Added: 4 years ago
From: CaptainDisillusion
Views: 110,786
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (444)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • The plane disappeared after it passed the tree at the end. That fact doesn't matter because by today's standards of CGI, the plane is obviously fake.

  • As the Nostalgia Critic once said; "So they board the shamefully fake CGI plane".

  • It has to be fake because there was no wind blowing the bushes

  • ....and when the person filming just happens to leave enough room in the frame to anticipate something unforeseeable about to happen at stage left or stage right. Or when the camera perfectly tracks some mishap, with no delayed reaction or shakiness. And consider the video where the best man trips and knocks the bride and minister into the water. He barely even touches the bride and they both fall over too easily, with no instinctive attempt to keep from falling.

  • Good stuff, I'm always looking for the give-aways in internet videos. Like when a witness to something "horrible" makes it a point to turn back to the camera, wringing their hands or gasping in horror or any number of other bad acting techniques. And often you have to wonder how did the camera just happen to be there, filming something nondescript until it happened to catch this incredible accident/fall/mishap.

  • Notice how there is no wind from it, particularly in the bush in the final shot...

  • that break in the screen scared me...but i like the "WHAT!?" phrase

  • It doesn't even look real

  • dirt not being flung up by 4 massive engines, do more in depth analysis.

  • "Uncertain case?" Very surprised to hear the "not detailed enough to draw a solid conclusion" There is one very obvious factor that shows its a clever animation. If you look at the shadow of the plane on the ground to gauge distance, that would be about 1/3 of the scale of the real plane. 

  • @bisesik Don't act like a know-it-all.

  • this is the first time i saw that video and i clearly saw the animation

  • @PaaTal2010 MIB = Men In Black

  • I repeat: You are a total HOAX. Surely this plane video shown here is ABSOLUTELY TRUE. The question about the inconvenience of children seeing some kind of YouTube videos concerns only and exclusively to their respective PARENTS. We don't need, -nor we don't want- stupid government's agencies becoming MUM AND DAD for us. OK you ... stupid people? Trying to protect children from seeing reality you are in fact DECEIVING the whole population. That's what you want with your ridiculous campaigns?

  • @PaaTal2010 reality? no, seriously, reality? only JETS can make something like that at this speed, you idiot. have you ever flied before? do you know that commercial or pasengers ships like that WOULD NEVER risk their cargo/passengers to do a shitty stunt?

  • @alastarian1 Nooooo!! I've never flied in all my life! Sorry IMBECIL. I don't give a damn shit about this concrete video, having in mind that this account is OBVIOUSLY a sacandalous attempt of debunking REAL CASES sponsored by our dear intelligence agencies. Have you seen the rest of videos exposed in this channel SUBNORMAL? Don't you still know what the word 'COVER-UP' means, piece of RETARDED?

    Why don't you tell your mumm to buy you a new BRAIN? We don't need "governments-daddies" idiot!

  • @PaaTal2010 oh, my ass, you see what you want to see. you really think that the MIB paid a guy to paint half his face and convince us that ghosts aren't real?

    Grow up, kid.

  • @alastarian1 The MIB? Who are those? Are they they your friends maybe?

    And you... Do you understand a single SHIT about SpFXs technics? I'm not talking about this video. I'm talking about "HAITHI UFO" video. Did you see that one? Do you consider it as a good "demo" of the falacity of that sightings? Yes? You want to know some more about it? Did you never know about governments propaganda issued all around the media in order to make believe a lot of lies to stupid guys like you? Want to start?

  • He says the clip is fake but the plane has a fuckin shadow I bet this guy would say 9/11 was a hoax "c'mon guys concrete and steel doesn't burn" wat a dumb-ass

  • that clip is fake as hell....it's like a well-budgeted tv commercial

  • MAN I LOVE YOUR VIDS!!! haha they really help

  • I dont believe youre real! im going to debunk you! mwahahaha

  • No dust blew into the air, either.

  • you are my favorite person.

  • He reminds me of Penn Badgely

  • Where is the dust and crap that would be thrown up.

  • The trees dont even move, lol. I live next to an air force base. That shit is LOUD.

  • no SHIT its fake it looks like a fucking cartoon, these fake videos are meant to ENTERTAIN people and mind fuck them....

  • Nevermind everything said in this video, what about the LACK OF DUST. There would be a cloud hundreds of feet wide/high behind the thing.

  • Could it have been a MODEL of the real plane?

  • 1st the sound: The KC flies fast enough to have his engines set to iddle, it also reduces dust ingestion. The Boeing is indeed slower and has a high angle of attack involving full throttle ( vertical component of thrust to compensing the weight blablabla...)

    2nd the shadows: this video was shot in Tchad, near the equateur were the sun is much higher in the sky.

    3rd the cameras: This happened about ten years ago and these men have old picture cameras(you know, crapy ones with roll of film ^^)

  • @braorius Please, tell me how you know where the video was shot, and how you know when it was shot. Also, how do you know what cameras they're using? Are you just talking out of your ass to try to disprove the debunk?

  • @sikproductions1221 One of my ground instructor is retired from the airforce and as we were talking about"fun but stupid behavior"in flight he showed us this video,told us that it was real and warned us about the danger of doing this kind of thing(not for our lifes but our licenses ^^). If you listen the debunk until the end it says that it might be real. According to my instructor I can tell you that it is and according to what I'm studying I can "debunk" this debunk.

  • See how much the Plane was, well basicly lagging? Thats how i told it was fake.

  • how did he get an i pad years before it even came out?

  • @itshammer Holy crap you're right. I never realized that before.

  • @Ahmed176E

    haha :P

    green piece of square

  • CD fails to mention a couple things i find most obviously fake about this vidio. Anything that big, moving at that speed,in such a dry enviroment would create a significant dust cloud behind it. Secondly the plane seems disporportionatly small after it passes the bush.

  • wWll, that's OBVIOUSLY fake. You didn't need to "debunk" this one Captain Disillusion. 

  • It was obviously fake. My mom worked at an airport for a few years cleaning and fueling airplanes. I've seen those sorts of planes taking off up close. Those engines are just way too loud for that audio to be legitimate.

  • Unexpectedly good, considering the weird make up.

  • I NEED YOU TO LOOK AT ALL WORLD TRADE CENTER VIDEOS. I dont think here were any planes at all. I was there, i saw no plane just an explosion.

  • "love with your heart, use your head for everything else." holy crap I love that.

  • @pdlbean gonna quote that too

  • i love the "NAVIGATOR" love with your heart and use your head for everything else..ACE

  • it couldnt be real, if you look closely, the plane lags slightly, while the other things around it move smoothly

  • damn i had to stop from watching this at 48 seconds (-_-) that was the worst CGI i ever saw in my life...it was like growing up in the age of PS3's and XBOX360 just to have sumbody say....we bring out a new system called... THE ATARI !!!...sorry for who ever drew up the plane but get a life

  • Watch the actual video, and if you STILL can't see that it's just BAD cgi, then I guess we all know why Avatar was so popular. It looks AWFUL.

  • if i was the flyer of that smaller plane id be so pissed

  • @AlchemyOtaku0922 They won't, until the exhaust pressure hits them, which will be several seconds after the plane passes. I've seen C17s and KC135s do stuff like this.

  • I love how the plants don't move at all when the plane goes by.

  • Wow that is the fakest video ever

  • i dnt tnk he wuz relly flien at de end.

  • @kirbyfan95 seriously, the way you type makes everyone think your illiterate.

  • @mushroomchrisn Seriously, the way you can't detect sarcasm makes everyone think you're illiterate.

  • @kirbyfan95 bleh i got slammed =(

  • the real plane it's from TAP a portuguese plane company :D

  • Its sad how he didnt even notice how fake the plane looks. Its obviously done by computer.

  • hes just so smart he missed it

  • I helped guide in MANY C-135, C-131, and C-5s while stationed in Australia in the Navy. Five minutes before they were to land and taxi on to the runway, we had to have three layers of ear protection on. The sound was so loud you couldnt hear your own thoughts. Any one who has helped land a plane of that size would know the vid was a fake.

  • @flashpenguin86

    Anyone who knows what "3D animation" is would know that its fake also.

  • Ha yeah, i have never seen the video before, but even in the little Youtube player that he holds and plays the clip on, im like "That is 3D animation".

  • @howincrediblyshit

    It's good to know I'm not the only one who can tell the difference between badly rendered 3d animation and a real plane.

  • @Berniebud And those of us who've seen pilots do that know that it doesn't have to be fake, but that every douchebag on youtube likes to say so.

  • Comment removed

  • @mzmadmike

    It's so obviously a cheap 3D animation on top of a video! It looks like it was made in a free 3d animation program!

  • the plane would have made a sonic boom and a wind disruption so the plants would move

  • it would only make a sonic boom if it was going extremely fast.

  • @MrLolcat5000: sonic boom? Google sonic booms, and what it takes to create them (hint: traveling at supersonic speeds). Then, take the time to realize that your name is MrLolcat5000. Then go hump a kitteh.

  • I will take your step, and be the next CDL. :)

  • also the camera was way to close for the plane to be that small. and the people were way to close to be safe nobody would be that stupid if it was a real plane. the other 2 people were prob there so they could see which shot was the best

  • also, dunno if it has been mentioned, but there was no dust blown up by this supposedly 4 engine plane flying so low.

  • NO SHIT ITS FAKE -_-

  • was not a KC135.

    It's a C135FR from the french airforce.

  • I hate it when someone posts a cool video, and the comments ALL just say "fake!". Lighten up, people! Sometimes, you just gotta say, "That was cool."

  • no sh*t that was fake anyone who thought that was real is an ass.

  • Not an ass A DUMBass

  • amen

  • XD yup

  • Yerp.

  • Okay, you are clearly pretentious...we get it. Whats up with you sitting in a corner? Do you not have a chair? Where is your desk? How do you call yourself a captain without a cape.

    And why are you wasting your time making videos about other videos...no one cares.

  • 77,980 people care. 1 viewer dosen't. boo hoo

  • it seems you care enough to leave a stupid comment like that saying you dont care.

  • So was I :D

    and everyone else who has commented on this video...

  • Was Jesus the flight attendant?

  • Actually, SHE is my great-grandfather's friends grandsons pet's past owners barbers brothers friends daughter!

  • The plane looks fake it's brighter than the scene. Here's a fake ufo, is it fake.. check it out watch?v=b_xDpqSTNEQ

  • its so fake, there's no kick up of dust. Agh! And it looks fake too!

  • tap air portugal!!!

  • and also take note that the plane moves not one grain of sand

  • thats what i was thinking. thats all i thought he would say, but he didnt mention it

  • Notice how the plane is very clear ans the background is shitty quality,.. so they super imposed the plane ontop. Also the shadow is way to small for a plane od that size... the whole vid is obv fake

  • Even though I never saw that vid, it did look a little off...

  • silver bodypaint

  • That plane doesn't even look REMOTELY like its actually in the shot. I've seen better cgi in a Michael Bay movie! Ps. I took his advice and used my head for everything else. My girlfriend loved it, and my hair has never looked healthier.

  • actually I think it's your dignity.

  • zing

  • wow........mature.

  • The only argument I have is about the sound dispute. I work around military aircraft on a daily basis. When you are off to the side, like the camera man, it is much quieter and you can actually hold a conversation. I'm not saying this video is real since I am not 100% sure on this planes capabilities.

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • lolwut? how'd it take off then? did they build in in the air?

    not saying the video is necessarily real, but lol you're retarded.

  • how bout this? a stunt plane was in the air, flew by, was recorded, then a bigger plane was superimposed in its place? duh!

  • yea cuzhe didnt say that..

  • i know he said that, but it's not hard to comprehend

  • no he just wants 2 explain things

  • He's hoping to boos the intelligence and reasoning of the kids that believe anything they see on the internet.

  • Ah, I can see that as a reason for what he does

  • yes. yes he must. but he's smart.

  • just dont watch his vids

  • Didn't you see what I said about it being good reason?

  • ye but first after O.O

  • Another clue you could use to identify that this video is fake is looking at the plants. The plants remain still as the plane passes by. If the plane was moving at such a high speed, it would at least blow the plants in different directions; especially the large plant at the end.

  • maby its an modell r.c plain

  • the plane by itself looks fake... coming out of a ps2 game or something lol

  • Possibly real? No, I doubt it.

    An airframe that big, flying that low, at that speed, would generate a hell of a ground effect cushion and there'd be a huge amount of dust kicked up just behind it. There's not even a wisp in this video. Even a small plane would kick up a small dust cloud.

  • I think it's a model jet. Type in model jets here on Youtube. Bam! There are some pretty big models. From certain perspectives they look real.

  • know it alls that dont know it all suck**

  • live by the ending... know it alls suck that dont know it all suck :P

  • I think this case is pretty certain, it is pretty clearly fake.

  • Its clearly fake, i known that from the beginning, sorry cpt disillusion.

    I have developed a special sense identyfing 3d models added into a video.

    You can see the light effect on the object, doesnt looks natural.

  • The texture on the plane is shite too lol

  • one of the guys who are suppose to be recording the plan when the plan passes the man is still recording in the same spot he doesnt follow with the plane.

  • its PLANE you dumb fuck. jesus christ.

  • shut the fuck up your name dont even make sence fuck off

  • sense*

    ::face palm::

    poor soul.

  • if you're going to insult someone, spell everything correctly.

  • There is the Dutch airport where planes actually pass pretty much that low over the beach:). It's called Maho Beach, and is located at St. Marteen, and if you go on the Web you'll find plenty of real pictures that are reminiscent of this clip:).

  • 1.36 lol portuguese plain!!!!

  • also if a plane was that low wouldn't there be dirt in the wind?

  • ..... including sex BAM!!!

  • i knew it was fake when i seen that no sand or wind was uplifted

  • in your ilusion... the camera view its nearest when you change O_o hehehe

  • hes spoofing religous people metaphoricaly. People who believe in childish things need that grow up -thats what hes saying

  • his not a waste man like you....

  • And you have to look at the rating -.-

  • What do you use to make these amazing videos? Which software?

  • What? Are you kidding me? It's obviously a poorly made airplane model, probably made in anim8or by a noob. They didn't even use textures! Just colors and a light!

  • "...use your head for everything else" like people who post text responses who can't spell and use correct grammar! And what's with the caps lock? I truly weep for the future.

    CD, Love your stuff! Can't wait to see more!

  • WHERE IS YOUR HEADQUARTERS LOCATED?

  • "DAMN!" LOL

  • Captain Disillusion is pretty hott

  • Before I watch this let me guess. The plane clip is actually from higher up because that one was way too small and what MaestroJah said.

  • How about the obvious lack of dust flying off the ground...

  • why are you always sitting in the corner

  • STALKER....

  • ehm, this particular video contains ABSOLUTE proof for cgi editing.....

    no matter what resolution, you can always check things (res-consistency e.g.)

    The very FIRST frame shows a 'cut' in the clouds.

    Later frames show the tail's 'black point' 'drag' . its not edited out right at later frames so it appears to 'get stuck'.

    These pop out like hell, but im sure I could find LOTS more....

  • you can even tell that's cgi

  • he sounds like ben stiller lol

  • Even refuler planes arent painted stark white

  • cant be real a plane that low would make a bunch of wind and it would have moved the trees and lookers and some of them looked completly oblivious

  • Not to mention that the jet blast and turbulance caused by a large plane like that would have caused HUGE amounts of dust to be stirred up as it went past. That looked to be a pretty dry day, and the people standing closer to the plane would have gotten blasted with sand and small rocks when that plane throttled up to climb out!

  • Ben Stiller could play in a comedy called Captain Disillusion.

  • by debunking al this shit your giving the makers an insight to there mistakes, i fear more relistic fakes will flood onto youtube, but hey, what ever rocks your boat

  • so what though. thats good. healthy competition

  • It is so very very VERY obvious that it is 3d animation

  • yea it is :)

  • the ended was kool [: lmao

    thats all i has to say [=

    lmao

  • Also with something that big there is no dust from the ground being blown into the air from the engines ,

  • OK, since this is **superhero voice** Captain Desillusion, I quickly thought it looked fake. I still do, but you bring a good point: WE CAN'T TRUST VIDEO FOOTAGE ANYMORE.

  • Speaking as an animator, that plane is animated rather poorly, if only because when the wing banks toward the camera, it's low enough that it should be through the ground; the engine, at the very least.

  • Really liking your stuff, keep it up!

  • Hey... An airplain from TAP! lol

  • dude...what's up with the make-up?

  • hey! its CaptainDisillusion!

  • He grew up in a very conservative town, and now he's just going too wild.

  • The plane will lift up lots and lots of dirt.

  • that looked fake as hell anyways... you'd have to be a retard to think it's real

  • Lol its fake

    the air jet and turbulence should make the dirt on the desert go fly up as its going really low

  • Anyone who believes it was something other than an Airplane that hit the Pentagon is an idiot with just enough understanding of science to be dangerous. Take a look at REAL science and it becomes obvious. Always remember, the simplest explanation is usually the correct one.

  • You're right and the Earth is flat.

  • Like you poorly considered and completely ridiculous theory...your response makes no sense.

  • He was making fun of you duh? Anyway... it doesn't take REAL science to notice "white smoke" coming from the "airplane" (missiles have white exhast smoke, planes do not.)  Nor does airplanes emit a bright fireball, car crashes, air plane crashes, all have dark orange'ish soot colored explosions. A bright, clean fireball implies plenty of oxygen was available... REAL science will come to an answer it was a explosive there genius.

    Guess the Earth is flat.