Ya know, I'm hesitant to say I like either one better, just because they are SO different. The chorus sounds like something from Black Sails in the Sunset, which was great. And the bridge was very Art of Drowning, just because they kinda let it all fall apart and then crunched back up for the chorus.
But, I'll confess I very much like this version. To me, it's like hearing an AFI song I've never hear before, shich is fun.
i like the refrain better in the album version, but i like the main parts in this version a bit better, but overall id have to say the album ver was better
I LOVE the c.d. version but this version is SO much better... the c.d. version is TO produced... I noticed that whenever they over produce anything by AFI you can't really understand wtf Davey is singing most of the time! And I always thought he did that on purpose or couldn't control that! LOL
yeah, like the screams on here on more frequent and more enjoyable. rip it to your ipod so you can revel in it everyday. that's what i'm gonna do. lol
I love this version way better than the one on the Sing The Sorrow album.
Beast6170 3 months ago
0:28 "and we'll smell some perfect hay" ???
GuyNicknamedFille 4 months ago
@GuyNicknamedFille POT!
DomMenace226 1 month ago
this one doesn't feel so compressed...there's more "space"
I like it more...kind of, also there's no stupid BEEP in the chorus
FeelingFreshSon 4 months ago
This is beautiful. Simply great.
MoreThanEclectic 7 months ago
do they say "raped by monolithic?" I know that not reasonable, but fuck it sounds like that
Abercrombieand1Bitch 8 months ago
@Abercrombieand1Bitch XD Raise high monolithic statues.......but it does totally sound like that....
XxPromisesBrokenxX 7 months ago
I kinda like the cd version better.
Upwithlife123 8 months ago
Yes this version is way better than the one on the record. It sort of sounds like the old AFI in the chorus.
337Alexander 10 months ago
the chorus sounds completely different. i like it. the simutaneous singing and screaming of he album version was a little chaotic
ThroughLidlessEye 1 year ago
Ya know, I'm hesitant to say I like either one better, just because they are SO different. The chorus sounds like something from Black Sails in the Sunset, which was great. And the bridge was very Art of Drowning, just because they kinda let it all fall apart and then crunched back up for the chorus.
But, I'll confess I very much like this version. To me, it's like hearing an AFI song I've never hear before, shich is fun.
Wafflepopword 1 year ago
Personally I like the cd version more, but it is cool to hear a different version of it, and to hear what the song originally was
Sixpog 1 year ago
awewome! love the demos even more than the original
anyone have demos of despair faction? my fav song!
helloieatchicken 1 year ago
YES!!!!
DomMenace226 1 year ago
me encanto!! AFI ES LA NETA!!!
miyukiZETA208 1 year ago
This is still absolutely amazing, but I have to admit I like the chorus melody in the studio version better. It flows with the verses better.
famousitykills 1 year ago
Wowowow!!!! This is amazing. I can't decide whether I prefer this version or the album version. I like both equally, I think.
And yay for Jade singing! <3
xAuthorUnknownx 1 year ago
i got thrown off REAL bad lol i tried to sing along and got lost there for a while!!
goldphishez 1 year ago
Wow, this is the best sounding version on youtube, and it's the demo, lol.
commlink101 1 year ago
Wow, that chorus threw me off. I do prefer the STS one, but this is pretty awesome.
thx4thevenom 2 years ago 4
oh.... i miss this voice
he still uses it, just not ON ACTUAL ALBUMS! check out the bleed black live 09 edgefest footage. better vox than the album
spyhunter1223 2 years ago
That was insane!!! I like both versions of the song but, I do like to see something done differently.
Greywolf717wp 2 years ago 2
woow, this version is even better
1Jennyver 2 years ago
I love how the guitar sounds. I almost like this version better(:
ohshittkailaaa 2 years ago
i love this version, but i prefer the STS chorus
sampyree 2 years ago
Wow, this went in a different direction on the chorus. I don't know which one I like better.
ominousXstorms 2 years ago 3
i like the refrain better in the album version, but i like the main parts in this version a bit better, but overall id have to say the album ver was better
Deathless1One 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i luv this song
xshygirl13x 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I like this version much better than the album version. I'm super excited for Crash Love, too.
Hopefully it won't be such a disappoint like DU.
Satochan123 2 years ago
Comment removed
canesrule96 2 years ago
I LOVE the c.d. version but this version is SO much better... the c.d. version is TO produced... I noticed that whenever they over produce anything by AFI you can't really understand wtf Davey is singing most of the time! And I always thought he did that on purpose or couldn't control that! LOL
xKidXHavokx 2 years ago 12
God this version fucking rules..personally i dont like this song on STS but this version is f'awesome!!!
Zelixleo 2 years ago 4
mp3?!
BreValintine 2 years ago 4
seems like no matter what afi does i'm always going to love it haha. they never disappoint me and i hope they don't.
dash5775 2 years ago 14
@dash5775 im sure once in their life afi tried to screw up as a joke, but they just cant.
Jonathanism1 10 months ago
i dont think itsthat the chorus is bad, it just seems to skip into the chorus so it sounds a little weird
psychomidget482 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
when this chorus come the song loses its balls. Good demo btu the album ones sicker. Afi rocks.
FoxMulder101 2 years ago
the chorus is weird, but if i'd get used to it, i could maybe like it? the demo version by itself isn't bad.
MiseryParapluie 2 years ago
I'm so glad they changed the chorus for the record. This one just didn't fit the song as well. But it is still catchy
APutridRomance 2 years ago
the picture thingy gets bigger!
Slooter93 2 years ago 5
I really like this. Not quite as much as i like the refurbished one, but still really interesting to hear.
Paynekill 3 years ago
People think the chorus is bad but I think if they'd of polished it more and given it a cleaner sound it would be way better than the new version
xenogis 3 years ago 2
yeah, like the screams on here on more frequent and more enjoyable. rip it to your ipod so you can revel in it everyday. that's what i'm gonna do. lol
spyhunter1223 2 years ago 2
Hm, everyone hates the chorus so much in this song, but I actually like it. The melody's rad. :P
JeTbLaCkLoVe 3 years ago 4
I like the chorus better on the demo. I like all the demos better except for but home is nowhere. Only because Davey clearly needed studio help. lol
Devoted2Mariah 3 years ago
So raw... So amazing. :]
InstantDrop 3 years ago
can i get this actual song somehow? ? ? i want it for my ipod sooo bad! and same with Synesthesia's DEMO and This Celluloid Dream's DEMO!!! omg!!!!
xblaqkaudioxafix 3 years ago
background vocals are amazing, sounds like jade but hunter does have a voice on him if you've seen his band.
ldiablo233 3 years ago 3
forever will remain
from below
in my seclusion
look up to the sky to see
wings
and watch them burn.
profitprophet368 3 years ago
everything else almost sounds better but the chorus, the chorus is shit compared to the original
TreeFighter5000 3 years ago
Awesome version, but i've got one question:
I can't understand very well the chorus backing vocal lyrics, can someone please put it here? I've already search it and I just can't find =\
eduardosn01 3 years ago
woo there from my home town!!!
mendobrawler22 3 years ago
I like the rough sound of this demo more, but I like the chorus they went with for the album version more.
Of course, the rough sound is only cause it's a demo, but it sounds cool. Sounds raw.
mellonxcollie 3 years ago
I love the vocals of this =].
♥ AFI
killingxxlights 3 years ago 2
if anyone wants this recording message me on youtube and provide your msn, i will e mail it to you
AxFireXInsidex336 3 years ago
woahh,
I like this version better than the one on the album.
they should have kept it the same,
But the one on song the sorrow is still GREAT!
But you really should tell where you got this,
So much greatness can't be kept to one person!
SHARRRE THE LOVVE!
:D
XtheligatureX 3 years ago 4
fully agree, this version is better, but maybe its because it is new to us?
SurpentineSacrifice 3 years ago 4
Who's singing in the background at "Id stop it had you a heart.." ?
that1gurl7 3 years ago
It could very well be Jade. He plays and can sing some phrases while he plays.
celluloidxdreams 3 years ago
Awesome...He's really hott.lol
that1gurl7 3 years ago
or it could be Hunter as in some songs he does were I'm assumeing Jade can't (what with playing the guitar part and all)
MidnightxxxRunner 3 years ago
This is so freakin cool.They rock no matter what! lol
that1gurl7 3 years ago
the courus sounds different.
thetruerater5 3 years ago
no it doesnt, its exactly the same, there is no change whatsoever! (if anyone didnt pick it up, that was totally sarcastic)
SurpentineSacrifice 3 years ago 4
i LOVE the harmony in this one!
pokepick 4 years ago 5
awesome, where did you get it ?
i can't find it anywhere ='(
thoms667 4 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
It's obvious this is a live demo recording with no mixing to speak of. You can clearly hear the mic bleed.
zdrax 4 years ago
lol try playing both versions at the same time
MgSqueerO 4 years ago
thanks for uploading this, this demo really sucks though, this sounds like garbage compared to the great version that's on STS
crustpunk 4 years ago
whoah, i think i like this version more. thank you. i think this is the only song i don't really like on STS :P
xGoMxMAGGOT 4 years ago
wow
im so glad they put the other version on the album
im sure
if i heard this first
i would have liked it
but
beacause im so used to the other
this is just terrible
lol
thank god for afi changing their minds
AFIownage 4 years ago
i love this song
777xdanx777AxFxIx 4 years ago
omg thank you SOOO much!! could you send me this i love it!! the chorus is completely different.
mikesxr600r 4 years ago