Added: 3 years ago
From: 56258870
Views: 343,452
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (296)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • She is from Sichuan of China.

    Not from Tibet of China.

  • 这歌歌词好傻啊,和心战一样,把歌毁了啊

  • @BeitingCheng09 我觉得词非常好啊。引用苏轼的词,《三国演义》的词,很有古典味­道

  • to all the uneducated political freaks: alan is from Sichuan Province. She is a member of the Tibetan ethnic group but she is 100% Chinese. If u don't like it, then don't listen to her song, close the window and go spill your trash comments somewhere else. If you have doubts, do some research. If u like her simply because you THINK she's not Chinese, then shut up and stop taking the pleasure of listening to a nice song away from other youtube users because we all know ur not here for the music.

  • 川妹纸啊。。。

  • Comment removed

  • 念奴娇应该是豪放的,她唱的那么婉约。应该唱比较rock的曲子­。可以又中国风但又摇滚,像fir 一样。

  • @aggiesmoon

    把念奴娇唱成rock的? 你是沒按时吃葯吧

  • @aggiesmoon 唱的不婉约吧。可能你对婉约的定义不同

  • 词写得真好

  • 是我们云贵川来的妹子都要支持!

  • the most beautiful voice in the world..... alan

  • creo que salio en el 2008, en argentina yo la vi el año pasado por primera vez, tengo una duda ¿red cliff es la traducción de chi bi? yo conocia esta guerra como chi bi pero al ver esta pelicula me entro esta duda. Muy buena la canción me gusta mucho escucharla tiene muy linda voz.

  • wasn't red cliff released in the U.S. sometime ago? :O

  • 好卡呀!

  • She's not Chinese. She is Tibetan.

  • @H770907

    tu es vraiment un idiot !

    Alan est née à la province du Sichuan, mais pas le Tibet.

  • @H770907

    Tbetans are Chinese, you SOB!

  • @H770907 She's half and half

  • @H770907 proof?

  • @H770907 Chinese is not a race its a nationality.

  • 此曲應是千古滄桑, 不堪回首

    找錯人唱了

  • @bladevincent

    You are an egghead! She is wonderful in this song!

  • @david1234lee

    詞曲有滄桑之感, 她的音色確實不適合

    你不應該這樣侮辱人

  • She's from Tibet

  • @FlyDragon911

    no, she's actually from Sichuan.... she's ethnically Tibethan, though.

  • 台灣第一名模+中國赴日歌手~都是大美人阿~~沒有什麼好比的~­

  • She's so beautiful! She has a lovely voice :D

  • 阿兰 加油

  • She is a Tibetan Chinese currently serving as a ranking officer in the Chinese army's non-combatant division. Smilar to her status but senior to her ranking are such famous artists as Tan jing and Sung Tz--ying.

  • @david1234lee, I don't know if what you said applied to guys also. So if you want to be a ranking officer, all you gotta do is to be a good singer. right???

  • @wingchunexpert

    Naturally, one has to be really good. Those singers have to win national contests, receive formal training and join the military forces where they climb the stairs. Sung Tzu-ying, the most famous singer and also the most popular, sang at New York's Carneige Hall, where she was addressed as a "royal" because she serves as a military general in China. Tan jing was also there; she is a navy colonel!

    China's military service is an honor now.

  • love Alan

  • The melody, singing and arrangement of this song are much better than Echoes Of The Rainbow. Do they have ears??

  • wow! she can sing in chinese too! cool!

  • @st1010 that's because she is chinese...

  • @botreepri she's japanese..

  • @euphoric5huffle proove it, she always tells others, she's Alan from China, so where is your proove to your point?

  • @euphoric5huffle 阿蘭(alan) is chinese

  • @euphoric5huffle shes not japnese..shes from china

  • @st1010 

  • @janatajay sb去死

  • @janatajay

    are u STUPID?!

  • Сучка китайская за мяукала

  • art is pure... the whole world is one.... there is no boundaries between countries, nor any difference between people really. We are all humans, all the countries are on Earth, why not just accept peace?

  • Hands down.  Perfect.

  • 小喬這角色應該不用林志玲..

    用阿蘭.達瓦卓瑪就可以了!!

  • @bhang0507 我覺得是各有各的美,同樣都有東方古典美人的婉約與優雅!!

  • 我的天, 應該要注意歌的, 不過0:52林志玲那回眸一笑實在太迷人了啊啊啊.

  • Beautiful !

  • she is so PRETTY!!!

  • She is an amazingly talented singer.... Truly a szechuan beauty.

  • 有的歌一聽就打動人, 但很快就會膩, 而有的歌初聽沒什麼感覺, 但越聽越有味, 此之為藝術之吸引所在.

  • 笑了...怎麼會像鬼叫?沒聽過藝術歌吧?沒聽過音樂劇吧?

    說實話,歌詞和歌曲旋律聽著是有點怪怪的(可能因為是日本作品!­?XD),但整體還是覺得很好聽,很有感染力,這就是功力了吧。

    漂亮的歌手滿街都是,不覺得這是亮點。。。當然alan是很漂亮­,也滿有氣質的^^

  • 那时的汉人,勇武豪迈,比宋朝时的腐儒强一万倍。

  • Comment removed

  • 一首完全没有意境的歌曲。除了阿兰漂亮一点,没有一定点的亮点

  • she is a great singer, like her songs and love her too.

    those talking politics in here fuck-off, in here we talk music and no hate, we only like peace and love and music, just like john lenon said, peace and love, no war!

  • woaaaa what is her name

    she is the most beautiful woman i saw in my life

    and her voice is the most beautiful voice i ever heard

  • @reemstrrr Alan Dawa Dolma is how her name is romanised from Tibetan. You can read a wikipedia article on her by searching her name.

  • @mrfriendlyguy  thx

  • why are there so many idiots who are obsessed with politics? don't fucking ruin the mood of the people who want to enjoy this song.

  • @jwzhu then why did u read it

  • 说实话 这首歌歌词和音乐意境完全不配

    实在是阿兰长得太漂亮了才让人可以忍受的...

    To be totally honest,lyrics doesn't go with the melody at all.

    If it's not the sooo beautiful mv, I couldn't possibly finish watching...

  • @ycy19888 why?

  • @abc9527abc

    i soooo agree with you....

  • @H770907 thank do you japanese you like alan Beautiful ^^

  • @abc9527abc

    你还不是一样```台湾连美女都没```都是猪```你妈是猪`­``你爸是猪```你也是猪``将来你肯定根猪日```所以你儿­子或是女儿都是猪``说白了你全家都是猪```你就住一猪岛上`­`

  • 正翻了 唱歌又超好聽~~~

  • 3:43 两人对视的场景让我联系到《唐伯虎点秋香》里 师爷和华安 对吻 的镜头 XD

  • Comment removed

  • @Kratos0909 are u saying chinese dont sound beautiful in normal speaking lolz

  • @86005537 are you gay? hmm.. must be

  • @Kratos0909 is the best u can come up with? that was irrelevant to my question. what a tard

  • Comment removed

  • @86005537 well, your comment was pretty gay, therefore that makes my comment completely relevant to your question. but obviously you are much too retarded to comprehend that. hmm.. now how ironic is that? haha.. Fag. 

  • @Kratos0909 maybe you should go search up what gay means, how can a comment be homosexually gay? being homosexually gay had no relevant what so ever with my first question of wether or not you think chinese language sounds beautiful in real life or not. 傻b

  • @86005537 hahaha you mad?

  • @Kratos0909 nah im not mad =] i just think your a retard datz all. was my chinese too hard for u to comprehend?

  • @Kratos0909 wow ur comment was flagged as spam, dont rage fag. i had enough talking to you, it was just a simple question on whether or not you think chinese language sounds good in real life. u such a troll and stop spamming tard

  • @86005537 haha someone's mad..

  • @Kratos0909 thats the only thing u can come up with? your mad? fukn wasting my time talking to u fukn troll.

  • @86005537 haha someone really needs a timeout :D

  • @Kratos0909 haha someones a retard =] and should go fuk himself

  • @86005537 I'm a retard? Haha.. that's funny coming from someone that can't even spell. Fag.

  • @Kratos0909 yes, you are a fukn tard n a homosexual gay faggot. your the one that cant even understand a simple question and gets all offensive. fukn troll.whats your point im not allowed to type in txt language? u got a problem wif that? faggot spamming the channel and deleting ur own comments.

  • @86005537 Haha there's a huge difference between typing in text language and in typing in retard language. Go back to school moron. Did I hurt your feelings that bad little faggot? And I never spammed this channel or deleted my own comments. Now you're just making shit up. Lol get back to bed you bitch.

  • @Kratos0909 wow keep dwelling on a single typo to make yourself feel smart. this is really going no where maybe you should stop changing the topic and answer one simple question in the start. im not going to waste my time going in circles with you. obviously you dont have the IQ to understand my question.

  • @86005537 that's cute.. coming from a legit retard/faggot

  • @Kratos0909 the words coming out of you make YOU dirty not the human to whom you are talking. didn't you know? surprise! =))))

  • @limpopo18 oh im very dirty indeed ;)

  • Comment removed

  • 阿兰比林志玲有气质,有才,还比她漂亮几百倍

    那里比不上那姓林的?

  • which film is it ???? pleaseeee !!!!

  • @kresnikblue Red Cliff

  • @kresnikblue -- red cliff

  • 總有人喜歡吱吱歪歪, 只想問一句, 你能代表阿蘭嗎? 憑什麼幫她決定想法, 這是一種暴力, 不是自由。

  • 支持阿蘭不做支那人 移民去日本

  • @jackyesyes2000

    有你這種台灣人真丟臉。

    臺灣人以前跟現在的中國人比也沒好到哪去ㄚ。

    經濟發展不同而已。

  • @s946163 你又知道我是台灣人 看到繁體字就是台灣人 看到駡支那人就是台灣人 你少自以為是 中國人

  • @jackyesyes2000 你又憑什麼以支那人來說中國,以後中國變成世界強權連日本都會向­他低頭的,你眼光如此似井底之蛙,將來你想說你是中華民族的一員­,我們才懶的鳥你呢。日本那嚜多電車癡漢,你很喜歡喔!?

  • @jackyesyes2000 我是中国人,看到你打中文是侮辱中文了。语法、词语不通!现在是­简体字,然後是繁體字。台灣,澳門,香港,作為一個中國人,我都­去過!在大陸上youtube是翻牆的。政府字這樣限制了,也沒­有辦法。但是翻牆過來只為聽聽歌。不要提起什麼種族的事。(打完­收工,唔使多讲耶~)

  • 阿蘭要解救同胞達賴~

  • @crakcer123  傻13,你觉得美国会把土地还给原住民吗,不然你觉得中国会放弃­台湾吗,就更不要提西藏了,达赖所谓的人权就是保护他们所谓的奴­隶主义。虽然GCD的确不怎么好,但至少比奴隶制度强吧。

  • @vampaireload

    美國也不會放棄台灣州

  • @crakcer123

    sb

  • @crakcer123 争论没用,我只想说,站在中国的立场,台湾只有两个将来,和平回­归,或者打成炮灰再重建.

  • sound track ....-dB

  • 江山代有人才出,各领风骚数百年

    阿兰美女一歌带过

  • 超好聽!! ^_^ I like it !

  • やっぱり母国語で歌った方がいいね、透明感があって癒される歌声­だ

    意味はわからんけどw

  • better than xin zan

  • u dunno china hv more how chicks? IS a facts since long time ago

  • 這首歌比日文版好聽得多

  • 这穿透力!

  • 惊为天人!

  • 比心戰好一點....

  • I think she is pretty but she is not 1000000 times prettier than lin zhi lin i think lin zhi lin is prettier coz lin zhi lin is natural beauty, and she is good at singing than lin zhi lin but not 1000000 times better.

  • I think she is pretty but she is not 1000000 times prettier than lin zhi lin i think lin zhi lin is prettier coz lin zhi lin is natural beauty, and she is good at singing than lin zhi lin but not 1000000 times better.

  • Comment removed

  • @fortpflanzor じつわさ、くおんのかわです。

  • @hanfresco yes you're absolutely right, i didn't know when i typed this comment

  • Yes, the Chinese version is far superior in delivering the original "soul flava" of the theme of the song.

    This girl Alan, sings in a unique Tibetan vocal technique called "Tibetan Wailing".

    That 's why she can stretch her notes so high and so long like gliding in the air.

  • 目前聽過最好的一首關於三國的歌曲, 曲詞編唱皆一流水準!

  • 散發出如此濃郁袓國味道的曲子 , 想布到居然是依個日本人寫的曲子 , 真是大開眼界!!

  • WoW i cant believe people are criticizing this film for its inaccuracy? although im not a fan of ancient war action movies, cause they fight so slow with their armor.. but this film is an inspiration and lets me know how awesome the novel could be.

  • what is this song's title in English?

  • @ANTWO909 "River of No Return"

  • 他的聲音真好聽:))))))))))))))))

  • Comment removed

  • 還有很多像我一樣的歌迷支持她,我們要做的是努力於自己的工作崗­位,我不認為阿蘭會理會這種評語。所以,真正喜歡阿蘭的歌迷們,­請無視及原諒那些無聊及可笑的評語吧。

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • 藝術無分國界

    她真的唱的很好

  • o she has a great voice

    movie was good... kinda out there i wouldnt call it great

  • 这那是人啊~~天上飞下来的仙女吧!!!!! 听她这声音一不留神以为进天堂啦!!!

  • 藏人,阿兰是藏族姑娘,但是她中国人,中国和藏人永远都是站在一­起的,你脑袋被崩了吧,你傻了吧。阿兰就是唱的好,不喜欢滚远点­,别借着阿兰,侮辱艺术。没文化

  • her voice is godlike =]

  • 每个人的口味不同,自然不能强求大家都喜欢她的歌。你也有理由不­喜欢,但是也请你自重顺便积点口德。这是对人起码的尊重也是让人­尊重你的前提。不喜欢完全可以说不喜欢没必要说人家唱得像鬼叫。­一句评论就可以看出你的素质

  • This is a good song. I got the movie, never had the chance to watch it tough. I should soon.

    Takeshi is so good looking. I could stare at him all day. And the singer is pretty.

  • Example if you are writing a composition and it required 500words and you only have 300 what will you do add rubbish? If there is no such things at most the movie length will be only like 60miniutes do you understand?? Failure. Your English seriously IS BAD! It seems like you won't be able to understand what I am trying to say .... ah looking forward to see your improvement in your English.

  • Ah, finally I have some free time to explain to this kid. Hey. you said one does not need to be a film maker to criticize a film, when did I said you need to be a film maker to criticize a film?? I said '' IF YOU WANT A FILM TO FOLLOW YOUR WAY THEN CREATE IT WTF? YOUR ENGLISH IS BAD!

  • shes like one of the most prettiest girls i've ever seen!!!!

  • Well that's your problem if you hate it why let us know? This is the song not the movie.

    Btw. Do you want to create a movie and stick to the history of it? You know how much money did they spent to create this money? The history is simple you know? Maximum 50miniute and boring. Who wants to spend money to watch this kind of film? Then how much will you earn?? No idea. So if you were the director you want to do this and waste your precious money? If not then don't say other people.Think ---Think

  • @awingwe funniest comment ever seen in a few years. when was the last time i laughed out so loud? thanks, you really made my day, lol. i guess your partly damaged brain couldn't allow your eyes to catch my comments on THE SONG, and the word "BTW", so i'm not gonna say anything like plz read before you respond.

  • @coleustone you said its neither true to the history or novel and you hate it. That means you like the film to follow the history?? or what ?? Funny.

  • @awingwe all right, so it seems that you really have some problems with reading comprehension. fine, i'll deconstruct a complex sentence into simple ones: it's neither following the history nor the novel ---> therefore, if one is either a fan of the history or of the novel, s/he will get pissed off. (i suppose you know in terms of 3 kingdoms period, fans of the history and fans of the novel can never stay together peacefully for a sec? except when discussing Red Cliff)

  • @awingwe i hate the film, b/c it's not following the history, or the novel, so i have no choice but try to appreciate and criticize it as a new derivative work -- however, compared to the novel & the history, Red Cliff only has a crappy and lame plot - it's not entertaining (well, it's sorta entertaining when you laugh how crappy it is), not touching, not informative, not anything. awful dialogues, unnecessary sex scenes, modern values ridiculously imposed on a history of wartime..SO BAD. Happy?

  • @awingwe MORE IMPORTANTLY, did i ever mention anything like "you have to strictly follow the history when making a film"?? are your half blind or is your graphics card too crappy to show texts in full length? my point was "either a fan of the history or the novel, you'll hate the film" - which is exactly what's going on now both in china and among the int'l audience. you should really go take a logic class. please argue like an adult who is not intelligently disabled!

  • @awingwe BTW, the film is lame and crappy even in the sense of commercial entertainment: stupid plot, awful dialogues, unnecessary sex scenes, love stories which do not make any sense, modern "PEACE & LOVE" values ridiculously imposed on a history of wartime...just to name a few. and YES I DO HAVE THE RIGHT TO CRITICIZE THE FILM, b/c it's a publicized commercial movie. if one's too fragile to read any negative comments, please hide your film from the public.