*超級星光大道-敗部PK賽-潘裕文-安全感

[kas123459]

當初一直在晚上廣播 一直聽到這首歌

親愛的 一直在耳邊繞樑，後來才知道是 潘裕文 唱的

很多人都說唱的比原唱好，我也這麼覺得XD

[jennifer20281]

我是聽潘裕文唱了之後才去聽王力宏，我覺得潘唱起來，會有畫面，­開著車在一條公路上，然後邊流淚～

[Cantoner]

那時潘裕文還比不上小美小許

[juiharry]

個人覺得還是王力宏的比較好聽 潘也不錯啦

[kay2907]

阿潘cd的version已經唱得比這個好了~~

[tam1234hk]

@kay2907 cd版和比賽以後的live演唱的確很不錯

可是這一段演唱就不太突出了

[xatwo187]

誰唱的好都是個人主觀問題

[myacnt8999]

please watch leehom's version in his recent concert. excellent quality.

watch?v=3vD5fDZaBUc&feature=re­lated

[max0715]

唔知而家既阿潘唱返安全感又會係咩感覺呢

[aoimiyazakiissohot]

如果單比聲音, 聲線, 潘欲文跟王力宏沒有什麼好比的 王力宏歌聲比較好是大家都知道的事實. 只是有時候也是要看怎麼發揮 像潘欲文唱這首歌 我個人是覺得還不錯 雖然我自己也是王力宏的歌迷

[a83911123]

配上潘獨特的氣質

與這首歌的背音

就先大大的加了分

[l0vel0rn520]

我覺得是各有特色,

本人較喜歡阿潘唱這首安全感.

大家不用爭執吧,

這些都是因人而異,

很主觀的感覺。

[winnie95130]

小潘好適合唱這首歌

比原唱還有感覺

(我不是故意說原唱不好)

[winnie95130]

每個人都有自己唱歌的風格

我沒有說原唱不好

我的意思只是說小潘的風格我很喜歡而已

我也喜歡王力宏啊

只是我對他這首歌的風格比起小潘沒有這麼喜歡而已

[0988720560]

不要嘴砲好不好

[winnie95130]

說真的,就算真的不喜歡也不會直接罵吧?

這樣不是很傷人心嗎?

[0988720560]

@winnie95130 低能

[abcddddaaa]

peter pan is so good!

[tototo383]

超好聽~I like him!!!!!!!!!

[myacnt8999]

but leehom is still better, because leehom's vocal range is wider than peter's.

[myacnt8999]

peter is good! this song is so hard to sing. i think his voice is better than yoga, although yoga is very good too. it's my opinion.

[myacnt8999]

you mean pan yiwen, right? yeah.leehom has more technique..but pan yiwen sings amazingly nowadays. better than this.

[connie1996913]

this is one pk one it is not 敗部pk

[skinwon1]

Peter .you are so good!:D

[fabianlam619]

out d de 1st ep 夏雨诗

[vampireknightzero]

one of the best songs he had sung!

[zhutouxx]

潘裕文, GOOD! :D Hope he comes out with his own personal album~

[zeddydd]

so good. he sings even better now. his cd version is so good!!

[hasu360]

我覺得原唱王力宏在演唱這首歌上有相當的演唱技巧和純熟度。畢竟­是他創作的作品，加上本身是專業的音樂人。

潘裕文在演唱他這首歌時，保持了他原本夢幻式的歌唱風格，聽來和­他的綽號潘王子很符合喔!

兩個人唱得都很好聽~^^

[XiaoJieee]

哇。。。

他好帥喔 <3

[1ceZzyu]

我个人觉得这首歌潘裕文除了技巧其他的都没问题

因为他我才喜欢上这首歌

我也很喜欢王力宏

但是这首歌两个人诠释的方式都不同

力宏的会比较忧愁悲伤

裕文诠释得比较新鲜

我超爱听啊潘唱这首歌 !

加油哦 !

期待你的个人专辑

[jawbraker84]

我也是覺得這樣，是他讓我喜歡上這首歌的。。。潘裕文加油吧

[aerozx0]

潘玉文唱這首歌...好像把它變成一首輕快的歌了

我聽聽原唱 他把這首歌的感覺變的非常柔和 我個人認為這首歌有他的淺力在 我非常admire潘裕文能把這首歌用另外一種方式呈現 但是我還是覺得在唱的時候像 主旋律把的放的輕一點 能夠更突現那種溫柔和輕快感

[ntnuhyd]

我覺得這首歌就是他的歌~~~~~

蠻適合這種歌路的。

希望他的專輯會出現和這樣適合他的歌~~

[ceciliayam]

great!!!!!!!!!

[ohretro]

OMG, he sang this so nice.

It's hard to do a good job on Leehom's songs because Leehom is so amazing already.

Love Peter's voice, it's so smooth & soothing, but powerful as well.

Ahh, love Peter. He's so talented & so gorgeous.

[aznpower92]

He's not bad, but still lacks some skill/techniques that make An Quan Gan a good song. More practice I guess?

[girlslulubelle]

nice=]

[fish81099]

不錯聽

可是..心的距離.能縮"短"

那個"短"怎麼聽都覺得怪怪的耶

也許是我耳殘..

[pangster2]

我很喜歡他阿!

[brian79104]

well of course, comparing with leehom, i mean no one can compare with leehom, but he definitely did a great job singing this song

[MedivhLee]

他唱的安全感卻少了原唱的哪一種Feeling,這首歌本應該有­一種黯然的悲傷和狂野的感覺.LeeHom在原唱中的那一種急刹­車的感覺就非常好的詮釋了這點,而潘在每一句的結尾唱的都很柔和­,失去了這首歌的獨特的感覺.

不過這是唯一的缺點吧.

[vvv777000]

每個人詮釋的方法不同，我覺得那不算是缺點

王力宏的版本在我聽來很絕望，尾音斷得很明顯

像是一格一格在看電影慢速播放一樣

而潘裕文的版本卻意外帶出了歌曲的那一小部份的希望

這首歌沒有悲傷到那種程度(光看歌詞部份)，奔放的感覺倒是有出­來

兩個版本有不同的感覺，不一定翻唱就要照著原唱的方法去唱

[gy20022]

龜啦！我也覺得他唱的不怎麼樣

[boy0boy0]

dont be a hater please (: it aint gonna do anybody any good .

maybe you think you are just voicing out your feelings but

its assumed that you are jealous . so yea, why create such image for yourself ? be smart and get a life man (:

[gy20022]

請問到目前為止，是否你所遇到的每個人都能令你十分讚賞，都能讓­你佩服不已？如果不是，代表你也在忌妒他們嗎？

我確實只是說出我個人的看法，別人要怎麼想也不是我能決定的，但­如果連自己的感覺都不能誠實面對的話...人生會有多smart­？我不敢茍同

[AznMed]

well, no one can be perfect; i actually think that considering different opinions are important for making the right judgment. i'm not supporting anyone... just a thought. also, please just use "jealous" instead of "hater", since it has a negative connotation that's really unjustified (i.e., hating what is bad is actually good, agree?)

[carolinewr]

nice!!

[zhengyih87]

I cant deny he sing good, but the unique part of this song is the ending with high vocal range and he never sang it! So i feel tat overall is still ok! So i feel tat leehom sing better alot alot alot!!!

[zhengyih87]

王力宏比較好聽!!!!!!

[dalun21]

yup!pan yu wen! chao hao ting! :]

[fff0722]

好聽耶～

[fff0722]

GOOD!

[starwishzzz]

so nice :D

[carolloveyou]

很好！

真的很適合唱這首歌！

[WFROE527]

比較喜歡王力宏唱的感覺

[BrandaWu]

好聽好聽

[TMJFTONY]

他唱這首在適合不過了.真的好聽!!

[sally0822]

超好聽!