Added: 2 years ago
From: Kari7
Views: 21,876
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (237)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Also the english and subbed version are different on what Roxas says to Xion about ice cream.... In the Jap version he says all 3 of them but in the dubbed version he implies he only wants to have ice cream with Xion only since he is no longer on speaking terms with Axel.... Anyone else notice that?

  • I watched both versions of this scene in english and japanese and i gotta say this version is sadder but both are are good at bringing me to tears everytime i watch this scene:)

  • @zziwhcs180 wow what a compliment to the vid :D although I would have to say this scene isnt happy :) Its meant to be sad. But dont like dont watch :D ((IM not trying to pick a fight ^^; I think it is awesome for some people to not be sheep and disagree (or agree) with somethings))

  • @zziwhcs180 I'm gay and that was a great compliment.

  • Okay this is me but i'm a FF-Fan not a KH-Fan but i like the game i just hate only a few things about it but KH is the equivalent of FF just with not that great of a story, but i do like KH and it's sad to see a great character like Xion die like that...

    *sighs* I had this same feeling when aeris dies in FFVII :(

  • This video is so sad TT_TT

  • If you pay attention to the beginning of the clip (or played the game), memories of Xion were fading with her defeat. She leaves with "please don't forget", and his eyes widens as he remembers. The comment about the ice cream proves that.

    Though I do admit, I rewatched the "who else will I have ice cream with?" line when I want a laugh. Ohhh things lost in translations in attempts to make words match with mouth movement.

  • Guys! the ice cream means much more. Remember the beginning when Roxas asked Axel what were friednds and he said friends were people who had ice cream with each other. Roxas basically asked who else will be my friend.

  • He just HAD to mention the ice cream!!!!!!

  • But Roxas had to learn the truth(leave the Organization)and forget Xion and Axe?????l!!!!!!!

    Its just not worth it !!!

  • i wonder why some people mad at the ice cream part!.. at least roxas found happiness in such small thing as eating ice cream.. he portrayed ice cream as a good time to spend with friends and proved that nobodies are not hollow or emotionless

    i cried a lot when i watched this!! poor xion she's one of the forgotten T-T

  • this was sadder then the eng one.... T.T

  • @xXanimefreakstylexX lol cause theres no "who will i have ice cream with line" changed to "lets eat ice cream together...like always" making it more dramatic and not childish

  • @animegamesbiggestfan lols T.T

  • too many stories with such sad endings.....

  • If you can watch this video until its end, without even feeling a bit of sadness within you, then you're a TRUE Nobody...

  • @FFefnir Fair enough, maybe I'm the biggest Nobody of them all *dons Org Cloak*

  • Xion- the creation that never was- *sobs*NOBODY REMEMBERS HER NAME OR OF HER EXISTENCE EXCEPT THE LAST MOMENT WITH ROXAS.........................­......XIOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOON!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!!!!! OnO

  • ....breaks my heart to see this, love kh but the ending in jap is so saddenning >.<

  • @XXSoosaXX94 awww. that was beautiful. sad but true she was forgotten. :'(

  • OMG I STARTED TO CRY!!!!!!! T_T

  • I AM A XION COSPLAYER AND PROUD! >.<

    (im a boy btw. :3)

  • i cant believe i cried @ this part!! T.T

  • @antivalentine1 i cried too. at least till roxas said the thing about the ice cream

  • @SoulRprMax uhhhhh whats wrong with roxas mentioning eating ice cream? well thats where their most cherished memories were eating ice cream together at the clock tower after missions hes losing his friends and he just wants to enjoy ice cream with his friends but instead these good times will just go away now

  • @Sasorilover149 i mean the one in the english version. it made it funny when it should've been kinda sweet

  • IMO, this is the saddest scene in KH!! T^T

  • Is kingdom hearts even about sora anymore?

  • for some stupid reason, I think this cutscene is sooo much cuter in Japanese than in english! :)

  • i cried at the end of that when i played it on the ds its so sad

  • I have a theory as to why xion looks more like aqua. xion appearance changes with each person depending on how well they knew sora because she is composed of his memories right? and roxas is soras nobody but was modeled in vens image since soras body was returned from the darkness. sooo perhaps xion looks like aqua because vens heart and memories are reacting with both roxas and xion in a way to make him see her as a younger version of aqua.

  • @xxxholic9895 I still see her face closer to Sora's than to Kairi's or Aqua's O.o the haircut is just another story...

  • omg roxas has a heart hey does he ever meet sora and this is so sad T-T wahh

  • @chaomaster42 if u played kingdom hearts 2 you would know.

  • I just reliased how ugly xion is!!

  • xion is eeeeeeeeeeeeeevvvvvvvvvvvvvvvv­iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiilllllllllllll­llllllllllllllllll

  • i dont like xion shes EVIL

  • @Kh2rOxUrSoX101 No, she was never evil. If you've seen more than just the cutscenes, you'd know that. Axel captured her for Xemnas and then dumb Mansex altered her memory and persona to serve his purpose. After Roxas defeats her, her memories and personality return and she follows through with the orgional plan she had created with Namine, for her to return to Sora so he could wake.

  • @Kh2rOxUrSoX101 You really don't have to spam three times that you don't like Xion on a video where there are likely to be xion fans...

  • i dont like xion

  • @Kh2rOxUrSoX101 I like Xion. She was my fav character (apart from Axel)

  • T_T This scene is sad no matter what language. English probably hits me harder though 'cause it's what I'm used to.

  • I personally like this dialogue more. It's so sad ):

    But even though I didn't like it at first, I prefer Xion's english voice.

    And is it me, or does Xion look more like Aqua?

  • @EternalXin She kind of does, but I don't see how Aqua can be tied so directly to Kairi. I know Aqua saved her when she was little, but I don't think it's like the Ven-Sora-Roxas connection...

  • @Exlon13 Well, *spoiler alert* Kairi is Aqua's succesor because Aqua accidently chose Kairi in BBS as her apprentice sort of thing. The same way Terra chose Riku. I think Aqua meant to get Sora, but ended up choosing Kairi instead.

    But you're right...It's not like Xion is Kairi's nobody, she made up from Sora's memory. So maybe it's Ven's memory of Aqua mixed with Sora's memory of Kairi?

  • @EternalXin [ SPOILER ALERT!!!! ]

    Actually-- Aqua didn't choose Kairi. Kairi touched her Keyblade accidentally in BbS in the world Radiance Garden. Thus preforming an unintentional inheritance to it. Which creates the Keyblade: Destiny's Embrace when Kairi thanks her and gives her flowers for saving her (Later scene in Kingdom Hearts: II too)

    She's not Kairis nobody because she is made of Soras memories, and appears to people differently. Strongest memory dominates the appearance for her.

  • @trinkun Lol, I know XD I just figured that out about a few weeks ago :3

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • i am roxas xion and sora's cosplayer, and i would hate to end up like this, leaving roxas and axel nothing of me exxcept for a shell, which is kairi's

  • why is Xion part Sora? I never got that.

  • @Umi7chaba she is sora's collective memory in physical form

  • aww man, i REALLY want to play kh 358/2 days and kh bbs, in english (not like i´ve already played in japanese), but still, i want to play in PS2! i know that is a impossible dream but, i want it, cuz square enix made us a bunch of kh games i ps2, so why stop now? i´m talking about all the ps2 fans´s shattered hearts that want to play this games much as me!

  • Man...Disney really changed what they said...I actually like the Japanese one better...

  • You know, I actually wanted them to kiss. but no! Or else that would have to rate it teen! lol

  • @kingdomlanelover *jiggles* That and Sora x Kairi would be soooooo wrong because this is about friendship not love.  ^_^

  • Ok soo... People are wondering why Roxas is worried about the ice- cream while Xion is dying... It's because in the beginning of the game Axel tells him that friends eat ice- cream and laugh together, so he really means who will be his friend...

    (Well, this is how I see it)

    xD

  • @gingersydnee0099 You´re totally right my friend.

  • Comment removed

  • wait didnt axel died by Castle Oblivion ( i dont know everything im by day 51)

  • @MrSuperSacredfire You're probably by a later day in the game(or beat it), but why would you watch the other parts anyways if some parts don't correspond correctly?

  • @MrSuperSacredfire nah he was the ONLY survivor he made sure of that or... sora made sure of that >:)

  • Xion! Who else will I have ice cream with?

  • roxas......your best friends dieing and your worried about not eating ice cream???!?!

  • Why in the world was roxas' last to words to xion is, "who will i have ice cream with"

  • @jek19801980

    Well, Roxas can't really trust Axel because of all the lying and events going on, so when his now only friend Xion, someone who he can still trust, dies, his only time being happy was eating ice cream with Axel and Xion.

  • naaww :( i didn't really like xion from the start, but when i started to like her she dies D: that's sad! (sorry for bad english)

  • this scene is rly intense. I havent watched the english one yet (i dont plan to till i get there in the game) but my opinon i dont think roxas and xion will be a good couple. I mean sure in this game yea theyre pretty cute, but thats jst my opinon. Plus if u read the interview on khinsider, nomura explains kinda bout xion's "death"

  • Why do video games teach us more about life than our own parents do? I mean come on, you play all the kingdom hearts games and you learn about how great friends really are and you find so many new ways of looking at life. Beats the whole idea of parents sending you off to school and expecting you to learn this there lol.

  • @HyperZxTole57 jajaja that´s what they told me a few years ago.

  • Haha, I love the jap ending way better than the english one.

    English Version :"Who else will I have Ice Cream with?"

    "Let's have ice cream again...just the three of us..."

  • @PinoyYoung you had to sayy 'jap' . wow .

  • Roxas is in love with Xion. He thought about her throughout the whole game. They would be a good couple though! :D

  • Even without memories Nobodies do act like their original selves. Sora thinks a lot about Kairi as the same Roxas always think about Xion. Xion is based on Sora's memories about Kairi after all...

  • The moment Xion puts her hand on Roxas, I started to cry...

  • I love this scene !

    The english scene killed it though,

    Roxas' line change "Who else will i have icecream with?!"

    I just burst out laughing compared to when i saw this I cried my eyes out...

    I like Roxas line in this "Lets eat icecream again, the three of us!"

    Meaning Roxas isn't ready to accept his friend is dying. So much sadder. ;~;

  • lawl,

    Xion's High at 0:07

  • threre wrong

  • A poem about my dear xion faceless puppet with no past Among those with no heart, A nothing with the silent cast Who sit a World apart. The first of those who sought the truth, She fought with mythic blade; She blocked the darkness nail and tooth And won against the shades. Alas the blade was not her own, 'Twas borrowed from a friend, And this, the tragic seed, was sown, Which would make him her end.
  • @JwhudexNLS

    uggg now the scene is sadder after reading this...damn i hate Square Enix sometime...but damn wat a story

    "K"

  • Square Enix makes you want to be Emo dont it? lol

  • @JwhudexNLS wow that was really good =)

  • @JwhudexNLS (whistles long)wow man

  • @JwhudexNLS you are a master poet

  • why am i thinking ov Hope and Vanille right now oO

  • @RageGS the English version has just as much meaning to it, Roxas left Axel behind and Xion is dissaperaing, he doesn't want to be alone, he is scared of losing both of his friends and having nothing left

  • yeah but the funny thing is, Roxas, instead of confessing his love for Xion, confesses his love for sea-salt ice cream...

    Omg, Roxas... thats a great way to leave your love, "Who else will I have Ice-Cream with?!" WTF, Roxy?

  • I don't think Roxas loves Xion, at least... if he does it's only in a friend way.

    Cause it'd just be weird since they're both Sora...

  • @RoxasandAxelShow

    it's not so bad here, he's just trying to use the memory of eating ice cream together to try and encourage her to live on

  • @RoxasandAxelShow icecream=seasalt ice cream

    roxas loved xion as a dear friend not a lover :3

    the seasalt icecream symbolizes pain as the seasalt represents the salt in tears.

    Thus when he said "who else will i have ice-cream with?!" he meant

    "who else will i cry with?" :3 kinda hard to understand. x]

  • Mmm I do agree with you,

    however it's just a cheesey line change, no where near as emotionally impacting as this version.

  • my sis said that instead of Roxas and Namine it should be Roxas and Xion

    and also how did Xion become cuz isnt she a nobody and cant she use the keyblade cuz my sis said that Xion is the nobody of Sora also cuz in kingdom hearts 1 he lost 2 hearts his and Kairi so roxas was his orginal nobody and Xion was the second cuz she was the second heart Kairis heart yes no i dont know the answer but thats my guess comment back if you think somethin different

  • xion is a replica sorta like the riku replica in kingdom hearts chain of memories but a far superior model she was created in castle oblivon & is made from soras memories of kairi from kh1 she has a keyblade because she is apart of sora roxas is soras nobody...

  • in some scenes you will notice she has her hood down one second then up the next this is because xion changes in the eyes of who is looking at her for example xigbar saw ven when he sees her saix just sees a being in a black coat thats because xion isnt really a girl she changes forms depending on how close to sora you are

  • so your sayin that she is a boy at one part and a girl when she is not near sora his lil sis

  • no i'm saying that depending on whose looking at her she will look like a certain person, she isnt soras little sis hell he doesnt even have a sister she is just a replica that was made from soras strongest memories his strongest memory was of kairi so that why she was basically created from the memoreis sora had of her

  • ooo ok i get it now thanks

  • ohhh thats why.... I was wondering why that happens

  • I love Xion...I'm a Xion's cosplayer.

    She's sooo sweet. I'm so sad for her ç-ç

  • @Laudiele I love you Xion is like my favorite female character in KH

  • @Laudiele totally... I'm a Xion cosplayer too (sometimes)

  • Wow, I don't know which ending I like better! English or this one...both cute and sad

  • @TheDreamer721 I like this one because Roxas says lets have ice cream togther again which is sad but in the engilsh its who else will i have ice cream with

  • I love her little "No..." XD

  • so sora has two nobodys ?

  • @keroro1122

    no sora only has ONE nobody. Xion's not a nobody. But im not gunna spoil anyone on wat she is. ull have to figure that one on ur own.

  • @Twilightdreamer123 i think i know already that Xion is a mess up clone of sora's memory

  • Xion is a construct made of Sora's leaked memories, she isn't actually a nobody.

    Roxas is technically Sora's nobpdy but i wont tell you more then that

  • ;( poor xion

  • xion(member xlv) is so hot

  • when it comes to anime/rpgs, i generally prefer subbed over dubbed, except for satoshikon and ghibli movies, then both are just as good. for one, dub is almost always inferior quality.

    as for kh, im fine listening to dub, but i still prefer sub BECAUSE:

    as an example, in this scene, just the way xion words certain lines, which dub lacks.

    "that alone... plz dont forget it."

    knowing what namine told her, xion wanted to tell roxas that if anything, thats the only thing she'd want him to remember.

  • u really have to learn japanese a bit more if u want to keep subbing(NO OFFENSE)

  • Why? I didn't translate this, I just subbed it. And if you think the official english translation is 100% equal to the japanese, you're wrong. They change the text to fit the lips movements.

  • @Kari7 oooh k, i knew that i saw the voice moving faster than lips XD

  • @Kari7 that's true, I can translate a little bit of it, and it is very different from the USA dialogues

  • @AgentZ009 honeslty bro i beat the game and he got it down pretty well so stfu and watch no one wants yo hear you talk shit

  • @Madara757 Wateva dude...

  • @AgentZ009 thanks you

  • Seriously, I don't get why people fight over which version is better.

    Why don't we all agree that it's a terribly sad scene. *cries over scene again*

  • Personally I Thought that her death in Japanese was a lot more dramatic than the English version

  • she's complicated. xion would have a heart cuz shes not a nobody, shes a replica. so she has her own.

    axel learns how to feel via close contact around those with them (roxas/xion and their abilities to feel), so he can feel his own with sort of a "ghost heart" as long as anchored by another's heart(s) to give it body.

    and whats weird? xion's the fourth of FIVE soras. O_O

    cuz thers sora, then roxas, then her, then data sora in coded, and then thers ven before any of them.

  • The Riku Replica also had emotions. Riku said that the RR's heart would go to be with Riku's.

    Since Xion and the Riku Replica were both made by Vexen does that kind of make them...siblings?

  • ...huh.

    maybe thats why in her dream she crossed over into riku's memories! =OOO

    ive been trying to figure that out forever!

  • I never made that connection before...hmm.

  • I've found a better song for this scene than Xion's theme.

  • well japanese subbed is much better than english thou...

    in english subbed, roxas says "Who else will I have ice cream with?" and japanese subbed says "Let's eat ice cream together again, the three of us"

    i prefer japan subbed this time= =

  • Yeah, me too.

  • Wait, I'm confused. Some people say Xion attacked Roxas because she had gone crazy, but I thought it was because she WANTED to disappear.

    Like back when she was about to fight Axel, she said, "Please don't hold back, Axel. Promise?"

  • okay just 2 clear this up xion is SORA when he is in the chamber he has only 1/4 of is heart ROXAS has 1/2 and xion has 1/4 xion was made because of kairi in soras heart thats why she is a she plus for ppl who like rox/xion theyre the same person but thats okay O_o sorta

  • She's not made of 1/4 of Sora's heart, she's made of Sora's memories of Kairi.

  • @022107 no shes based off of sora's memories, but she lookes like kairi because sora's strongest memory is of kairi

  • That's what I said She's made of Sora's memories based on Kairi.

  • you're a fuckin NASTY person, Jojax333

  • scre namine xions better and should of been roxas' girl

  • AGREED

    After going through the story a bit I realized I like Xion ALOT more than Namine

  • i gotta say this scene is more emotinal than the english. e[pscially the last part where she dies of this cutscencve

    english(who will i have icecream with ) wtf but this one is 10x better

  • so so sad but roxas is dum he should had the chance to kiss her

  • u know what? ur dumb, he doesnt even have a heart from where should he know what love is?

  • He doesn't have a heart but in a special issue of Nintendo Power, it says that Roxas and Namine, due to the strange way that they were born, do in FACT have emotions

  • They co-existed with their Somebodies. Roxas was active while Sora was put to sleep, but still very much himself. Kairi was still living on Destiny Island when Namine was active.

    I read something about that because they co-existed with their Originals, they were able to have more true emotions than the other Nobodies.

  • @SolitaryWinterStar But, their Sombodies are Heartless now. Sora and Kairi were just special

  • Whos somebodies? The other Nobody's Sombodies?

    Well Kairi and Sora never became heartless, or stayed heartless forever until they ceased to exist. So they co-existed.

  • @SolitaryWinterStar It's ibly because Sora became a Heartless and was turned back into a human an Kairi is a princess so she cannot become a heartless

  • I don't know if I follow your point.

  • @SolitaryWinterStar HOW?!?! ITS SO SIMPLE TO UNDERSTAND!!!!

  • so sad T.T

  • Comment removed

  • I usually would be the type of person to say "Kingdom Hearts... >:( so lame, there are like a million people pathetically attempting to english dub anything Axel or Roxas ever says. Get a life..." But I have to whole heartedly say that this is a pretty awesome scene that can really pull at the heart strings. It's actually been placed up in my top 20 must see scenes from games list which I have stored in my brain.

  • TTTTTTTTTT-TTTTTTTTTTTT

  • her theme is soooo sad! poor roxas! love u Xion! I nearly cried! T-T

  • that was so sad........but wait a sec....Roxas cryied at the end and i thought nobodies didnt hav emotions??? anyway i wudnt hav blamed him i almost cryied myself :(

  • that's what makes him a mystery. Axel and namine speculated that he might have a heart.

  • kual

  • Remember Roxas is Sora's Nobody which means he's a special type of Nobody, so that means he does have emotions like Sora, get it? :)

  • yea i think so

  • Its kind of funny cause since Roxas and Xion was from sora doesn't it mean that Roxas was in love with himself? XD other then that I am about ready to cry my eyes out just thinking about it,

  • dun take this the wrong way, but that kinda makes sora a threesome by himself...

    then just add their semes axel and riku.

    ...ok i admit, that last part mighta gone too far. XD

  • She's dieing and all Roxas wants is eat ICE CREAM!?!? I find that funny, yet mean at the same time.

    Poor Xion T_T

  • Saying that showed her just how hard he was trying to remember her.

  • i am baling my eyes out i am so sad

  • poor Roxas

  • when xion touched roxas's face and then "died" and he grabbed hr hand i lost it.