Believe me I like Jane, but in this song she sounds pretty flat. Not saying it's a bad performance, because it isn't at all, but it's definitely not on par with Faye's or 蔡幸娟's renditions, much less Teresa's.
Jane's a very good singer but this ain't her song.
天大的笑话,为什么老说经典不能超越总要压后来者半头呢?人类文明一天天发展,为什么各方面都超越古人,唱歌那么简单的事就无法超越了呢?是现代人的迷信想法?还是个人崇拜不允许自己立起来的神被打破的心理在作祟呢? 这首歌能唱的好的人多的是,登能唱到张靓颖这种感觉?比如印象西湖雨?your song?take it like a man? 我看未必。
天大的笑话,为什么老说经典不能超越总要压后来者半头呢?人类文明一天天发展,为什么各方面都超越古人,唱歌那么简单的事就无法超越了呢?是现代人的迷信想法?还是个人崇拜不允许自己立起来的神被打破的心理在作祟呢? 这首歌能唱的好的人多的是,登能唱到张靓颖这种感觉?比如印象西湖雨?your song?take it like a man? 我看未必。
天大的笑话,为什么老说经典不能超越总要压后来者半头呢?人类文明一天天发展,为什么各方面都超越古人,唱歌那么简单的事就无法超越了呢?是现代人的迷信想法?还是个人崇拜不允许自己立起来的神被打破的心理在作祟呢? 这首歌能唱的好的人多的是,登能唱到张靓颖这种感觉?比如印象西湖雨?your song?take it like a man? 我看未必。
She is just average with very flat singing of this song. Her voice is neither soothing nor touching. There is no way to compare with Teresa Teng, none at all ... ... ...
To the contrary, Jane's strength is in Chinese songs. Jane's technique has surpassed Teresa. As for "feelings or emotions", that's very subjective; and Jane is still young. Jane has sung songs that Teresa wouldn't feel comfortable to attempt..
I love Jane's voice, but comparing her to Teresa Tang on this song, she is not half way there yet.. I don't feel enough feelings or emotions.. Her strength is English songs.. love her song "Loving You"..
I got an ear for music? Yes, I'm fccxxking serious. Actually, it's the experts who're more fxxking serious. if u'r open minded enough, u'd be fxxking serious as well. BTW, I'm a fan for both Teresa & Faye.
Jane is a great singer, she sings 天下无双 beautifully and also she has a very lively personality, but her voice is not sweet like the one of Teresa Teng. Teresa voice touch your heart and soul.
well, that's a given considering she, like every other singer out there uses singing as their ultimate way of expressing themselves to the fullest. More then half of the artists in the music industries no matter where in the world are not good at verbal communication, hence why they use music.
no teresa those day, no jane today
adulchang 8 months ago
finally ...,,,i find someone can sing teresa teng songs......2 thumb up..jane
OffTheShip 11 months ago 2
她有她的特點,聽她自己的歌 畫皮 就知道有多好聽了。 我雖然不是70年代而是90後但是鄧麗君在內地的確非常有名。以前小時候會聽到小姨她們唱一倆句。能唱鄧麗君那麼好聽那就太強了。應該也沒幾個吧。
unei1321 1 year ago 2
拜託不要汙辱台灣鄧麗君..光唱第一句我就聽不下去了.
james650203 1 year ago
@james650203
真是无知,不怕货比货,怕你不识货。
去多听下她的代表作吧。
nightsucks 11 months ago 2
Jane is definitely way much much better than Teresa Deng and Faye , her colourful voices enable her to sing all kind of songs
if u guys understand Jane 's voice well enough , you will understand why I dare to say that and I am pretty confidence many people will agree with me
nightsucks 1 year ago
很漂亮呀 我喜歡
SMALLWHITE6921 1 year ago
Believe me I like Jane, but in this song she sounds pretty flat. Not saying it's a bad performance, because it isn't at all, but it's definitely not on par with Faye's or 蔡幸娟's renditions, much less Teresa's.
Jane's a very good singer but this ain't her song.
shinsenrc 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
天大的笑话,为什么老说经典不能超越总要压后来者半头呢?人类文明一天天发展,为什么各方面都超越古人,唱歌那么简单的事就无法超越了呢?是现代人的迷信想法?还是个人崇拜不允许自己立起来的神被打破的心理在作祟呢? 这首歌能唱的好的人多的是,登能唱到张靓颖这种感觉?比如印象西湖雨?your song?take it like a man? 我看未必。
nightsucks 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
天大的笑话,为什么老说经典不能超越总要压后来者半头呢?人类文明一天天发展,为什么各方面都超越古人,唱歌那么简单的事就无法超越了呢?是现代人的迷信想法?还是个人崇拜不允许自己立起来的神被打破的心理在作祟呢? 这首歌能唱的好的人多的是,登能唱到张靓颖这种感觉?比如印象西湖雨?your song?take it like a man? 我看未必。
nightsucks 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
天大的笑话,为什么老说经典不能超越总要压后来者半头呢?人类文明一天天发展,为什么各方面都超越古人,唱歌那么简单的事就无法超越了呢?是现代人的迷信想法?还是个人崇拜不允许自己立起来的神被打破的心理在作祟呢? 这首歌能唱的好的人多的是,登能唱到张靓颖这种感觉?比如印象西湖雨?your song?take it like a man? 我看未必。
nightsucks 1 year ago
great prtty!
and cutty very fine girl.
amp3cx10000a7jp 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
少裝了,要唱別人的歌連名字都不知還敢唱,難怪會唱的那麼難聽,你有努力過嗎?回去多聽幾百遍吧?
h49149190 2 years ago
tw fag suck my dick
U2B8 2 years ago
@h49149190
说得好
cjxing3211 1 year ago
She is just average with very flat singing of this song. Her voice is neither soothing nor touching. There is no way to compare with Teresa Teng, none at all ... ... ...
CherryMangoLover 2 years ago 2
its funny to see tone deaf ppl like u commenting here, Jane is the best, period
U2B8 2 years ago
@CherryMangoLover concur!
angchu1 1 year ago
這分明就是...張靓穎.....什麼廣州鄧麗君呀???
franklau1013 2 years ago
她的拉音需要改进。。。此外她胡乱在不该的时候吸气! 不够柔。。没有邓丽君的"功夫"... :(
polaris0126 2 years ago
her voice is definitely sweeter than teresa deng or faye wong , her voice is inter changeable , god damn it i just duno how to describe her voice ,
her 民歌alone seriously i heard over more than 20 voices she had sang
nightsucks 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
唉!連鄧麗君的名字都不敢講,音樂果然仍被政治操弄!!
traveling7841 2 years ago
你还活在什么年代啊?
太可笑了。
一看就知道你是个土包子,从来没有见过世面的!
可悲啊!
ava174 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
To the contrary, Jane's strength is in Chinese songs. Jane's technique has surpassed Teresa. As for "feelings or emotions", that's very subjective; and Jane is still young. Jane has sung songs that Teresa wouldn't feel comfortable to attempt..
anoneagle 2 years ago
This is not "鄧麗君" as title says.
dchuang8 2 years ago
I love Jane's voice, but comparing her to Teresa Tang on this song, she is not half way there yet.. I don't feel enough feelings or emotions.. Her strength is English songs.. love her song "Loving You"..
sunshineca8 2 years ago
Comment removed
anoneagle 2 years ago
I just compared Jane with Faye and Teresa. Jane is the best. Her voice has such unbelievable quality.
anoneagle 3 years ago
Are you fxxking serious? What kind of ears you got?
joft625 2 years ago
I got an ear for music? Yes, I'm fccxxking serious. Actually, it's the experts who're more fxxking serious. if u'r open minded enough, u'd be fxxking serious as well. BTW, I'm a fan for both Teresa & Faye.
anoneagle 2 years ago
all these years Jane is the only singer that has so many kind of colours inside her vocals , i have never seen such a singer like this
nightsucks 2 years ago
Jane is a great singer, she sings 天下无双 beautifully and also she has a very lively personality, but her voice is not sweet like the one of Teresa Teng. Teresa voice touch your heart and soul.
wwwtips 2 years ago 3
一把出色的聲是開聲的就知道是誰,
因為那是獨一無二的, 模仿的都只是那被模仿的名字而矣, 這裡唱的是誰, 合著眼來聽,
認不出來.
lcsthomas 2 years ago
她唱出來用情不夠呢!
lcsthomas 2 years ago
確かに、カラオケレベルなのかもしれません。
ただ、涼粉はリャンインが"我只在乎你"を歌ってくれただけで、十分満足なのです。
また、成都で聞いたときは、Pubの観客がみんな会話をやめて聞き入るほど上手かったですよ。
momolyfans 3 years ago 2
カラオケレベル。正直にこの歌に関して彼女より私のほううまい。
就這首歌来説、唱得没有我好。
yasanma 3 years ago
おまえはカラオケレベルに違いない、彼女は歌姫
U2B8 3 years ago
really? may be only this one.
vi0l0ncell0 2 years ago
she's good at singing but not speaking.
manthrineye 3 years ago 5
well, that's a given considering she, like every other singer out there uses singing as their ultimate way of expressing themselves to the fullest. More then half of the artists in the music industries no matter where in the world are not good at verbal communication, hence why they use music.
MizTressX 3 years ago
I love her singing whatsoever. No offence. Just thought in that way. Cheers!
manthrineye 3 years ago 5
lol none taken, I was just stating my thoughts as well.
MizTressX 3 years ago
最後にすごいのをアップしたな!
retlyfan 3 years ago