Why do you people waste time with vids like these. Yes, the song has the same chord progression. So does another million songs do. Hell if that's the case then Natasha Bedingfield ripped off a song someone else cause I'm sure someone has made the song in that EXACT same cord before. ON ONE OWNS CHORD PROGRESSION!
@Yukihiro21 - As a music major, I can tell you that is MORE than the chord progression - it's almost the exact same melody, down to the staccato eighth notes!
@BigRedEO only the staccato eighth notes and the chords are similar. It's not the same style of music at ALL! The fact of the matter is, WHO CARES? Natasha Bedingfield Isn't original either. No one is Original ! cause it's all been done before. I'm not a big fan of Gaga but these Vids are absolutely stupid.
@BigRedEO and it only proves the quote" The more success someone has, the more shade you'll get." and this is someone who's studied music theory for years and has play an instrument for years as well. If you're a music major then you SHOULD know that somthing like this is not NEW cause even in in the classical music genre songs sound similar right down to a friggn syncopated rhythm. I wonder why people don't put vids up for them calling the directors " unoriginal" ? hmm...
I always thought the Express Yourself/Born This Way comparison was a bit out there. But in THIS case, when the song's melody is so similar, I can't help but wonder.
WHat THe FUck ... She is a copycat ... yes i am too... You know she copy everyone ... because she make music ... so she copy all the artist that make music ... Stupid Idiot ... Seriously GET OVER IT
@MsMollyGrand First of all, that's you're opinion and that's not the point. The point is that everyone acts like she's so original, and fresh, and new but everything she's doing has been done before time and time again. She's nothing revolutionary. That's the point.
@xPowderBluLolipopzx i never said she is original or fresh. i just said i like her music better. so actually i agree with you that she isnt a revolutionary, but my point is: pop music in general isnt original or fresh because everyone copies everyone there is no use getting upset over it because its been happening for years. and yes that was my opinion and i have the right to express my opinion, as do you, so please calm down.
@xPowderBluLolipopzx I'm not sure when you got the idea where she act's like she's " original" but you're dead wrong. It's her FANS putting her on a pedestal. She;s done nothing but make music. Calm down. and this is coming from someone who doesn't even like her all that well.
we can't always blame the artist for how their music sounds, its obvious these 4 or 5 cords are what people respond to the most, all pop songs use the same cords they jus keep rearranging them. Her entire career is controlled & modeled after the artists who came before her, if she didn't make this music somebody else would have.. the puppeteers tell her what to sing, what to wear and how to act ..Who knows what she does on her own
It has the same beat what are you talking about? The backround music wasn't the same; niether were the lyrics. I am a huge fan of Natasha Bedingfield and I think Lady Gaga is OK, but seriously to even try to convince someone that she stole anything from the song is ridiculous. Do you know how many songs have the same beat throught out the entire song?
@superbeeto I see her ripping off. Im a huge fan, bought all her albums, seen her live twice, met her once, my whole room is decorated with GaGa poster/pics and some Eminem and Shakira. But im not dumb. i know she copys lol. Her song Fashion of His Love is an exect copy of Express Yourself. I know she has songs that sounds like other songs but thats okay, We have 100 years worth of released music, do you think there is going to be an original song nowadays? exactly!
It's more than obvious that Gaga copied this song... On it's own it has no ability to write anything decent, but when it steals music from someone else it is praised for it. I refuse to say "her" instead of "it" because Gaga is a transvestite
Of cause Lady Gaga is copying most of her songs. Because she's smart. She knows that the people will talk about all this Copied stuff and because of that her Songs climb higher and higher in the charts.
@Biene1989Bo actually she's not climbing higher and higher on the charts. all her latest singles flopped except "born this way". and her album sales dropped by 85% once her album was no longer available for $0.99. i think her star is fading. and fast.
Gaga I do not like at all. Dont worry I wont bash or care about something I dont like. Natasha though is real talent and my favorite female musician. Gaga definitely ripped her off.
when artists write songs they have to do their research... I mean the with the usher homer simpson thing... it's not like that song was so widely known but pocketful of sunshine is a pretty big song.
I didn't say that you said that other genres don't sound the same either man i was just giving EXAMPLES cause everybody says yeeah popmusic is all the same which annoys me because it's not, most of the people who say this are like rock dudes and whtv but well...let's end this here.
… as a fan of both… no, she didn't rip her off. You'll notice that a lot of the songs on GaGa's first two albums pay homage to other female singers. I assume that instead of one copying the other in this case, both were inspired by a previous artist.
u have no life i've heard a lot of music that sounds same but i dont go around "OMG this dude ripped off that dude because there songs sound the same"
Have you ever thought about what happens when all the songs have been invented not inventing any more because all the songs have already been used. Same here too: the rhythm has not been invented so that it has been borrowed from another song. Gaga, and is not necessarily self-selected rhythm / music producers, but someone has chosen it. Gaga is not even necessarily aware of this.
Gaga does write her own songs actually.. She's actually super talented if people would take the chance to not judge her on her appearance, they would see her talent.
Ok is this video talking about how she dresses? No it isn't, it is talking about the "similarities" between the songs. I'm not saying the song was stolen I am saying bring up relevant evidence to prove she didn't steal it.
@clllaaaiiirrre How can they not judge her on her appearance? She obviously wants to be judged as a weird, unique, whatever pop star or she wouldn't have randomly gone from being normal to like that when she started getting more popular.
@clllaaaiiirrre What about that song they wrote for Brittney but they didn't put on Brittney's album? It's the EXACT same song, just Gaga singing it. Same lyrics, the back track sounds unchanged, probably the same recording.
I'm not saying Gaga isn't good, she is, I'm fine with that. But don't she writes her own songs. Most pop stars don't. They don't even say they do. They're not supposed to. They know their place, that's all. Lada Gaga is not Prince. She's not a songwriter.
@clllaaaiiirrre if tht is true which im sure is these songs n born this way+behappy r really similiar im not gonna jump to conclusions cus theyre all awesome but it does make u think twice about Lady gag bein a genuine song writer
All the artists you say that you love aren't worth scum... They only get money off of people's ignorance, stupidity and gulability. Britney, Lady gaga, Jonas Brothers, Justin Bieber, and most of all the pop rock culture celebs are carefully selected and built by music companies that only want money and that are happy to spread no talent what so ever to the world so they can get profits! And you know why this abuse works??? Because ignorant people love ignorant "flashy" things.
@JinKsed17 Never said I liked any of those people actually. And I never have liked any of them. You don't know me so don't assume I'm "ignorant". Think before you speak and don't make a fool out of yourself.
@clllaaaiiirrre nobody is saying she copied the lyric she copied the music just like many of her songs. Nobody argue she is talented but her copyness overshadow her talent
Alright, they both suck. Now that is outta the way, the melody is simple. E to G to D. You can probably find many examples of those same intervals all over the place, in different keys, from the past few hundred years. It's really not that hard. E minor?
Plus it's pop music, it can't get too complicated for the 14 year old girls to listen to, and they probably run out of ideas quick.
@BAXTSPRCHRGD yes it is! she did NOT copy...they sound NOTHING like eachother, people need to get this fact. Lady Gaga is a real Artist! she is not some Shaddy artist like Justin Bieber, or Rihanna or Kesha!
@GaGa4Kate You said "gaga is a trillion times better!...people are so jealous!" that is retarded, Gaga is pop trash for a start and people being jealous of her (morons) isn't gunna make a song sound similar. More then likely someone heard the similarities and made a video to highlight it. I doubt the person who made this said "You know what? I am jealous of Lady Gaga imma make a video comparing her song to another and say they are similar MUAHAHA"
@BAXTSPRCHRGD No. people are jelous, that shes famous, and sucsessful! she didnt copy anyone. thats not a opinion but a fact. dont fight with me about this! im done talking to you
@BAXTSPRCHRGD your wrong. she writes her own songs, and shes VERY dedicated to her work! This is stupid i dont know why im wasting my time, talking to you. Your wrong, she writes her own music, deal with it!
Well, I like pocket full of sunshine better, but in a way it seems like she ripped her off, but in a way she didn't. Nothing is original anymore. Everything is based off another.
Eh well, I liked pocketful of sunshine immediately, but took a while to like so happy I could die, and I pretty much love it now. There's a similarity, but not crazily obvious.
I hate people who hate on popmusic. pop is like all kinds of music. It is a genre which is in general commercial. And that does not mean that every song who is made in that way is shit.
I mean, for me for example screamo bands sound all the same but should I hate on it because of that?
@thexcoreissilent i did not say YOU hate popmusic but it's kind of ridiculous saying Popmusic sounds all the same, because it's not. People who say this just lean on other People's opinions. Listen to 100 complete different artists and not just 2 or 3 and then tell me it sounds all the same. I hear a lot of other genres too, for example rock in almost all kinds. When you hear all of the fashionista punkrock bands you'll see, that 90 percent of it sounds alike. just for example.
@ILoveLLawlietxD I did not say other genres didn't sound the same either, this just happens to be about pop music, hence why i made the comment, you're making a big deal about a small comment :) Let's move on, okay?
@thexcoreissilent i did not say YOU hate popmusic but it's kind of ridiculous saying Popmusic sounds all the same, because it's not. People who say this just lean on other People's opinions. Listen to 100 complete different artists and not just 2 or 3 and then tell me it sounds all the same. I hear a lot of other genres too, for example rock in almost all kinds. When you hear all of the fashionista punkrock bands you'll see, that 90 percent of it sounds alike. just for example.
@thexcoreissilent i did not say YOU hate popmusic but it's kind of ridiculous saying Popmusic sounds all the same, because obviously it's not. People who say this just lean on other People's opinions. Listen to 100 complete different artists and not just 2 or 3 and then tell me it sounds all the same. I hear a lot of other genres too, for example rock in almost all kinds. When you hear all of the fashionista punkrock bands you'll see, that 90 percent of it sounds alike. just for example.
Gaga is Caca. She's talentless (or her handlers tell her what to wear and sing) therefore, her "style" is always tracked by to someone else. If she really had her own style, it wouldn't look so much that she just randomly chose to "look like" someone else every day. Her outfits would have something in common, but they don't, because she can't have her own ideas/sense of style when she copies everyone.
Humans are pattern seekers. We are trying to match new information to already existing information. That is why we see Virgin Marys in toasted bread and hear other pop songs in pop songs. Basic psychology. ;-)
i preferrrrrrrrrrr a million times natasha than gaga, what a shame gaga, is clearly similar.
willKCFAN 1 month ago
Why do you people waste time with vids like these. Yes, the song has the same chord progression. So does another million songs do. Hell if that's the case then Natasha Bedingfield ripped off a song someone else cause I'm sure someone has made the song in that EXACT same cord before. ON ONE OWNS CHORD PROGRESSION!
Yukihiro21 2 months ago
@Yukihiro21 - As a music major, I can tell you that is MORE than the chord progression - it's almost the exact same melody, down to the staccato eighth notes!
BigRedEO 1 month ago
@BigRedEO only the staccato eighth notes and the chords are similar. It's not the same style of music at ALL! The fact of the matter is, WHO CARES? Natasha Bedingfield Isn't original either. No one is Original ! cause it's all been done before. I'm not a big fan of Gaga but these Vids are absolutely stupid.
Yukihiro21 1 month ago
@Yukihiro21 Thank you. You're the only one who's being mature here :)
msfunnybunny101 3 weeks ago
@BigRedEO and it only proves the quote" The more success someone has, the more shade you'll get." and this is someone who's studied music theory for years and has play an instrument for years as well. If you're a music major then you SHOULD know that somthing like this is not NEW cause even in in the classical music genre songs sound similar right down to a friggn syncopated rhythm. I wonder why people don't put vids up for them calling the directors " unoriginal" ? hmm...
Yukihiro21 1 month ago
Comment removed
toddstohs 2 months ago
I always thought the Express Yourself/Born This Way comparison was a bit out there. But in THIS case, when the song's melody is so similar, I can't help but wonder.
PungiFungi 2 months ago
wow this really sounds the same
kille6 3 months ago
LOL "Lady Gaga - Bad Kids" sounds like a twin-song of "MyChael - Old without bolt" what is years old
take a look at yourself "similar songs video" of my channel
sowhat0151 5 months ago
Lady Gaga is a fucking untalented copycat! It's easy to copy other songs, I can even do that!
ITurnToMelanieC 5 months ago
HA and she says she soooo original lol
ItsLuisGonzalez 5 months ago
OMG.....who care's!! just enjoy the music!!!!
btw SHUT UP......NATASHA AND GAGA ROCKS (:
Japoneshaa 5 months ago
all pop music sounds the same
lollipop56651 6 months ago 5
She ripped me off too...I WANT MY 20 DOLLARS BITCH!!!!
boxmouth1 6 months ago
WHat THe FUck ... She is a copycat ... yes i am too... You know she copy everyone ... because she make music ... so she copy all the artist that make music ... Stupid Idiot ... Seriously GET OVER IT
Fiana24 6 months ago
she may copy but she does it all better then any of the other people. and besides, who doesnt copy today
MsMollyGrand 7 months ago
@MsMollyGrand First of all, that's you're opinion and that's not the point. The point is that everyone acts like she's so original, and fresh, and new but everything she's doing has been done before time and time again. She's nothing revolutionary. That's the point.
xPowderBluLolipopzx 6 months ago
@xPowderBluLolipopzx i never said she is original or fresh. i just said i like her music better. so actually i agree with you that she isnt a revolutionary, but my point is: pop music in general isnt original or fresh because everyone copies everyone there is no use getting upset over it because its been happening for years. and yes that was my opinion and i have the right to express my opinion, as do you, so please calm down.
MsMollyGrand 6 months ago
@xPowderBluLolipopzx I'm not sure when you got the idea where she act's like she's " original" but you're dead wrong. It's her FANS putting her on a pedestal. She;s done nothing but make music. Calm down. and this is coming from someone who doesn't even like her all that well.
Yukihiro21 1 month ago
Thank you Captain Obvious
FatalInjury111 7 months ago
@FatalInjury111 yes, it is obvious, still some people still deny it. LOL
JosephKh1994 7 months ago
Who hasn't she ripped off? It's funny wen
wiseguyknowsit 7 months ago
The only difference here is... The first one sounds horrible!
VillNessPSN 7 months ago
Yeshh:)
DizziGhoul 8 months ago
Ehm.... So Happy I Could Die is older than Bucket Full Of Sunshine? Or is it just me.
AnoukSiep 8 months ago
my god!!! who hasn't she ripped off!
fahd08 8 months ago 18
we can't always blame the artist for how their music sounds, its obvious these 4 or 5 cords are what people respond to the most, all pop songs use the same cords they jus keep rearranging them. Her entire career is controlled & modeled after the artists who came before her, if she didn't make this music somebody else would have.. the puppeteers tell her what to sing, what to wear and how to act ..Who knows what she does on her own
tootit24 8 months ago
It has the same beat what are you talking about? The backround music wasn't the same; niether were the lyrics. I am a huge fan of Natasha Bedingfield and I think Lady Gaga is OK, but seriously to even try to convince someone that she stole anything from the song is ridiculous. Do you know how many songs have the same beat throught out the entire song?
DollFaceHottie 8 months ago
now i know what So Happy I Could Die reminded me of! HaHa GaGa youre just great! love ya!!!!! keep coming with the hits!
VampireWeirdoFreak42 8 months ago
@VampireWeirdoFreak42 it´s so bad that you all don´t see the truth :S... bad
superbeeto 8 months ago
@superbeeto I see her ripping off. Im a huge fan, bought all her albums, seen her live twice, met her once, my whole room is decorated with GaGa poster/pics and some Eminem and Shakira. But im not dumb. i know she copys lol. Her song Fashion of His Love is an exect copy of Express Yourself. I know she has songs that sounds like other songs but thats okay, We have 100 years worth of released music, do you think there is going to be an original song nowadays? exactly!
VampireWeirdoFreak42 8 months ago
@VampireWeirdoFreak42 well said! :)
Avatar10110 8 months ago
Yeah, she also copied Madonna's "Express Yourself" and some Keygen song from Unreeal Superhero 3.
TheMagicOfNutella 9 months ago
yes!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! =)
juliarocks1311 9 months ago
It's more than obvious that Gaga copied this song... On it's own it has no ability to write anything decent, but when it steals music from someone else it is praised for it. I refuse to say "her" instead of "it" because Gaga is a transvestite
TheXipeTotek 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
sounds like blue ' all rise'
mjjestateTOownsony 9 months ago
Comment removed
mjjestateTOownsony 9 months ago
Comment removed
mjjestateTOownsony 9 months ago
Of cause Lady Gaga is copying most of her songs. Because she's smart. She knows that the people will talk about all this Copied stuff and because of that her Songs climb higher and higher in the charts.
Biene1989Bo 9 months ago 13
@Biene1989Bo actually she's not climbing higher and higher on the charts. all her latest singles flopped except "born this way". and her album sales dropped by 85% once her album was no longer available for $0.99. i think her star is fading. and fast.
anoziraflaminghot 2 months ago
it isnt important íf it could be from natasha. the version by lady gaga is very better... sorry for my awfull english... :-)
julchen908 9 months ago
theyre not that similar
csimas0918 9 months ago
TOTAL RIPP!!! Gaga honey, yer not gonna last like this!!!!
DollyMausDeux 10 months ago
Lady Gaga may use the same rhythm, but the lyrics are her own. She probably used Natasha Bedingfield's song as an inspiration.
What's nice for me to find out is that both are my favorite singers. So eat that, haters. :V
lf2net 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
NO similarities at all rofl
shazenmaire 10 months ago
love both doesnt matter! :)
sPaRkLiFy24 10 months ago
GAGA = UGLY COPYCAT.
mirame100pre 10 months ago
All this made me do was want to listen to So Happy I Could Die ;L
xxxigotboredxxx 10 months ago
Gaga I do not like at all. Dont worry I wont bash or care about something I dont like. Natasha though is real talent and my favorite female musician. Gaga definitely ripped her off.
ChrisMarquetteslover 10 months ago
NO ONE WILL NEVER HIT LADY GAGA!!! LUV U MAMA MONSTER
linikedemo 10 months ago
YEAH GAGA MADE IT SOOOO BETTER NOT EVEN FUNNY
ArielAbstract 10 months ago
nahh its more Diana Vickers ripping off RHCP ;)
NarcoticEvil 10 months ago
its just the beat and the rhyme that are the same
megylegie6 11 months ago
haha i just cracked up at 0:08
toymachine135 11 months ago 2
Lady Gaga copies everyone. Pop music might all sound the same, but there's a difference between copying and being influenced. Gaga is a copy cat.
zarbar2 11 months ago
whaaat????. no.
KaelGian93 11 months ago
Rip off for sure
5504ever550 1 year ago
Total rip off!!!!!
shazu1990 1 year ago
she did
shayenum15 1 year ago
Lady Gaga May have copied..But she also Made it Better..Just My Theory..
IloveNixable 1 year ago
Hmh gaga rip off Natasha and Natasha rip off me and i rip off my dog
ihkonparas 1 year ago
natasha beddingfield ripped off jordin sparks, so it's okay :)
EuphoriaMusicSession 1 year ago
thats like saying katy perry copied tik tok and came up with california gurls. yes its the same beat, but its what people like.
iheartwebkinz1 1 year ago
@iheartwebkinz1 actually both songs were produced by the same guy.
ThePhotomusic 1 year ago
@iheartwebkinz1 actually dr. luke wrote both songs
AznLiishii123 1 year ago
Its a relatively simple rift, if it were something more complex then yeah it would have been a rip off, but i'm gonna call bullshit.
airbagguy 1 year ago
lady gaga also ripped off BAD ROMANCE to BILLY TALENT's SURRENDER
the chorus of 2 songs are very similar hahahaha, to the creator of this video,please create a video about DID LADY GAGA RIP OFF BILLY TALENT
jeremyunderground41 1 year ago
@jeremyunderground41 actually, bad romance is a combination of samples, which would mean that billy talent also sampled from another song..
rswallace24 1 year ago
when artists write songs they have to do their research... I mean the with the usher homer simpson thing... it's not like that song was so widely known but pocketful of sunshine is a pretty big song.
thryn11 1 year ago
\LMAO! lady gaga made it better :3
FUCKitsSeanXD 1 year ago
because e-g-e-d-c is such clever composition it's difficult to not to copy! LoL
cerabeara26 1 year ago
No, not really
ParamedicBK 1 year ago
totally! wow lady gaga
hdcutty24 1 year ago
Nope
TheKnightsStar 1 year ago
TOTALY rip off
kasara323 1 year ago
I Love Natasha beddingfield :) x
Emerbm 1 year ago
rip off
hannah111ist 1 year ago
I didn't say that you said that other genres don't sound the same either man i was just giving EXAMPLES cause everybody says yeeah popmusic is all the same which annoys me because it's not, most of the people who say this are like rock dudes and whtv but well...let's end this here.
ILoveLLawlietxD 1 year ago
@ILoveLLawlietxD we'll i'm not a "rock dude" as you put it. You are really just arguing for the sake of arguing, it's kind of funny.
thexcoreissilent 1 year ago
i love both of these songs!!
lollipop56651 1 year ago 2
… as a fan of both… no, she didn't rip her off. You'll notice that a lot of the songs on GaGa's first two albums pay homage to other female singers. I assume that instead of one copying the other in this case, both were inspired by a previous artist.
deliriumbubbles 1 year ago
With the amount of songs around today this is bound to happen a lot. I don't think anyone cares any more tbh
LoupsGarouASYLUM 1 year ago
u have no life i've heard a lot of music that sounds same but i dont go around "OMG this dude ripped off that dude because there songs sound the same"
HunterBEllis 1 year ago
Shit This is stuck in my head again!
MsNeilD 1 year ago
People rip off from each other all the time
but really rip off such a great song
TheArizonaCrocodile 1 year ago
total rip off
2012joshc 1 year ago
lol ya she did rip her off.
rainbowglue2 1 year ago
its similar but not same
neoarcadezr 1 year ago
I don't give a shit because Pocket full of shine was play waaaaaay too much. And lest lady ga ga has made a sing that annoys me..........
I just screwed myself didn't I.
starwarsgeek4ever 1 year ago
Weeee D;
inhibeeldolor 1 year ago
Have you ever thought about what happens when all the songs have been invented not inventing any more because all the songs have already been used. Same here too: the rhythm has not been invented so that it has been borrowed from another song. Gaga, and is not necessarily self-selected rhythm / music producers, but someone has chosen it. Gaga is not even necessarily aware of this.
MilliLoveful 1 year ago
search for California Gurls Tik Tok Same Song, see what u get
ayumunarumi15 1 year ago
Listen´´Four chords son´´ by Axis of Awesome
haskapaska 1 year ago
they dont really sound alike
yunbabed 1 year ago
Gaga does write her own songs actually.. She's actually super talented if people would take the chance to not judge her on her appearance, they would see her talent.
clllaaaiiirrre 1 year ago 31
@clllaaaiiirrre
Ok is this video talking about how she dresses? No it isn't, it is talking about the "similarities" between the songs. I'm not saying the song was stolen I am saying bring up relevant evidence to prove she didn't steal it.
wod377 1 year ago
@clllaaaiiirrre How can they not judge her on her appearance? She obviously wants to be judged as a weird, unique, whatever pop star or she wouldn't have randomly gone from being normal to like that when she started getting more popular.
MarkehJLL 1 year ago
@clllaaaiiirrre What about that song they wrote for Brittney but they didn't put on Brittney's album? It's the EXACT same song, just Gaga singing it. Same lyrics, the back track sounds unchanged, probably the same recording.
I'm not saying Gaga isn't good, she is, I'm fine with that. But don't she writes her own songs. Most pop stars don't. They don't even say they do. They're not supposed to. They know their place, that's all. Lada Gaga is not Prince. She's not a songwriter.
Greydawg 1 year ago
@Greydawg You fucking idiot, Lady Gaga wrote that song for Britney Spears to begin with.
scratch799 1 year ago
@clllaaaiiirrre You don't know how right you are.
ThatxVillianxCYPR3SS 1 year ago
@clllaaaiiirrre Aghhhhhh , why if she then wearing all those costumes, if she was more than looks?It's amazing how her fans are brainwashed
mediasansnom 1 year ago
@mediasansnom Image is important if you want a record deal.
Nannirk 1 year ago
@clllaaaiiirrre oh please another denial person shut the fuck up obviously she copies your a joke
AndresChavez201 1 year ago
@clllaaaiiirrre if tht is true which im sure is these songs n born this way+behappy r really similiar im not gonna jump to conclusions cus theyre all awesome but it does make u think twice about Lady gag bein a genuine song writer
xXHeavenXx13 11 months ago
@clllaaaiiirrre She's asking to be judged on her appearance.
DontShakeItUp 11 months ago
@clllaaaiiirrre Perhaps if she wasn't batshit crazy her talent would actually be apparent.
Archeminos 9 months ago
All the artists you say that you love aren't worth scum... They only get money off of people's ignorance, stupidity and gulability. Britney, Lady gaga, Jonas Brothers, Justin Bieber, and most of all the pop rock culture celebs are carefully selected and built by music companies that only want money and that are happy to spread no talent what so ever to the world so they can get profits! And you know why this abuse works??? Because ignorant people love ignorant "flashy" things.
JinKsed17 9 months ago
@JinKsed17 Never said I liked any of those people actually. And I never have liked any of them. You don't know me so don't assume I'm "ignorant". Think before you speak and don't make a fool out of yourself.
clllaaaiiirrre 9 months ago
@clllaaaiiirrre nobody is saying she copied the lyric she copied the music just like many of her songs. Nobody argue she is talented but her copyness overshadow her talent
cunni3tv 8 months ago
@clllaaaiiirrre
What talent?
sassuhfrass93 7 months ago
Lol there both kinda retarded
JellyFilledDoughnut1 1 year ago
nah!!!
mhdgirl 1 year ago
tats lame!
TheHeartbreakinDiva 1 year ago
it's a line sample hardly a copy of a whole melodic line... this will happen alll of the time in pop actually?
nyxmaroercheostrea 1 year ago
All pop music same
hardstyle ftw !
WalkingExecution 1 year ago
May be they had the same writer.
DBLSIX1 1 year ago
@DBLSIX1 seeing as Natasha Bedingfield writes her own material I don't think so.
OnlyOneTyping 1 year ago
Love how when Lady Gaga copies someone, everybody defends her, but when a rapper copies someone, everybody slates him.
Double standards, much? Saint Gaga can do no wrong I guess.
janieiscool1 1 year ago
@janieiscool1 Agree! Gaga is lameee!!
TheExtremeFootball 1 year ago
in these days you can't invent something that we never heard before because it's all been done. anyway I LOVE BOTH OF THE SONGS, THEY'RE BOTH GREAT.
xomiri 1 year ago
They both suck. Natasha ripped of Souixsie and the Banshees. The music industry is a cannibal feeding on itself.
harryfromwork 1 year ago 7
Comment removed
harryfromwork 1 year ago
no
PohlDani 1 year ago
i dont think gaga ripped off anything. they dont even sound the same:d anyway i think gaga is better soo
xrawwrstarx 1 year ago
Alright, they both suck. Now that is outta the way, the melody is simple. E to G to D. You can probably find many examples of those same intervals all over the place, in different keys, from the past few hundred years. It's really not that hard. E minor?
Plus it's pop music, it can't get too complicated for the 14 year old girls to listen to, and they probably run out of ideas quick.
petethebanjo1138 1 year ago
how is that even similar? not even the same amout of talent! lady gaga is 100 trillion times better! this is stupid..people are so jelous!
GaGa4Kate 1 year ago
@GaGa4Kate Valid argument.....oh wait no it wasn't.
BAXTSPRCHRGD 1 year ago
@BAXTSPRCHRGD yes it is! she did NOT copy...they sound NOTHING like eachother, people need to get this fact. Lady Gaga is a real Artist! she is not some Shaddy artist like Justin Bieber, or Rihanna or Kesha!
GaGa4Kate 1 year ago
@GaGa4Kate You said "gaga is a trillion times better!...people are so jealous!" that is retarded, Gaga is pop trash for a start and people being jealous of her (morons) isn't gunna make a song sound similar. More then likely someone heard the similarities and made a video to highlight it. I doubt the person who made this said "You know what? I am jealous of Lady Gaga imma make a video comparing her song to another and say they are similar MUAHAHA"
BAXTSPRCHRGD 1 year ago
@BAXTSPRCHRGD pwnd.
superfunnydove 1 year ago
@BAXTSPRCHRGD No. people are jelous, that shes famous, and sucsessful! she didnt copy anyone. thats not a opinion but a fact. dont fight with me about this! im done talking to you
GaGa4Kate 1 year ago
@GaGa4Kate She didn't copy anyone but the person who wrote her songs may have.
BAXTSPRCHRGD 1 year ago
@BAXTSPRCHRGD your wrong. she writes her own songs, and shes VERY dedicated to her work! This is stupid i dont know why im wasting my time, talking to you. Your wrong, she writes her own music, deal with it!
GaGa4Kate 1 year ago
@GaGa4Kate Mmmmm Hmm she 'wrote' her songs. Just like Usher 'writes' his songs and just like how Beyonce "writes' her songs. gotcha ;)
BAXTSPRCHRGD 1 year ago
How long did it take you to come up with this?........
luvunomore101 1 year ago
I like both songs. The end.
silhouettexstars 1 year ago
Well, I like pocket full of sunshine better, but in a way it seems like she ripped her off, but in a way she didn't. Nothing is original anymore. Everything is based off another.
PrincessTalia999 1 year ago
Eh well, I liked pocketful of sunshine immediately, but took a while to like so happy I could die, and I pretty much love it now. There's a similarity, but not crazily obvious.
grace317 1 year ago 3
I don't even seen a similarity
OhhNooYouuDidntt 1 year ago
No copy there. similar, that is all.
honduhchicken 1 year ago 6
gaga's song is better in my opinion anyways.
i dont even like natasha bedingfield :|
JustToBeQuiet 1 year ago
so? Gaga is better anyway, stfu and get a life
xxxxtokishonexxxx 1 year ago
@xxxxtokishonexxxx WHY DON'T U SHUT THE FUCK UP AND GET A LIFE U FUCKING PRICK.
b0x3s 1 year ago
@xxxxtokishonexxxx I agree with you there :)
domenica312 1 year ago
@xxxxtokishonexxxx
Gaga better? You must be kidding.
chr1sjeh 1 year ago
All pop music sounds the same, it's not that hard to figure that out.
thexcoreissilent 1 year ago 228
@thexcoreissilent and so are rock, dance etc. too
I hate people who hate on popmusic. pop is like all kinds of music. It is a genre which is in general commercial. And that does not mean that every song who is made in that way is shit.
I mean, for me for example screamo bands sound all the same but should I hate on it because of that?
ILoveLLawlietxD 1 year ago
@ILoveLLawlietxD when did i say i hated pop music, i just stated it all sounds the same!
thexcoreissilent 1 year ago
@thexcoreissilent i did not say YOU hate popmusic but it's kind of ridiculous saying Popmusic sounds all the same, because it's not. People who say this just lean on other People's opinions. Listen to 100 complete different artists and not just 2 or 3 and then tell me it sounds all the same. I hear a lot of other genres too, for example rock in almost all kinds. When you hear all of the fashionista punkrock bands you'll see, that 90 percent of it sounds alike. just for example.
ILoveLLawlietxD 1 year ago
@ILoveLLawlietxD I did not say other genres didn't sound the same either, this just happens to be about pop music, hence why i made the comment, you're making a big deal about a small comment :) Let's move on, okay?
thexcoreissilent 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@thexcoreissilent i did not say YOU hate popmusic but it's kind of ridiculous saying Popmusic sounds all the same, because it's not. People who say this just lean on other People's opinions. Listen to 100 complete different artists and not just 2 or 3 and then tell me it sounds all the same. I hear a lot of other genres too, for example rock in almost all kinds. When you hear all of the fashionista punkrock bands you'll see, that 90 percent of it sounds alike. just for example.
ILoveLLawlietxD 1 year ago
@thexcoreissilent i did not say YOU hate popmusic but it's kind of ridiculous saying Popmusic sounds all the same, because obviously it's not. People who say this just lean on other People's opinions. Listen to 100 complete different artists and not just 2 or 3 and then tell me it sounds all the same. I hear a lot of other genres too, for example rock in almost all kinds. When you hear all of the fashionista punkrock bands you'll see, that 90 percent of it sounds alike. just for example.
ILoveLLawlietxD 1 year ago
@thexcoreissilent denial its hitting you hard huh haha dumbass
AndresChavez201 1 year ago
@AndresChavez201 i'm not sure i know what you're talking about, but starting out with an insult is definitely the way to go.
thexcoreissilent 1 year ago
Um i dont really think so
BannanadogProduction 1 year ago
No..
monster0energy 1 year ago
This sounds like an RnB hit from about ten years ago.
koshermal 1 year ago
not that much really
LeChemostron 1 year ago
Okay for you people who think Lady Gaga copied your retarded it's not the same tune!
Look up the instrumental!
busteroxie101 1 year ago
@busteroxie101 its a similar tune but she still sucks and i don't really care for her but natasha rules all the way p.s. please do not respond
Esmyi 1 year ago
@Esmyi RESPOND.
KoessandDeath 1 year ago
Gaga FTW!
MultiLily2 1 year ago
Prefer GaGas tbh honest. x)
DoughnutMixer 1 year ago
who do you think is better if you thing natasha thumbs up if lady gaga thumbs down
badboy17718 1 year ago
she copied the beat and stole some words also
badboy17718 1 year ago
Gaga is Caca. She's talentless (or her handlers tell her what to wear and sing) therefore, her "style" is always tracked by to someone else. If she really had her own style, it wouldn't look so much that she just randomly chose to "look like" someone else every day. Her outfits would have something in common, but they don't, because she can't have her own ideas/sense of style when she copies everyone.
sdblosom 1 year ago
Yeah kinda . . .
TheWolzen 1 year ago
Humans are pattern seekers. We are trying to match new information to already existing information. That is why we see Virgin Marys in toasted bread and hear other pop songs in pop songs. Basic psychology. ;-)
clothearednincompoop 1 year ago 117
@clothearednincompoop THANK YOU. I've been trying to point that out to my friends!
rainbowmuppet 1 year ago
Haha, she did ;)
BabyJane4444 1 year ago
That is a RIP OFF cant believe you Gaga Natasha is awsome
SeskiBaby09 1 year ago