Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (231)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • 9 dislikes ?!? lets hold hand and pray.. Dear Lord, please forgiveth them and allow them to taketh their head out of their asses and smelleth the roses. Amen

  • Is and always will be the finest live cut ever of this song, each member is on uber awsome form, one of the best tunes bono has written ever,and particularly in the last 14 years, makes me proud to be Irish when my country can create such beauty, peace and love.

  • the guy can still sing

  • Amazing !!!

  • This song is fantastic !!!

  • This would rock much better than the remix one one the 360 tour !

  • one of my fave u2 songs :)

  • u2 fans should learn to love n not hate. pls respect one another bcos that's d message of u2.

  • What delay does The Edge use?

  • @margera97 This is probably s digital unit. I think he uses something by Line 6. - Used to use a Memory Man pedal.

  • Just awesome!!

  • mans got a voice!

  • i think every time you see U2 playing they have a different guitar than another time. they all sound great though.

  • @matrixman609  Yeah, The Edge has a different guitar because they all sound different.

  • one of the best songs u2 ever made and kick ass performance! bono is awesome!!

  • Oh yes, this song just kicks ass! One of their best in years!!! I will see them for the third time live next July in Nashville. Seen Pop, Vertigo, and soon Horizon. I cannot wait. Paid $250 recently to see McCartney, $ 125 for the Eagles, $100 for Clapton, on and on, but I guarantee this will blow all of them away! As a mountain climber, this song just hits deep to my inner core! : ) Long live U2!

  • You know I am a huge U2 fan, I have not bought this LP, but the more I listen the more I like, and the more I compare right up there with their best, October, Joshua Tree, Achtung, and others. Truth is this album rocks and too bad many can't hear that. Their live shows are the best and no one other than Pink Floyd compares, and I've seen everyone from AC/DC to Zeppelin, but then again, that's like comparing apples and oranges. U2 is just a great band and so is this album. I'll buy it now!

  • @NikonFstopper ur not a fan if you dont have their albums sad sad guy

  • @corku2 Dude, I have all their albums except for the last one. I've traveled hundreds of miles to see them, twice, and are a payed member of U2.com. I will see them live for the third time in a few months, so before you put your mouth further inside your mouth, you better get your facts straight, OK?!!!! Bono himself has sent me emails and songs, what the fuck has he done for you? Nothing?...I thought so, you fucking looser!

  • @NikonFstopper , Traveling to see them doesn't mean your a bigger fan, seen them twice doesn't mean you a big fan.. been a paid member of U2 is a stupid excuse, the atu2 website is ten times better for U2 related info. someone is winding you up by sending you e-mails claiming to be Bono. What has he done for me. i didn't ask anything of him so i don't expect anything. And if you on about u2 related content id destroy you and the amount of times ive seen them live, dickwatt

  • lol you dont have to like the album its ok but please don't try to say its bad just because it hasn't sold as many albums as other albums of theirs. You are entitled to your opinion but trying to say that they think the album is bad when they were talking about it being a commercial flop for their standards is much different than they saying its bad. I've been to 10 shows on their current tour and they have all been packed full stadiums. Sounds like you just don't like them and thats ok.

  • so good like the album.

  • Brilliant, thank you :)

  • This album is not crap.  It's different, very different, but through the years, so many have bitched that U2's songs sound alike. When they try to do something different people start bitching again, saying it's crap. There are many great songs on Horizon, you just have to open your mind a little to appreciate them, that's all. Give it a chance!

  • @NikonFstopper Its an amazing album from a band that has done everything already. Smart people appreciate the great music from the biggest band ever

  • It's not a hill it's a mountain

    As you start out the climb

    Listen for me, I'll be shouting

    Shouting to the darkness, squeeze out sparks of light

    You know we'll go crazy

    You know we'll go crazy

    You know we'll go crazy, if we don't go crazy tonight

  •  Best of a bad lot on a crap album

  • @breda83 Its a fantastic album. Its too bad you dont see that. Diehard U2 fans (their biggest critics) rate it in their top 3 or 4 and thats pretty amazing.

  • @dalivoxhewson U2 have admitted themselves that is wa a flop...

  • @breda83 flop as in commercial flop which means they have sold 5 millions copies which for anyone else is a major success. they love the album and so do quite a few people. Flop is much different than Bad. They don't have a bad album. Not trying to convince but just saying its ok to like the album its a different one for them but still very much U2. They have more success than any other band so its ok to have an album that is not their biggest. U2 fans appreciate it. Not trying to convince.

  • @dalivoxhewson Are you Bono by any chance? U2 manipulate concert sales and they try it with Album sales but this album was so bad that no one wanted to buy it. They put more PR into this album because deep down they knew it would flop.

  • the best 4ever

  • I love this song sung either way. It was great fun to mix it up "hands in the air, now shake like an old fool". That is just part of u2's genius...that they can not just remix for the dance clubs, but for the died in the irish wool fans/supporters as well...shows that they aren't sitting around on their haunches just going into 'auto mode' and grabbing our money....they are still just as awesome as when I first heard them in 82.

  • I wish I was in the US, they are coming to Argentina by the end of this year (or next year)!! Best band ever!!! Best tour ever!! What else could you ask??

  • @micuentaesunica te veo en river cuando bono se de una vuelta por argentina hermano! ! ;)

  • @micuentaesunica te veo en river cuando bono se de una vuelta por argentina hermano ! ;)

  • @jojkljkl oka. esperemos que pueda venir, a pesar de la lesión que sufrió. U2 forever!

  • @jojkljkl nos veremos en marzo del año que viene?? en river??

  • @micuentaesunica esperemos que sea en river y no en el estadio unico de la plata pero si te veo en el concierto y a todos los otros fans latinos !!

  • i love u2

  • Ah..eh, uhm meh....arhh ohh boowhoo. Too good.

  • awesome awesome awesome!

  • You asked me to sing, but I don't sing, I do other things and will do anything you ask.

  • I am going crazy thinking of you and why I didn't come to you behind the cabanas, but why didn't you come to me, just to talk, I mean I love your singing and can listen forever, but I would rather talk to you my baby. Please forgive me if I have saddened you. I am crazy for you and will wait for the day we WILL be together.

  • Lol, I love the way this song starts out all calm and ends up with Bono screaming his face off.

  • @Revan347

    I guess he went crazy afterall lol...

  • J'aime U2!

  • mon aussi!!!

  • esta kancion esta bien bonita

  • best live U2 for me

  • Just saw them at the Cardinals stadium here in AZ last night.. They freakin ROCKED and the stage was the most amazing one i've ever seen!!!!

  • I love this song and U2 rockksss!!

  • WAY better than the remixed live version they're now playing on the 360 Tour... I really wish they would stick to the original. This song has soul, and I'd take soul over dance-ability any day of the year.

  • i think so too.

  • @ChewyMcMittens: They went crazy. ;)

    But I like the new mixed live version.

  • @ChewyMcMittens Couldnt agree more. This is a great song...might even be the best one from The Horizon !

  • @ChewyMcMittens Same here. Going to see them at M&T Bank Stadium in a week, and I really hope they play this version.

  • @GivepeaceachanceJL Saw them there w/ you. My first time ever! Blew me away so I had to see them in Pittsburgh too. ;-) I should have forked over the cash for Philly as well!!! I vow to never miss any performance within a 150 mile radius ever again. And...I told dh I'm saving for their Dublin concert when they release their next album and tour! Can't wait!!

  • Letterman crowd typically very mellow, U2 works the crowd like no other band, can't wait to see them in NY in three days..

  • MAN they are awesome live!

  • U2 is huge in the USA!

  • This version is way better i dont like the live one

  • This is live you div

  • Sorry I meant the 360 tour version

  • Only 10%

  • This original version is great, but I also liked the dance live version of the 360 tour!! :D

  • SwEeT SonG, iS tHere An OffiCial ViDeo SonG???(Can'T FinD iT)

  • brilliant tune......love it:)

  • me encanta!

  • are U2 big in the USA?

  • They're big everywhere really. There is a nice blackberry commercial going around with this song.

  • yep

  • They aren't exactly mega-stars, but they are fairly well known

  • When you take the overrated bands out, they're "megastars." All in all, they're very well known in the USA

  • they're in the rock and roll hall of fame.

  • GReat quality!!`~

  • I miss them so much!

  • its so clear its like i'm there.

  • Sept. 24th, Giants stadium. i can't wait!!! =D

  • sept 25th giants stadium!! =D

  • U2 ROCKS

  • yea U2

  • amaaaaaazing song <3

    i got floor/pit tickets for their concert in october in california! :D

  • jealous urrrg :P

  • i swear if i was in the front row of that i would b singing as loud as i could

  • LOVE this TUNE:) C*O*O*L  *_* :)

  • i think ive listened to this song about 40 times in a row

  • Same here

  • no words

  • i love this song. its a song that can make you cry because its so beautiful. and in my opinion the new album is one of their bests!

  • wheres the real music vid with the cartoons?

    i like that one better

  • This is amazing!

  • thats amazing he sounds EXACTLY like the recorded version... hes a true artist unlike most shitty bands these days U2 is the real deal man

  • Really like this song. Very nice.

  • if u have tickets 2 there concert ur very lucky man i was the on the 27th of july and all i can say wow fucking wow u will have the best time of ur life at a concert amazing peace out U2 4ever

  • Theyve still got it.

    Amazing :):)

  • I love this song sounds AMAZING!!

  • Wow this moment of magnificent had chills go down my spine. I love this song now. Awesome

  • i was watching hangover and i saw this ad now i love U2 and this song!

  • thats how i heard it but i was watching the ugly truth

  • oh my god that was brilliant!!!!

    Can`t wait for Glasgow in August!

  • u2 is the best ban for the over times is the best band of galaxy

  • thankyou blackberry

  • I love this song now because of the Blackberry ad.

  • j leno is alot better then MR democrat letterman. who loves sochilisum!

  • *socialism

  • is that such a bad thing?

    the concept is that the government and the people help one another for the betterment of everyone and not just themselves.

  • Amazing quality of image congratulations =D

    This band is the best of all times man =) Simply magic

  • wow this ong is excellent i heard it on a comercial and i love it! AND THE HD QUALITY IS AMAZING!!!

  • IT LOOKS SO GOOD IN HD WOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO.

    Lov U2

  • The Edge is a wizard on guitar.

  • See you tom in Paris ..... will be exceptional, sure of this ..... First time i saw U2 in Paris was .... in Zenith, always remember this concert , since 20 years

  • is there a song better than this from the album "no line on the horizon"?

  • U2 POWNS

  • This version is by far the best so far performed of this song. It's pretty much perfect.

  • I wait a lot July 12th for see you on Paris guys ! (Sorry my english is not so good bu I'm french and I'm 13 and a half ^^)

  • I think I might explode if they play Unforgettable Fire. Greatest band in the world! Can't to see them in Dublin

  • This is a straight forward pop song but it's so soulful you can't help but enjoy it. I think there are better songs on the album, but this is a damn fine tune as well.

  • this performance is a little rough, but this song is great! can't wait for Soldier Field.

  • U2 are the Beatles of our time!

  • you are definetly right

  • according to reports online, u2 completed their first rehearsed full set list. mlk, ultraviolet, drowning man, in a little while, angel of harlem and unforgettable fire were all practiced.

  • wait, so they're gonna play unforgettable fire on this tour? that would be sick!

  • they've NEVER played unforgettable fire... AND we might get Ultraviolet?? this is gonna be so awesome!!

  • They have played The Unforgettable fire, On the Joshua Tree tour.

  • Brazil is waiting for you boys!!!!!!!

  • we´re waiting in Chile Bono!!

  • LOVE the new album back cover w/ Dave on it.

  • Bono is on amazing form right now!!! This new album is amazing, i think this is the best song though!!

    Cant wait, Berlin and Glasgow!!!! :D:D:D

  • beautiful song!

  • i love it! i love the band, they are the best ever!!!!!!!!!

  • U2 are simply magnificent, Letterman however is a complete idiot

  • agree disagree

  • 14/08/09. will be their best perfomance beside the dublin shows!!

  • nloth is truly a classic u2 album

  • u2 forever.....

  • I love this song!!!!! One of their best ever and absolutely one of the best on NLOTH!!!!!

    See you in Dublin 24/7 and Gothenburg 31/7 & 1/8!!!

  • this is a very good song on the album NLOTH

  • Uma cançao lindíssima,mais um hino para os nossos ouvidos,obrigado aos U2 por comporem a banda sonora da minha vida cada momento uma cançao.Viva os U2 desde Ponte da Barca - Portugal.U2 FOREVER!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Pena que este ano eles não venham cá... mas... eu vou ter com eles a Barcelona! :) U2 always from Porto PORTUGAL

  • my favourite part of the song start's at 3:32

  • one of the best song ever

  • One of the very best songs from No Line. Beautiful!

  • Straordinari.

  • Their lyrics are so catchy, thats also what makes their songs so amazing!

  • absolutely perfect

  • A properly BEAUTIFUL song...very lively and so very U2ish

  • my favorite song of U2

  • my favourite song on an awesome album

  • Todavía siguen haciendo buenas canciones y rockeando como en un principio,.......sana envidia la mia.

  • This performance is pretty much perfect. I can't wait to see them in Chicago. My fist concert!

  • The 27 of august i am also gonna se U2 live in Gotheborg. It's gonna be my first concert, and a life experience i think. u2 rock my soul out ;)

  • A band that ages gracefully. You don't see that in many bands anymore.

  • The boys are pushing 50 and still having fun making music that they believe in. I couldn't ask any more of them.

    NLOTH is a great album

  • Great song!

  • love this song keep rocking u2

  • People might not care, but I do. I need it to be more than music and lyrics if its going to be a great song. It has to turn a switch in me and give me some meaning while I listen to it, or else its just a "good song".

  • amazing vocal

  • i am a huge u2 fan, they've been my favourite since 2001 and i've been to a concert in oslo 2005.

    initially i didnt like the new album, but since then i've begun to love it. a couple of songs on it i just dont understand but thats ok

  • Why do people care if they make sense? The songs are all great. ;)

  • that's exactly my opinion of the new album!

  • Green day hahaha if ya like simple power chord /drop D tunning music , no offence but green day can keep making tunes for the little ones. Have you compared U2's discography to Green days?

  • green day suck!

    the definition of good song is this: U2

  • hot

  • this is a man that puts so much power..soul.. emmotion in his voice...

  • yes i agree god bless U2... no other are like them.... fantastic

  • I love U2's 80's Rockman sound eversince! thanks Edge & Adam

  • Favorite Song on NOLM. HANDS DOWN!!!!!

    Better than magnificent or White As Snow!!!

    moment of surrender comes second...

  • NOBODY comes close.......nobody.

    God bless U2

    X

  • Next single is "Magnificent".

  • boogie ua boogie kapoow! la la ha ha

  • the best song of the year and probably one of the best songs in their whole career. it gives me shivers, God bless you U2