nice filming! You clearly know the song. I'm glad the punch brothers play this. Its one of my favorites off how to grow a woman (next to the instrumentals cazadero and eleventh reel). Hope they play it when I see them.
Thile's voice is phenomenal. He's a high baritenor with a gorgeous upper chest voice and essentially no break between chest and falsetto. His pitch is as close to perfect as I've heard, and to top it all off, he's singing while playing virtuosic mandolin parts only a handful of people in the world can play as well. He could make it as a singer, or a mandolin player, but in combining the two he is crazy good. (I say this as a singer and mandolin player myself).
I didn't mean he's off-key or anything like that. I just meant that his voice is pretty forgettable and lacks that certain charismatic pull that some singers have.
In short, it just doesn't appeal to me. But the musicality of these guys? Holy Cow!!
i could agree with your analysis. nothing real soulful about it. i mean he's a good vocalist but an outstanding instrumentalist. He's, technically speaking, waaaaaaaaaaay up there with the likes of sam bush, jesse cobb, etc.
I would actually have to disagree with you. His intonation (and the entire groups) is so tight it may as well be a synthesizer. I'm almost certain he must have perfect pitch or a phenomenal ear because they often start their acappela pieces with no pitch. But really, I've seen him 4 times in concert and every time his singing is so in tune and spot on it's out of this world. I'm not trying to down talk his playing at all, just saying I truly admire his and his groups vocals just as much.
@pianomatteo that's something you see in REAL LIVE music... these guys, like most musicians of a truly acoustic vein, sound just as good standing in a dusty field unplugged, vocaly AND instrumentally, and that is something pop musicians can't do.
I saw them in Luisville the day before this! Some guy kept yelling for them to play this song and when they finally did Chris said, "And now we're gonna play..." and pointed to the guy! And the guy said nothing!
It was hillarious! Chris pointed at him like four times! And he never said anything!
nice filming! You clearly know the song. I'm glad the punch brothers play this. Its one of my favorites off how to grow a woman (next to the instrumentals cazadero and eleventh reel). Hope they play it when I see them.
thanks for getting this on youtube!
ericwolff6 10 months ago
Punch Brothers are great!
volleyballjones 11 months ago
This is the best bluegrass video I have seen in a long time!
It made my day :)
dizzey05 1 year ago
This song deserves a rowdier audience!
Lukeypoo91 1 year ago
Thile's voice is phenomenal. He's a high baritenor with a gorgeous upper chest voice and essentially no break between chest and falsetto. His pitch is as close to perfect as I've heard, and to top it all off, he's singing while playing virtuosic mandolin parts only a handful of people in the world can play as well. He could make it as a singer, or a mandolin player, but in combining the two he is crazy good. (I say this as a singer and mandolin player myself).
mrlandby 1 year ago 7
Eat yer heart out Ricky Skaggs, LOL! :))
lrover03 1 year ago
They played this in their encore last night here in Ann Arbor... just incredible.
samiamfink 1 year ago
hey is so sexy. :)
mattphat23 2 years ago 2
i totaly a gree with you, Chris is the hottest most talented peron evar!
Vswimmer2012 1 year ago
what are you talking about he singing is great! he can hit all those high notes
bromberg25 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
He can throw down mandolin and star in Twilight! Is there anything Robert Pattinson can't do? :O
;-)
juli0sus 2 years ago
I didn't mean he's off-key or anything like that. I just meant that his voice is pretty forgettable and lacks that certain charismatic pull that some singers have.
In short, it just doesn't appeal to me. But the musicality of these guys? Holy Cow!!
berkeleymlkhouse 2 years ago
i could agree with your analysis. nothing real soulful about it. i mean he's a good vocalist but an outstanding instrumentalist. He's, technically speaking, waaaaaaaaaaay up there with the likes of sam bush, jesse cobb, etc.
blugrastooth 2 years ago
Chris Thile's mandolin playing is almost without peer, but as a singer I find him pretty average. I really prefer his instrumentals.
koreankayagum 2 years ago
I would actually have to disagree with you. His intonation (and the entire groups) is so tight it may as well be a synthesizer. I'm almost certain he must have perfect pitch or a phenomenal ear because they often start their acappela pieces with no pitch. But really, I've seen him 4 times in concert and every time his singing is so in tune and spot on it's out of this world. I'm not trying to down talk his playing at all, just saying I truly admire his and his groups vocals just as much.
pianomatteo 2 years ago 4
@pianomatteo that's something you see in REAL LIVE music... these guys, like most musicians of a truly acoustic vein, sound just as good standing in a dusty field unplugged, vocaly AND instrumentally, and that is something pop musicians can't do.
jazzfolkrocker 1 year ago
I saw them in Luisville the day before this! Some guy kept yelling for them to play this song and when they finally did Chris said, "And now we're gonna play..." and pointed to the guy! And the guy said nothing!
It was hillarious! Chris pointed at him like four times! And he never said anything!
dkale 3 years ago
that's awesome!
MilesPittman 2 years ago
I loved Gillian Welch's original version, but this is incredible.
dragknuckle 3 years ago
That's awesome!
I wish they would do a show in Toronto!!
chrisricker 3 years ago
Did you get a video of when Chris Eldridge stepped on Greg's mic and they had to start over? :D
mandolinking 3 years ago
No. Missed that one!
deneicee 3 years ago
My pleasure! I love these guys!
deneicee 3 years ago
thank you so much for sharing all of these
starthrowbanjo 3 years ago