings shit! I like some of her music but lets be real gaga is way o to better and i hear that madonna copies some Ppl so don't come here and tell us lil monsters that gaga is fake ok!! And that guy or girl who made this video GO FUCKYOURSELF!! LADY IS ORIGINAL and Madonna is a old bullshit!!

[gogetamusic]

@24freemonster LADY GAGA IS A COPY OF MAODNNA,..... SORRY FOR YOU...

[caorr]

I don't care what you do with your lives after this tour ?! -.- pretty pathetic statement if you ask me

[gsh73la]

@rob42996 Then why has she copied so many other artists, too ?

[StefanDot]

Fuck you little monsters. Sorry but you are really idiots and ignorant!

LADY GAGA IS A RIP-OFF!

ACCEPT THIS!

Lady gaga isn't creative, she steals from a lot of other artists (not only madonna). It's not a simple "inspiration".

SO SAD!

HER CREATIVE DIRECTOR ADMITTED THIS!

Even without admitting it is too obvious. People are stupids but not too much!

[TheZoRetro]

Monster ball is one the best tours of all time! it was theatrical, and magical! madonna sux compared to gaga! she actually loves her fans and is a nice person! mother monster rules!

[gsh73la]

@TheZoRetro It was generic.

[TheZoRetro]

@gsh73la please! what was generic about it!

[TheAngelmuse]

@TheZoRetro FYI, and I know u hate hearing this, but the FACT is that Madonna was the first artist to merge both the theatrics presentation of live act with the concert concept. What Gaga did with Monster Ball, we Madonna fans lived it out 20 yrs ago w/ Blond Ambition and we can understand what your feeling for Gaga is now.

But Dont hate Madonna for being the pioneer of what you think is being original today. At least Madonna was up front when she used or re-invent old concepts.

[TheZoRetro]

@TheAngelmuse What about david bowie, kiss, micheal jackson, tina turner, grace jones, and elton john?. All of these people did it before madonna. You think madonna was the first person to think outside the box?! hell no! and do you gaga is only inspired by madonna! HEll fuck no. especially since madonna has been making ignorant and snide remarks about gaga since she's been back in the media. Madonna didn't invent anything she just publicized it.

[ErickSemel]

@steph0318 I'm not saying it's a "blatant rip-off" but there's some comparison. It's all Laurieann who did it like that, not Gaga, so people need to stop saying Gaga's a "copycat".

[ErickSemel]

You fucking people!! GAGA DID NOT DIRECT THE HBO SPECIAL. If there's someone to blame, blame LAURIEANN GIBSON! FLAT OUT!

[steph0318]

@ErickSemel So you don't deny then, that the Monster Ball special is a blatant rip off of Truth or Dare?

[youthinkyourecute]

When I first saw this, I thought gaga was so full of shit!

[TheComedyParty]

Lady Gaga did NOT organize THE MONSTERBALL ON HBO. She's not the copycat.

[WasWasLo]

oh so how should gaga get her make up? while standing on her head?.. make scense atleast....and madonna is such an egoistick bitch....

[Brn2Snap1]

They are two very different people. I mean, as a complete Madonna Lover, I must say they are quite different. I respect Gaga as an artist who is trying to bring something back and I do enjoy her music but I do love Madonna with a passion. :) So please, with all do respect, lets just listen to the music, dance and leave it. :)

[j2490n]

wow i felt that prayer way more than any speeches gaga has ever and will ever make.

[queenmadonna82]

gaga copy cat! Me das asco! Pinche fea!

[lilbilly25]

Oh my God, would you give it a rest already. We get it, you think she's a copycat. Who cares. As long as she's making music and entertaining, who really cares where the style came from.

Chris Brown is the copycat you need to go after. Compare She Ain't You to Micheal's song

[steph0318]

@lilbilly25

Because it's called plagiarism and it's a crime. She's not "getting her style" from somewhere nor is she just "inspired". She is ripping off, plain and simple.

[BornGaGaMonster]

@steph0318 Nope it's called Creativity Use. Plus, have you seen the contract? GaGa will do an 80's theme duet with Madonna for her fourth album. Hmmm... Madonna's not mad, nor does she think it's plagiarism. She would address Gagaa if she was copying her don't you think? Yeah. thought so...

[steph0318]

@BornGaGaMonster Provide me a link to your story claim? Just did a search and nothing comes up. In fact, madonna's manager laughed when asked if she would collaborate with Gaga and Madonna's publicist told them to look at Stevie Nicks new album name for their answer. The album name is "In Your Dreams." So suck on that delusional little monster.

[BornGaGaMonster]

@steph0318 There is no link BUT TWITTER. She said back in January that she might collab with her. In fact YOU provide me a link where Madonna's manager laughed at that. NOW or you're lying.

[steph0318]

@BornGaGaMonster January is past. Things change. Your mommy monster is a mega thief. deal with it. here's your links

NY daily news

allaboutmadonna

do a goodle search madonna collabortation with gaga and more will come up. youtube wont let me post the entire links but they story been reported on different sites. happy reading.

[BornGaGaMonster]

@steph0318 Why is she a theif? that makes me sad to know what mom's done =(

[gsh73la]

@BornGaGaMonster No, it's called being a generic fart unable to come up with anything of ones own.

[gsh73la]

@lilbilly25 Who cares ? You support a clone and a fraud ? So essentially you'd be okay with having your things stolen ?

[belovedboy87]

madonna is playing madonna, gaga is playing a character hahaha, I'm waiting for madonna to return and kick gaga's ass!

[BornGaGaMonster]

@belovedboy87 Nope. They're really great friends actually.

[tiki8761]

ugh yeah but madonna's truth or dare is much better though, at least she doesn't give long speeches to her fans and barely sings her songs onstage

[StefanDot]

Fuck you liar. did you watch the documentary? Do you have seen the revolution in act? Fuck you idiot teenager.

Your lady gaga is totaly a rip-off of other very creative and real artists.

Your lady gaga is a marketing product who can only copy others and convince you little monsters.

Learn art, music, fashion and the history. Don't be stupid.

I am sorry for english, i learn.

[YourHighwayInTheSky]

@tiki8761 ugh yeah but Gaga is much better though, at least she isn't a huge bitch, and actually CAN sing

[MusicManiaacify]

@YourHighwayInTheSky haha, this made me laugh