Ever Present Past(The Rooftops LIVE!)Paul McCartney

[djrtc1]

Kudos to you for playing a such a great latter day McCartney song! And you did a fine job to boot. How old were all you you when y0u did this?

[patriagada]

JAJAJA JAPONESES CULIAOS JAJA

[Denthedragon]

The title of the video is very misleading.

[blossomsquirrel]

Yeh well it's not great, but at least by playing it they're acknowledging that McCartney wrote great songs long after the Beatles expired - which is more than a lot of people (who prefer to let nostalgic subjectivity rule their critical faculties) are prepared to do. Songs like 'Only Mama Knows', 'Waterfalls', 'At the Mercy', 'Driving Rain', and 'Distractions' are just a few that match anything he wrote in the 60's.

[SirDues]

the singer couldn't even hit the low notes

[TheLoscedros]

hahahaha.....well if you think so...i go to vomit an come back...

[jequx]

Hey, what's wrong with you Guys? It's unfair to compare their vocals with Paul, of course. But, if you love Macca, these Japanese or Chinese also love him dearly and who gives you right to condemn? I believe even Paul will love to see his songs played by all the people around the world though their sounds might be terrible or even probably the music is really bad. The most important thing is the soul and the love and Paul knows that.

Anyway,the music is quite good. Thanks for posting&sharing

[SethMacFarlane502]

WTF?

[bluegoateex]

very good!!:) still rockin'!

[psheno505]

you suck!

[funebrero1982]

buuuuuuu  buuuuuuuu buuuuuuuuuu buuuuu

[jimvo]

this is fucking terrible

[m25mig006]

vocals suck!

the rest is good

[Abby1983]

a great live performance

[nicomoon2]

estos chinos no entienden nada

[Halfstrom]

I agree, these chinese don´t get anything!!! Estos chinos no caza una, or something like that, my spanish is very poor

[estudioalonso]

my dog sing best !!!  terrible vocals

[KimCyunHi]

You're being too harsh. The vocals lack projection in the lower bits because it's too low for the singer's voice. He should have either transposed the song or rearranged that part a bit to suit his voice better.

[vivekiyer20]

Pretty good cover actually. I don't care what the others have stated, but I thought this was pretty well done. Nice job.

[suefab4]

I am glad of your comment.

[hayabusafmw]

Very good cover!! you are one of the first to do it!

if you speak cantonese , or chinese , japanese ??

I Tell you you are very great english speaker!

because i know how hard to pronounce can be for you guys!!

please make other!!!!:)

[KingOfTheAir]

Alright, I never post comments but I have to this time.

This is probably the single, most terrible cover of any song I have ever heard in my entire life. The entire band needs to shoot themselves in the foot and personally apologize to Paul McCartney for completely ruining such an amazing song. Shame on you Rooftops for this idiotic, pathetic, excuse for a performance.

[suefab4]

Thank you very much!!

[KingOfTheAir]

You're welcome! =D

[valerian9191]

@suefab4

ahaha what did you understand ?

[Trevornator]

Well I know what you mean but I think they did a pretty good job cause you got to remember, these people are just ordinary people and they are Japanese too so they probably don't have any idea what the lyrics mean. So they did a pretty good job from starting at 0% but yeah if that was actually Paul McCarntey singing like that, then it actually sucks.

[1446672]

suck.

[Thata2opa]

terrible, terrible vocals.

[Brazilady]

nice job!

[PaulMcCartneyFan]

Seriously WTF?!?! If that is what Paul McCartney sounds like, then Paul needs to put his Hofner down... Please stop doing Paul McCartney songs...

[thenoseymethod]

your trying so badly to sound like him that it just sounds...bad

[Kajagoogoo3]

I think it'll sound better if you sung louder.

[juand0989]

tiene ke praccticarl mas neta por ke solo asi es una mentada de madre,la rola es buena pero pracctikenla mas

[gualterseitz]

From Argentina: The band sounds great, but keep working in vocals..

[taka27185]

ジョージも最初の頃は？がつく演奏する

こともあったし、ポールもリードギター

で酷い失敗したこともあったらしい。

ボーカルの方、ボイトレ受ければ結構

大きく化けるような気もします。

メゲずに頑張れ！

[suefab4]

ありがとうございます。

そう言って頂けると気持ちも楽になりました。

世界の皆さんの有難いコメントを素直に受け止め、初心に返って頑­張ります！！

[suefab4]

しかしボロクソコメばっかやな。

確かに自分で聴いても酷いわ（笑）

いい勉強になります。

いつか必ずリベンジさせていただきます！！

[Guitar4Life2007]

wow 3 minutes of my life ill never get back.. that sucked.

[sgtbeatles4]

the voice is horrible.

[roguejedi420]

If you say these guys play good you must have no ears!!!!!!!!!! These guys are the definition of sucking!!!!!!!Give it up!

[MaximeeK]

Catastrophe

[fnphoto]

Good song, but the band will be better with practice.....

[muchomuypaul]

a cat sings better

[PromoCalaita2007]

huhu die japsen kommen

[mesho4show]

where are these guys from?

they play good

[wings4ever]

hey great song