Added: 3 years ago
From: IMusicideMontreal
Views: 27,970
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (46)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • i just played this at carnegie hall!

  • Meh. Mozart is better.

  • Beethoven was THE composer

  • amazing how much sound a small group can put out..

  • I wouldn't start bow up.

  • SHIT

  • Watched/heard this piece performed by the Los Angeles Philharmonic, it was amazing. This is one of the best pieces I've ever heard, I play piano, but I hope someday to play violin in an orchestra, especially this piece!

  • Love this

  • best ever....

  • Totally weird sound...

    Nice playing but I can not stay with this way...

  • @heldenbariton I agree.

  • I'm a cellist and playing this piece was by far the most fun I'd had in an orchestra.

  • I'm a cellist and this was by far the most fun I'd had in an orchestra.

  • 1:20 sounds like Smash Bros. Brawl XD

  • Comment removed

  • @L1ghTx the main theme?

  • @helmsdeep84 don't remember :D but some of the songs of brawl begin like that.

  • ASTOUNDING! Especially with a small orchestra where mistakes would have been easier to hear (there weren't any), this was a top notch performance.... and the best acoustics I've ever heard in a performance hall yet. It was alive and vivid, with nearly palpable expression and dynamics - like you were hearing each instrument one by one, yet brought together in one complete whole. Perfectly clean performance - absolutely amazing!

  • excellent musical concept but the balance and ensemble problems are distracting

  • Shame it was never finished..

  • Stunning.

  • they r absolutely precise. Is different coz u can hear details that r not evident with the complete orchestra

  • Wonderful sound. The acoustics in that hall create a pleasing reverberation that enhances the overall sound. I Musici of Montreal does have many CDs available. They are well worth owning.

  • Supreme !

  • What an amazing reddition of that masterpiece ! Thanks.

  • wow..this is not bad..

  • You know, the orchestra may be smaller than we're used to seeing, but they're producing a marvelous sound and everyone is very together! You really can't complain when the orchestra is this skilled.

  • Mozart was THRILLED when he could get a larger orchestra,espicially with his concertos and symphonies. Personally,I think it does Haydn and Mozart a disservice to always play their music with smaller orchestras just because "Thats the size of orchestra they had" when it comes to symphonic music,I say bigger orchestras produce a bigger and more powerful sound---And with the early composers,all you have to do to keep the proportions correct is to keep the ratios the same and double it up.

  • Uh, isn't the orchestra supposed to be larger?

  • the orchestra size you are probably used to seeing is the Romantic era orchestra. This is the traditional classical sized orchestra

  • Beethoven called for larger orchestras than Mozart and Haydn

  • mabey in his symphonies but that doesnt make it the standard size for everything he wrote

  • doesn't he call for larger orchestras in his Egmont?

    obviously, you need a larger orchestra for Romantic era pieces

  • hmm that is a good question, ill look into that.

    And yeh obviously , but i woldnt think that this overture would qualify as a Romantic era piece...

    I think that the closest of his works would be his 9th symphony but the writing style of this is clearly Classical era

  • Egmont is more on the Romantic side than the Classical side, though.

    This isn't pure classical, unlike the works of Haydn and Mozart and Beethoven's first two symphonies

  • Egmont is more on the Romantic since written later in his career .

    Now Coriolan which is more towards the middle of his career would still qualify as classical in style, but late classical.

    As far as size it think that generally a classical orchestra would be scored :

    Vio 1 - 8

    Vio 2 - 8

    Vila - 6

    Cel - 4

    Bass - 3

    and winds horn/ trmpt , flute. ob, basn,clar with 2 of each. So with that being said you cold argue that this orchestra is on the small side.

  • ...yes! Very good observation!!!

  • But in the end it what ever the score calls for which again will be easy to find out come tmrw morning.

  • Yes, of course! But the problem is: Is Beethoven a romantic or a classical composer? - I think we cannot really answer that but as a conductor you have to find your solution and if you want to play it in a "classical" way, this orchestra would be very appropriate!!!

  • You're absolutely right! Beethoven is often played much to romantic and by that I also mean that today's orchestras are almost always much too big!!

  • WOW

  • best performance ever...

  • Have you seen Kleiber's? I recommend it.

  • Awesome!

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more