That's a really difficult choice. I always felt that In Camera was overwhelmed by Gog/Magog, and in turn let down by those tracks. However, the remastered version includes the three Peel Session masterpeices, and those three tracks could indeed turn it into the best solo album. Excluding bonus tracks, my own choice would probably be 'The Silent Corner and the Empty Stage', but there are so many great songs on the first four (solo) albums that I cannot easily decide.
Another favourite of mine is the live "Skeletons of Songs", and also "Typical", because live and solo without the overdubbing, engineering and orchestration is definitely my favourite way of listening to PH.
@professoricon I suppose it's an impossible dilemma, very subjective. The reason I raised the point was that all the 'songs' on In Camera are exceptional and, to my mind, find Hammill at a creative peak (solo-wise). As for Gog/Magog? Yes, not sure if it stands up well to the test of time (and repeated plays). Probably one of the most diverse (and risky?) things he's done. More of a soundscape. But, again, perhaps it's that which makes In Camera that bit special?
that our options diminish/as our faculties for choice increase,/till we choose everything and nothing,/too late, at the finish." are truly profound and impressive.
The minutes from 4:02 to 5.45 are very chilling and breathtaking.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Can you please stay away from spamming?
We have all seen the available videos, we got all the records. All you do is spam spam spam I makes me want to puke. There is nothing new you offer, EVER. Spam Spam Spam.
This version is slightly rare because until recently it was only available on a deleted live album, and only now is available as a bonus track on a recently released remastered album.
beautiful, melancholic, and original
the ledward
TheLedward 8 months ago
beautiful, melancholic, and original
TheLedward 8 months ago
Heater Panel at full flow: love his vibrato and falsetto, and his falsetto vibrato too, of course.
lindavid1975 9 months ago
In Camera is Peter's best solo album. Discuss.
neckercube1 11 months ago
@neckercube1:
That's a really difficult choice. I always felt that In Camera was overwhelmed by Gog/Magog, and in turn let down by those tracks. However, the remastered version includes the three Peel Session masterpeices, and those three tracks could indeed turn it into the best solo album. Excluding bonus tracks, my own choice would probably be 'The Silent Corner and the Empty Stage', but there are so many great songs on the first four (solo) albums that I cannot easily decide.
professoricon 11 months ago
@neckercube1:
Another favourite of mine is the live "Skeletons of Songs", and also "Typical", because live and solo without the overdubbing, engineering and orchestration is definitely my favourite way of listening to PH.
professoricon 11 months ago
@professoricon I suppose it's an impossible dilemma, very subjective. The reason I raised the point was that all the 'songs' on In Camera are exceptional and, to my mind, find Hammill at a creative peak (solo-wise). As for Gog/Magog? Yes, not sure if it stands up well to the test of time (and repeated plays). Probably one of the most diverse (and risky?) things he's done. More of a soundscape. But, again, perhaps it's that which makes In Camera that bit special?
neckercube1 11 months ago
questa canzone mi ha sempre messo i brividi per quanto è bella e profonda...
pierumberto 1 year ago
@pierumberto:
si prega di consultare i miei altri video e lasciare un punteggio
professoricon 1 year ago
Oh! To be the captain of a ship of war!
professoricon 1 year ago
questa versione dal vivo è particolarmente bella, molto delicata, direi intimistica
hammill88 1 year ago
@hammill88:
si prega di verificare i miei video di altri per più
professoricon 1 year ago
Versione acustica di questo meraviglioso brano.
ariacurva 1 year ago
最初に買ったアルバムが「In Camera」だったので、個人的にこの曲がハミル先生のヴォーカルの破壊性と悲哀感における代表作になっています。あのフリップ先生のソロで聞かれる曲には涙します。日本のコンサートでも熱狂しました。
usagisama100 2 years ago
私は大好きです。
してください同じものをさらに私の他の動画をチェックします。
してくださいまた、評価ままにします。
professoricon 2 years ago
Comment removed
prosoloist 2 years ago
this is a performer ! what a song, what a voice
mobyboy 2 years ago 6
This is so good it almost makes me cry....
Phangaea 2 years ago 10
oh the voice is lustrous ...how well it works stripped down here a great song.great as solo piano thing
aloeveraqueen 2 years ago 10
Wenn man erwachsen wird, sieht man andere Tugenden als heldenhaft an, als in der Kindheit.
Sirenengesang 2 years ago 5
Hammill at his best
Sirengesang 2 years ago 14
Hamill's Peel Sessions Maybe the best PeelSessions ever!! and definitely Hammil at his best!!
mamelaurent 2 years ago 8
i like the original album version (in camera) better. it's more dramatic than this. still nice though!
DAJAROO 3 years ago
The verses "It's a hallmark of adulthood/
that our options diminish/as our faculties for choice increase,/till we choose everything and nothing,/too late, at the finish." are truly profound and impressive.
The minutes from 4:02 to 5.45 are very chilling and breathtaking.
This song is an outstanding masterpiece!
TeoOrlando 3 years ago 12
I just love this performance so much.
professoricon 3 years ago
great¡¡. thank's
roroguitar 3 years ago 7
This comment has received too many negative votes show
SPAM SPAM SPAM will you ever post any original material
ilka7000 3 years ago
Please check out my other videos for original live videos and rare recorded live material.
professoricon 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Can you please stay away from spamming?
We have all seen the available videos, we got all the records. All you do is spam spam spam I makes me want to puke. There is nothing new you offer, EVER. Spam Spam Spam.
ilka7000 3 years ago
This version is slightly rare because until recently it was only available on a deleted live album, and only now is available as a bonus track on a recently released remastered album.
professoricon 3 years ago
simply amazing! Thank you for posting this
prosoloist 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Please check out my other videos, and leave comments (and ratings).
professoricon 3 years ago
wow, i forgot I had heard this a year ago. Hmmm, gettin' old
prosoloist 2 years ago 2
In a p-38 intercepting Yamamoto!
telemacherT2 3 years ago
wow!
Eiselberg 3 years ago
Yep!
professoricon 3 years ago