my only prob with this is that the sheet music in the book ISN'T the way she actually plays it, live or in the actual song. trust me its not it. BUT you played what you learned very well, even if it wasn't what Amy plays :)
The sheet is easily findable on google, "my immortal piano sheet". Nice interpretation, a bit too fast sometimes, and yes try to use pedal :). Anyway, good job !
You go too fast on the middle part. You wouldn't be able to sing to that at at your tempo. Keep the tempo consistent and don't speed up and slow down like that.
pretty good, i have the same book but in the begining i think u played it abit wrong. like right notes but remember the last two parts or the repeating is a e a e a e, then the begining when starting is a e a then stop on the left hand while ur right hand repeats. lol sorry if this is kinda confusing you, but your very talented at the piano :)
It's probobly in the garage, Erm...That wasent quite right teh timing is to early and you should use you're pedal, And you keep switching tempo, sorry but this wasen't good =/
dude i don't care if the timing is off yeah ur a little fast but who cares half the people who write those comments dont even play this song or can' even play the piano i'm in the middle of learning this song and i think that was very well played i wish i could do that but i can't seem to get the chorus right it's kinda frustrating but i'm still gonna try u rock! ☺☺☺
i must agree, it sounds very... off, and poorly timed. you for the most part have the notes down though i noticed a few were off, but really need to work on the timing, listen to the song, its not just all consecutive 8th notes, there are lots of pauses. granted this is a fairly difficult song to play, it took me at least 10 hours to get it down but timing is something that is so easy to fix and actually makes the song much easier to play
So you didin't use the sustain pedal, the tempo is off, and your piano is out of tune a bit. It was amazing! You obviously did your best, and that's what counts. Don't worry about getting your piano tuned, I like the sound, and I think the tempo is good for what it is, and the timing is fine considering it's hard switching verses (for any song). 5/5
Its ok, but the timing all the way through except the verses is bad. You don't pause for long enough, and cram everythin in, you dont use the pedle to let the notes resinate and you thump out the notes with least meaning of their sensitivity. I have mastered my immortal, i know the piece backwords
fallen sheet music =D i been lookin for that book :/ they dont sell it in my local music shopp :'( but they have the open door, soo am gunna get that!
You're very good, but I was trying to sing the words and you were going too fast, which I think you're used to, because your Eternal cover was perfect.
omg ur play it all in chords don't do that. ur taking all the passion away from it. play it w/o hard pedaling and don't do cords, and for god's sake clean ur floor. did some one have a food fight in there? dude really thats gross
But, if piano is your passion i think you should play more.. and not "you suck. too fast. out of tune. playing with mittens on. never play piano again. " =D
But even, she/he's right, with the too fast, out of tune, mittens on..
that was good, sorry, i dont want to be mean or anything, but i just don't like the sound of honky tonk pianos(the one your using) it would have sounded better on a grand
amandeus, because everyone is used to hearing the song with the vocals which covers up most of the weird rhythms heard in the chorus when its just a piano solo. the voice makes the piano part of the chorus smoother and less abrupt. furthermore, it doesnt help that the piano part goes partial major when the vocal part goes minor but hey...together it works.
Could you play the 2nd part of the song after the verse with "And it won't leave me alone" slower on another video? I would really like to know how to play it.
NEEDS tuning + second is't in the same with your right hand the left is good but needs some work about the right hand (one white futher to the right + tuning of the piano) but good for the rest
/watch?v=d0umXWULtrc my cover ;)
maxkubot 4 weeks ago
T.T.T.T.T.T.T.T i play this song too!
ysisvivas 4 months ago
Listen to this with rainymood video in a different tab:)
ilovefinn96 5 months ago in playlist piano
Waaaayyyy too fast. :l
1029384756wes 5 months ago
O_O YOU'RE TOO FAST
patatamonmusic 9 months ago
youve done a really good job dude
tjames801 10 months ago
horror))
Ellaigely 1 year ago
clean your room man
Ttimpable 1 year ago 5
de repente te aceleras pero aun asi lo haces bien
HikaruIwakura 1 year ago
care over time
alarac97 1 year ago
please check my videos. feel free to comment and rate it.. I'm just starting though. I did a version of this song. Thank you.
jenilynfabian 1 year ago
Gotta play slower, mannn. And yeahh the tune is meh. Other than that, you're good :]
TallyTot 1 year ago
my only prob with this is that the sheet music in the book ISN'T the way she actually plays it, live or in the actual song. trust me its not it. BUT you played what you learned very well, even if it wasn't what Amy plays :)
iloveevanescence1795 1 year ago
that face is so creepy.. i was hoping it won't crawl out from my screen..
kaiiiiifung 1 year ago
is other tone =S
arcangelsad1 1 year ago
is other tone =S
arcangelsad1 1 year ago
that is amazing i wish i knew how
younglover554 1 year ago
this is amazing!
BrunoESWE 1 year ago
i think your pianos out of tune:O
WestleyLam 2 years ago 46
way out of tune
lhaarbye1488 1 year ago 3
@WestleyLam
I agree. :P
horsegirl951 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@WestleyLam I agree, :P
horsegirl951 1 year ago
god can you not count to 4? its driving me crazy!
kaimarie10 2 years ago 2
sounds flat, if it was tuned it would sound much better:)
Nfinity82 2 years ago 2
w refrenie gonisz troszkę i nie zbyt rytmicznie ale ogólnie spoko
krzynu 2 years ago
ya play it like the song goes. you were fast and choppy all over and ur pianos out of tune. Youve almost got it, tho!
Denny8128 2 years ago
your piano needs to be tuned. and you skip and rush beats all over the place
kaimarie10 2 years ago
Agreed. He loses his 4/4 time by the 45 second mark, and then falls back with the chorus.
TearsOfLithium 2 years ago
das klavier ist voll verstimmt oO
hummelrico94 2 years ago 3
Not really that good, wrong notes and everything. Keep trying tho!
Hanslowc 2 years ago
Yeah and sweep the floor. That's distracting.
sobodude 2 years ago 2
I think he's outside. i'm not sure. I think those are leaves, but I'm not sure.
JansenFriedh 2 years ago
Das Klavier ist ähhh...ein bisschen....verstimmt
MrZweifler 2 years ago
Ja stimmt
But it was still a good interpretation ;)
shannyogirl 2 years ago
To fast....
WildCeetah17 2 years ago 2
you go to fast...
xxonegirlonemindxx 2 years ago 8
I have the sheet music for My Immortal, but the part leading up to the chorus and the chorus itself does NOT sound like that.
yourveritaserum 2 years ago 2
The sheet is easily findable on google, "my immortal piano sheet". Nice interpretation, a bit too fast sometimes, and yes try to use pedal :). Anyway, good job !
Einderos 2 years ago 3
Good, use pedal please xD I like pedal wayy better
MurasakiGurl 2 years ago 5
do you have the sheet music for this? this is AMAZING! ive been trying to learn this song for ever but i cant find good sheet music...:(
edward4ever192 2 years ago
the timeing is a little off..in pre chorus, chorus, bridge and solo. maybe slow it down a little bit. But it was still good
dandymoose 2 years ago
i love it
eternalmind7 2 years ago 3
good
chinitta17 2 years ago
i was singin along and wen u hit when u cried i wiped away all of ur tears its was like fast SLOW IT DOWN MAAN!!, happy easter!
DanielRuggerioishot 2 years ago 18
you went a too fast on the chorus so try to slow that down. great job!!
trackandfieldboy 2 years ago 3
You go too fast on the middle part. You wouldn't be able to sing to that at at your tempo. Keep the tempo consistent and don't speed up and slow down like that.
pumpkin2244 3 years ago 6
nice..you need to tune your piano:)
if you want come and check my cover too;) 5 stars for you:)
velasquez87 3 years ago 4
use the pedal and it will sound better. (p/s: thats one creepy looking book XD)
scotty0107 3 years ago 5
this is good, just you need to use your damper pedal, but other than that, great!
trix4Him 3 years ago 3
right^^ :D I agree to the others but I think with a pedal and more practise you'll get it
getaheadrightnow 3 years ago
this is good but you need to youse your pedal and tune your piano and not rush as much
alixspaz 3 years ago 3
Tune your piano, use pedal, and try to follow the time on the chorus ;)
good luck!
MetalNicola 3 years ago 4
this is great , thanks
pumpkinite1990 3 years ago
Yes you have to use the damper, but the song sounds great!
Redlion94 3 years ago 2
your getting there, keep it up, you did a good job
AshISMusicallyHungry 3 years ago
this isnt in the original key, is it?
Smilley76 3 years ago
As I see it, key is original but that piano is out of tune. Still very nice.
WalterFucker 3 years ago 3
ah! usa pedal!
tarudi6 3 years ago
ese piano esta super desafinado!
tarudi6 3 years ago
LOVED IT!
Juliek94 3 years ago
the piano made it sound bad :(
Bajan55 3 years ago
it was alright...but it`s not how the song goes.
you paced it way too fast.
but it`s nice.
baYraised 3 years ago
ang kapal nitong iupload ung video nya..haha
boklogsi 3 years ago
Wow. No emotion, and the song isn't even played the right way!!! Whatever you do don't ever ruin a piece like this ever again
loganthompson26 3 years ago
I envy your... Piano book ^^
Go inside, and practice!
RevBlood 3 years ago
played without any emotion :(, thats not what the piece was written for !
Chrizschy 3 years ago
what is ' tune ' ??
Vernowned 3 years ago
sustain and improve the crushendo.TUNE YA PIANO!!
bodharry 3 years ago
You keep your piano outside?! I guess you want to have to tune it about 3 times a day huh?
And a good idea would be to use the sustain pedal so that the song "flows" more.
But other than that, good playing.
helimeef 3 years ago 3
you need a metronome
0zKaR425 3 years ago
the intro is good but after that you speed up too much and tune that piano plis
plamen040404 3 years ago 2
hummmf, i could never play that, i suck at piano
---
...allmylove
Crapnight 3 years ago
WOW its so out of tune bud!
xxiangel 3 years ago
where is ur piano outside... it sounds like shit and u should clean ur floor!
cardude666 3 years ago
I have the same piano book!!
stilldoll95 3 years ago 2
u dont feel the song...its not flewn
iweyrauch 3 years ago
to the person who asked where he got the music from..
he has the book durh
your playing the song to fast
and your pianos out of tune
meggapple 3 years ago
you play very well but i think you need to tune your piano :0/
hazeyconeytootle 3 years ago 3
I agree..
laurap19 3 years ago 2
u dont know the song
Whitetiger90 3 years ago
um were can i get the sheet book?
hrmega5 3 years ago
it sounds as if your piano is alittle off tune... :\ sorry.
daydreamerkupkake 3 years ago 10
yh no offense but ur piano sounds totally different to mine
EvanescenceFanNo1 3 years ago
yes... i think so too
MuseekFreek 3 years ago 2
pretty good, i have the same book but in the begining i think u played it abit wrong. like right notes but remember the last two parts or the repeating is a e a e a e, then the begining when starting is a e a then stop on the left hand while ur right hand repeats. lol sorry if this is kinda confusing you, but your very talented at the piano :)
deadrussianvampire 3 years ago
Wow. That was horrible.
Sorry.
TheCatIsDry 3 years ago 2
It's probobly in the garage, Erm...That wasent quite right teh timing is to early and you should use you're pedal, And you keep switching tempo, sorry but this wasen't good =/
madelejne 3 years ago 2
dude i don't care if the timing is off yeah ur a little fast but who cares half the people who write those comments dont even play this song or can' even play the piano i'm in the middle of learning this song and i think that was very well played i wish i could do that but i can't seem to get the chorus right it's kinda frustrating but i'm still gonna try u rock! ☺☺☺
shikashadowpower 3 years ago
clean your floor man, disgusting!
gottahabrice17 3 years ago 2
I agree XPPP
Biudiz 3 years ago
i agree with the one below..
the verses are alright, but the chorus timing is wrong..
Ivanescence17 3 years ago
i must agree, it sounds very... off, and poorly timed. you for the most part have the notes down though i noticed a few were off, but really need to work on the timing, listen to the song, its not just all consecutive 8th notes, there are lots of pauses. granted this is a fairly difficult song to play, it took me at least 10 hours to get it down but timing is something that is so easy to fix and actually makes the song much easier to play
cul8r2fast4u 3 years ago 2
you got the basics but try listening to the original and practise, you'll be able to play like amy lee before you know it
metalheadlass 3 years ago
Is your piano outdoors?
hipnhappenin 3 years ago
its awesome but it'll b awesomer if u tune ur piano
ruby00roxnsodoi 3 years ago
Ahhh! your in desperate need of tuning. Great job though, you gave it a great effort. =D
musicalxtide 3 years ago
So you didin't use the sustain pedal, the tempo is off, and your piano is out of tune a bit. It was amazing! You obviously did your best, and that's what counts. Don't worry about getting your piano tuned, I like the sound, and I think the tempo is good for what it is, and the timing is fine considering it's hard switching verses (for any song). 5/5
darkpiano7 3 years ago
I agree on the pedal. You should definatly use it. Gives it a much more full sound.
Timing is indeed very bad. OK, it's not that easy to go from verse to verse and staying in temp. But this is really really off tempo!
Didn't enjoy listeng .. sory dude
yves159 3 years ago
Its ok, but the timing all the way through except the verses is bad. You don't pause for long enough, and cram everythin in, you dont use the pedle to let the notes resinate and you thump out the notes with least meaning of their sensitivity. I have mastered my immortal, i know the piece backwords
maneatingsquirls 3 years ago
ur amazing!!! XD i love watching your vids, i wish i could play as good as you ^_^
renoxcloud 3 years ago
your piano is out of tune...
EmmsiLimegreen 3 years ago
except for the fact that your piano is way out of tune it was quite ok! :)
bellabelliboo 3 years ago 2
Yeah... quite out of tune
Esbenkm 3 years ago
oh waw! wear did you get the book from?!
i want one!
YUMxxxhehe 3 years ago
whats that book with amy lee face??
luuurock 3 years ago
book with all the songs written in it so you can play it =]
0munky0 3 years ago
fallen sheet music =D i been lookin for that book :/ they dont sell it in my local music shopp :'( but they have the open door, soo am gunna get that!
lykOMGlyk 3 years ago
We couldn't find it either, so we asked the music shop to order it.
Amandafeye 3 years ago
It's the Fallen Sheet Music Book by Allegro. I have that exact same book :)
metragoon 3 years ago
you're lucky you have that book.I DONT!!!:=(
chummychizzle 3 years ago
Pick it up online or at the music shop :)
It's only $19.99
metragoon 3 years ago
you got the book?
chummychizzle 3 years ago
Yes
metragoon 3 years ago
dude just find it for free on the internet :). the sheet music, not the book...
yeswell123 3 years ago
Uhhh... I'm pretty sure it's not played like... that...
bobcat1115 3 years ago
Uhmm wtf??!!
XxMelissaxXabc 3 years ago
What are you guys on about?
i REALLY liked it.
BlackOrchid66 3 years ago
tsk tsk tsk..
xerxesxerography 3 years ago
uhm.... it was good, but:
1. hey, there's no feeling in your playing!!
2. your piano is daaaaaamn, extreeeemly biliously. GEt your piano tuned ;D!
and 3. uhm... you used the pedal quite little.
but, good work!!
VampiresLoverNr8 3 years ago 3
well you didn´t do this so well. u are much too fast and where´s the feeling?! it´s not a jazz-thing.
it sounds terrible!
MariuHanna27 3 years ago
You're very good, but I was trying to sing the words and you were going too fast, which I think you're used to, because your Eternal cover was perfect.
oscarthefattycat 3 years ago
omg ur play it all in chords don't do that. ur taking all the passion away from it. play it w/o hard pedaling and don't do cords, and for god's sake clean ur floor. did some one have a food fight in there? dude really thats gross
Inuyashagurl93 3 years ago 5
ur ok. Aye whats that on ur floor?
madlyn14 3 years ago
Miksi sen lattia on niin likanen?
9770187786 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i can Play this VERY well!
12345snooplog 3 years ago
And yes, let your piano tune. =D
But, if piano is your passion i think you should play more.. and not "you suck. too fast. out of tune. playing with mittens on. never play piano again. " =D
But even, she/he's right, with the too fast, out of tune, mittens on..
Make a New Version &'nd make it "better". =D
LeniiiRocks 4 years ago
Nice work. i like it, but you should may usw pedal. so it goes over in each other. like in the real sheet. =D
-best wishes helena
LeniiiRocks 4 years ago 2
from 1.00 to 1.15 you made it sound very horrible,work on trying to smoothening the notes, they should follow each other...very mechanical
enwy nice work
montelka 4 years ago
tach me
Emilyrox787 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
YOU'RE TERRIBLE
GET THE FUCK OUT
m4m4m4 4 years ago
your piano needs to be tuned.. but otherwise very good
hockeychick2342 4 years ago 4
urr awesomee, i can playy it half wayy but it getss hardd. please give a tutoriall
XsweetZildjianX 4 years ago
i think your fingers has lag....
Breathor 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
you suck. too fast. out of tune. playing with mittens on. never play piano again.
JRemaley14 4 years ago
Crap Cover
bateria 4 years ago
TUNE YOUR PIANO... PLEASE!
dwampls 4 years ago 3
great playing!
witchylynx 4 years ago
try it with a metronome .. good playing but terrible synchronism
skouradakis 4 years ago 2
tune your piano :)
rok133 4 years ago 2
your piano is terribly out of tune :(
xxDressedInBlackxx 4 years ago 5
piano needs sum tuning man... gr8 job tho
chubble101 4 years ago 3
Nice job! I am learning piano. Any advice?
degrassiCTV 4 years ago
im not sure but i think that the high note is out of tune (i think its C#, the top one) but other than that awesome job
StarSeekingGuitar 4 years ago
HhHhIiIiI
wow its great, i play piano too.
im probably not as good as u lol
i will 1 day lolz
beautiful221 4 years ago
that was good, sorry, i dont want to be mean or anything, but i just don't like the sound of honky tonk pianos(the one your using) it would have sounded better on a grand
stopmotionfilms 4 years ago 3
I agree however we have to use what is available
corythecobra 4 years ago
lol.. aww dont b cruel.. it is hard ya know..
i cant even play the chorus but i can play the rest =/ a bit fucked up but there ya go lol o.o
heartlesssoul666 4 years ago
Why does everyone seem to have so much trouble with the chorus?
amadeus2490 4 years ago
y not? what if there just beginners? thats understandable. and no ones perfect. -_^
lilfirekutie5 4 years ago
Well my rendition isn't perfect, either (see my video if you're interested).
amadeus2490 4 years ago
Ever tried to sing and play something that complicated? Probably not...
ACEcoggins 4 years ago
lol Yeah, I practiced "singing" along while I played. . .the fact that I have a low and terrible voice not-with-standing.
amadeus2490 4 years ago
amandeus, because everyone is used to hearing the song with the vocals which covers up most of the weird rhythms heard in the chorus when its just a piano solo. the voice makes the piano part of the chorus smoother and less abrupt. furthermore, it doesnt help that the piano part goes partial major when the vocal part goes minor but hey...together it works.
onetoughguy920 4 years ago
hey!!! good, but where did you get that book???? i want it!!! please please tell me where to buy it
ely3105 4 years ago
Could you play the 2nd part of the song after the verse with "And it won't leave me alone" slower on another video? I would really like to know how to play it.
Wolfcrazy92 4 years ago
sounds (and looks) as if hes in a western bar...
piano out of tune, and what the hell is that crap on the floor!
from the wild west!
azurelement 4 years ago
I say he played it perfectly. He is showing how he can play the piano - not how he lives - You play great! Keep it up! =D
Also, I was wondering if you could tell me what version of My Immortal your playing?! :) Thanks!
Wolfcrazy92 4 years ago
The piano IS out of tune, but he's hitting every note right...
heyperson123 4 years ago
kinda like a video game-ish..
phayz9 4 years ago
Hey I just got that EXACT same Evanescence piano tab book!!
You're great!!
I've started playing the beginning of it, and I can't wait until I get where you're at!
P.S. I got the tab book at:
sheetmusicplus(dot)com
(I had to pay for it though, but it is the like original piano tabs so yea! LOL)
TheSamanthaA 4 years ago
Whats all that crap on the rug
wenuswielder 4 years ago 3
LOL
nmilosev92 4 years ago
LOL! he got it right by starring at amy lee's face..
MSR06 4 years ago 2
haha!
TheSamanthaA 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
hey bitch give me the tabs or else ill kill u!!!!
lala007hahahehe 4 years ago
stick to the tempo...
OpenRomantic 4 years ago
i think your piano is out of tune or something because this isn't good
tjbrandreth 4 years ago
It's good, but you're right. The piano is a bit off.
zomgFletch 4 years ago
sounds funny
GaaraLuver96 4 years ago
DEV CSÖVES
MeliceFlor 4 years ago
bad
emploiev 4 years ago
brilliant [=
bigbignosedestroyer 4 years ago
NEEDS tuning + second is't in the same with your right hand the left is good but needs some work about the right hand (one white futher to the right + tuning of the piano) but good for the rest
listen too
David D. Scott and you will see!!!
swoop0007 4 years ago
your piano needs tuning
but you are good
4 stars
dhmos15 4 years ago