The Saturdays - Forever Is Over (BBC Switch Live - 15th November 2009)

[xxliftithigherxx]

I love Frankie and Una's outfit!!!

[Rubbii101]

@ 1:52 DAMN VANESSA!!! why you mess it up lolz... Still got love for you though xx

[spider23000]

It sounded better at the kingle bell ball 2011, and when they performed it on the Headlines Tour

[silviasunlight90]

They're WONDERFUL in this video!

[LOLSmileyzLOL]

Aww, I miss how Vanessa used to sing like this :( Just before their 2011 tour, Vanessa started losing her voice :( I HOPE IT COMES BACK STRONGER THAN EVERR

[3003AMBERashleyshow]

you girls have fans in Romania too:X

[SirHarrison9]

Rochelle and Vanessa are definitely the voices of the group. But Una sounded great. Frankie and Molly just need a lot more training and then they can stand out more amongst their group members

[MisZHypah1]

Frankie looks really pretty here!

[jadetanchannel]

i go for Frankie over Mollie

[cal4th]

mikes r shite! need turning up

[nane62387]

وآآآآآآآآآآآآآآآآه يافرانكي

احووبك ياجعل اهدايتك ع ايدي هوع

[xvik1234x]

they still need to spend more time in vocal training and less in makeup.

[rustydevilll]

@xvik1234x

what are you bitching about....

they sounded great apart from vanessa pissing her high note.

[xvik1234x]

@rustydevilll no they dont, they cant hold notes at all. such a weak vocal. the chorus sounds horrific in this.

[iamsd1]

this shows that frankie can sing well

[Leenskes]

lol at the drummer's fail at dropping around 2:00 .. too long fill

[ajdo1991]

All the people saying that Vanessa performed weakly are wrong; I was there and Vanessa was by far the strongest there, she sent goosebumps down my spine, don't forget the sound would have been edited so that the audience wouldn't be heard, live, Vanessa was amazing. Full stop. Ooooh comma, she was sexy too ;)

[andreesSC7]

Vanessa is the strongest and Mollie the weakest. Una, Rochelle and Frankie are in the middle: good voices.

[martinjamieson]

@andreesSC7 So it works well that Mollie is the hottest, and Vanessa comfortably ugliest (though not ugly, to be fair).

[katyburns123]

@martinjamieson thats harsh, vanessas not the 'ugliest'.

[martinjamieson]

@katyburns123 I did qualify it, kind of... it's just a relative term.

[katyburns123]

@martinjamieson but shes not ugly at all in any waayy:/ in my opinion shes the prettiest but most people would agree shes prettier than mollie and rochelle anyway

[JonesOwen]

I love how Frankie notices that vanessa nedded so help with some note a the chorus, you can hear her sing out loud at 3:06 lol love herr

[HannaJLS]

Vanessa's voice is amzying:)<3

rochelle is gorgeous<3

[da1suk1day0]

@ffxswiman33 I've always wondered as well! I can imagine her doing this though.

[brady556]

skeooooooo

[Ineeee]

frankie was so awesome here ♥

[ilhan691]

Rochelle , Vanessa and Una best voices ...........

But ilove frankiee .

[shazzerboi]

is vanessa ever gonna belt that note!!!!

[amsmart1]

i love this performance. they all sound good live. the only thing bugs me about this performance is ness goes really quiet at "i'm no longer afraid".

[wolly5678]

1.52 is it just me or do they mess up? Think timings with band and them were abit off

[Al3xJordanSaid3]

at the beginning of the chorus, Vanessa sounded like she was proper going to go for it, then she didn't, which is disappointing i just hope once she'll do this song proper belting it out like the studio version.

[etreduardo]

This performance was WAY better than the Paul O'Grady's one!! The harmonies were good and they sounded brilliant separately.

P.S: Frankie and Una are the bests!!

[phylliewilly]

Frankie actually looks straight up confused at several points! Who wouldnt luv to do a half arsed job on stage in return for free nice clothes, hair and make up done all the time and high profile boyfriends and hefty pay outs from sales, appearances and endorsements? Well, real music lovers i guess!

[Spurs4Eva01633]

for you people moaning, i would to give you a mic and put you on that stage and see how you get on!

[MermaidLovesYhoo]

they clearly couldnt hear themselves as they keep going out of time and vanessa clearly has a sore throat cos this is so dissapointing from her! She usually really projects her big notes and this is so weak on the chorus from all of them

[bitchxo11]

wow this is terrable..

[TheLittleCris]

This is for the people who say that they can't sing in live. Awsome performance:)

[drewfan14]

I love the Saturdays <3

[finndapin]

Quite poor actually.

[DudeDudetteChannel]

they are my fav girl band, they ace the acoustic covers but their weak point has got to be the live because they obviously cant hear themselves cuz of the drums and guitars, etc so they cant hear what exact note to sing if tht makes sense. but love these girls they are amazing :)

[JulietheQueen]

@DudeDudetteChannel It's just the lack of practice imo. They quite rarely do the wholy live shows, mostly it's just their vocals with the playback, the digital sound is less harmful for ears, hence they can hear themselves better. I'd say, the more they do LIVEs the better, as they have got great vpcal potential and their harmony is beautiful when it's present :)

[keldorn1982]

i don't really care if they can sing or not... They look perfect... Especially Una. ;)

[11223kainath]

Luv The Saturdayz,,, They Are So Better Than Girlz Aloud,,! :D

[skinslappa]

ive heard frankie likes it up the shitter......... fact!

[Punkprynces95]

frankie does look like she gained weight in this performance. idk y but maybe its cuz of the skirt

[02ablake]

rochelle sang amazingly!

[sxcgul]

NONE OF THEM CAN ACTUALLY SING!!

[RoydsLovesMerrygold]

Una's voice is the best.

[FOB4Eva1]

the Saturdays aren't always note perfect in all their live performances but they all sing brilliantly when they sing acoustically, which is supposed to be harder for other acts isn't it? lol

[LittlexguitarxJones]

Unaaa and vanessa were amazing ! but i cant hear mollie !!

[jgordontwi]

i think they are good

[Stepha321]

they stole that song from kelly clarkson

[sanesenas]

yea its true...mollie king did it

[kickmypantsdry]

2:06 Frankie was like, wtf Vanessa! You were off! Classic. But this IS a hard song to sing though, so cut them some slack. I think they can perform this much better now.

[Al3xJordanSaid3]

@kickmypantsdry ahahha Frankie can not talk about out of tune but it was a funny face haha!

[fififane85]

I don't understand why in all the performances of Forever is over all the chorus are bad !!

[MidnightStarRuby]

I thought the lyrics were: 'cos if i don't get out now'

but they sing 'cos if i don't get up now'

???

[LunaL360]

2:28 I love Una :3 she is my idol, my grand idol :D

[kickmypantsdry]

Frankie was very good in this! Rochelle was off on every single note in her solo. And poor Vanessa needed to go falsetto on us, with the support of Frankie and Mollie on the chorus. Una did well too!

[22Criss22]

Vanessa and Una Perfect!

[radioxxflyer]

great song, but oh my god they really need some vocal training, they sound so breathless with little control live. i was mortified watching this. vanessa who has such awesome power in the studio was going all falsetto on us during the chorus, very shocking considering the power we all know she has.

[ashkariuk]

@radioxxflyer They seem to seriously lack confidence live me thinks. Guess some artists are best as studio acts, as the festivals proved last year :-S

[thesatsfan09]

love the saturdays and frankie sounded good here! if anything it was rochelle who was the let down and considering una was ill she did it well! but generally i don't think they handle performing forever is over very well.

[phototgenicposer]

for me its vanessa who disappoinnts she never does her big notes strong!!!!!

[JOdayJR]

i agree...but not always!!in other songs she sings the big notes but not in Forever is Over

[rustydevilll]

@phototgenicposer Maybe she was sick or something.

[xXxcomYxXx]

@phototgenicposer Music was too loud so u couldn't hear her beautiful singing...

[missmzhu]

And yeh Frankie quiet and this song is quite out there and loud! Bless her....lol

[mrjamezdean]

wow kimberly has way too much lipstick on :L

[missmzhu]

lol her lipstick is just bright thats all lol

[Punkprynces95]

i swear, i dont know how people think that frankie can sing!? she cant. shes wayy too quiet i can barely hear her and the rest of them r all loud enough but her. they should have never given her a part in this song when she has the weakest voice!!!!!!

[thesatsfan09]

you really have it in for frankie

[mcmaximon1]

the audience is totaly jealous

[carlabow22]

i love Una's voice