Added: 2 years ago
From: DisappearingSaint
Views: 201,553
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (720)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I really love Green Day.

  • @SigneTingen IKR.

  • back when green day was cool even though they were all tweekin, anything after dookie just sucks. so let that be a lesson to all u kids out there- dont ever stop doing drugs!!

  • story of my life.

  • this is when billy joe was the man!! one of my fav gd songs

  • @ThaThri11 Who's billy joe?

    Anyway, Billie Joe is still THE man, including Mike and Tre Cool

  • Green Day suck now, there no longer punk there gay pop rock

  • @123SLIPKNOTRULE Shut the fuck up.

  • I love this song, it's my favorte from Kerplunk :)

  • J.D.Salinger wrote Holden Caufield. did you know that crazy bastard drank his own piss?

  • @wolve95 lawl

  • highlight all

    go to the FIND box

    ctrl- f

  • KEPLUNK KERPLUNK KERPLUNK KERPLUNK WHOOOOOOO WWWWWWRRRRROOOOOTTTTTTTTTTEEE HHHHOOOOLLLLDDDEEENNN CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC­CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCAAA­AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA­AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAU­UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU­UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUGGGG­GGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG­GGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGHHHHHHHHHHH­HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH­HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHFFFFFFFFFFFFFF­FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF­FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF

    LD

    :D :)

  • Now go listen to "I Wrote Holden Caufield" by Screeching Weasel ( :

  • @sarahEllen182 They literally sound like Screeching Weasels

  • Yeah!

  • Happy 20th Birthday, Kerplunk! :))

  • happy 20th birthday kerplunk! :)

  • when ever some one asks me whats ut fav band, i say Green Day..then they say 'OMG that's sooo old!'

  • @nathan926greenday What's even more ironic about those comments is that the people saying that are likely alluding to their new material; I bet they have no idea bout half this old shit lulz

  • old green day = best green day

  • @philcockram Green Day = Best Green Day

  • ATTENTION: we try to get that song into the charts on the day Kerplunk! turns 20, that's on January 17th ;) so it would be great if you helped and get WWHC in the charts....what you have to do? just download the song in the week before the 17th (that would be from 9th-15th, i think) it's not expensive and if many people do that we can really do that!! it would be awesome if some of you helped :)

    if you want to know more you can check out the thread in the Geen Day Community ;)

  • @mjandicehockey4ever Did it get on the charts

  • @Geekstinkbreath123 nope, it didn't....they fogot about it on GDC and didn't make enough promotion for it :D ...maybe next year ;D

  • Chill out he's just trolling referencing the catcher in the rye

  • screechign weasel was

  • I like the bass sound...........It's kinda loud.

  • This group is full of Phonies

  • @UDSMxCYLDE I have a few things to say to you. You're just jealous because you can't do the things that Green Day can do. Would you be rocking for over twenty years if you had the chance? Also, Green Day's fans kick more ass than anyone else's fans. If you don't like Green Day, why are you watching their videos? Go listen to the music you like instead of trashing our favorite music.

  • @EvanescenceXKISS Your a Phony.

  • @UDSMxCYLDE Excuse me, calling ME a phony because I've listened to Green Day all my fucking life? Real mature. I bet you're 11 or some shit. Get out of here and leave us Green Day fans alone!

  • This was one of the first albums i stole from my brothers cd collection in the mid 90es along with Smash from Offspring. Great music :D

  • @TPKKPT Yep! :)

  • @TPKKPT

    i had those two ablums, i remember that feeling. Smash actually had advisories all over during that time, you would never see it with an advisory now

  • @EvanescenceXKISS Whoa there, have you read Catcher In The Rye? No need to go getting all mad; if you'd read the book, you'd understand that this UDSMxCLYDE person is just making a joke referencing the book...which is kind of what the song's about. They're not actually trashing Green Day or you...so you can CALM DOWN.

    It's a great book, by the way. I strongly recommend it.

  • @EvanescenceXKISS If you read The Catcher in the Rye, you'd understand what he's talking about

  • @guitarist2195 I'm not trying to start a fight, so don't make me. ^_^

  • @UDSMxCYLDE Phonies? I went to their concert and Billie Joe played more than four instruments throughout the concert. If you want to hear a phony, go listen to Fergie or whatever the fuck you listen to. Cause Green Day would never blow the Super Bowl half-time show.

    P.S. Go listen to Platypus by Green Day, your the subject of the song.

  • now this is  the good shit

  • Hmmm my name is holden

    

  • So here I am listening to this goddam band called Green Day. Jesus Christ these sonuvabitches are such phonies, but this song kills me y;know. I'm crazy, I swear to God I am.

  • @guitarist2195 I see what you did there.

  • @guitarist2195 You win :)

  • @guitarist2195 God doesn't exist

  • @bgsgbja good job crushing his dreams.. lol ;)

  • @guitarist2195 That's really smart!!! Haha!!! I just finished reading Catcher in the Rye for school. I like the comment, though. Thought it was funny XD

  • @vladradforpres5 you probably don't know he was saying a joke

  • I wrote Holden Caufield and so did you.

  • Screeching Weasel did

  • great song!

  • I just stumbled back to this part of youtube, this is now what my ears fap to

  • I don't believe that Holden deserves a song..

  • @gibbyjibbs lol...get your facts right

    

  • @TheKillaHorse lol up yours

  • @gibbyjibbs up my what? i dont understand. up my ass?

  • I love Green Day... I play guitar. Its a red fender strat and it was my dad's... I call it Red :D

  • Greenday: who wrote holden caufield

    Screaching wesal: i wrote holden caufield

  • :O8E--< look at side ways-person whith boobies

  • when I was 10,

    I tediously looked for all the green day albums & discovered that no one knows good music.

  • for most poeple, green day is just a stage they have at 10 years old, and they only know american idiot, maby dookie, but for some people, green day is a religion, life style, and addiction

  • @greendaykicksass1101 I agree, I know people who go through a mini Green Day fase and start obsessing over them, claiming they only like there "first alblum dookie" , 2 weeks l8r I never hear them talk about the band again, you can tell they aren't true fans because the kid swore Dookie was there first alblum.

  • @greendaykicksass1101 That phase was when I was 5, but now I know every album , every song and know how to play every song on dookie. 

  • @MrTech991 i cant play the solo of coming clean :(

  • Il giovane Holden. *brrrrrrrr * D:

  • i actually bought the book because of this song !! :D ...and well, i like the story, but i don't like the german translation so much xD ...so maybe i'll buy it in english, too xD ...but anyways: this song is better !! :D

  • I never did figure out Who wrote holden CAULFIELD.. But now I have to figure out Who wrote holden caufield too... -_-

  • @SaintTimid J. D. Salinger wrote Holden Caufield in Catcher of the Rye, please if I am wrong someone correct me:)

  • @Jaivk I have the book lol.

  • I love green day and I love every song but most of the songs I dont get???

  • My teacher played this for our class when we were reading The Catcher in The Rye. It was awesome.

  • I discovered the book because of the song. I read the book in english to have the real quotes. And back to school, my friend's that in International section says "Wow, we're going to have Inter tests about books we had to read during the holidays. Fuck, the smartest and more hard to analyze is this catcher in the rye thing!" "I've read it!" "You can read THAT HELL OF A THING?" "Actually I loved it. Man, listen to the song, you'll understand!"

  • I hated the book....i love the song

  • @iworshipTreCool12 ...how did you hate the book?...

  • The book is good. and this song comes close to the book then "I am a Rock" by Simon and Garfunkel.

  • This song explains the book too well. Awesome book though..:)...love to read it, love to hear this.

  • When I think of Holden Caulfield, this first thing that comes to mind is Billie when he was in his late teen years. That's what I think Holden looks like. Some real punk ass who doesn't give a fuck.

  • A great book and a great song.

  • My favorite book. Fantastic song as well.

  • Catcher in the Rye was the only book i picked up myself and read, front cover to back

  • you spelled it wrong. you spelled it caufield, its cauLfield, forgot the l

  • i wrote it!!

  • best album by green day

  • this was the only book that you can say, " no way man, the song is way better"

  • @xxelove

    Except that the Catcher in the Rye is one of the best books written in the 20th century. Not hating on this song in the least bit.

  • @xxelove idk I love them both equally :D

  • @xxelove i have to say i disagree... completely

  • Dear replay button

    Im sorry about me clicking you with no mercy, but this song is so fucking addictive and awesome that I could not control my self at all :S

    I hope that you forgive me and that we may become frieds again and...

    ....0:00 ops i did it again :S

  • green day lost 90% of their original fanbase when they went POP with dookie

  • @controlah lol, dookie is no more pop than kerplunk. and insomniac is even less.

  • @controlah Dookie was hardly Pop

  • @controlah pop? Are you an idiot? Green day is Punk Rock, and some alternative rock.

  • @MrTech991 No their pop/Punk they said it their selves!!!

  • @musicadict121 They do have pop punk songs, but their old stuff (kerplunk for example) is straight out punk

  • @jamesbullet55 punk rock. not punk.

  • @MrTech991 ? And the difference is? Why is punk being defined by a ridiculous amount of subgenres? Doesn't make any sense, goes against what punk is meant to be about.

  • @jamesbullet55 punk IS whatever the hell it wants to be, but there are still separate genres.

  • @MrTech991 Exactly, but punk and punk rock is hardly as different (if different at all) as, say, punk and pop punk.

  • Love this song,  and love that book :)

  • i 'accidently' hit the replay button 25 times

  • holden is from his favorite book :3 (catcher in the rye)

  • I'm gonna read the book just because of this song( and to find out how many times he says "phonies")

  • love the shit out of this song

  • isent this song about how billie joe can relate to cather in the rye?

  • Catcher in the Rye is a good book.

  • I LOVE THE CATCHER IN THE RYE OKAY SO SHUSH and respect Holden Caulfield and everything he stands for, including hypocrisy.

  • who wrote holden CAULFIELD*

  • @GRINDCOREJOEL78 That's a gay name.

  • @MrTech991 screeching weasel sux donkey boner compared to green day

  • @ohgravity1000 whoa dude shut the fuck up theyre both good bands until their 4th album. then they both suck.

  • @summerofska green days 4th album was nimrod and tht was a punk masterpiece

  • @ohgravity1000 HAHA DID You SAy "PUNK"? go listen to some circle jerks and tell me this again.

  • @summerofska circle jerks? nah im not into gay porn

  • @ohgravity1000 Green Days fourth album is Insomniac not Nimrod it goes

    1039 Smoothed Out Slappy Hours , Kerplunk ,Dookie ,Insomniac, Nimrod

    and Insomniac is the most punk album from Green Day

  • @ohgravity1000 their a band a punk band

  • @ohgravity1000 you're stupid.

  • @summerofska green day sounds a lot like the ramones who were one of the most essential punk rock bands.

    and just cause the singer has no scratchy voice, it doesn't mean that green day are not punk.

  • I like all of Green Day's stuff. I like their new songs just as much as the old ones.

  • they've grown up! they've changed, as everyone does! they dont stuck in a style... but i think the spirit is the same, i fuckin love every of their songs!

    and the rest doesnt care! .|.

  • STORY TIME! Sorry, I just remembered this thing that happened today, and i HAD to share it with my beloved friends of youtube. Okay, so, at lunch today, we were talking about the heights of my and my friends. One of my friends said she was 5' 5". After she said that, I couldn't help but yell, "THAT'S JUST TWO INCHES SHORTER THAN MY FAVORITE ROCK STAR!!!!!!!" Then people thought I was pshyco. THE END!

  • SW > GD

  • @Punkification101 who the fuck is SW? even then nobodys better than Green Day

  • @Punkification101 Never heard of "SW"... does it stand for shitty whores?

    

  • @MrTech991

    screeching weasel

  • @MrTech991 no its screeching weasel

  • Green day I fucking love you

  • i dont think they sold out! but then again i LOVE them just like i did 17 years ago... it will never change, i will never "grow up." i get made fun of all the time for my obsession but really i dont give a fuck...i LOVE this music and htere will be nothing that can change it....

  • god, love this.

    it's kinda cool how much their music has changed since kerplunk...

    Green Day 4ever

  • this is how im studying for my the catcher in the rye exam! lol

  • @RNRPioneer me too

  • i don't agree with zustakhn about the song, but yeah, how come no one's mentioning catcher in the rye?

  • How come no one mentions The Catcher in the Rye? And this song is not that good.

  • @Zustakhn fuck you. this song rocks

  • @Sunnycool198

    I fully agree but their new stuff is go to

  • the old songs are the best *_*

  • wtf is he saying lol

  • GREEN DYA SUCKS I LUV LADY AGAG MORE AND KESSA IS REALLY GOOD SHE CAN PLAY VOICE WELL

  • @NickMcNinja YOU ARE NOT WORTHY TO COMMENT ON GREEN DAY VIDEOS, DREADFUL CHILD!

    GO AWAY!

  • @EmmieTheDino can you not read troll?

  • @NickMcNinja I just thought you couldn't spell.

  • @EmmieTheDino no -_- im a troll. and "kessa" cant "play voice well" xD

  • @NickMcNinja I Speed read :) Hahaa

  • Who wrote Holden Caufield?.... No One Knows.

  • @panicatdsteuer Actually Billy Joe Armstrong Wrote This Song! haha

  • I honestly think green day should still write songs like this instead of there poppy music they do today, still green days music today is pretty good, just not as good the classics

  • @greendayandponys No, there very much so is. I'm not going to argue whether or not Green Day sucks nowadays, but there definitely is a difference between their old punk stuff and their new mainstream stuff.

  • ok, im a huuge gd fan, but to get things straight theyre is an OLD and NEW gd. mabye not officially but 21st century sounds nothing like this, theyre 2 different sounds. and when ppl say OLD gd, theyre talking about it in a sense of what year the album came out. and tbh, i like gd from 1039 to insomniac, the GOOD gd

  • @pyroslayer83 i count old gd as before warning and new gd as warning and on

  • @nimrodguitarist96 yea you could say that

  • Oh how balls this band became. Such a shame.

  • @joostay don't be an ass. keep your negative comments to yourself and go watch your hannah montanna music videos

  • who argees tht awesome as F**K's is much better but this is also gd

  • @stubbztheassassin  dont be a dick

  • about 4 months ago, i knew who Green Day were, but only knew a few songs, (Holiday, Boulevard Of Broken Dreams, American Idiot) 4 montihs later, i now have 144 of their songs on my ipod, all of their albums up to date, and i fucking love them! and being a guitar player, i just love playing their songs!

  • I love how this song is from Catcher in the Rye. Awesome book.

  • Fucking Awesome

  • Honestly, I didn't know this song until awesome as fuck came out (because this is sadly the only green day album I don't own) and its one of my favorite songs now! Hehe :) I love billie Joe so fucking much! And tré cool! And mike dirnt! Lolz

  • Ok to begin this id like to say STOP BEING A HATER. I used to be a huuuuge greenday fan, and i still love them its just i stopped listening to there new stuff. I really like the album 21st century breakdown. But thats besides the point, the point is, is that im not a huge a fan of their newer stuff but you dont see me bashing them and greenday fans. DOWN WITH THE HATERS >:/

  • I think it's stupid to dismiss people who listened to only their old stuff as "not real fans". Personally, I love everything Green Day has ever recorded, but everyone has different tastes, and the old stuff could've had a great impact on them at one point, but they don't quite have that connection with more recently recorded GD stuff... Does that make them not a "real fan"? I sure as hell don't think so.

  • @StardustBeatle1039 Well of course they are still fans but not very good ones, because good fans stick by the band they love even at the low points in their career, they say yeah I like that band but only when they make music that appeals to me, how shitty does that sound. They just want Green Day to make the same shit over and over again, pretty much they want another Dookie, and i think Green Day will present that but not before they expiremented with new ideas and they suceeded.

  • @AstrophelTDeath I mean come on those in a way are not fans they don't want Green Day to make their music they want Green Day to produce music that appeals to them, thats not a fan thats an undergroud greedy recording company. So fuck them and anyone who supports that idea, all their music is good not just the old, its time to grow up and literally face the music.

  • @AstrophelTDeath That's exactly what I'm talking about... Green Day is not your spouse. You don't HAVE to stick by them your entire life. If you don't feel as connected to some of their music, you shouldn't HAVE to pretend that you like it in order to dodge the "real fans" who judge everyone.

    "Of course they are real fans but not very good ones..."

    That just sounds stupid and pretentious. Grow up.

  • I don't mind if people stopped liking their new stuff because it is different but it annoys me more when people JUST like them 'cause of their new stuff. I still love there new stuff, but there's no denying their old stuff is better. If people only like them because of American Idiot and 21st Century Breakdown, that what I consider not a true fan. But the old fans are the real fans, whether or not they like all their new stuff.

  • favorite song ever