Who is the Best CARMINE?!

[awesome38800]

clayton carmine

[BetterOnichThanSorry]

Benjamin, hands downn.

[kwballa26]

Anthony!

[thexboxman38]

the d in d carmine stands for damien

[L3G3ND125]

@thexboxman38 that might be baird

[thexboxman38]

@L3G3ND125 no the d in bairds name is damon

[thewheelman222]

clayton looks way more badass and he is the only carmine that survived.he is the best!

[xKICKINxBEERx]

all are cool but i like ben best

[tiaanwolfie]

so what who is the best. i would be part of the carmine family anyday.-raises xbox controller to all the fallen carmines.

[Blitzball16]

Ben Carmine

[moneybags724812]

I say clayton is the beast cause he survailed all the stuff that killed ben and anthony and he is out for revenge and bulked up so clay it is for me

[supaSwagHypn0]

i think its a tie between clayton and ben carmine. anthony carmine died in like acter 1 chapter 2 and he barely had any lines. ben died in act 3 but u got to know him way more than anthony he is the youngest he listened to the golden rule of the cog he also had a little trouble reloding but he wasnt as bad as anthony clayton he barely in the the game because he is in cole's squad . but he has grub killer on his armor his brothers and he is has a tatoo of his fallen brothers

[halopop909]

no Clayton

[halopop909]

Ben

[xxsebartxx]

antony carmine <3

[ANGRYMAPLE]

Clay survives a sniper round to the head "Good thing I wear a helmet" that's enough reason for him to win

[kornfarmer54]

@ANGRYMAPLE ya and i love how anthony dies by a sniper (clay lives) ben dies by a chopper chrash into the worm thing (clay's chopper crashes and he lives) they made it to where clay carmine over comes all the ways the other carmines die and he finally lives.. oh ya and by the way SPOILER

[naverruncus]

Definitely Crumclutz

[reksub10]

who was deavcon carmine and where in the games or anywhere that i can get this info on a deacon carmine

[reksub10]

the best 1 is got to be sgt madison carmine as he is the only one we have proof of that was recorded as a HERO in the emrergence war .we know nothing of deacon carmine or clayton ,and ben and antony got twatted in the 1st 2 games so scince they where privates and we havent seen clayton or know about deacon the madison .which i thik is their mother was the best as she got the medal..but if its coolness then i think clay looks cool so far in the realesed pics

[rogelio747]

Anthony Carmine :)

[407Carmine]

I agree with TheGoldenMinnow 407Carmine is the best Carmine! Not a great singer I'm told. But still the best Carmine.

[awsomefoxy007]

clay carmine because hes the only one who hasnt died yet



[reksub10]

@awsomefoxy007 madison carmine hasnt died yet either and she survived the emergance wars aswell as the war in gears plus she was a sergant and got a medal for heroism so as the others where privates and we havent seen clay or deacon yet then the title of best has to go to madison in terms of soldiery

[joshua53492]

Clay he's to cool to die

[TheGoldenminnow]

n my opinion 407Carmine is the best Carmine! Tell the world "Carmine must Die"!

[AQWBadji]

Ben

[chriswafflezs]

clayton will live

[hutchd77]

@halogamer117100

clayton will live



[hutchd77]

clay is the best

[TheEpicWarrior2]

Can anyone find footage of clayton carmine in a video what will he look like in the game?

The other carmines will look beast in gears 3

[Labyethan]

@TheEpicWarrior2 type in Gears of War 3 Clayton Carmine then go down to the one with the description satying 'here you go you crazy fans' i think it should be there

[Labyethan]

@TheEpicWarrior2 forget that one...got it wrong, type in 'Gears of War 3 Clayton Carmine gamplay' it should be the first one

[BIOSHOCK1960]

claytons the best hes not as wimpy as ben and anthony

[DemonCaz]

Obviously Crumclutz

[MegaNaturalbornkilla]

savveeeeeee clayton

[Jasmic7271]

all of them are the best

[Xsecretdude]

anthony

[TheMedman15]

gears of war 3 carmine is the bast

[MegaXJosh]

in the 4 gears derreck should die like this he gets fraged and loses his legs clay comes and puts his hand around his head and say everything is going to be okay and then madison carmine comes and cry and derreck has a flashback play with all his brothers and sisters and he slowly faids away and madison and clay go crazy in a horde of locust thumps up if u agree

[superkyler123]

i like carmine but i think he should die because it makes the game beter wean your fav chareter dies like my fav tai!(sorry for spelling typeing fast)

[IxROCKGODxI]

@superkyler123 It hardly makes the game better if your fav character dies -.-

[superkyler123]

@IxROCKGODxI no because you dont know wean or if your fav character if going to die and all the deaths are like saving someone or something like that. in gears 1 carmine what my fav character but then he died and it was cool from how he died aney way thats in my apinyen (sorry for spelling)

[Officialhungergames1]

alright ill tell you this now there are 5 carmines anthony ben clayton derreck and madison madison is the only girl and is member of the carmine family

[HeirofMacedon09]

where is dereck carmine mentioned same with madison is it only on gearspedia

[phhw1]

clayton carmine is the best crmine yet i mean comon he is bigger than cole and marcus combined and he is choking a locust with one arm and lifting him in the air i mean ome on he is the best

[teeth562]

go to "gears of war wiki" there are tons of info even some some useless knowlege like knowing that anya cant give birth and dizzy saved marcus and dom in operation hollow storm

[moekaheeta]

Poor Ben, he died the worst death... so far.

[hegie1172009]

Best Carmine is "GOING" to be Clayton Carmine. No one knows about Derek Carmine, and I think Madison in is Gears 3

[TheMedman15]

clayton carmine is the bast carmine and he is bad ass

[jacobakabunz]

i pick the one with the mulcher clayton carmine is a total BADASS

[xXxV3RS3xXx]

Clayton is the Best Freakin Bad ASS!!!!!

[MrJayj19]

wel i say clayton carmine because hes a bad azz in gow 3 ive played wit him in the gow beta and they showed a lil bit of storuy mode so c.carmine da best 2nd b,carmine3rd a.carmine d.carmine and madison are lame plus d,carmine is unkwoun

[ismaelop11]

@MrJayj19 that is a lie, i had the beta, no story mode at all nor any carmines

[FrancisDaBadAssBiker]

Anthony is by far the best. Not a puss like Ben and didn't die by getting eaten by stomach monsters :X

Anthony had the energy, attitude, and courage. Although he didn't die a hero's death the way Ben thought he did, dying by getting shot in the head is pretty damn gruesome if you ask me! >:D

[littleqinvasion]

@FrancisDaBadAssBiker your an idiot he had five lines he was a pussy couldint even un jam hes gun at least ben lived thrue a chapter

[anthonyduran15]

@littleqinvasion not anthonys fault the gun jamed why dont you try go unjam a gun?

[MegaShadox]

clayton carmine is bad a**

[Jmangoo2]

benjamin carmine cause he survived alot longer than anthony and clay is better then benjermen and deaton

[GOPACKERSJT]

@Jmangoo2 Actually Anthony lived longer, he just died sooner in the game.

[Arkaeya]

Pffff, really guys? You're judging which Carmine is the best? First off you can't even include Clay because you know nothing about him other than what he looks like. And Anthony wasn't even in the game long enough for his character to develop. He had five lines (literally!). So clearly, at the moment, the best Carmine is Ben because we know about his character and have seen enough of him.

[saayywhaa009]

@Arkaeya there was an official gears website that says clay is a veteran, seasoned gear who can choke a drone to death, i believe that makes it a win

[RIPNETWORK]

@Arkaeya how the fuck do you make a comment about sarcasticly asking if theyre judging the best carmine. then judge it????

[Arkaeya]

@RIPNETWORK I didn't judge it. I stated several facts pointing out that they can't properly judge them yet, as we only know anything about one of them.

[RIPNETWORK]

@Arkaeya ARE YOU STUPID? you clearly stated a bunch of facts on why NOT to judge it but then you JUST stated Ben was the best. i swear stupid/smart ppl piss me off. Try n get some common sense along with those statistical arguments of yours dipshit.

[Arkaeya]

@RIPNETWORK That is common sense moron. You know absolutely nothing about Clay so you can't say he's the best yet, and Anthony wasn't around long enough for you to learn anything about him. That's like saying you like the newest album from a band the most...when the album hasn't been released yet. It just doesn't make sense. And what are you 8 years old? For what reason do you need to insult me for trying to defend my point?

[RIPNETWORK]

@Arkaeya you realy are a dipshit, ur simply defending your stupidity cuz you know that shit looks retarted

[Arkaeya]

@RIPNETWORK Again. Are you 8? Because you're incredibly immature. If you're to pathetically ignorant to comprehend what I'm trying to say then I feel sorry for you, but there was no reason to insult me. Although you probably don't even understand the first half of this message...those were some big words I used.

[Arkaeya]

@Arkaeya Says the guy who says "trynna". And no, my comment wasn't ridiculous, you just failed to understand. That in no way means that I deserve to get insulted by some little prick who decides to troll and start an argument for no reason. Every response you have given has only proven my point that you're very immature.

[RIPNETWORK]

@Arkaeya DUDE YOU JUST SENT THAT COMMENT TO YOURSELF

[Arkaeya]

@RIPNETWORK And you didn't insult me for my mistake? Wow.

[DasomSCJ]

@Arkaeya clayton carmine lives i saw ending of the gow3 game so he is the best :]

[Arkaeya]

@DasomSCJ I know. I can also say that Clay is the best. At the time of writing that comment though the only thing we knew of Clay was what he looked like.

[reksub10]

@Arkaeya the best in soldiers term would have to be sgt madison carmine as she/he made it to sergant and recieved the medal for being a hero ..(page 5 of the war journal jacinto newspaper gears 2)as the otther where privates and got twatted and we havent seen what clyton is capable of yet  so i agree no point speculating about him .but i have no clue who deacon carmine was

[davidbomb123]

@Arkaeya But Clay lives

[Arkaeya]

@davidbomb123 Yeah I know. What's your point?

[instituteforocelots]

@Arkaeya Game's out, Clay's the best.

[TheColeRants1]

@Arkaeya every body knows clay is the best he was choking a locust and have you ever seen him fight and hes the oldest brother.

[0nintendofan0]

@Arkaeya now we know XD clayton is badass

[MikeeyD01]

@Arkaeya dude that was clayton he had that tatto and mulcher i have the game so yeah

[SlothOnWeed]

@MikeeyD01 you retard. he said we know nothing about him OTHER than what he looks like, and his comment was way before gears was out.

[MikeeyD01]

@SlothOnWeed dude i was just saying what if he didnt have gears at the moment gosh

[SlothOnWeed]

@MikeeyD01 no, you were just trying to be a smart ass, even though you failed to read his comment clearly stating that he knew which one was clayton

[MikeeyD01]

@SlothOnWeed orly?

well i should be sure what i type in is correct so how do you even know that you stupid freak

[SlothOnWeed]

@MikeeyD01 how mature :P resorting to name calling because you've been proven wrong

[MikeeyD01]

@SlothOnWeed hey guess what

R.I.P to me reply to your comments =D

[georgeblinga]

The creator mentioned Frank, Gaary, and Hugh Carmine before but said they probably won't be in the games

[aenimic81]

clayton cuz he is choking a locust in one hand and a mulcher in the other

[electron769]

clayton carmine must get  revenge

[kolton03]

DIZZY IS D.CARMINE! O_O LOOK IT UP!!!!

[UltimteLifeForm]

@kolton03 Dizzy's last name is Wallin. He is not related to the Carmines, especially sine he is way to old to be their brother

[dmandbz]

@kolton03 lol twat,

Dizzy WALLIN, not Dizzy CARMINE

[theGREXify]

i thought D. Carmine was Damian

[arashikage3]

BEN CARMINE IS THE BEST =)

[adamricher]

ARE YOU KIDDING C.CARMINE!!!!!

[ThatKittyWhoCamps]

forgot d carmine

[dontkillbernie]

madison ben ftw

[M3TALH3AD413]

A. Carmine :)

[Hotpockets0]

@M3TALH3AD413 It wasn't his fault he got sniped unjamming his crap gun.

[CheesyBigMac1]

@harryosbournez so your crappping your pants because i said a wrong answer for a video game on youtube because someone didnt answer correctly again on a video game youtube video and sorry for not listening to the dialogue as close to you fucktard

[harryosbournez]

omg you ben carmine idiots are so stupid how can you say ben carmine owns clay and all that when clearly it says so that clay carmine was the bully out of the others, he is the only carmine brother who can choke a grub to death with one hand and hold a really heavy mulcher on the other

[skaterapboy]

O_O clay carmine looks like a fuckin wall clayton carmine wins man

[l8dArwen]

clay can stop a bus when he looks at it he is so buff



[ClusiveC]

of course clay is, look at the pictures of him. ben was a kid. anthony got his head taken off.

[btheking4]

Ben Carmine was awesome... Ever since the point where he died. I repeat the level over and over again to kill the Worm and Parasites...

[wasterzphysco2]

anthony carmine

[SKAT34L1F3123]

did i say i was the REAL ben Carmine REAL LIFE cousin?

[laxbeastboy]

Clay is Awesome, nuf said

[TheGear4ever]

clayton looks like a thug, he needs a more macho name tho

[thecjc97]

they most likely wont kill him because they have to keep one brother alive its just not right if they all die

[1rebelboy]

@thecjc97 Well, you seem to forgot there are four, not three.

[TheGeneralBurn]

carmine #4

[eaglesx8x]

I vote to save him

[Lancerthirst]

there is no D Carmine. its madison carmine. and its a guy not a girl. play gears 2 campaign and in the beginning train benjamin and dom will say "did u have a brother named carmine?" and ben will say yeah there's 4 of us"

[theGREXify]

i thought it was Damien Carmine

[xxxTheron117xxx]

what type of question is that, CLAY CARMINE he has a machine gun and is bigger than all of his bro's

[1rebelboy]

@xxxTheron117xxx They all had machine guns....

[msairybaby13]

save carmine he lost 4 brothers now save him or im going to put a bullet in your head

[1rebelboy]

@msairybaby13 .....He's lost two, brothers, two out of four.

[TheBitterDoubt]

@CheesyBigMac there's 4. When Ben is dying his last words are 'Tell my BROTHERS.. My ma.. That I love them." or something very close to that. Nevertheless, there are FOUR Carmine brothers.

[CheesyBigMac1]

There's threeeee brothers not 4

[jongsin]

@CheesyBigMac1 theres 4 trustttt

[harryosbournez]

@CheesyBigMac1 there are 4 brothers dip shit

[purplemonkey3221]

B.CARMINE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!

[samtheman7975]

d. carminine

[legallywierd]

dude their are only 4 carmines b. carmine even said so in Gears 2

[mikemoney123]

a carmine has the best helmet

[OzzyBlue97]

Ben Carmine is the best. End of disscusion

[THEAKAM]

clay sucks, he better die in the next game.... painfully and it better last ten mins

[BRUT4LxKILLER]

b carmine is best

[GL4dia70r]

Clay is the oldest of the four carmine brothers! D carmine is the youngest!

[samtheman7975]

@GL4dia70r benjamin is the youngest he said so in gears 2 also the word benjamin means the youngest

[1rebelboy]

@GL4dia70r No, Ben is the youngest.

[geargirl42]

ben rules simple as that

[MsDannyrocks]

c.carmine looks like a badass anothony rocks to so does b.carmine they all rock u cant really compare them

[SKAT34L1F3123]

dude are you an idiot Benjamin Carmine FREAKING RULED CLAYTON and ANTHONY o and SAVE CARMINE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[MAJORONETHREESEVENx]

@SKAT34L1F3123 agree

[jesusrockful]

@SKAT34L1F3123 ben carmine rules

[shadowxXxcrow]

@SKAT34L1F3123 ARE u and Idiot Clay could grab his 2 brothers in each hand and kill him plus from the votes he aint gunna die... so ya feel dumb

[SKAT34L1F3123]

@shadowxXxcrow feel dumb????

[SKAT34L1F3123]

@shadowxXxcrow feel dumb???? retard prolly???

[kolton03]

@SKAT34L1F3123 NO, its clayton, dude i played the demo, and it gives 1st and last level, 1st you meet clay, but on last the cutscene clayton takes out a brumak with only a chainsaw gun! then he kills like, 2 waves of locust, including reavers

[bxboi08]

@SKAT34L1F3123 you know nothing about clay do you he survived a bullet through the brain now that rules

[iSxiSoul]

d carmine should die in the lines of gears of war 3. clayton is the oldest and a walking tank and @ sithsharnos. no thats just a random cog gear its just by luck sometimes hes called damien it is not damien carmine

[johnny15400]

ben should be 3rd becouse he lasted pree long til he was eaten by the worm

[fatsuburbanwhiteboy]

anthony was ok, ben was funny and more relateable,clay is badass,d. carmine still a mystery,and madison was a war hero from the fall of landown.

[Narutothebestshow]

Clayton Carmine is the most badass!

[1Bullet2Ki11s]

Madison Carmine is the Best.

[jonothangrace]

madison is a girl,clay is badass,ben was eaten,anthony was sniped, and d(damion) carmine no idea what happond.so madison and clay tied for 1st,anthony 2nd,ben 3rd,and d (damion) last because i dont know anything about him

[keltar2007]

Clayton Carmine is so Badass

[TheHoyHoyHoyhoy]

d carmine is unknown and madison carmine is a girl do u know that? if u hav more info to the carmine family plz add me on XBL BuKo Be CluTcH

[MAJORONETHREESEVENx]

@TheHoyHoyHoyhoy I DON'T KNOW ANY MORE INFO MAN :(

[IamPoison633]

@TheHoyHoyHoyhoy Madison Carmine is the father of the Carmine brothers.

[SithSharnos]

@TheHoyHoyHoyhoy .... idiot no didnt you here what B. Carmine said? he said four brothers in his family meening Damien (Died trying to run away from the beserker but got killed by it because he ran the wrong way Gears of War 1) Anthony (kept jamming his gun and got killed by a sniper in an ambush) Benjamin (got his insides ripped out by the big ass worms little guys in him and then died becasue he got acid on his stomach) and finally Clayton carmine (A badass veteran with a mulcher and muscles!

[mrevilpieguy]

@SithSharnos d. carmine was never seen thats gyules who died to the beserker

[1rebelboy]

@TheHoyHoyHoyhoy Actually Madisons gender isn't confirmed yet.

[Afitwalka]

@TheHoyHoyHoyhoy

in the game they're talking about 4 carmine brothers

clayton carmine.Benjamin carmine, Anthony, carmine and Madison carmine i saw that in the gears pedia site madison is a male

[Hotpockets0]

@TheHoyHoyHoyhoy There will be girl gears in Gears of War 3 So there is a chance Madison Carmine will be in the battlefield.

[keggie09]

Benjermen but I think i'm switching to clay once the game comes out

[Zeraigan]

@keggie09 i hated both but clay looks like he might not suck

[MAJORONETHREESEVENx]

Benjamin Carmine!

[bxboi08]

@MAJORONETHREESEVENx you dont even know nothing about clay he survived a bullet through the brain