nice lecture but i disagree with that point that poet can not explain philosophy in their poetry. for that i must recommend him to study prof. ali arshad mir's book (ik katha de war) hope he will find satisfactory answer for rest of his life
It seems unbelievable that Mr Jinnah fought on the basis of two nation theory and upon the creation of Pakistan proposed a "secular" country. If secular country was the goal, then why bother struggling for Pakistan? Hindus were willing to establish a secular India!! What Jinnah must have meant is that minorities and are Pakistanis and are free to persue their religion and the state will not interfere !! In any case Pakistan is now a reality and we need to decide what kind of country we want
One of the problems with us Pakistanis is that of utter confusion. We can't make up our mind how progresseive we want to be against how traditional. We cannot achieve a goal if it is not set or clear. Confusion results in more confusion and loss of resources, time and achieving meaningful progress. We seem to mean well but are divided over how best to achieve it including religious parties.
I am a Trotskyte myself and we condemn fundamentalism and US imperialism alike. Both are faces of one coin. This is official stance of International Marxist Tendency
Comment removed
Dathinkingman 3 weeks ago
nice lecture but i disagree with that point that poet can not explain philosophy in their poetry. for that i must recommend him to study prof. ali arshad mir's book (ik katha de war) hope he will find satisfactory answer for rest of his life
geniusarshad786 2 months ago
It seems unbelievable that Mr Jinnah fought on the basis of two nation theory and upon the creation of Pakistan proposed a "secular" country. If secular country was the goal, then why bother struggling for Pakistan? Hindus were willing to establish a secular India!! What Jinnah must have meant is that minorities and are Pakistanis and are free to persue their religion and the state will not interfere !! In any case Pakistan is now a reality and we need to decide what kind of country we want
mubashir56 5 months ago
One of the problems with us Pakistanis is that of utter confusion. We can't make up our mind how progresseive we want to be against how traditional. We cannot achieve a goal if it is not set or clear. Confusion results in more confusion and loss of resources, time and achieving meaningful progress. We seem to mean well but are divided over how best to achieve it including religious parties.
mubashir56 5 months ago
A wise study presented by Dr. Mubarak Ali.
BishopIjaz 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I am a Trotskyte myself and we condemn fundamentalism and US imperialism alike. Both are faces of one coin. This is official stance of International Marxist Tendency
goodmemories215 5 months ago
Comment removed
goodmemories215 5 months ago
Comment removed
goodmemories215 5 months ago