阿B寸新人唔識唱歌

[bbriansiu]

佢自己都唱得唔好聽..

[horlickdrink]

@bbriansiu 捧捧堂最好聽喇係咪? 

[bbriansiu]

@horlickdrink  同你講都徙氣, 你個世界係唔係得阿B同棒棒堂呀..如果係咁棒棒堂最好聽囉..­.

[horlickdrink]

@bbriansiu 咁即係你承認捧捧堂好聽過鐘鎮濤

[bbriansiu]

@horlickdrink 傻仔..

[horlickdrink]

@bbriansiu 你話捧捧堂勁過威過好聽過鐘鎮濤 我講出你既諗法 話我傻仔 你係咪On撚鳩?

[iCeCrEaMpak]

@bbriansiu

你有冇聽過?

b哥起碼有實力. 好唔好聽太主觀

起碼佢真係見議d新人要練多d

[bbriansiu]

@iCeCrEaMpak  你既意見比較溫和, 不過你點Define實力先? 當然有聽過啦...

[TheFushuo]

有道理啊前輩～

[a782551321]

佢講得岩喎 到左現場聽d新手唱歌 先知-,- 咁9難聽

[papalsk]

其實唔關邊個係前輩邊個係後輩事既.... 身為歌手...就應該要唱得好 家陣唔係去k房玩唱歌仔...係響台上面表演受大家矚目 你話我呢d小朋友去k房唱歌就話姐~~你係一個歌手啊大佬 身為一個歌手...唔係話「無走音」就係勁....唔係話首歌難­唱所以唱到就係勁 歌手應該係要比平常人唱得好上幾倍先可以叫歌手,,,要諗下個「­歌」字點黎 如果唔係就啊豬啊狗都做到歌手啦...雖然家陣個樂壇真係成班豬­狗 唔認同我講野果d人...唔好講埋d「你咁勁...你去唱丫笨」­呢種低能發言 我唔係歌手~~我無需要響台上唱歌~~所以我唱得差我無需要付上­任何責任 但係我有耳仔~~我都會聽歌~~我有權去評論其他人唱歌~ 無人話一定要唱得好先可以評論其他人唱歌架喎???唔通啞既就唔­聽得歌唔評得歌？ 我地呢d都係以事論事...唱得唔好就係唔好~~我只係評論番班­「歌手」既表現 每個人有每個人既工作責任...做歌手就要唱好歌感動觀眾 做觀眾既~~欣賞歌之餘仲要提出意見同評論比歌手改善進步 我認為上述視頻裡面既校長同B都無錯~唔在於佢地係咪前輩 在於佢地耳仔感覺到d咩~~反正佢地講既係事實~

[babbyfaces]

ils reprennent le micro??? ils sont trop vieux non?? tam win lung he never stop???

[friensddogdog]

就算走音呀,都可以走得好聽!

係我心目中只得一個人可以做到!

[winghowwh]

@friensddogdog 邊個?

[friensddogdog]

@winghowwh 家駒 :)

[sumiji888]

好老师 我喜欢

[yuenj01]

most of the hong kong music is a joke. i mean, everyone can be a singer? don't need talent, look at tvb artists. they are actors, they started to sing?

[WSH74]

Spot on ... newer generations mostly rely on technology, they need more time before the experience kicks in. Alan + Kenny have a very strong point there!!! Even I can go create an album using technology and be tuned to sound like a super artist lol.

[SuperGazette]

林峯ed,5識唱歌,難聽到......

[ken6852]

講得好

[winghowwh]

雖則話B哥哥就唱歌都唔係好叻...佢話人說服力都唔係好高..­.但B哥哥真係未見過佢演唱會走音...未見過佢係大型表演節目­走音...相反而家既歌手...仆街啦你地-,-

我真係好撚懷念80,90年代...

聽下呀麟唱歌...啲歌唱到幾撚激昂 有冇走過音?? 人地一年一場演唱會 而家都成60歲,唱得重好過班後生!!

再聽下張學友... 仆街 佢啲高音高度咁撚樣 都未走過音....而家所謂班女歌手,唱果兩句,唱高音 走到ON9...屌你老尾

聽完80.90年代既歌手

聽返而家果啲...乜撚野的士陳 屌! 假音嘈撚到啪啪聲 難聽到嘔

乜撚野鄧麗欣 屌 仆街啦!!

不過當然有唔少都真係識唱歌 不過同80年代90年代果批比(除黎明) 都係差好遠

在個人感觀與角度上 2000後識唱歌 只有古仔 醫神 容祖兒 當然重有幾位,,,泳兒果D... 其餘唔該!!一概收皮!

[iamaveryuglyboy]

@winghowwh 冷靜d-_-"

[ttk200505]

@winghowwh 王宛芝都係實力派黎-v-"

[winghowwh]

@ttk200505 我話果d-,-王宛之當然係,,,,重有張敬軒果幾個嫁

[mickyiu822]

講得好！

[mika880829]

佢唔係串,係講事實!

[bonanza2331]

你估而家d 所謂歌星唔知道自己未夠班咩﹐佢地心照啦﹐衰就衰在有班偶像派迷­捧場﹐唱到走晒音都拍爛手掌﹐銀兩照樣奉上﹐重要邊個批評佢地既­偶象就鬧到你唔敢想像﹗唔好講話Kenny B 批評啦﹐就算叫林子祥或者鄧麗君番生批評﹐佢地一樣唔會接受。

[kkdance]

怒我直言, B哥哥唱歌都唔多好聽, 聲底太沙... (個人感受)

[grandymui]

@kkdance 佢聲底好沙...但佢係一個 excellent performer!

[Akaliko]

Agreed !

[20010813]

搞撚笑咩, 香港歌手幾時開始識唱歌架

對海台灣d 團全部都識唱和音, 香港d癈柴唱個定音都唔知識唔識唱.

[ppyyoonnii]

@20010813 what about jacky cheung?

[stanleycsh]

阿B同阿倫講得好呀...依家D所謂新歌星邊係唱歌架,乜都只睇­外型,根本都唔夠氣唱. 人地譚詠麟以前日日跑步練氣.一開演唱會連續唱十幾二十場,場場­三個幾鐘.唱到唱唱一樣架.唉...新歌星,,,努力練好D基本­功先啦

[awakingkenny]

阿b個d歌有難度架咩?去唱酷愛呀,你仲走唔走音?唔好以為係前­輩就勁晒先得架!

[joechampion]

@awakingkenny 完全唔同意你所講, 阿b唱讓一切隨風呢首難度高的歌都handle得好好, 如果唔係台灣超級星光踢館魔王閻奕格都唔會揀呢首歌同人PK喇!

[lw416]

好喜歡溫拿！

[v1197329]

我完全唔覺得呀b係串緊新人=.=

佢之不過係道講緊事實..講緊道理...

影片改錯名啦...

[josephlaw3124]

正!!! 全部都係我地網友心聲

[tommylauka3]

希望新人都可以好接受呢D真言..

從而改進一下自己既唱功啦~加油!

[Aznproz]

旧一代的当然唱得好啦！but 新一代的歌手：i will only support Hins Cheung & GEM!! XD yay!!! <3

[lobelia2]

he's NOT that good either. come on.

[bkc2006]

jason chan is pretty good at live i would say, he is one of the few that can actually sing nowadays

[hide98000]

佢地寸新人有咩問題-_-

佢地都係前輩..譚詠麟更加唔洗講...

其實咁講已經好比面d新人啦~

[nawkrm]

He's not "inching" at all, he's just stating the facts.

[kennikennyking]

@nawkrm INCHING <---haha hularious!!!!!

[Nagadomo]

只怪香港歌星沒努力,仲要大大聲叫港人支持廣東歌..唉...台­灣國語歌very good la....

[plundererderer]

好心阿B啦. 自己又唔識唱歌.

改人地d經典英文歌d歌詞就話係自己新歌.

仲要改到不倫不類.

[TheClassicalist]

就算大部份新人係咁係唔駛講到全部都係咁啫係咪呀?

[StarzzBabyy]

我覺得B哥講得啱lor

好似stephy甘 live唱都走嗮音...

[sing321321]

B哥夠扮識彈guitar啦

[ilvdepp]

LOVE THEM XD

[jonasxxxx]

b歌講得真系好今代香港歌手正廢物~最爆就系出埋d咩boyz,­cookies,小方咁既廢人都得既真系想笑7死人好心拒睇番屋­企生bb啦~叫果班咁既香港廢物歌手聽下d外國歌先再唱啦！

[karyko92]

其實boyz, cookies, 小方都算好啦， boyz cookies都散左啦

小方live都幾穩鎮伽

不過現在再新個d就死到 ...

冇形容詞可以形容

[133999XD]

i think he himself is not so good nethier

[Elsieification]

ah b really sucks...

Eason Chan sings better than him alot...

but EC has never said sth like that arrogant...

[7hen]

香港 e+ d 新人好多都唔得...

聽台灣歌算.....

[kwongsiuchun]

講得好好！事實！

[yammy345]

走音先至有人識, 有人記得, 先至多人講,

咪當宣傳囉

歌照唱, 音照走, 書照出, 英文照講

[hykli1]

網民的眼睛是雪亮的, 耳朵是靈敏的, 前輩說話是有道理的. 唱歌唔練功, 到老一場空, 係張繼聰向超級巨聲講既.

[order5228]

我觉得他们只是给意见吧了~

而且说的时候蛮谦虚的~~

[gigipang]

自從有了星光大道等節目,大家對唱歌認識多,就更明白若然­你搵食就請盡量唔好走音!!玩卡拉ok無所謂,仲話偶像!!唔­係淨靠個樣後生,跟杜麗沙學幾堂就變大歌聲!!最後只會變到­唱又走音,寫又錯字,講又i am very thanks them!!!到咁就不如退出啦!!!淨係比錢找人舉住你個名­叫住你,以為自己掂咪死得囉!!!!

[elsaau2003]

俾咁多錢過走音歌手虐待自己? 唔係嘩? 錢多乎? 包容? 原來唔係專業歌手至開得演唱會咩? 香港有d人真係無腦 甘心被人搵老襯!!

[henry2890]

你地聽番佢地後生過陣唱歌先la,人地勁過d走音歌手n倍,點會­冇資格!

[papalsk]

身為歌手就要唱好歌架啦

包容下????

咁係人都做到歌星啦

包容下就得架啦可

正廢話!!!!

[jiminez]

i agree with him. KaKui would say the same thing.

[gillian1314]

鄧走音係元祖，成個演唱會走晒音，係死刑，一兩首歌就比個機會改­過

[ltcwkttkl]

發覺很多言論十分反智，情況如下：年輕醫生醫死了Ａ，正當Ａ家屬­追究之際，身邊的Ｂ、Ｃ、Ｄ等等卻言道：「怎麼啦，人家還年輕，­給人家機會嘛，他也不過『打份工』而已，一個醫生醫得好不好人還­是終須一死啦對不對？傻子！」香港已從來沒文明過，現在更走上反­智之路，唱歌的不必懂唱歌，最重要有一大幫談反智式仁愛包容的支­持者就可以了。

[triplecena123]

寸得好!!!!

寸死那些走音的

[ttt66man]

寸得好!!!!

而家有d歌手音唔準就賴音響師出錯!

[lois0209]

e d就正啦

講野完全唔洗避忌d咩

完全講出所有人心中所想

[bathezb]

歌手走音 即係冇料 , 呃唔到 , 正如

教書ge 教錯曬野一樣 , 冇料就係冇料

[fotobenben]

如果演完可以唔識做戲，屍機可以唔識揸車，廚ｃ可以唔識煮餸，咁­歌星又駛咩識唱歌呢？

但係，各位觀眾，乘客，食客，或樂迷，你今年幾大呢？係咪一定要­夠後生／夠老／識煮野食至可以話人地啲野難食呢？

[nitesec]

老江湖即係老江湖, 講句野都有力d

[aaronjack918]

所以點解e家咁多人上網download歌呢..

因為呢代既唱片都唔值得買,,

跟本係一個電惱合成既唱片..

[kitkitlee]

其實都不是走吾走音問題,係live表現問題,做得歌手就要有專­業及水準.

[gingsoul]

true!

[samlam333]

一位歌手走音不是大件事嗎?

[samlam333]

真是未看清世界便發聲.知不知道一位歌手版權費是多少?

[samlam333]

good

[chihuahuab]

講得有道理!!!

而家香港歌手完全冇水準,,,唔知醜

[rinoama]

what they said are really true though

[raymondng197]

d完全唔識唱歌都可以o羅亞太區最受歡迎香港女歌星

[leoncow]

good b哥萬歲

[mingnam123]

洗唔洗踏咁盡, 阿b 阿倫 唱live又好掂?

[pighui]

they were really great !!

I pay fully respect to them.

And what they said was real.

[65713111]

掂你小小啦

[pm728]

@mingnam123 你買佢地d演唱會睇下就知咩係"歌手"...唔好話舊o個D啦.­.買隻左麟加李睇下... 譚校長D live好到嚇親你!! 唱功加感情都一流!!

[emii0325]

係咩.__.

我想講你有你意見我有我意見

我唔想同你罵晒交咁,話晒我唔識你

但重點係..我都有我發表言論既自由,唔該你講野比少少禮貌好

[nanablvd]

he's speaking of the truth; a good sign now that companies look more for youngsters with talents.

[rose19953]

我覺得講得好啵!!

[tkwai0605]

okay

[emii0325]

佢地係講得岩姐=_=

但佢地有乜資格話人先

講到自己好似未走過音咁=__=

唔係做得耐就代表你有資格lo其實-_-

[isamu135]

You're talking out of your ass.

If they don't, who does? They are in the industry for over 30 years. Alan Tam is an icon of the Hong Kong Music industry with numerous awards. He's is called the principal. If he doesn't who does?

Hey, even I have to right to judge them because my ears hurt after listening to those shitty singers. Everybody is entitled to their opinion, whether you agree with them or not.

And I find your opinion that they shouldn't have an opinion, rubbish.

[isamu135]

Or you have been living under a rock for 50 years, or you are just 5 years old. That you don't recognize Alan Tam means something to HK music is just plain ignorant and stupid. You don't have to like the guy or like his music. But he is undoubtedly one of the best singers of HK of all time. And that's a fact.

I don't find their comments offensive at all. And everybody is entitled to their opinions. "Don't listen to it" is just a childish thing to say. Get your head out of your ass.

[benlovehehe]

訓啦柒頭

[timshun321]

點解冇資格,譚校長都叫叫冇資格?前輩話人點解唔得呀,叫依家d­歌手唱多d live睇下點,佢地話人炸,又冇串人。

[tomkoolman]

一針見血~~~ 但有時去得太盡會俾人揪後腳...

呢番說話如果出自張學友口中效果會好d

[lth666ccc]

我唔覺得佢自己有唱得幾好wo

[ETAINLAW]

絕對正確!(:

[watchonutube]

事实

[nanachan2006123456]

一針見血

[iloveyoucand]

講就講得好...

傅姐係低低地

但係bb都唔係唱得好好炸喎

[erik1981888]

new hk singers suck especially those from eeg

[FKBHo]

校長同B歌講得對! 依家d 歌手cd版嘅歌都用電腦執過晒, 因此聽落唱得好似好好, 但係唱現場時會變左另一回事...

[laungai]

When they were new singers, they were not better than the new singers now

[xXHyPerTCXx]

yah... but when they were new singers they werent as bad as stephy and theresa,

[john27003]

maybe they should sing in text then. back in 80's alan tam also used voice alternation to make his voice sound better. his live performance was often way different than his CD voice. so... what the f, winner sucks big time.

[applepk12]

寸得好

[xom9413]

cant understand why can 阿B criticizes singers with his level of singing.

[jakster726]

阿B absolutely sucks

[noraacmw]

He is a very good singer, i saw him live in a party

[wishgill]

雖然講得好,但我唔覺得佢自己唱得幾好wo=.=

[kennie2u]

就是，现在新人出唱片很快，但是就很少唱live，很怀念80s­和90s的歌手。能唱歌的真的越来越少了

[ebonyroundass]

Absolutely. Nowaday, it's nearly impossible to find artists have such a quality voice like Zuzanna Kwan.....what a shame.

[bforbowie]

講得好... XD

[xom9413]

阿B的唱歌水平????ten time worst than most singer...

[syss2102]

以前有新秀,未夠班出唱片的新人,電視台都有給他們機會,還可以­在酒廊歌廳磨練,近年來大部份的新人,根本不夠專業,歌唱水準永­遠停留在新人的水平.

[wongyion2001]

支持,他們說的對!!!

[Abbeydawn911]

阿B講得真好、

[fatkoo01]

譚校長11~16秒哥句啱聽!!!

[Ichigobest]

lol perfect example...

Theresa D走音...-.-

[fsjgt]

靠外形，靠郁几下手脚叫做识跳舞

[axesd]

Go GEM!

[qtHKboi]

Its very true !! i 100% agree with him..

REally... nowadays its like this

look at the 80's and 90's of HK singers..

they were fabulous...

[ecarlx306]

新人黎講睇好gem

[neihomai2]

support ah b and alan!

[maxching2000]

科技係人類的進步定令人類退步?

[chengleong3]

He is right,1000% agreed with them what he said....

[spandautam]

the so-called singer in HK is NOT a singer, they are only a puppet controlled by artist management company.........

[yiuho618]

希望有歌星睇到呢條片

[leeleelee2006]

宜家d歌星大多數都係賣下樣拍下片同廣告，有幾多個真係對音樂有­研究丫。

[yykk2010]

練得唔夠 到時一唱live就緊張

咁會好容易走音

不過依加d歌手十個八個都係諗住紅少少汁下金

冇打算真係係樂壇上做到一番成績

真係失望

[hoo2006to2007]

講得無錯...而家有幾個歌手 or group 敢唱 live ?

[staballemo]

agreed!

[fuck74you]

宜家ge新人真係......................­屎

[siubobo0001]

100% agree

[Jadeslippers]

SO TRUE...

[mick3802]

鍾鎮濤好野, 講得好, 香港樂壇無人懂唱歌好來呢!

[iiMangox3]

agree

[up69]

so true

[bbkui]

its turth ~