Added: 3 years ago
From: RoverTCB
Views: 75,060
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (68)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • The great Johnny Cash...He is missed..

  • R.I.P. Greatest of all times see you in heaven brother

  • I think that both versions are awesome!

  • its only a matter of opinion who's version is better.. know what i mean? think about it

  • this version and most of this album had tomm petty and the heartbreakers as the band. cash was old in this version

  • this version and most of this album had tomm petty and the heartbreakers as the band

  • Johnny sounds in this version likes he is out of breath on nearly ever stanza. What's interesting is Hank Snow was NOT the first person to do this song. He WAS the first AMERICAN to have a hit with it, however. It was originally written in AUSTRALIA, using names of Aussie towns. Legend has it, Snow heard it on a trip to Australia, but that may be only a 'legend'.

  • @K9AF

    Dang, dude, how could he NOT be out of breath singing this awesome song? Lol.

  • Johnny Rock this song. Sorry Hank.

  • the best

  • Youtube is for videos

  • he's naming all the places he's played a gig.

  • Better than Hank Snow's version!

  • Hank Snow Rocks... this is His song and He owns the Best version!

  • Sorry. I just listened to both versions and I would have to say Mr. Cash's is far superior. Hank Snow was TOO monotone. It made the song boring. Who did it first?

  • HANK OWNS THIS SONG!!

    Oh Yeah!

  • if all y'all people think Hank snow did a better version then quit listening 2 the Johnny cash version and commenting on all the ppl who like this version more it's a matter of wat u like

  • @ihateall95 ...You have to listen to both versions in order to compare them......As great as Johnny Cash is, and believe me, I love his singing....I have to admit that Hank Snow's version is better.....sorry.

  • @Labaron26 oright man i finally broke down to see what the big deal bout hank snow is and illhave to admit he does beat johnny in this song

  • Hank Snow was a native of Liverpool NS I dont think his references were to parochial Yankee towns

  • Please God, give Johnny Cash back to the world. You can take Justin Bieber, just give us Johnny Cash !

  • Who made the song Hank or Johnny?

  • @TheDragonsGhost It was actually first hit the charts in Australia in the late 50's with a version by Australian singer Lucky Starr. Hank rewrote the lyrics to refer to American towns as opposed to Australian towns, and released his version, which was then released by Johnny Cash years later.

  • @FeldsterProductions Some small Canadian towns are in the lyrics.Catalina Kingston Waterville,Waterloo,Frontenac,­,Schefferville.

  • @willmanimp Thanks for telling me that, I'm not crash hot on my North American geography unfortunately. Doesn't change that it was originally an Australian song thought =)

  • @willmanimp He could have been referring to Kingston, New York, or Kingston, Pennsylvania, or any other number of places named Kingston.

  • what's the mater with all yall sayin someone did it better this is the best version of this song there is arounds

  • @ihateall95 hank snows version is better by far

  • @jaromeiginla1 I agree with you. Completely. No contest. Hank Snow has the best version, by a LONG distance, as far as Hackensack (New Jersey, and mentioned in the song) is from Catalina (California, ALSO mentioned in the song)!

  • @ihateall95 I'm going to take a lucky guess. I don't think you ever heard the Hank Snow version.

  • I am surprised that he overflew Africa and said that he had been everywhere. This is something that we can challenge the writer on.

  • well, JOHNNY SANG HER great! !! BUT HANK, OWNED IT !! GREAT SONG & JOB FROM EVERYONE WHO DOES HER !!! MUSIC !!

  • @yukonnahanni

    Please tell me our joking. Cash kicks the originals butt.

  • @kingkull0423 Johnny Cash is one of my heroes, but, sorry, there's no comparison on this song. HANK SNOW's version is BY FAR the best. Plus, Snow sings it MUCH faster. Plus, Cash seems to be struggling with the lyrics; Hank Snow sings it faster and makes it seem almost EFFORTLESS!

  • @frozenfood500 But cash has the accent down perfectly, and the nuance. Cash makes you really feel it in his performance. Cash translates it better. Just my opinion.

  • @kingkull0423 Well, I'll agree with you that he makes you feel his songs just about anyone else. I think it's his earthy quality that make me and others appreciate Johnny so much. He's so sincere. Of course, your reference to "accents": NATURALLY, we ALL have different accents all over the U.S., so there really is no CORRECT accent. And not only that, but Hank Snow is Canadian. I don't really understand what accent you're referring to when you say he has THE accent down perfectly. THE accent????

  • @frozenfood500 The accent for the song...no biggy.

  • Who in the world could remember all those cities??

  • Nice language trash mouth

  • Johnny Did this song as a cover. The real owner of this song is Hank Snow.

  • Hank did a hell of a version; so good I can't sing along. But I can almost keep up with Johnny. You're right. Hank owned it.

  • @ONRrailfan

    Johnny did a hell of a job on this song!

  • He totally did.

  • Just listen the TEXT!!!!! :D

  • i like the way he quickley sayes "im a killer " the one thing you dont want a hitcher to say

  • When does he say that?

  • 0.58 or around there

  • Oh! Thanks! :)

  • sinister isnt it

  • Yeah! Haha!

  • Johnny Cash FTW! You can never go wrong with the man in black.

  • good song

    but when u hear his song hurt

    its amazn

  • hurt is a cover. not his best

  • Great man.Terrific song.Gotta love Johnny.

    Thanx.

  • ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ...... dont get me wrong I love the man in black.

  • He does it better than the writer Hank Snow

  • the writer was Geoff Mack although Hank sang it americanized

  • This is AMAZING! I'm wondering how the hell he was able to sing without taking one breath in those long passages - I'm an opera singer who sings coloratura runs and I'm jealous of him!

  • maybe you ought to take some more breathing lessons

  • u must be pretty bad

  • im fourth

    and im the first to actually comment about the video - ITS LEGEND AND I LOVE IT

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more