a person that sings with love and passion, this is singing... skilled and full of emotions. Totally guided me into her song!!! This by far the best version of this song.
she has got the whole package, pretty and got a great voice, even better than yang zhong wei. this competition is no longer exciting without her, i predict that the winner will probably be yuming... haiz... i rooted for her so much...
so sad that she faced alisa and got eliminated. i think she will be the most successful participant, at least i will buy her disc if she is going to have one.
Once again English song wins and Chinese song loose. Judge 'Zhan Yi' said emotion is more importance than performance in M'sian 'Lim's PK with 'Peici' in the show on 23th nov 2007 but how come here is difference????
Because judges have no wonder to Liang's talent. For her, how to control her feelings and multiply performance style are her challenge now. Judges all agree she control this song well, me too.
If 'Liang Wen Ying' use this song's performance to PK with Alisa, who will win? high quality, touch emotion and difference judges, who is your winner???? what is your opinion ????
Because judges have no wonder to Liang's talent. For her, how to control feelings and multiply her styles are her chanllenge now. Judges all agree that she control this song well, me too.
This is by far her best so far in the competition. She always performs well, but there was too much 'performance'. This one is different, there is something very personal and touching beside an excellent performance. The place where the judges felt she almost lost control actually makes it so much more convincing. Almost perfect, just like one of the judge said.
i can't help but listen to this over and over again. there is true feeling when she sings. i can hear her pain and suffering through her voice even if it might be just a little of what she went through.
i personally don't think it's just her trying to get higher points by having the judges to pity her. if people listen to her sing other songs, they would know.
yup...The first song I heard from this contest is "Hai Shang Hua" sing by Leong..a really touching song ...and is why I like to watch this contest since then...Today, I hear again a tocuhing song ag
一地鸡皮
claudia1201 2 weeks ago
聽了很多次文音不同場合唱的"流浪記"
每次都被感動到
真的很棒
changchaokuan 2 months ago 2
文音 had a very sad childhood..But Im sure she will have a GREAT life ahead (: Jiayou to her!!! She's the bestt!!!:DD
coolgurlx97 7 months ago
真的好聽!
40145009 7 months ago
我覺得第一次的散得像沙 那四字唱得最好聽
himalayabest 7 months ago 5
看過真情布落格上的文音、就可以體會唱的心情
victorcclin 8 months ago
哭了
TheLeonSilver 1 year ago 2
我覺得林志炫很自以為是
f128102 1 year ago 21
@f128102 说得好!同感!
TheLeonSilver 1 year ago
@f128102
聽說
沒能力的人叫自大
有能力的人叫自信
我覺得他是自信
他夠專業 你呢?
unique19860409 7 months ago 2
@f128102
我倒覺得你很自以為是~
fure0502 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
看了N次了!但又很不争气地哭了!梁文音~~~~!为什么每次都弄我哭!!
playplay89 1 year ago
看了N次了!但又很不争气地哭了!梁文音~~~~!为什么每次都弄我哭!!
playplay89 1 year ago 5
我好感动 听文音唱歌好感动
miumiuniu 1 year ago 4
獻給陪我渡過彩色生活的朋友們~~~
brother247823 1 year ago
慘了!!! 眼淚潰堤,淚奔~~
hopefully426 1 year ago
梁文音样子很耐看!
是天生吃这行饭的。
人面兽心,她形容得非常好。
现实上的人就是这样。(".)
muanmuancally 1 year ago 8
懷念這時的文音~~討厭她唱魚的時候
beck520520 1 year ago 2
@beck520520 唱鱼?是什么?
muanmuancally 1 year ago
@beck520520
忘記那次魚吧...相信文音第三張專輯會給我們驚喜
leongtracy 1 year ago 3
好感人的文音
She is great
I love her voise
我的專輯都是她的
可惜只有2張
太太太好了!
f2546806y 1 year ago
@f2546806y 沒關係 未來還會有N張
iammonkeychi 1 year ago 4
好感人
f2546806y 1 year ago
超感動的!!!眼淚狂飆!!
每當離鄉背景時
聽梁文音唱這首歌!!每一次都泛淚
聽的出來梁文音想要表達出的情緒
感情濃郁!!~實在是很療傷
希望梁文音能夠大紅大紫
永遠支持你的粉絲!!
小黑=ˇ=一起支持梁文音
讚阿!!!!實力派歌手→梁文音
b0492941473 1 year ago
哭慘了
感覺他身上藏了很多故事
外表看似溫和內心卻蘊藏著令人疼惜的堅強
Sunmoonben 1 year ago 6
哭了.
faifai1204 1 year ago 2
听得~好难过~
好想跟梁文音作朋友~ =’(
muanmuancally 1 year ago 2
我也是從部落來的原住民-太魯閣族.每次聽這首有很多的感觸和感動.每一次都會掉淚.因為那種無奈真的說不上來.雖然遠離了家鄉.也不會再回去.但是我依然告訴自己我永遠是那個單純又純樸的原住民勇士!加油哦!
bawan521 1 year ago 11
雞皮疙瘩..
tifffee 1 year ago 4
挖 眼匡泛淚
ming761125 1 year ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
@shinglai
對我認同你的說法~她內心超出她的年齡~離鄉背井的感覺如同現在的我~說那些話的人我想一定沒有也沒甚麼機會來體驗~沒辦法就是井底之蛙~
amy22811 1 year ago
很感動
KittyRed1987 1 year ago 4
梁文音參賽以來一路上感動了我好幾回 加油
aaahiwin 1 year ago 20
感動 ...
KIT7732KIT 1 year ago 8
什么是 duy uma??
waterapple 1 year ago
拼音是puyuma
是台灣原住民卑南族的意思
放在歌詞裡大概是指過去的單純和鄉愁吧
bohemian1989 1 year ago 8
一聽到「如果」,心頭的淚水湧了出來,真感動!
wylsonhk 2 years ago 16
這首歌真的唱得很sad...
AI913 2 years ago 9
感人。
我同意林志炫说的唱歌的最高境界,她这一首有达到/
Marthelda 2 years ago 28
3:15...我掉眼淚啦...後面的配樂除了鋼琴外那是口琴嗎?聽起來就很淒涼
takaoila 2 years ago 15
這個完全表演出live 跟錄出來的分別,
因為唱live 就是會有這個感情的分別
比錄出來的感情是活生生那麼多~
bennyhideto0502 2 years ago 34
very touching!
good performance!!
vnie86 2 years ago 9
聽了真的很想放聲大哭 真的感動到不行
aaahiwin 2 years ago 30
Great voice...=)
4infebruary 2 years ago 19
一个字(好)
The0000000000123 2 years ago 19
我聽到起雞皮疙瘩了...好感動...
kItYee93 2 years ago 41
我哭了。 很感動。
aquariusmint 2 years ago 97
我十分欣賞文音那麼堅強!!!
aesopp99319 2 years ago 23
This has been flagged as spam show
我不是很同意林志炫老师说法,这首歌有些部分还是需要多一点点感情!不过梁文音场给自己听,以这个角度做得很好
huhq1 2 years ago
真的真的很感動呀!希望文音姊妹能唱更多動人的歌!
stephenlam71 2 years ago 31
聽了真的想流眼淚...感動....超好聽.....
fai198211 2 years ago 36
堪稱經典
nrfmjtvcxz50 2 years ago 42
感动ing!
evinn94 2 years ago 29
This has been flagged as spam show
You know why all of us mark your comments as "poor comment"?
Its because we know much about her
You don 't know anyrhing ...
Plus, i have watch this video upteens time but i din 't feel bored at all...
You know why?
SIMPLE!
Because her voice had touch us....
johboy2418 2 years ago 26
This has been flagged as spam show
唱的真難聽....
她以為唱歌
就是要唱的愈用力 愈誇張愈好
哭腔愈重才叫做有感情
其實根本就是搞錯了
最不可思議的是林志炫的不專業講評
tea550 3 years ago
suck a dick mother fucker, i dun think u can sing better than her anyway, so keep ur mouth shut
sataychicken12345 2 years ago 4
可惜的是這裡只有你不喜歡 , 可能你是與眾不同吧 ~ 你是火星人嗎 ?
shinglai 2 years ago 3
好感動耶
on9123456 3 years ago 25
另外...樂隊老師的改編跟演奏同樣不能忽略...
kit369632 3 years ago 16
Yes, I am with 張宇, think about your audiences first.
cyhjason 3 years ago 6
太完美了
真的很喜歡文音阿...
hiya78325 3 years ago 17
好感動耶.
rammie521 3 years ago 17
真的!!
dueduedd 3 years ago
文音唱這首真的很打動人心 很堅強的女孩!
Charlehurst 3 years ago 14
白木的人常說文音哭一哭騙分數 , 請看看畫面有幾多人被文音的歌聲感染到吧 ~ 說騙分數 ? 有誰可以一邊唱歌一邊又要記住歌詞 , 又要唱得好 , 最後再把自己弄哭騙分 ? 請問有誰可以示範結我看 ? 做得到的話我就相信文音是騙分的 ~
shinglai 3 years ago 294
@shinglai
對我認同你的說法~她內心超出她的年齡~離鄉背井的感覺如同現在的我~說那些話的人我想一定沒有也沒甚麼機會來體驗~沒辦法就是井底之蛙~
amy22811 1 year ago 6
This has been flagged as spam show
評審說的很廢話XDDD
hardstar54 3 years ago
you're mean, it's all for her good, so shut up.
HyperStella17 3 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
你在說誰?
kit369632 3 years ago
文音這首歌 live 演繹得比 cd 板好聽得多 ,
就是多了那濃厚的感情
shinglai 3 years ago 26
This has been flagged as spam show
我覺得她只是好聽~但巴奈唱到心坎裡...
ccface21 3 years ago
很感人的演繹,勝過 studio 制作的標準作品
bihanm 3 years ago 16
好好聽哦~~0_0
我毛孔都開了~~
pigkJJ 3 years ago 26
真的很棒!
dominic921102 3 years ago 20
I like her hair.
perfectshiningstar 3 years ago 11
唱歌有感情 不論任何歌 都聽的出來有放感情..喜歡聽他唱歌 可惜他不是第2屆冠軍..那時候以為他一定是第一名勒 居然是那個會唱歌但是就只是會唱歌的人第一名= =
tsunglin0726 3 years ago 26
我太喜欢她了,不管她唱什么歌都很感动。加油。。。。。
ochow888 3 years ago 35
"如果"(鸡皮疙瘩)...
"怎样"(鸡皮疙瘩)...
太好听了!!
kuanyang 3 years ago 27
他真的很棒!!^^
ling0307 3 years ago 10
good sound ,nice person.....lovely soud~great....i like it very much...虽然文音没有拿第一,但是在我心中她永远最棒~~
yukikotyf 3 years ago 36
好令人感动! 好棒!
ToServeLord 3 years ago 9
我也覺得簡鳳君不錯耶 低音穩定 高音不尖
而且唱歌超有感情 不是那種庸俗的聲音
是一位很好的選手 可惜自信差一點點 要加油!
星光3的評審也看好她啊!
mandy92510 3 years ago 16
第二屆是實力最平均的!
yuchiehlin22 3 years ago 17
簡鳳君不錯阿
jeon83807 3 years ago 7
太好聽了,怎麼會這樣。
isitasibar 3 years ago 14
都哭了我
yyeeddaa 3 years ago 9
super touching!..
i love this song n i love her!
she's great!
145938 3 years ago 17
This song is really touching....
sabalala 3 years ago 11
第三屆我覺得蠻好的只有
林芯儀 徐佳瑩 黃靖倫 黎楚寧...
不像第二屆跟第一屆...
longlongkin 3 years ago
不過我覺得簡鳳君的聲音是三屆以來唯一我第一次聽到就驚艷的
jeffrey21735 3 years ago 14
touching...
pinkymulu 3 years ago 17
好好啊!!!! shes awesome, no doubts
Annie1314168 3 years ago 12
i love this song... it's amazing. and it truly explains how much she's been through.
Even though i don't know what it feels like to be like her, but i could actually feel that insecurity when she sang the song!
She's my favorite singer in this competition, i will sure buy her cd when she has one!!
mishymt 3 years ago 14
真的 都還會找第二屆的歌回來聽 若以第一第二屆的標準來看 第三屆可能現在只剩不到五位吧....
pause0110 3 years ago 15
i want cry when she sing this song,so touch
love meizhen n her
scorpio1116 3 years ago 12
good good goodx100000000000
helluniv 3 years ago 6
a person that sings with love and passion, this is singing... skilled and full of emotions. Totally guided me into her song!!! This by far the best version of this song.
alexchan338 3 years ago 22
唉 第三屆濫到不行
還是聽第二屆第一屆強
hugoootsai 3 years ago 16
第一屆強弱差還蠻多的阿除了前幾強其他沒什麼特色,第二屆就各有特色,我不覺得第三屆爛到不行,也是有好幾個很出色的人,坦白說第一屆除了楊宗瑋林宥嘉其他人應該過不久就看不到了,只是因為是第一屆給人印象太深刻的關係造成好像第一屆都很強的錯覺。
jeffrey21735 3 years ago 11
This has been flagged as spam show
對對對
第一屆真的只有楊林兩人強
第二屆我覺得前八強都蠻厲害的
第三屆4朵花都蠻厲害的
所以第一屆最爛
gain007004 3 years ago
也沒有到第一屆最爛的地步啦= =
yyeeddaa 3 years ago 3
oh come on...but 第一屆 has more classic moments than the rest combine together
esp the PKs
avdonzzz 3 years ago 7
This has been flagged as spam show
节目的可信度一屆比一屆低。
reginelim99 3 years ago
很棒啊~~~~
ZongLim 3 years ago 17
This has been flagged as spam show
不行不行....还是不行...没我家小昀好....恩恩....
那高音哦....哎哟哟...
lij1990 3 years ago
very good
q123q29 3 years ago 13
唉!第三屆爛到沒力看
只有聽聽她的歌懷念她的歌聲
vicky114608 4 years ago 43
今天再聽一次
這首真是唱的好
她輕快的歌也唱的好
這種歌也唱的好
不錯這個女歌手有前途
ellise1973 4 years ago 45
這首又是一首傑作
我真懷疑這小女生到底唱了多少首好歌
她只有二十歲
前途真是不可限量
ellise1973 4 years ago 130
flawless. excellent performance.
happybirdsday 4 years ago 29
這是屬於她的歌
heifetzso 4 years ago 39
這節目剩下的歌手中,梁文音的天賦是最好的。
她的形象也慢慢出現了,一個有著不幸過去的獨立少女,懷著無法忘記的悲傷記憶,但少女畢竟是少女,也會有著戀愛撒嬌與對未來幸福的期待,所以她唱有這兩種歌時都很容易讓人出現聯想畫面。
jhu022 4 years ago 59
Amazing!If u listen to it over+over,u will tell the power is growing...
ziashow 4 years ago 8
heard over n over again..so touching,hope she can win the competition..all the best
koroma15 4 years ago 14
真正的天后-即將誕生.皇天保庇.
alinyang2 4 years ago 29
台北的印象就像是文音帶來的這首歌最好的感想
Simon01148 4 years ago 25
張宇常常擺明偏袒美珍
one of us 真的沒有比流浪記好
morrisgordon 4 years ago 31
This has been flagged as spam show
我到覺得有時小胖太偏袒文音
而且張宇從來都沒有給過黃美珍滿分
sliu7 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
她唱得不值滿分當然不給滿分啦~~
heifetzso 3 years ago
說ㄉ好
ss32113 3 years ago 5
I'm so touched. She is one of the best femal singer in Tainwan.
ez4154 4 years ago 9
i hope that they will offer her a contract even though she didnt make it into the last few...
DANGersome 4 years ago 3
same here, i love her voice...she sing so good
mi036 4 years ago 7
she has got the whole package, pretty and got a great voice, even better than yang zhong wei. this competition is no longer exciting without her, i predict that the winner will probably be yuming... haiz... i rooted for her so much...
DANGersome 4 years ago 6
so sad that she faced alisa and got eliminated. i think she will be the most successful participant, at least i will buy her disc if she is going to have one.
DANGersome 4 years ago 4
one of my favourite song sang by her~ she is good. =)
blueymiao 4 years ago 4
Once again English song wins and Chinese song loose. Judge 'Zhan Yi' said emotion is more importance than performance in M'sian 'Lim's PK with 'Peici' in the show on 23th nov 2007 but how come here is difference????
tonyltm 4 years ago 5
Because judges have no wonder to Liang's talent. For her, how to control her feelings and multiply performance style are her challenge now. Judges all agree she control this song well, me too.
suu3616 4 years ago 10
If 'Liang Wen Ying' use this song's performance to PK with Alisa, who will win? high quality, touch emotion and difference judges, who is your winner???? what is your opinion ????
tonyltm 4 years ago 5
wei yin of course! this is what wen yin does best :D
eycatch 4 years ago 3
but wen ying scored 23 for this while alisa scored 25. alisa will stil win :(
jaetpy 4 years ago
Because judges have no wonder to Liang's talent. For her, how to control feelings and multiply her styles are her chanllenge now. Judges all agree that she control this song well, me too.
suu3616 4 years ago 4
這是我看星光大道第一季至今,唯一一首讓我落淚的演唱......
steve32978 4 years ago 17
wow. she's good. really good. thanks!
yayableu 4 years ago 8
很難不愛她...
cstsxl 4 years ago 13
同意...
josh17767 4 years ago 7
so touching!!!
hell1089 4 years ago 10
我是在康熙来了听到她唱偏心后才开始看这节目的,发现她每场比赛都能有高水准的表现,说实话,她的唱功比市场上很多所谓的歌手都来得好,真的很有实力。比赛里她唱的每首歌我几乎都听3遍以上,没办法,真的太动听
fannykok 4 years ago 15
Gitar or not, it doesn't matter any more. One can feel her heart at all times.
damaeimi 4 years ago 5
this is the most touching performance of this season so far...
sansan4ever 4 years ago 12
She really devotes a lot of emotions to this song ~~
Hope that she can go on ~~~
Victor3579 4 years ago 10
wow, she's so nice looking
verycoldice2 4 years ago 3
This is by far her best so far in the competition. She always performs well, but there was too much 'performance'. This one is different, there is something very personal and touching beside an excellent performance. The place where the judges felt she almost lost control actually makes it so much more convincing. Almost perfect, just like one of the judge said.
rj10204 4 years ago 3
awesome...
cmong260427 4 years ago 3
to rzimb..
你懂得屁啦
yaolee503 4 years ago 3
感動哩~ U are NO.1
rayman0422 4 years ago 2
吉他根本就該是她的
是這次的第一名才對!!
camellia1111 4 years ago 13
i can't help but listen to this over and over again. there is true feeling when she sings. i can hear her pain and suffering through her voice even if it might be just a little of what she went through.
zzz3210 4 years ago 11
唱的真感人。
好聽!
roger3793 4 years ago 9
by the way, my comment is to rzimb....find something better to do than just hurting peoples' feelings w/ ur cruel words
golfgolftee 4 years ago 2
to zimb
她唱這首歌時那有提到自己的身世
你才賤咧...靠
swerwesd 4 years ago
他真的很厲害
johnson80005 4 years ago 5
lov her so much ..
aNXie1y 4 years ago 5
She is definitely a talented and natural singer...Go Balen! You're the best!
golfgolftee 4 years ago 5
I cried..
cyquanquan 4 years ago 2
這是她第一次唱歌能感動到我的.
manmoon001 4 years ago 9
看看 1:42 秒, 第 4 句「不要害怕」的「怕」, 這出現了一個人情緒失控時才出現的抖音. 就是因為聽到這個音, 評審們個個都說很擔心好會在早段就崩潰了. (如果你沒仔細聽, 那重播一次吧) ^^
hkchess2000 4 years ago
i personally don't think it's just her trying to get higher points by having the judges to pity her. if people listen to her sing other songs, they would know.
zzz3210 4 years ago 6
she's the best among all..love her very much...^^
celestelys 4 years ago 7
she is amazing!!
but what does "puy uam" mean?
forever789rain 4 years ago 5
Puy Uma 好像是指卑南族
hkchess2000 4 years ago
你真厲害 我住台灣都不曉得
剛剛去查維基 知道了!
VincentMLE 4 years ago 4
puyuma means home town
jovotw 4 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
梁文音所欠缺的不是声音以及技巧层面的技术问题,而是怎样的用一个真实的简单的梁文音去诠释歌曲。要不然即使你拿到了100万,也只是拿到了一个暂时名利而已。
vintersummer 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
唱的确实不错,而且有感动到心的深处,但是接下来呢?所有的歌不都是为了你以及你的经历所写的。唱歌,像是李宗盛所说的,你首先要爱它,而且学会怎么爱它。因此 唱歌单纯,简单更好,不要想那么多歌唱以外的东西,比如分数,名次,人气。。。。
vintersummer 4 years ago
獨立生活的人很早就要學會演戲,很不容易突破心防,把自己陰鬱脆弱的一面呈現出來,這首歌不適合用力唱,情感的出口表達得很好。
抒情歌不是每首情緒都像火山爆發,希望聽到梁文音更多元的情緒表達。而人生也不盡然時刻都是悲傷,也偶有釋然微笑或是忘懷大笑的時候,也許也能有另一種歌聲來與我們分享。期待~
jhu022 4 years ago 4
其實她唱了很多"另一種歌聲"
但是我覺得她唱悲傷的歌特別動聽!!
cj122430 4 years ago 7
說真的。。她感動了我。。
我發現到文音的唱法有楊宗偉的爆發點
感動到人們的心。。
pinkpinkdepink 4 years ago 16
這絕對是這場比賽中最值得聰的一首歌, 這已經不是技巧的問題, 而是聽到讓人很有畫面, 這是她巴冷公主的悲歌. 讚!!!
hkchess2000 4 years ago
yup...The first song I heard from this contest is "Hai Shang Hua" sing by Leong..a really touching song ...and is why I like to watch this contest since then...Today, I hear again a tocuhing song ag
y2klaw 4 years ago 7
This has been flagged as spam show
拜托, 一直拿他的身世来博同情。
rzimb 4 years ago
她唱這首歌時那有說她的身世
她說這首歌是在說一個出外打拚的原住民的故事
你才是最機車咧...操
swerwesd 4 years ago
to rzimb
她唱這首歌那有提到她的身世
靠...你嘴巴真賤
swerwesd 4 years ago 5