I've listened to several of you're songs and I'm just breathless. Your voice is amazing in so many ways. I mean you're speaking Elvish and it's like PERFECT not many people can do that. I hope you find a great career in doing what you do.
"I am perfectly aware I was not able to do this song proper justice, nor do I sound remotely like Sylvanas" You don't need to. you just made me cry where the original song didn't...for the sweetness of your voice, the inflexions in it...i could go on but i think you know what I feel about it
@Rhawyneth Been playing for years and I agree with you, all due respect to her voice actor. I doubt there are many who can surpass Kate's abillities and voice though, ameature or professional, known to few or international celeberity.
@LucielStarz123 sorry for the late reply! Ah! I really should write it out, it was really fun to come up with ^^; If I ever get it down on sheet music, I will post it in the description of the video so you can download it to play! :D
There are a lot of Elfquest songs that could use a new arrangement..."Hands of a Healer" and "Shades of Shadow" (Both available on Youtube, just look for the "Elfquest" versions
I found your version of suteki da ne in my favourites, it's been sitting in there for a while and I decided to listen to some other stuff, you do this song great justice. I think it's a fantastic version. You sound beautiful.
I've never heard this song before I listened to Kate sing it (never playing any Horde characters), but I really like it. It's sad and kind of scary. A song about impending doom...and what makes it worse is that I was the one to wipe them out (during Warcraft 3). Damn! Only video games can make a 30 year old banker from Denver feel like a damned Nazi.
@Seanschemmelfan Ah! My CD is available on my website (erutanmusic . com) and it contains all my original songs. My covers are non-profit though, and you can download them freely from the link on my channel profile or from the links on my website ^^
I was expecting the same "medioker" singing most others seems to be posting. You completly blew me away! Never heard anything like it in my life! Bravo, keep it up!
i can't believe i haven't stumbled upon you before now - what a wonderful arrangement and performance. one of my most favorite songs, and you breathe a whole new perspective into it. love it.
Actually, I think that your version is better than the official one. The only thing I'd change is put a little more echo into the main voice line - just a tad more than you used in your "I'll Follow You Into The Dark" cover. That way it'd be the sound equivalent to light through the mist.
Other than that admittedly minor thing, this is a lot better than the official one.
This sounds even better than the original version (like almost everyone of your songs). And this song has been my favourite music in WoW for so many years til the point "Invincible" arrived.
Aww...Lady Sylvanas Windrunner, forsaken but never forgotten.
I've seen a couple vids of yours now and i have to ask...do you have a contract with anyone? You have an amazing voice and are very good at arrangement i cant see how you couldn't.
@SexyMonsterLover a contract? Not at all :O But even if one comes along I doubt I'll take it, I'm a bit too independent for a contract ^w^; But thanks so much for the compliment @.@
You are amazing. Your voice, your instrument usage; even the fact that you sped up the tempo a bit made it feel more like the way Sylvanas would have been singing it, being that their time was short and Silvermoon was being invaded relatively quickly.
For me it wasn't a matter a which one was better or not, because they both had a very different feel. The original made me think of the various forests I had to trudge through. (Mostly Eversong and Silverpine.) Your version however, had an almost Celtic feel to it in some parts and it made me think of Silvermoon City, with all it's splendor save for it's one physical flaw, a reminder of their past. Of course this is coming from a one of dem nasty little rolepayers. :D
Your version of this song has a life completely different from, but no less stunning than, the original. Very haunting and subtle, you are very talented.
I must agree with the mass here. You have an amazing voice miss... and the fact that you also played the track yourself means 10x more to the spirit of the song. I believe you to have truely captured the sentiment here by personalizing it and making it your own. Seriously, keep it up!
This is so better than the one Sylvanas sung. It's much different. Do you remember Noelle? She showed me this, I play WoW with her now.Wonderful job on the song! By the way Noelle really misses you!
This is actually really beautiful, and you did an amazing job. Blood Elves are my favorite race so I can really appreciate how this song ties into the lore.
I'm ready to make a petition to make KateTheGreat an NPC in Cata. :-) Blizzard gotta recognize this. This is talent at its finest. :-) Great job Kate!
I don't play WoW, so I'm pretty lucky to have stumbled upon this. If that's really you doing all of the instrumentation on top of the vocals, then I have to say it's the most well done fan-arranged song cover I've heard on here, especially video game related. Nice stuff.
*doesn't know what to say* I was entranced! Your voice is so beautiful! This is better than the original if you ask me. Wow, I can't get over how pretty your voice is! *listens to song again* ^_^
Silvana's fighting a battle to win they could not. Although she knew that she could not win, it has continued to fight for family and people. And now she is working on a poison that kills both human and undead to take revenge on the other alliance she and her people left in the engraving and the Arthas she tied forever to the earth
And i always thought the original artist was the best.. I was wrong.. Cosidering you playing the instruments you are much beyond her. I raise my hat, although i have none at the current moment, to you! Keep it up!
you did a good job on this song, like you said you don't sound like sylvanas does, but you did a good job :) *btw i got the music box finally from icc25 heroic !!! *shadowmourn final quest rewards*. made me happy.
@Voidrend There are so many accidentals in the song it is hard for me to discover the "true" key, but it starts in E natural-minor with some B flats thrown into the harmony for that "special dissonance" I start my melody on an E.
People in previous comments have said the song lacks the same emotion as the Gunn version. I disagree with that notion. It's all about the perspective and interpretations of the singer who I believe did a great service to this piece.
From what I've read on wowwiki the original was of Kaldorei origin lamenting the losses during the War of the Ancients. Therefore when I hear you sing it, I think of a younger Sylvanas reflecting on her people's past, rather than the Banshee Queen we have today.
Your voice is so Serene! It's so beautiful. I've never heard such a beautiful voice! I'm a singer myself and soon when I can I'll be putting some of my stuff on.
You did great an amazing cover of this song. And I get a true rpg feel from the video arrangement, as if you were seeing the pride of civilization rising and falling. Truly a lament of the highborne.
I read your side note, and I'm gonna be straight up with you... You have no idea what your voice is capable of. This is by far the best version of this song I have ever heard. You have a rare and beautiful voice that I could listen to till my dying breath. One could easily fall in love with a woman with a voice like yours.I personally think you did justice to the song just fine.
I think you sung amazingly! Most of us can't carry a tune in a bucket. It was a great cover! And I think the fact that you play so many various instruments so well more than "makes up" for the differences between you and the original singer.
Just wanted to drop by and say this cover is amazing! I just watched the Quel'Delar movie by Melvenor, and offer my praise for such a beautiful cover, better than anything I could do with the song. Keep it up!
this was well done. I haven't heard the actual singer but you did a lot better than I could ever hope to do! Violen is beautiful. Such a sad sounding song.
I listen to this repeatedly while I'm playing WoW... Even when I'm not playing, actually. It's... no words can describe how beautiful this is. ^.^ I started listening to this song a few months before, and recently I've watched more of your videos ^.^ I'm in love with every one of them! I <3 you Kate! =]
I could listen to the violin all day. On the second half I end up listening to it more than the singing. The singing is amazing, too. o: If you could put up some covers of songs on your violin solo I bet it'd be amazing too!
I have to agree with you on one thing; you don't put the same type of emotion into it that Sylvannas did. Slyvannas sung it with a sad, emotional passion and I think that's what really won the song for me. However, your composition and voice are lovely.
@Hikari2Yami I sung with all the emotion I could muster, but in the end it comes down to skill, which I have much less of than Vangie Gunn. I've seen this sort of comment a lot, which is why I put a disclaimer of sorts in the description.
@Hikari2Yami I would have to respectfully disagree with you on the "emotional passion" put into this cover version of the song. I felt the seemingly emotional sadness from this song. For me, it felt like it was sadness from a different person, which is actually the case since this artist is different from the original.
In your description, you tended to lie a bit. You said that this doesn't do the song any justice and that you said it wasn't that great. I've done the whole quest line in the game of World of Warcraft for them to actually play this song, really it isn't that long though <.<, and had them play it in Undercity. How you've done it is quite amazing, and if I understand it properly, you did this entirely by yourself. It is really amazing, and you should be proud of yourself for this.
okay..... this is epic in my opinion, and I don't even play WoW (I've played Warcraft 2 and 3, and have listened to the official blizzard endorsed video).
Well i can just say that this piece ist awesome in its own way...not worse not better than the official blizzard version...it just has its own special sound in a good good way.
keep up your work because you know what youre doing ;)
I've listened to several of you're songs and I'm just breathless. Your voice is amazing in so many ways. I mean you're speaking Elvish and it's like PERFECT not many people can do that. I hope you find a great career in doing what you do.
coolguy338 1 week ago
"I am perfectly aware I was not able to do this song proper justice, nor do I sound remotely like Sylvanas" You don't need to. you just made me cry where the original song didn't...for the sweetness of your voice, the inflexions in it...i could go on but i think you know what I feel about it
JoyZoneYT 1 week ago
Beautiful...just like our people.
ThalassianHighKing 3 weeks ago
@ThalassianHighKing Glory to the Sin'dorei!
yamibalus 1 week ago
I don't even play WoW, but I love this piece. Your violin playing is so amazing! :)
violagirl333 1 month ago
A lot of players will probably get mad at me for saying this, but I actually think your version of this is prettier than Lady Silvanas'.
Rhawyneth 1 month ago
@Rhawyneth i am actually a huge Silvanas fan but i will agree with you it is better after all i don't see silvanas singing lol
Bloodcoverdreems 3 weeks ago
@Rhawyneth Been playing for years and I agree with you, all due respect to her voice actor. I doubt there are many who can surpass Kate's abillities and voice though, ameature or professional, known to few or international celeberity.
Talkingcamara2 2 weeks ago
Do you thin you can send me the violin part???
LucielStarz123 1 month ago
@LucielStarz123 sorry for the late reply! Ah! I really should write it out, it was really fun to come up with ^^; If I ever get it down on sheet music, I will post it in the description of the video so you can download it to play! :D
katethegreat19 5 days ago
no bad /barakobamaface.jpg xD well actually quite epic =P
egokatya 2 months ago
wow you are amazing
Ashleydesmith 2 months ago
There are a lot of Elfquest songs that could use a new arrangement..."Hands of a Healer" and "Shades of Shadow" (Both available on Youtube, just look for the "Elfquest" versions
RedwoodTheElf 3 months ago
you have a beautiful voice and i like how you take stuff like this for example and make it kinda your own
beautiful job ^^
KishikoSelkie 3 months ago
Comment removed
Cowscraft 4 months ago
;w; This is so beautiful~
So what if it doesn't sound like Blizzard's-
You do it justice, just in your own, beautiful way. <3
dangerofnothing 4 months ago in playlist dangerofnothing's favorites
Absolutely Beautiful!
TheJediRose 4 months ago
do u have a studio or something or u compose on a software?
gr8 work btw like ur style.
roflman87 4 months ago
wonderfull
Isathurisaz 4 months ago
I found your version of suteki da ne in my favourites, it's been sitting in there for a while and I decided to listen to some other stuff, you do this song great justice. I think it's a fantastic version. You sound beautiful.
wtfusernameftl 4 months ago
I've never heard this song before I listened to Kate sing it (never playing any Horde characters), but I really like it. It's sad and kind of scary. A song about impending doom...and what makes it worse is that I was the one to wipe them out (during Warcraft 3). Damn! Only video games can make a 30 year old banker from Denver feel like a damned Nazi.
AuspexAO 4 months ago
Where can i get your cds? I have to let my mom hear your singing kate, my mom sings at church and she has a good singing voice.
Seanschemmelfan 5 months ago
@Seanschemmelfan Ah! My CD is available on my website (erutanmusic . com) and it contains all my original songs. My covers are non-profit though, and you can download them freely from the link on my channel profile or from the links on my website ^^
I would love to hear your mom sing!!! *o*
katethegreat19 5 months ago 9
@katethegreat19 Thanks and I will have to record my mom singing infront of my camera.
Seanschemmelfan 5 months ago
Beautiful :)
MrKanojo 5 months ago
xD love this song make me miss my blood elf
PearlDante 5 months ago in playlist PearlDante's Favorited Videos
My best friend introduced me to this video U have such a beautiful voice! I love temple of the moon the best so far tho <3
DreaTheDragon 6 months ago
i like this much more than the original, i love ur voice
brittb8395 7 months ago
Wow, i stumbled on this just now, it's really nice of you that you included one of my art into the video AND credited it :P (i'm Umerean)
You have a very nice voice, your rendering for the song is really moving, nice work!
Kyalie 7 months ago
Bravissima...really an emotion!!!
Thank u for sharing and good luck for your future!
Have a nice life!
arafenix70 7 months ago
it's very beatiful voice....
LukadiYuna 8 months ago
Such a sad song :'(
XvShadowsvX 8 months ago
FYI.. Im a huge fan of the original piece, but IMO your version is better! Great Job!
chandlergriz 8 months ago
Hot damn, why have I not discovered you until now? Your voice is drop-dead gorgeous. Haunting. I'm always late to everything. >.< <3
NCISnerdette 8 months ago
This arrangement is absolutely breathtaking.
lyssachan 8 months ago
oh gosh kaite. this is so beautiful, but--alliance all the way >_<
MsMandaish 8 months ago
As always: Perfect! ^~^
DarkWolves19 9 months ago
I was expecting the same "medioker" singing most others seems to be posting. You completly blew me away! Never heard anything like it in my life! Bravo, keep it up!
valkyriaveve 9 months ago
Wow, you have a beatiful voice, I consider myself a okay singer, but not good enough to post and make a fool of myself, great video, keep it up.
TheEpicZelda1 9 months ago
The best.
TrUcOsWiNdOwS1 10 months ago
Wow...this is simply just....wow...I cant even sing this that good and I sing it on a daily basis!
kinasody 10 months ago
i can't believe i haven't stumbled upon you before now - what a wonderful arrangement and performance. one of my most favorite songs, and you breathe a whole new perspective into it. love it.
sambonz 10 months ago 22
@sambonz thank you so so much! *o*
katethegreat19 9 months ago
This song is magical when you sing it.
sveria1210 10 months ago
thumbs up if u heard this and thought...wow....
Darkioas 10 months ago
Actually, I think that your version is better than the official one. The only thing I'd change is put a little more echo into the main voice line - just a tad more than you used in your "I'll Follow You Into The Dark" cover. That way it'd be the sound equivalent to light through the mist.
Other than that admittedly minor thing, this is a lot better than the official one.
BenMaynardOfManyArts 10 months ago
I have to disagree on the statement that you didn't put as much emotion in this as the original singer. You did a VERY amazing job ñ_ñ.
I play a Blood Elf, and I'm kind of like a lorewhore. I just love the High/Blood Elf lore.
Listening to this song gives me tears, thinking on everything that happened in the game, but also in real life. This song keeps me together ^o^.
Keep it up!
Love,
Bjørn ;)
magicbjorn 10 months ago
That's really sweet !!! I love it maybe more than the original version ^_^
"ladyreemz86" has sent me your video ;)
I wish you the best of luck you're a talented musician
thumbs up
Zalaband 10 months ago
This was surreal love it
:')
DjCINEMA 10 months ago
WoW!!!<3 :DDD
SaiaFayy 10 months ago
you have a beutiful voice and an amazing tenacity if you can memorize the calstria ( i believe thats how you spell it) language. much props
illidanswrath 11 months ago
This makes me want to cry you were amazing.
Blackangel120 11 months ago
This sounds even better than the original version (like almost everyone of your songs). And this song has been my favourite music in WoW for so many years til the point "Invincible" arrived.
Aww...Lady Sylvanas Windrunner, forsaken but never forgotten.
Ana Alah Belore
JustifiedH8 11 months ago 3
The Sin'dorei will prevail!
damunzta 11 months ago
Someone on a European Server? Maybe german? Die Aldor is my favorite realm and I love playing my Bloodelf-Warlock Halfric
NightOfSamhain 11 months ago
i'm crying with amazement of how beautiful you sang this song
WNxDroid 1 year ago 2
EEE i love this song! ^^
I play A undead priest on Senjin server so this excited me when i saw it! hehe
Setsuna2468 1 year ago
"I am perfectly aware I was not able to do this song proper justice"
~LIES!
teodortenchev 1 year ago
I read your sidenote and thought to myself, "well, I guess I'll listen to it anyway..."
You then proceeded to totally blow me away.
It's beautiful.
ut000bs 1 year ago
I played this riding through Eversong. It was very atmospheric. Lovely.
Ryusola 1 year ago
Stunning.
DiotisHimself441 1 year ago
Nice song and nice photos..Rly cool job :P
intrigantebella 1 year ago
Amazing. You could make a career out of your talent.
JakRizen2 1 year ago
5-10 seconds in the son, and i'm faving it
AlaskanWarden 1 year ago
@welsj I've got a blood elf priest! :D I'll heal youuuuu!
katethegreat19 1 year ago 35
@katethegreat19 OMG Me too ^^ I love my Blood Elf Priest
Neroscam 1 year ago
@katethegreat19 ZOMG, For the horde! :3
Casanovf77 1 year ago
@katethegreat19 ZOMG, For the horde! :3
Letti: Blood elf priest, Shu halo server! :D
Casanovf77 1 year ago 2
@katethegreat19 really? it's a small world after all. I've seen you runnig around once or twice now :)
LindelDragon 10 months ago
@katethegreat19 Wow, you're fucking amazing... o.o
ITFNxSpartan 4 months ago
pure talent...great job!
ParnHawk 1 year ago
I've seen a couple vids of yours now and i have to ask...do you have a contract with anyone? You have an amazing voice and are very good at arrangement i cant see how you couldn't.
SexyMonsterLover 1 year ago
@SexyMonsterLover a contract? Not at all :O But even if one comes along I doubt I'll take it, I'm a bit too independent for a contract ^w^; But thanks so much for the compliment @.@
katethegreat19 1 year ago 6
You are amazing. Your voice, your instrument usage; even the fact that you sped up the tempo a bit made it feel more like the way Sylvanas would have been singing it, being that their time was short and Silvermoon was being invaded relatively quickly.
You ma'am, win. ^_^
TJTerry101 1 year ago
After hearing your version of the Lament, I HAD to make a BE Mage. Your voice just captivated me like you were a siren on the ocean...
:D
msunami 1 year ago
For me it wasn't a matter a which one was better or not, because they both had a very different feel. The original made me think of the various forests I had to trudge through. (Mostly Eversong and Silverpine.) Your version however, had an almost Celtic feel to it in some parts and it made me think of Silvermoon City, with all it's splendor save for it's one physical flaw, a reminder of their past. Of course this is coming from a one of dem nasty little rolepayers. :D
Ryju 1 year ago
I'll admit I had my doubts when I saw fanmade. But you did pull it off very well. It is a great song.
Be that as it may. The blood elves can't hold a candle to the Worgen
ElJorro 1 year ago
Its always good to be reminded that the blood elves are the loveliest... and saddest race of Warcraft.
TheKhanken 1 year ago
Kate I have one question....Alliance or Horde?
realkagome1 1 year ago
@realkagome1 :D I play Horde at the moment ^^
katethegreat19 1 year ago 16
@katethegreat19 Blood Elves aint Horde, pointy ears !
LalaThaOlo 1 year ago
Kate I have one question...Alliance or Horde?
realkagome1 1 year ago
alll hails for kate...a real sylvannas...victory for kate. the new sylvannas from the forsaken.. :X
yager943 1 year ago
Your version of this song has a life completely different from, but no less stunning than, the original. Very haunting and subtle, you are very talented.
ryodark 1 year ago
ah lovely as always... wonderful...and I agree it is better than the original
Brett276 1 year ago
Oh gowd.. I now love you.
Omgdiamondelfy 1 year ago
Your voice is as beautiful as your music.
Takurai 1 year ago
I must agree with the mass here. You have an amazing voice miss... and the fact that you also played the track yourself means 10x more to the spirit of the song. I believe you to have truely captured the sentiment here by personalizing it and making it your own. Seriously, keep it up!
-FTH
Leudorien 1 year ago
For Quel´thalas!
Rioxful 1 year ago
Oh no! The music combined with this song is too much! It's too good for youtube, but thanks for posting it anyways! ;)
Hawt sin'dorei+amazing voice=best warcraft vid ever
<3 <3 <3
Firemoonsoul 1 year ago
This isn't Sylvanas. It's one of her more talented sisters.
TheHairline 1 year ago 3
This is so better than the one Sylvanas sung. It's much different. Do you remember Noelle? She showed me this, I play WoW with her now.Wonderful job on the song! By the way Noelle really misses you!
Icearroww 1 year ago
So beautiful, every time I listen to it. <3
Never gets old. Love it sooo much. ;w:
AyaandCeres 1 year ago
Tempo's a little up, but otherwise it's exquisite.
ShadowXII 1 year ago
this is totally my favorite of ALL ur covers so far. <3333
OnlyReitasGirl 1 year ago
This is actually really beautiful, and you did an amazing job. Blood Elves are my favorite race so I can really appreciate how this song ties into the lore.
Lordojamablack 1 year ago
I'm ready to make a petition to make KateTheGreat an NPC in Cata. :-) Blizzard gotta recognize this. This is talent at its finest. :-) Great job Kate!
WhiteKnight74648 1 year ago 3
I have goosebumps right now.
hironeden 1 year ago
Beautiful. I had chills from the experience.
The best MMO game i have ever play. Soundtracks are awesome, and that's amesome arrangement
Aikoox3 1 year ago
amazing, this brought tears in my eyes!
pmlopmlop 1 year ago
I don't play WoW, so I'm pretty lucky to have stumbled upon this. If that's really you doing all of the instrumentation on top of the vocals, then I have to say it's the most well done fan-arranged song cover I've heard on here, especially video game related. Nice stuff.
Kalmyel 1 year ago
Wow, this is beautiful o.o
Leygoes 1 year ago
i like it
god751010 1 year ago
ah super awesome. all your stuff is great. i used these lyrics in a music project during college hehe
meigaria 1 year ago
Despite my intense love for the banshee queen... I must say, you have bested her, :3
eggshapedcarrot 1 year ago
you always sing the heaven song!!!
...so...you are an angel who have got very very angel voice :D:D
this is very perfectly beautiful ^^
pandablahblah 1 year ago
I like this one more than the original. You sing beautifully. Not to mention you play beautifully as well.
Medinaxz 1 year ago
most of youtube.com cover songs are crappy but this one isn't! well done imo.
celestica83 1 year ago
When I listen to this, it's easy to imagine that an elf is singing.
denkitekaizoku 1 year ago
*doesn't know what to say* I was entranced! Your voice is so beautiful! This is better than the original if you ask me. Wow, I can't get over how pretty your voice is! *listens to song again* ^_^
xDragonSpirit 1 year ago
This quite honestly could have played during WoW, I may actually like this better than the original.
hitokiri0kenshin 1 year ago
Amazing song and pictures
boyongroel 1 year ago
Even better than the original imo. Very, very impressive
Stektanudlar 1 year ago
I don't even play WoW (wish I could, though) and I fell in love with your voice in this one. @_@
zephyrantes88 1 year ago
Very nice instrumentation, and I like your voice. Could have lowered the tempo a bit, maybe that's just me.
NexEstVox 1 year ago
this is better then the one from the game,keep up the good work :)
elykg93 1 year ago
k so ur a singer, anime fanatic and an online gamer~? oh gawd ur great xD im loving ur songs so far, such a soft voice~
snowe8 1 year ago
Silvana's fighting a battle to win they could not. Although she knew that she could not win, it has continued to fight for family and people. And now she is working on a poison that kills both human and undead to take revenge on the other alliance she and her people left in the engraving and the Arthas she tied forever to the earth
Dreanorei 1 year ago 11
And i always thought the original artist was the best.. I was wrong.. Cosidering you playing the instruments you are much beyond her. I raise my hat, although i have none at the current moment, to you! Keep it up!
Kocke95 1 year ago 51
@Kocke95 Thank you! :O
katethegreat19 1 year ago
You had me at "violin"
ChadAutry 1 year ago 6
@ChadAutry xD thanks! I need to use it in my music more often ^^
katethegreat19 1 year ago
@ChadAutry I know right? My thoughts exactly.
Thecatoflostwords 1 year ago
quality :)
shathriel 1 year ago
you did a good job on this song, like you said you don't sound like sylvanas does, but you did a good job :) *btw i got the music box finally from icc25 heroic !!! *shadowmourn final quest rewards*. made me happy.
SanosukeSagara09 1 year ago
would you happen to know the key of the song or pitch you start on?
Voidrend 1 year ago
@Voidrend There are so many accidentals in the song it is hard for me to discover the "true" key, but it starts in E natural-minor with some B flats thrown into the harmony for that "special dissonance" I start my melody on an E.
katethegreat19 1 year ago
@katethegreat19 Kate, I am seduced by this singing that Blood Elfs are real!
darkwarrior303 1 year ago
sounds fantastic, thank you for posting!
molecular74 1 year ago
Dude! I just got chills. You and all that you do are so great.
MarthofGermania 1 year ago
People in previous comments have said the song lacks the same emotion as the Gunn version. I disagree with that notion. It's all about the perspective and interpretations of the singer who I believe did a great service to this piece.
From what I've read on wowwiki the original was of Kaldorei origin lamenting the losses during the War of the Ancients. Therefore when I hear you sing it, I think of a younger Sylvanas reflecting on her people's past, rather than the Banshee Queen we have today.
StellusBattersea 1 year ago
@TheSolx Thankyou! *o* Oh, I'm from the USA ^^
katethegreat19 1 year ago
After all you've put me through, woman, the last thing I'll give you is the peace of death.
Commandos12 1 year ago
Your voice is so Serene! It's so beautiful. I've never heard such a beautiful voice! I'm a singer myself and soon when I can I'll be putting some of my stuff on.
doodleM0nster1 1 year ago
This is soooo pretty! You sound amazing.
keybladewizard49 1 year ago
You did great an amazing cover of this song. And I get a true rpg feel from the video arrangement, as if you were seeing the pride of civilization rising and falling. Truly a lament of the highborne.
JaceBelerin 1 year ago
BLOOD ELF FOR LIFEEEEE
Nerdydork666 1 year ago 2
Amazing. very well done. I am just wondering if some of the pictures are hand drawn because it looks like some of them are.
Ancientsleeper 1 year ago
I read your side note, and I'm gonna be straight up with you... You have no idea what your voice is capable of. This is by far the best version of this song I have ever heard. You have a rare and beautiful voice that I could listen to till my dying breath. One could easily fall in love with a woman with a voice like yours.I personally think you did justice to the song just fine.
I look forward to hearing more... Very well done.
runeskyr85 1 year ago
wow...JUST WOW....Great singing, as with your other songs. A beautiful peice of art! (I wish the gaming community had more pationate females!
miningchild 1 year ago
i began to lisiting to the violin to morethen the song but its just becasue i kinda didnt undertsand it ^^ but amiazing any way :3
ngh1814 1 year ago
Leider lagen einige Töne daneben, aber die Stimme ist schön. Danke fürs hochladen.
charmnessa 1 year ago
It's been a while since I heard your version of this song. I still find it very good.
thekatana09 1 year ago
I think you sung amazingly! Most of us can't carry a tune in a bucket. It was a great cover! And I think the fact that you play so many various instruments so well more than "makes up" for the differences between you and the original singer.
eineminutenbitte 1 year ago
this is beautiful... i am totally speechless at how lovely you sang this song :')
WNxDroid 1 year ago
much better than the original! :) 24 ppl were distracted by your beautiful singing and missed the 'like' button.
gagaspearscyrus147 1 year ago
Your voice is SOO amazingly beautiful! i LOVE it! Amazing job!
Ghhost2 1 year ago
Omg that jus Beautifull!!!!
Omg i can die happy now XD
I loved the original but i love this even more plz countinue to sing!!!
Sing like the wind!!
NekoKitsu 1 year ago
Just wanted to drop by and say this cover is amazing! I just watched the Quel'Delar movie by Melvenor, and offer my praise for such a beautiful cover, better than anything I could do with the song. Keep it up!
sopranophantomista 1 year ago
this was well done. I haven't heard the actual singer but you did a lot better than I could ever hope to do! Violen is beautiful. Such a sad sounding song.
Cidean 1 year ago
I listen to this repeatedly while I'm playing WoW... Even when I'm not playing, actually. It's... no words can describe how beautiful this is. ^.^ I started listening to this song a few months before, and recently I've watched more of your videos ^.^ I'm in love with every one of them! I <3 you Kate! =]
Anastasia27May 1 year ago
I could listen to the violin all day. On the second half I end up listening to it more than the singing. The singing is amazing, too. o: If you could put up some covers of songs on your violin solo I bet it'd be amazing too!
Sian0410 1 year ago 2
@Sian0410 thankyou! I should feature my violin more O.O It's my main instrument!
katethegreat19 1 year ago
@katethegreat19 I think there´s some elven blood in you ;) really in love with your remakes of songs!
BumfuzzledZeb 1 year ago
Superbe, genial !
AnkasDemons 1 year ago
wau que pasada la te quedo genial :D
ladyrikku123 1 year ago
I have to agree with you on one thing; you don't put the same type of emotion into it that Sylvannas did. Slyvannas sung it with a sad, emotional passion and I think that's what really won the song for me. However, your composition and voice are lovely.
Hikari2Yami 1 year ago
@Hikari2Yami I sung with all the emotion I could muster, but in the end it comes down to skill, which I have much less of than Vangie Gunn. I've seen this sort of comment a lot, which is why I put a disclaimer of sorts in the description.
Thankyou for listening through this though.
katethegreat19 1 year ago
@Hikari2Yami I would have to respectfully disagree with you on the "emotional passion" put into this cover version of the song. I felt the seemingly emotional sadness from this song. For me, it felt like it was sadness from a different person, which is actually the case since this artist is different from the original.
redhorizon2012 1 year ago
I like this version better. Your voice is pettier. Also this has a much more haunting feel to it.
cobaltslayer 1 year ago
I wish i could sing that good :< Lol very VERY good job :D Keep it up
catr0156 1 year ago
In your description, you tended to lie a bit. You said that this doesn't do the song any justice and that you said it wasn't that great. I've done the whole quest line in the game of World of Warcraft for them to actually play this song, really it isn't that long though <.<, and had them play it in Undercity. How you've done it is quite amazing, and if I understand it properly, you did this entirely by yourself. It is really amazing, and you should be proud of yourself for this.
chaosvincentvalentin 1 year ago 3
OMG!!!
Your voice is lovely!!! Now I know how to picture my Half -Elf sounding when she sings this song. ^.^
:3
angelgirl148 1 year ago
You have a beautiful voice. I heard your version a long time ago and was just browsing youtube to find this video again because I liked it so much.
Helljumper91 1 year ago 20
@Helljumper91 aww thankyou!! I appreciate that you wanted to hear it again!
katethegreat19 1 year ago
okay..... this is epic in my opinion, and I don't even play WoW (I've played Warcraft 2 and 3, and have listened to the official blizzard endorsed video).
All in all, very good job!!!!!!
DarthDeslauriers 1 year ago
@DarthDeslauriers you're a Warcraft veteran! ^0^ Thankyou so much!
katethegreat19 1 year ago
This was done quite well if you ask me. :3
killseeker24 1 year ago
For Sylvannas!
Ins0mnia365 1 year ago
Angel voice! You are a profesionist singer?
MbLancer1 1 year ago
I think this is great, I just think you should hold some the notes out longer - let them ring!
bowstodeer 1 year ago
Well i can just say that this piece ist awesome in its own way...not worse not better than the official blizzard version...it just has its own special sound in a good good way.
keep up your work because you know what youre doing ;)
thenameisalreadyused 1 year ago
@thenameisalreadyused thankyou so much!
katethegreat19 1 year ago