she sings punk cabaret. sing in the right tone is not her first objective.. she cares much more to the feelings of it.. the clothes, the wrong notes and everything are part of her, and it make an fantastic expression in my opinion...
If you're going to dress like that, you'd better bringing a lot more to the table on vocals than that. Especially with a world class cellist behind you. Fail. =/
@redbarronz125 I'ts Amanda Fucking Palmer, she makes music because she enjoys it...
The fact that her vocals sound bad to you are exactly the reason her fans love her, she does what she wants to do and sings how she wants to sing.
Her attitude is one of ''If you don't like me, fuck off!''
And obviously Zoe Keating heard her music before agreeing to play with her... The fact that she's playing with her proves there's a talent there that you don't understand.
I'm confused. Why are people slagging this off so much? What is honestly wrong with this? Amanda doesn't sound off-key, the microphone is just really bad.
@ukpnumber1 I totally agree. NOT a good cover at all. I like some of Amanda's stuff but for some reason she comes off as a bit arrogant or egotistical in this cover. Not sure which.
@jenn2604 sadly Amanda is not consistent, the first time I saw her I actually flew from Florida to LA to see what I thought was her last show for a while, FANTASTIC SHOW worth every penny. then 2 months later she came to town and was HORRIBLE. Her performance was flat and she lacked the energy I think this show was a week or two before .
I love how wrenching her voice sounds, like mournful. It puts so much more into this song. And I also love how she doesn't shave her armpits like every f-ing girl on the planet. That takes guts. And she's still so incredibly beautiful.
this version doesn't quite compare to the sound of 10,000 people singing along with matt at glasto. But its an interesting choice of instruments. I agree with the dude below you got to have the bass in it, everyone knows the bass to this tune
who the fuck does she think she is butchering a great fucking song like this i mean this is the song that got me into muse and she fuckin ruined it this should be taken off youtube its so bad
if you only like muse, go listen to muse. we love amanda fucking palmer and if you don't, then get the hell off her youtube pages ^-^. i love this cover.
Amanda Palmer is an amazing singer. This video has crappy audio, for one thing...just because she is doing something different doesn't mean it's bad. Maybe not for everyone. But not bad. I love Muse as well, and this is a powerful take on the song. ^_^
i really love how tastefully people bash amanda palmer just because she covers an amazing song and they dont like it as well as the original. this woman is an amazing singer and just this video makes her sound like shit doesnt mean anything. also, she is veerrrrrryyy artistic in everything as an artist and if people cannot appreciate something different than shame on them!!
certainly a very brave cover...some of the cello chords, double stops and such have great punch to them...i like it at least as much as the original! good show!
;-; Oh god, Please sing more Muse songs *dies*
<3 <3 <3 <3
shadowbarrowman 5 months ago
she sings punk cabaret. sing in the right tone is not her first objective.. she cares much more to the feelings of it.. the clothes, the wrong notes and everything are part of her, and it make an fantastic expression in my opinion...
maarisiqueira 6 months ago
wow
TheMulhollands 9 months ago
probably the best combination...awww
nicemimomisu 10 months ago
live=amazing
goegul101 11 months ago
Zoe Keating deserves better... Just sayin...
Shorty39624 11 months ago
If you're going to dress like that, you'd better bringing a lot more to the table on vocals than that. Especially with a world class cellist behind you. Fail. =/
redbarronz125 1 year ago 2
@redbarronz125 I'ts Amanda Fucking Palmer, she makes music because she enjoys it...
The fact that her vocals sound bad to you are exactly the reason her fans love her, she does what she wants to do and sings how she wants to sing.
Her attitude is one of ''If you don't like me, fuck off!''
And obviously Zoe Keating heard her music before agreeing to play with her... The fact that she's playing with her proves there's a talent there that you don't understand.
FinnyIicious 1 month ago
I'm confused. Why are people slagging this off so much? What is honestly wrong with this? Amanda doesn't sound off-key, the microphone is just really bad.
It's a damn good cover of a damn good song.
Laneh 1 year ago
i wish the sound quality was better, it makes her notes all fuzzy..
NevanImranTheCambion 1 year ago
my life just completed itself. i can die now. i love them so much. just like exfooxg said..
maryfks14 1 year ago
what a disgrace. her voice doesn't do her justice. she butchered the song.
7shadowslover 1 year ago
Sorry...not a fan.
BeautifulTragedyx21 1 year ago 4
How awful. Out of key and doing a morrissey impression to boot!
ukpnumber1 1 year ago
@ukpnumber1 I totally agree. NOT a good cover at all. I like some of Amanda's stuff but for some reason she comes off as a bit arrogant or egotistical in this cover. Not sure which.
LOVE ZOE! Such an awesome cellist.
jenn2604 1 year ago
@jenn2604 sadly Amanda is not consistent, the first time I saw her I actually flew from Florida to LA to see what I thought was her last show for a while, FANTASTIC SHOW worth every penny. then 2 months later she came to town and was HORRIBLE. Her performance was flat and she lacked the energy I think this show was a week or two before .
suku7764 1 year ago
i was there:)
rocanlover345 1 year ago
not a bad cover but it doesnt hold a candle to the original [2]
francolinonogueira 1 year ago
horrible voice dude :(
marcoabl123 1 year ago
not a bad cover but it doesnt hold a candle to the original
XxFuzzballsxX 1 year ago 4
Amanda Palmer is hawt.
manueleslava 1 year ago
Amanda Palmer and Zoe Keating. Together, they can cover any song and be amazing. <3
HaysoosLovesYou 1 year ago
I love how wrenching her voice sounds, like mournful. It puts so much more into this song. And I also love how she doesn't shave her armpits like every f-ing girl on the planet. That takes guts. And she's still so incredibly beautiful.
xSnipSnipx 2 years ago 2
i love this pairing of amanda and zoe!
ammre 2 years ago
I prefer her cover of Creep, that song works better for her vocally. But I still love her. x3
XxShishouxX 2 years ago
This is sexy. :3
xtehsex 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
WTF?
ok a girl in bra on stage who sings like hell
what's the point? except maybe looking at her tits
painsek 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Amanda Palmer ruins every piece of music she touches. Love the original song and the cellist.
And just in case her complete lack of talent is ignored somehow, you wont miss her most awful of fashionalbe choices.
blehbre 2 years ago
this is an amazing cover of an amazing song
jekyllcorvus 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
she should be done for attempted murder of this wonderful song!:O:(
carbitor 2 years ago
Clean out your ears man... it wasnt murder... it was in Praise of a really cool song!
larryoduncan 1 year ago
my friends went to coachella this year withut me and got to see amanda live. I was so fucking jealous!
Mattymunch67 2 years ago
el audio de la camara es un asco
bionicle72 2 years ago
this version doesn't quite compare to the sound of 10,000 people singing along with matt at glasto. But its an interesting choice of instruments. I agree with the dude below you got to have the bass in it, everyone knows the bass to this tune
jonobonnowonno1 2 years ago
i would LOVE a studio version of this! i adore the original song and this is such a different take on it! afp ftw <3
trelipapia 2 years ago 2
amazing cover
wiLdLikeoatmeaL 2 years ago 2
Very experimental and very Amanda. I like it.
xdmatthew 2 years ago
This is fucking awesome.
SonOfAPunk 2 years ago
I rarely like Muse covers, Muse are just incredible and no one can come close, but this is a damn good attempt
One of the few covers I really like
Shiney2510 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
crap crap crap her voice is terrible
xXTallManXx 2 years ago
Her voice is amazing...
You don't have to sound like you came off an assembly line to be a talented musician...
Shes origional.... get over it...
Shes amazing! ^^,
raynbow105 2 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
who the fuck does she think she is butchering a great fucking song like this i mean this is the song that got me into muse and she fuckin ruined it this should be taken off youtube its so bad
murloc1 2 years ago
if you only like muse, go listen to muse. we love amanda fucking palmer and if you don't, then get the hell off her youtube pages ^-^. i love this cover.
xbanxsanityx 2 years ago 4
You're a terrible excuse for a Muse fan...
She just interpreted it in a different way, and as a fan of muse and amanda It makes me extatic to think she's in to them.
It's an amazing cover and I think matt would enjoy it and be flattered...
Go cool off.. youtubers need to sort out all this pent up anger...
raynbow105 2 years ago 4
AFP is a hugely powerful voice and I love Zoe on cello! Fan Fucking Tastic!
morbidwonder 2 years ago 5
The audio quality isn't good, but this is still an amazing cover.
Man, I love Amanda Palmer.
ClinicallyChaotic 2 years ago 5
i like the bass rift on the bass guitar better
myspacceer 2 years ago
This is the best version of this song I've heard.
SpasticSeamonkey 2 years ago
Amanda Palmer is an amazing singer. This video has crappy audio, for one thing...just because she is doing something different doesn't mean it's bad. Maybe not for everyone. But not bad. I love Muse as well, and this is a powerful take on the song. ^_^
ShikamaruRain 2 years ago 4
i really love how tastefully people bash amanda palmer just because she covers an amazing song and they dont like it as well as the original. this woman is an amazing singer and just this video makes her sound like shit doesnt mean anything. also, she is veerrrrrryyy artistic in everything as an artist and if people cannot appreciate something different than shame on them!!
beautifullie180 2 years ago 2
haha, just because she did her own interpretation people act like dicks. intense imperfection is the brilliance of this lady.
I think its great. very afp.
wettyh 2 years ago 6
This comment has received too many negative votes show
jaja bad singer whore
illchewie 2 years ago
i want her long socks. where does she get those i wonder...
dorisblake 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
oh lord, i hope she watches this and takes some singing lessons....
jujubmuse 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this version sucks
sotoccer 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
wow, she is way off pitch 3/4ths of the time. Ouch. Give me Muse and get her out of the world
dhechler 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I love the Cello chords and I want to hear the cello chords and Matt's voice... I don't like her voice
shakugan666 2 years ago
Hi! come too see me singing too if you want :)
valerie098765 2 years ago
much better than the original
(but maybe it's because that song is so overplayed on the radio...
matt bellamy's falsetto does tend to grate on the ears after the first hundred times)
24asteria 2 years ago 4
hell no. the original is a hell alot better, and bellamy is the better singer.
but this cover is good.
josephXbliss 2 years ago 3
This is so vastly different and so so fun too...
turnoffthetv 2 years ago 12
hmm this is a bit weird, bit out of tune but it sounds pretty cool
wagoneers 2 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I was excited to hear this as I always like a good cover - but that truly was TERRIBLE!! She's so out of tune.
lostintimidation 2 years ago
this made my rough day a little better. thanks Beth.
seventeenpercent 2 years ago 3
The quality on this is awful.
I love AFP, but this does absolutely no justice to her voice.
geniat 2 years ago 4
wow, she makes a bearable song into an actually good one!! :D I love Amanda Palmer!
ReiversMusic 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
WTF is this shit?
Man this is making Coachella Music Festival looking bad.
alexq1350 2 years ago
this rocked my whole day
McCabeCRM 2 years ago 6
This comment has received too many negative votes show
-_-
this fucking sucks......................
Apx911 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
The best part is the CELLO SOLO.
(Because there is no singing in that part)
syntheticjesso 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
O.o ....... No.
krickonaut 2 years ago
AFP + ZOE KEATING + MUSE = PERFECTION
exfooxg 2 years ago 21
This comment has received too many negative votes show
wtf... i really dun understand this kind of cover tht people call good
honestly this sounds like someone who use crap before singing
lxworld2808 2 years ago
I LOVE THIS WOMAN! My god she can do no wrong
baconlady11 2 years ago 6
This is fucking great. She always does amazing covers. Wish I was there!
Rehabinc 2 years ago 4
Love this cover :)
kiiabby 2 years ago
what a BEAUTIFUL cello cover of such a great Muse song!! Amanda Palmer fucking ROCKS!!
freakincages 2 years ago 6
Ab Fab!
dymphnasis 2 years ago
Three of the best things ever: Amanda, Muse, and cello rock covers. I love this.
ghvorim 2 years ago 4
Man this is rad. Zoe FTW
Freethinkingskeptic 2 years ago
BEST THING EVER.
MystikEel 2 years ago
The only thing that could have made this better would be if Zoe followed through on her threat to perform naked.
kurometarikku 2 years ago 6
HAHAHAHA!!!!! Here here! *raises glass*
TormentedByDemons 2 years ago 4
fucking amazing
lobschta 2 years ago 2
Just because it's such a beautiful and intense song and the clapping spoils it a bit...
Suih 2 years ago
oh my, amanda palmer is covering my favorite band... i think i have died and gone to heaven :)
StarlingMaster 2 years ago 3
same here X)
MuseMunchkin 2 years ago 3
That totally made my day. Amanda is fucking amazing <3
The clapping is rather disturbing though -.-
Suih 2 years ago
Why?
DaveO15 2 years ago
-orgasm- HA.. ily Amanda :D
DuncanMcFarlane1 2 years ago 2
<3 Zoe and Amanda
GoldfishGirlIOM 2 years ago 2
fuckin brill!!!!!!!!!
aliasjc 2 years ago
'Awesome' does not even begin to properly describe this clip.
arthursucks 2 years ago 2
amanda fucking palmer you are AWESOME!
MissTorrance 2 years ago
certainly a very brave cover...some of the cello chords, double stops and such have great punch to them...i like it at least as much as the original! good show!
THEMARSHALLOFJOHNIAN 2 years ago
Another urgent, scorching, rebellious message which may or may not be directed at Roadrunner Records. ;)
I wish I'd been there. Actually I'm glad I wasn't there, because I would have exploded into a million pieces when Zoe started playing.
TormentedByDemons 2 years ago
Happy dance - my favourite singer covering one of my favourite songs :)
totalfrog 2 years ago
FUCKING AWEEESOMMME!
LimboLinda 2 years ago
this is bad ass!!
SimonRivas 2 years ago
this cover is delicious. i don't even know what that means. it's just amazing.
theflawintheplan 2 years ago 4