The movie was an abomination. The making of this amazing book into a movie, in itself, has robbed children of the free will to create and imagine. It provides young viewers with a prepackaged product of capitalism, strategically designed to generate income -- not to feed the imagination. Tolkien, C.S. Lewis, Homer, Dr. Seuss, and now Pullman are being appropriated by Hollywood. This is equivalent to book-burning, only worse. Philip Pullman should be fed to snow leopards.
Even though I'm not a young child, the previews actually led me to pick up and read the Golden Compass (before I saw the film) as well as the following two books in the trilogy, and I know others who have done the same as a result.
I do admit that the movie was not as good as the book, but it's not an abomination. It was actually one of the better adaptations I've seen. If you want a book-to-film abomination, read Everything is Illuminated, then watch the movie. What a tragedy!
Pullman says that the introduction of the series to film was softened to allow the public to ease into it. He also states that he wants no part of watering down of the second or third stories and that the first film includes all necessary scenes to justifiably recreate the second and third stories on film. That being said, i agree, the movie seemed a total disaster.
I'm surprised Pullman approved of this movie. The original story flowed so well, I don't see why they changed the order of things so much.. other than to have a big explosion towards the end of the movie. I understand not wanting to end the movie where the book ends, but people that have not read the book have little idea how thought provoking the story is. To many the movie is just another kids CG adventure.
Comment removed
nagizaa 2 years ago
His dark Matriels are the best book of the book.
F6JRW 3 years ago 2
i loved the books the films great i understand great parts of it were different but its impossible to fit every aspect into one film
pampers92 4 years ago 6
when we read we visualise
a picture is worth a thousand words
i now wish to read the book
i am a child of 53
so maybe my Daemon is Lyra
kwackajak 4 years ago
you cannot have a human daemon ..
siliconchipped 2 years ago
The movie was an abomination. The making of this amazing book into a movie, in itself, has robbed children of the free will to create and imagine. It provides young viewers with a prepackaged product of capitalism, strategically designed to generate income -- not to feed the imagination. Tolkien, C.S. Lewis, Homer, Dr. Seuss, and now Pullman are being appropriated by Hollywood. This is equivalent to book-burning, only worse. Philip Pullman should be fed to snow leopards.
rommelhower 4 years ago
Even though I'm not a young child, the previews actually led me to pick up and read the Golden Compass (before I saw the film) as well as the following two books in the trilogy, and I know others who have done the same as a result.
I do admit that the movie was not as good as the book, but it's not an abomination. It was actually one of the better adaptations I've seen. If you want a book-to-film abomination, read Everything is Illuminated, then watch the movie. What a tragedy!
supercyle 4 years ago
movies are often times worse than their written counterparts
raikiri23 4 years ago 3
Pullman says that the introduction of the series to film was softened to allow the public to ease into it. He also states that he wants no part of watering down of the second or third stories and that the first film includes all necessary scenes to justifiably recreate the second and third stories on film. That being said, i agree, the movie seemed a total disaster.
beatisagg 4 years ago
preach! preach!
mutanyagwa 3 years ago
Pullman is a genius, i've never enjoyed a series of novels so much in my life.
SNKTHX2000 4 years ago 5
I'm surprised Pullman approved of this movie. The original story flowed so well, I don't see why they changed the order of things so much.. other than to have a big explosion towards the end of the movie. I understand not wanting to end the movie where the book ends, but people that have not read the book have little idea how thought provoking the story is. To many the movie is just another kids CG adventure.
drockncrisso 4 years ago
nice interview
fortunateizzi 4 years ago
Thank you SO much for posting this :)
QuetzalPhoenix 4 years ago
TERREFIC!!!
ek2039 4 years ago