Best song off Scarsick. hands down. well, except for Enter Rain. and Kingdom of Loss. or maybe Spitfall, or Scarsick itself. or maybe..............Fuck! POS rocks!
PoS doesnt shock you with crazy time sigs all the time, to me thats not what being progressive is about. Prog rock is about being different..key changes, using chords that arent used often, abstract song structures (not always having the chorus/bridge in the same place etc..) This is why i love porcupine tree, pain of salvation etc..
@Kisamefan2 I know they can do it, but they dont overdo is like some prog bands do. In my opinion, a good writer writes melodies, and can move you emotionally. The technical stuff is impressive, but i cant listen to a whole album of that stuff.
They are so much better than dream theater 'they are trully a prog band with no limations . dream theater has the same formula on wvery album so you always here the same stuff
@SpaceDyeDream thats exactly what i thought when i learned of his departure. i am sure that now they will produce a good album and maybe it will lean more towards prog rock as portnoy was the main metal element of the band..
The tempo and high energy kind of make it really subtle, but there is a checkerboard pattern of call and response (in the prechorus sections about 2:05 etc) with the screaming, lead guitar, rhythm guitar/bass. JH scream while Daniel plays guitar, and then Daniel screams as Johan and Simon play. Intricate, yet so subtle. Musical win.
Only small problem I have with this band is Gildenlow playing the guitar. Not that he's bad, no, but I prefer the lead vocalists to be whipping the crowd up into a frenzy and going nuts up on stage but meh...can't complain about the quality of music that these guys put up there
I think considering their skill level and intensity of emotion, especially live, PoS deserve at least as much recognition as Dream Theater has gotten...
I have to agree. Pain of Salvation have gone upward and more creative in their last 3 albums while Dream Theater keep whipping out... more of the same. =/.
Listen to Linoleum compared to Black Clouds. It may be 30 minutes shorter but there's for more creativity in Linoleum heh.
as much as I love Pain of Salvation, I have to disagree
sadly, most of Linoleum sounds like a hash of 70s and 80s prog, some alt rock and some modern prog rock to me,,
Daniel is losing it, i hope the album doesn't really disappoint
Dark Clouds is a fantastic album, more melody, heavier rhythms, less progressive yes, Shattered Fortress is one song that could've been avoided, terrible ,, i know its part of the AA suite and all, but it sort of sucked,,
Actually I think Shattered Fortress and Best of Times are the two good songs. The other four at times are very bland. Also having listened to Linoleum I strongly disagree.
@Saintsmaen I dunno man, for some reason I kept losing focus while listening to Linoleum
that never happens to me while I listen to pain of salvation , even the arguably "driest" album, BE had my undivided attention ,, scarsick was just too good
best of times is super song :) love it,, you didnt like the overdose of slow melody in Count of Tuscany?
@sswriter09 Dream Theater, on the other hand, deserve at least as much recognition as Justin Bieber or Korn or any other popular musician, but sadly that's not how this world works.
@sswriter09 :: intensity of emotion yes, dream theater have a much more 'wholesomeness' to their sound live, its elaborate and yet wholesome which is awesome, PoS in quite a few live videos have a big problem with being 'tight' and there is the whole 'epic' factor in dream theater's performances that sets them a whole world apart
having said that I must say PoS are still one of my favourite prog rock bands :)
where were all of you guys hiding? pos is my favourite band and everyone keeps telling me how much dream theater kicks their ass.... can't wait for a new album btw..
so many people are saying this album sucked, but i dont get it.. this is epic!
zeppelin88ab 5 months ago in playlist zeppelin88ab's Favorited Videos 4
Mmm, I say yes!!!
TheBassioso 8 months ago
Say no, say no, say no, say - NO!
Fimbultyr 8 months ago
All the members can sing really good (especially daniel and johan!) I never saw that before, this band is too awesome
chenille75 8 months ago
@chenille75
transatlantic it's another good example of that
dagga220 5 months ago
Greatest DVD I've ever bought!
Pimbmaster 9 months ago
This sends so many fucking chills down my spine.
ShortSonata94 9 months ago
In before "one person is x" posts
Foxer35 10 months ago
haha
SAY NO
YEAH..
jaaphoofd 10 months ago
this isnt my kind of music at all and i think there pretty good :)
evcsgirl811 10 months ago
Say no...
ShortSonata94 10 months ago
favorite band of all times
y7u7r7i 11 months ago
Best song off Scarsick. hands down. well, except for Enter Rain. and Kingdom of Loss. or maybe Spitfall, or Scarsick itself. or maybe..............Fuck! POS rocks!
killmeandit 11 months ago
what's up with this one dislike???????????
MisteriosaVampiria 11 months ago
I stood my ground an said "NO!". Have you?
lolwhoops 11 months ago
If You Love Music, You Love "Pain Of Salvation" -- Masterpiece.
inttgo 1 year ago
great song
vaggchrysgym9889 1 year ago
They are epic. I like everything they have ever played. Hope to see them in Poland again.
Morill8814 1 year ago
The fact that there is only one dislike so far surely proves how almost no one could NOT like such a song... Love it!
famousvim26 1 year ago
This band is musically/technically miles ahead of many bands out there.
LaceratedBalls 1 year ago
let's consider that we didn't like PoS at first sight.. At least, I didn't
the point is that people hear one time and don't like and throw the band in the garbage.. that is sad, but is the true
hyllsav 1 year ago
Pure talents...
DiabolicalDesire 1 year ago
That being said, the latter parts don't seem overdubbed, and they're excellent! My fav Scarsick song!
dragonsagoth666 1 year ago
Holy shit, intro main riff looks like it's overdubbed?! I would not expect this from PoS...
dragonsagoth666 1 year ago
PoS doesnt shock you with crazy time sigs all the time, to me thats not what being progressive is about. Prog rock is about being different..key changes, using chords that arent used often, abstract song structures (not always having the chorus/bridge in the same place etc..) This is why i love porcupine tree, pain of salvation etc..
AsG1989 1 year ago 3
@AsG1989 They DO have crazy time sigs. They're just less obvious than in, say, Dream Theater.
rurzan 1 year ago
@AsG1989 Imago= something like 19/32
Kisamefan2 10 months ago
@Kisamefan2 I know they can do it, but they dont overdo is like some prog bands do. In my opinion, a good writer writes melodies, and can move you emotionally. The technical stuff is impressive, but i cant listen to a whole album of that stuff.
AsG1989 10 months ago
Awesome song, never get tired of it.
007Pogo 1 year ago
2:10
Nice- old rockers ftw haha
GattlingGuitarGuru 1 year ago
They are so much better than dream theater 'they are trully a prog band with no limations . dream theater has the same formula on wvery album so you always here the same stuff
RobinUriah0927 1 year ago
@RobinUriah0927 Ya,they are kinda more ambisious , but dream theater is awesome too.
007Pogo 1 year ago
@RobinUriah0927
Well, buddy, Dream Theater has been like that since Systematic Chaos. Maybe with the departure of Portnoy they'll be fine...
SpaceDyeDream 1 year ago
@SpaceDyeDream thats exactly what i thought when i learned of his departure. i am sure that now they will produce a good album and maybe it will lean more towards prog rock as portnoy was the main metal element of the band..
MrDreamTom 1 year ago
@RobinUriah0927 Wait, you say Images and Word and Falling into infinity are the same?
sxestrid 1 year ago
the screaming is little ridiculous, but other than that its great. And god do I love the wah wah
LeeRLang 1 year ago
Geat DVD.
Watch my channel for a song of the new album Road Salt.
kingdomloss 1 year ago
the bassist does an excellent job don't you think??
camelspottergr 2 years ago 6
The tempo and high energy kind of make it really subtle, but there is a checkerboard pattern of call and response (in the prechorus sections about 2:05 etc) with the screaming, lead guitar, rhythm guitar/bass. JH scream while Daniel plays guitar, and then Daniel screams as Johan and Simon play. Intricate, yet so subtle. Musical win.
edthehead83 2 years ago 7
@edthehead83
Damn nice call there. You rock, sir.
angelicanime 1 year ago
Yes, thank you! It's the things like that that I try to put into my music.
edthehead83 1 year ago
2:10 Daddy's into prog music lol.
Horomaru 2 years ago 5
Yeah, I really like this version, its alot more intense
ARRGHcheese 2 years ago 2
i didnt love this song till i saw/heard this version. Its amazing
flippinfl00b 2 years ago
4:51
wow.
edthehead83 2 years ago 2
kug0t, that´s a live, so normally is better playing faster than cd. in another way people will sleep!!! :P
NeQproductions 2 years ago
Only small problem I have with this band is Gildenlow playing the guitar. Not that he's bad, no, but I prefer the lead vocalists to be whipping the crowd up into a frenzy and going nuts up on stage but meh...can't complain about the quality of music that these guys put up there
iqsymphic 2 years ago
This performance seems a little fast... Still, it's their song, not mine.
kug0t 2 years ago 2
4:10
Song of heavens.
Weirdesigner 2 years ago 2
I think considering their skill level and intensity of emotion, especially live, PoS deserve at least as much recognition as Dream Theater has gotten...
sswriter09 2 years ago 80
They deserve more!
Much better quality of music in my opinion. Especially in the latter years of Dream Theater.
In my mind: "BE" > "Scenes From A Memory"
neilpeart311 2 years ago 2
i disagree. Perfect Element is bout equal to Scenes in my eyes
flippinfl00b 2 years ago
I have to agree. Pain of Salvation have gone upward and more creative in their last 3 albums while Dream Theater keep whipping out... more of the same. =/.
Listen to Linoleum compared to Black Clouds. It may be 30 minutes shorter but there's for more creativity in Linoleum heh.
Saintsmaen 2 years ago 4
@Saintsmaen
as much as I love Pain of Salvation, I have to disagree
sadly, most of Linoleum sounds like a hash of 70s and 80s prog, some alt rock and some modern prog rock to me,,
Daniel is losing it, i hope the album doesn't really disappoint
Dark Clouds is a fantastic album, more melody, heavier rhythms, less progressive yes, Shattered Fortress is one song that could've been avoided, terrible ,, i know its part of the AA suite and all, but it sort of sucked,,
the other songs are def OK
TheRandomChap 2 years ago
Actually I think Shattered Fortress and Best of Times are the two good songs. The other four at times are very bland. Also having listened to Linoleum I strongly disagree.
Saintsmaen 2 years ago
@Saintsmaen I dunno man, for some reason I kept losing focus while listening to Linoleum
that never happens to me while I listen to pain of salvation , even the arguably "driest" album, BE had my undivided attention ,, scarsick was just too good
best of times is super song :) love it,, you didnt like the overdose of slow melody in Count of Tuscany?
TheRandomChap 2 years ago
@sswriter09 I dare say even more ;)
Cassandrart 1 year ago
@sswriter09 I'm sure they would if they toured in the US and got their name out here more.
Opaqueyes 1 year ago
@sswriter09 Dream Theater, on the other hand, deserve at least as much recognition as Justin Bieber or Korn or any other popular musician, but sadly that's not how this world works.
rurzan 1 year ago 5
@sswriter09 :: intensity of emotion yes, dream theater have a much more 'wholesomeness' to their sound live, its elaborate and yet wholesome which is awesome, PoS in quite a few live videos have a big problem with being 'tight' and there is the whole 'epic' factor in dream theater's performances that sets them a whole world apart
having said that I must say PoS are still one of my favourite prog rock bands :)
TheRandomChap 1 year ago
@sswriter09 They opened for Apocalyptica a number of times... I'd call that, at the least, a step in the right direction.
Foxer35 1 year ago
I love the drumset. So cool. I love the old drummer too, I m so sad he leaves the band.
SSSavio 2 years ago 5
where were all of you guys hiding? pos is my favourite band and everyone keeps telling me how much dream theater kicks their ass.... can't wait for a new album btw..
stathistate 2 years ago 12
I'm hiding in my bedroom, trying very hard to write songs that good... I'm almost there, just give me a few more centuries
eloann 2 years ago 5
those vocal harmonies are SO boss.
ryanyunck 2 years ago 9
GODS of prog
fsdream 2 years ago 5
Daniel I LOVE YOU ç__ç <3
He's god, holy Christ.
LucianBelmau 2 years ago 2
please Daniel! do not even think to stop challenging all the so called "good" music out there. you are the greatest!
jorninorion 2 years ago 5
I think I like this more than the studio version, heh.
Great band, or greatest band? <3 PoS.
I can't wait for my Ending Themes DVD to arrive in the mail tomorrow!
DirtyDoug669 2 years ago
solid. This is one of my favorite bands, the songwriting, the vocals, the words, the talent is all on point. kings of prog.
Balenciaga37 2 years ago 2
SAY NO!
flippinfl00b 2 years ago 2
YEAH! ;)
HellBone6 2 years ago
POS totally pwns Dream Wanker in both form and substance lulz
DarkFulanito 2 years ago
substance definately yes. DT is absolutely personal which i love in its own way.
form=POS and DT are definately different giants. hardly comparable.
jorninorion 2 years ago 6
POS > Dream Theater
sa3atsky 2 years ago
I agree. First DT album rules too, but i prefer pain of salvation. They are more intense, more emotional.
SSSavio 2 years ago
Bullshit!
Both of them have their own style and
their own point of view!
MusicalPilgrim 2 years ago 5
Sorry - this was deticated to sa3atsky
MusicalPilgrim 2 years ago
I LOVE YOU!!!
UPLOAD MORE!!!!!!!
saadazzz 2 years ago 3
incredible!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Kamizi 2 years ago
Best band ever
scarsickED 2 years ago 37
"NO!" "YEAH!"
leavingentropia 3 years ago 6
This has been flagged as spam show
I love it !!!!
Awesome !!!
GoDavidLee 3 years ago 2
Best video off the new dvd that i've seen so far (though Foreward was great as well) l I f'in love P.O.S!!!!
AXOLJ64 3 years ago
Handful of nothing and Diffidentia are totally mind-blowing too. Didn't see them on youtube though. I might give a try at uploading them.
eloann 2 years ago 2
the tempo.. xD
dreamfields72 3 years ago
Fuck yeah.
Nenyatje 3 years ago
holy shit, that's impressive.
Hadrhune0 3 years ago 3
Oh ... yeah :)
szabels 3 years ago