Added: 2 years ago
From: AnneMStegen
Views: 1,199
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (123)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • neither is better. really. I don't know who started this whole trek vs star wars or why one feels superior to the other. I mean really. I'd like to see one of those family guys demonstrate that. put down your phasers and light sabers and shake hands. its sci- fi . if anything eveyrone join forces to stop jj abrams from making a mochery of the franchise. because if he knew he could get away with it, hed be re-making star wars right now instead of star trek .

  • I like them both. I really don't get where this rivalry came from. Star Trek is science fiction, and Star Wars is science fantasy. Comparing the two is like saying I like oranges better than apples.

  • babylon 5 pownz them both. altrough i like startrek very much too

  • I just don't know why trek fans and wars fans always have to fight over crazy stuff. It is perfectly OK to prefer one over the other but why resort to name-calling and say "star wars/trek sucks" or "it's not even real" or "star wars/trek will never be beaten"?! All of them are only opinions and since it's a battle that cannot be won, why continue on?! Besides, it's against the YouTube Community Guidelines to resort to name-calling.

  • why the fuck does star trek and star wars have to be compared just because they both have the first name STAR.

    If star wars would have been named intergallagtic wars there would be no such bullshit. Im a huge star wars fan but i have to say star wars and star trek are both great in their own way.

    So give each other a rest respect both fan groups what does it matter to be a fan of star wars really seriously.

    This is going on for years now and its just a bunch of bullshit.

    Get A Life! For Real!

  • @stormtroopernl i guess if they´d call star wars "intergallagtic wars" there would have been much laughter ... but to be serious: you´re wrong. certainly star wars vs star trek is the most common nerdfight, as they are the most common sci-fy products. but: check the web, look around on youtube: there are so many other fights between trekkies, galactica freaks, star-(uh, star again;)-gate fans and all the other strange beings. this argument is just fun ...

  • Kirk loving, Spock sucker! Star Wars FTW

  • come on, do we need to fight. theyre practically the same movies!

  • ive always liked star wars better because in star trek theyre pointy ears always creep me out. lol!

  • its not even real

  • star trek sucks balls

  • @atomikus37 whats that ?

  • I'm gonna get Darth Vader to whoop your candyasssssssss

  • there both awesome!!!

  • Got many screensaves. Ships & whatnot.

  • @ anne; let me know if u want to trade pictures.

  • fuck you star wars is fucking better then star trek

  • star wars kicks the shit outta star trek. the movie was alright but the trilogy wil never be beaten

  • ......................

  • Nerve of some things people can say to an 11 year old boy.................

  • STAR WARS IS NOT ROCK AND ROLL! Have you even SEEN a Star Wars movie. The only Rock and Roll star wars music are only the Rock remixes. Also the Star Wars soundtrack is by John Williams who is probaly the best man ever in the history of the Universe. I do not like you and all the Trekkies on earth (and the galaxy!)

  • Star Wars and Star Trek are not in the same category from the logic and evidence I follow. Star Wars is more mythic fantasy like Legend of the Guardians and Harry Potter while Star Trek is science fiction like Back to the Future and the toxic Titan AE. I LOATHE Titan AE, and mere words cannot descirbe my disgust with the vile toxicity that is promoted by Titan AE. It would eb better to turn Star Trek against Titan AE. I would love to do a Star Trek Vs. Titan AE video.

  • @11FreeSpirit Star Wars is SCI-FI! I hate dealing with people like you and all Trekkies. Star Wars is 99% SCI-FI and 1% Fantasy like.

  • @Legovampire556 You did an Ad Hominem Abusive attack for the sake of a Majority Fallacy. Ad Hominem Abusive is where you heap the attacks on the person withthings like name-calling or cussing, not attacking the argument. A Majority argument solely relies on majority opinion to justifiy its conclusion, and the majority has been wrong often. You are a BIGOT from the message you wrote.

  • @MrOdyssey1999 WHY DO PEOPLE HATE ME?! I'm only 11. Well at least I'm a Martial Artist.

  • @Legovampire556 I am not saying that I necessarily hate you, I am just pointing out your logical fallacy. Since you are only 11, chances are that you have not yet studied logic, or how to spot various types of fallacious arguments. I am 27 and I have studied logic in both college class and on the Internet. An Ad Hominem is a logical fallacy that rejects an opposing argument and attacks the person instead of the argument.

  • @Legovampire556 A Majority Argument (Ad Populum) is a logical fallacy that only uses majority opinion to support its conclusion, and this is fallacious because the majority is often mistaken. The reason that the notion of Star Wars being actual science fiction is an Ad Populum is because most people happen to believe it. When I was your age, I too thought that Star Wars was sci-fi and until 2008. Even Geroge Lucas himself admits that Star Wars is not even sci-fi.

  • oh god.... some fat chubby sci fi nerd talking about something that is critiqued as the worst, campy scripts and story lines, compared to what AFI and film historians attribute to what changed cinema forever, along with highly celebrated scholars who said the folklore and mythology was dea on.

    LOL.... star trek = obesity, minimum wage jobs, 40 yr old virgins, social rejects

    star wars = rock stars, good looking, a lot of sex, surfers, top earners, stylish, cool people.

    FACT

  • @JessOnTheRun

    I know that Star Trek = aerospace engineers, scientists, and astronomers, free spirits such as myself

    Your idea that Star Trek = obesity, minimum wage jobs, 40 yr old virgins, social rejects, it is absurd. But to be frank, I am a social reject who turned into a free spirit whop wears a men's neackwear (bow tie) that I promise ot NEVER tie as a gesture of peace. I even wear my peace neckwear to bed every night!

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • @JessOnTheRun You are wrong about Star Trek: 1) Star Trek has a special relationship with NASA and 2) many astronomers and aerospace engineers got into their careers as a result of watching Star Trek, and there is no denying that, it is a FACT. I learned this in various sources like bonus features of Star Trek DVDs and Blu-Rays.

    To be frank, I cannot say what Star Wars has motivated people to do because I do not know, and I do not think you know either.

  • Star Trek has lots of beautifull classy ladies like you! On a different note don't you find it funny how everyone thinks of the original series whenever they think of Star Trek despite The Next Generation being the most televised Star Trek series of them all and won the most awards? Personally I like the original series but love The Next Generation more.

    Star Wars is also great but doesn't have extremely diverse characters because of limited screen time i.e. no TV series.

    Make it so!!!!

  • alright I get it, you like Star Trek, but you haven't realy given any reason why Star Trek is better than Star Wars besides your own opinion and that you find Shatner "hot" I'm not saying your wrong, I'm just saying you need to strengthen your position

  • @SUPERMEDIABROTHERS6 I agree, she needs to strengthen her position, like I did my position agaisnt Titan AE. I am against Titan AE for having a spaceship destroy Earth, casting a bully named Cale Tucker as a hero, and being filled with contradictions and logical fallacies! I use logic and evidence, not just my opinion to back up my claims that Titan AE, like GI Joe, is harmful.

  • I like both, but Trek was there first, and has done much more. And now Trek is doing better movies too.

  • i think any true science fan fan wil go with star trek,star trek has real science hypothesis in it like alternate universe,quantum physics,wormholes black holes and space diving,star wars onthe other hand its pure fantasy and less scientific

  • star trek is overated there are so many other science fiction shows better than it babylon five and farscape for example are way better than star trek. i like star wars but, not that much it is way too juvenile for my tastes the characters are two dimensional and the whole plot and story is suited for the minds of 5-12 year olds if the movie didnt have those ground breaking visual effects star wars would have been just another b grade movie.

  • Right on sister.

    Star Wars is like a shiny box with cotton candy inside. Star Trek is a brown paper bag with steaks inside and I'm a BBQ kind of guy.

  • i have the same opinion on the matter, only switched. star wars is better.

  • starwars is better,but thats my opinoin, thumbs up i u agree

  • Your true star trek is better. It started well before star wars!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Indeed Star Trek is better.

  • star wars and star trek are both good in diferent ways star wars has more action and star trek sometimes has a action but more science 

  • @smoothcriminalalex I agree. I like Star Wars. It's a cool story with cool elements, I just think Star Trek is more quirky and fun

  • umm so i just wanna say that you are completely and totally rite about star trek being better. first of all, all the cast members are way hotter in star trek. second spock just pwns period, and third we have freaking j.j. abrahms on our side. hes a genius.

  • Comment removed

  • First off if these civilizations met in battle Star Wars would pwn anything star trek can throw at them. Star Wars has Clone Troopers, Storm Troopers, Jedi, Sith, Millions of Battles droids, Battleships from the Rebels, Empire, Republic, and Sepratists. And to top it all off the Death Star.

    You could face either the Rebels,the Empire, the Republic, or Sepratists and the federation would lose.

  • go kill your self STAR WARS IS 100000000000000000000000000000­000000000000000000000000000000­0000000000000000000 times better thna star trek!

  • @hsyvhtg you wish

  • Star Wars had interracial relationships (Yes, in the movies, pay attention) between two species that didn't look EXACTLY LIKE HUMANS, which is all Star Trek can ever muster up for aliens in the first place. Everything down to the dialogue to the combat is more exhilarating. You could argue that they are from different times, but they're really not that far apart. Not to mention, the Star Wars universe is so damned huge, there are so many stories involved, it's amazing.

  • @ic3olate I like that point about interracial relationships, but in 1966 I think it would have been harder for the conservative-type people to accept a human interracial relationship than an alien one. It hits too close to home

  • @AnneMStegen i hate these type of debates im a hardcore star wars fan but i also respect both gene roddenberry and george lucas equally its like pie and whiped cream cant have one without the other so i gotta have both

  • Wow. I want to date you. That was awesome.

  • @Y2M20XX Haha thanks

  • @AnneMStegen you could not be any more incorrect, i know it's you're personal opinion.. but who cares about an interracial kiss.. you should be more focused on sci-fi

  • @666PTH Star Trek actually hasScience in it's fiction, LOL.

  • @Idazmi7 lol.it's hard to argue with a girl

  • @666PTH So to you, sci-fi is explosions...

  • @Idazmi7 star wars is a sci-fi saga ...look into it

  • @Idazmi7 i like my sci- fi to be awsome... not 5 hours of talking

  • @666PTH LOL.

    Awesome is something people are in awe of. Star Wars has no science it it's fiction, so it cannot be science-fiction.

    Star Trek is the most awesome sci-fi. Perhaps you should wager Star Wars against The Lord of the Rings. And BTW Star Wars can't compete with any sci-fi in the sci and fi areas. If it could, we wouldnt be having this conversation.

  • @Idazmi7 there's aliens= sci-fi space setting =sci-fi star trek has a penis shaped face guy and they spend like 5 episodes talking about the last 5 episodes

  • @666PTH "penis shaped face guy" I'd like to see that.

  • @Idazmi7 i think it's commander warf 

  • @666PTH Commander Worf has a ridged forhead.

    Have you even seen a small clip of Star Trek?

  • @Idazmi7 i watched a few episodes of it and i seen a copule movies. it's ok if you like star trek. im just saying i like star wars and not trek lol this argument will continue forever

  • @666PTH "penis shaped head" leaves be dubious as to your acceptance of a different type of fan...

  • @Idazmi7 umad?

  • @666PTH No. ustupid?

  • @Idazmi7 no Ustupid?

  • @666PTH "Penis-shaped face" was very childish of you.

  • @Idazmi7 yeah i know. i don't think i have anything goin on in the "make fun of" category

  • @666PTH ...okay.

  • @Idazmi7 not ok

  • @666PTH Now you are just trolling.

  • @Idazmi7 you are too technically

  • @Idazmi7 i think

  • when the dork machine rings you should say dork here

  • dork alert

  • And Vulcans are pacifists Try Boba vs romulans or Klingons

  • Spock vs boba? you know fet would win but its an unfair match... ok???? say if it was a star ship battle Any Starship enterprise could beet Star destroyer or super star destroyer Republic or Empire design

  • Wow, There's no doubt that this argument will rage for ever!! But I agree with you, Star Trek (in particular the original series) has more appeal to me, after all, I grew up with it. Nice!! I kindda like Enterprise too, but for different reasons.

  • u look so cute :-)

  • a phaser would kill before a light saber would get any where near you. X3 STAR TREK IS BETTER. JUST FACE IT.

  • ..... do you think a star destroyer would destroy any star trek ship? anyway star wars was made when there was no computers, you got to give them credit.

  • OMB, SCOTTY IS SEXY. *dies* I LUV U.

  • star trek sucks. star wars is the greatest movie trilogies in mankind. star trek is boring.

  • Id like to see your precious Spock go up against Darth Vader and his ability to choke some one WITH HIS MIND!

  • This fight will go on until all of us nerds die out. I am on the Star Wars side. And yes I enjoy the original Star Wars, and Prequels, and even The Clone Wars tv show.

    P.S you all are invited to hate on me. I know you will.

  • @NerdsInTheBasement As far as Star Wars is concerned, the original is always the best :)

  • @AnneMStegen The originals are obviously the best. But I don't hate the Prequels. I still love them. People always hear the wrong side the of the same story. The Prequels accomplished it's main goal. It appealed to children of that generation. I know because I am a Prequel kid.

  • @NerdsInTheBasement Ditto! The Prequels were entertaining, but the originals are the legend.

  • I Would Like To See SPOCK Go Against BOBA FETT. Spock Would Be Pwned In Seconds.

  • @smansam Naw, Spock would just pull out the Vulcan Nerve Pinch. That would settle it.

  • @AnneMStegen, Spock Sucks In Combat. Boba Fett Is A Bounty Hunter. And The Best To Be Egzact.

  • @Dyscrasia357 and you should put a gun in yours!

  • No worryz so am I !!! XD

  • OMG Anne.........

  • @EshenbaughRacing Don't OMG me :) I'm a dork!

  • star wars it better

  • Couldn't agree with you more cutie :)

  • get your thumb away from the other finger and it's correct :P

    you can't compare them. SW is fantasy like harry potter or lotr, while ST is sci-fi like back to the future or 2001

  • george lucas himself said that there is no science whatsoever in it and it's more about mystery ;)

  • agreed. LL&P

  • They are difficult to judge since they're different formats (TV vs. movies strictly). I forgot to address that, but I'd rather have a phaser than a lightsaber in a pinch because guns are always an improvement from swords :)

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more