ye man, this is the age of oneness.. one school system, one bank, one government to efficiently crush the freedom of individuals...dont like it, oh well, your going to do it anyway, or else guns and prison...come on world, join the stupid ass americans in theyr quest for total slavery
favoring for 1 school system doesn't mean i'm an Umno supporter, because 1 system is what it takes to bring all races together, just like the US or any other countries.
@Berrymore84 Agree with you..politician doesn't want 1 school system.. it is easier to divide and manipulate racial issue to secure their seat in the parliament.
non-bumis don't have to sacrifice their own mother tongue, it's their culture. they just have to go to national schools, speak good national language and study their own languages there. the main goal is to bring all students together and they must learn to mingle around and respect each other that's all.
@novelt burn9802 actually got his point there. if non-Malays wish to have equal rights i think it's sensible that they must first assimilate with the bigger community, fair enough. i give you an example, if Malays migrate to China and they dislike the Chinese system yet they ask for equal rights, as a Chinese how would you feel bout that? if you agreed that BM and other languages are equally important then why don't we incorporate all of them into national schools? segregation is unnecessary.
Why make so much noise-come 2 singapore & experiences d exclusively one system. If u re an Indian even better- Genetically Most competible. Dont worry about racism d President is an Indian & a former Boss of ISA but again dont worry he only detain Malay & Islamic extremist.U er Welcome.
It is such a shame that the indians and chinese after 52 years of independence, still can't speak malay properly.. yet the want to claim equal rights.. this is so freaking annoying.. If u guys are willing to assimilate more (in terms of language and partly cultural), I would be more than willing to accept equal rights.. Think about it.. think wisely..
I'm a malay.. I'm not being a racist here ok, but from my opinion.. as long as the non bumis not willing to sacrifice their language, don't ever dream about equality.. you need to sacrifice something to gain something.. but that's not happening rite now.. you guys only claim unequel here unequel there, but you forget the fact that you guys have sacrificed nothing.. remember, the malays have sacrificed a lot... maybe it's time for u to do the same..
We say BM is our official language & english as our international or 2nd language... but yet we have chinese, indian words everywhere & the malays couldnt understand any word. Why? Everyone wants to have equal rights but as long as "communication difficulties" which results to communication breakdown is around...until then we will be a confused lot! I dont like comparing other countries although ours is still the best in the world today to be living in... i still think communication is essential
of coz... it should just be English & BM...period! As each of us have our own mother tongue. Chinese in any part of the world mostly... i dont mean all... understands chinese language... (either cantonese, mandarin, hokkein...etc) & yet survived well in any countries! Its true what u said miloice! I agree wid u 100%. But why i said that my nephews are in chinese school is bcoz M'sia is a confused country! We dont have a core language.
Malaysia can be a strong nation on this palnet if the government politic to be more intelligent & fair.You have multiculture,multi brilliant brains,multi religion,multi nature resources to built up this country together with all the races with fair opportunity.Our children is the future of the country,the school & family education is the most important step of their life.The culture is the root of the identity & the value of the nation.Respect & tolerant.Conflict & violence=destroy & hate.
Just look forward & built up this country together.Today,the Malay have the goodlife than other races,please stop mention the old folk story!Peace on your mind,hate burn your soul!
Not just Tamil and Chinese schools. More Malays are sending their children to private religious schools instead of to cheaper govt schools. The main reason is the government schools failed to provide quality students, especially on religious and moral values. I expect my children to get 'pendidikan', not just 'pelajaran' to score more A's.
if u notice, most of the time in tertiary education is where all the race are more closer with each other. U will see more harmony in colleges & universities but u wont see this kinda unity in primary/secondary schools. Why do we teach our 5-6 year old to the polarization of race? Our Education system should be responsible for this & only by tackling this issue from the root up... is how the future of Malaysians to be united will be met! Im not sure if this is part of the "social contract" btw
I suggest we have one school sytem but make the language studies compulsary for the relevant races & open to the malays as well as part of they syllabus. If indians & chinese can learn malay language...why can the malays? right? I am no racist nor am i an ultra malay... but if we teach our children at the early age to be within your own race... then there goes the concept oh muhibbah! (continued next)
exactly! all my 3 nephews are studying in chinese school now regardless of us being malays. The reason being... communication is the essence of living.... therefore... the more u know, the more u r equipped to be"ready for the world" ! Nothin to lose but everything to gain!
this is not true, if you want to work in other countries, you need to learn english. however, that's not the main point. the main point is
"Is the chinese and indians ready to become malaysian by learning how to speak malaysian (bahasa malaysia) properly and being intergrated within the country?"
i noticed that 2nd generation chinese in australia can speak with australian accent and identify themselves as proud aussie. but this is not the case in Malaysia.
if we want BANGSA MALAYSIA...then it should be SATU BAHASA SATU BANGSA! no point of calling for fairness for all race but the malays are at the losing end. BM is for all & English is for the whole world but when it comes to tamil & chinese language... the malays will be at lost. But other races says that malays has too many privileges & u want the malays to sacrifice that for the sake of fairness but the tamils & chinese cant even sacrifice their language? (continued next...)
Well said MalaysianAgent. Having a OneSchoolSystem is a fabulous idea. However, the UMNO politicians have a different mindset when they think OneSchoolSystem. Closing down chinese and tamil schools to make SK as the only school will not resolve the problem. SK schools have not produced the brand of "Malaysian Identity" but very oppressed Malays, Chinese and Indians. It starts with home, then the politicians before we even think of change in schools.
Lastly, people similar to myself, are bred of the national school system. Do I sound like one that had been racially polarised? To those who say 'Yes', then Im here as a living proof that although Im from a Sekolah Kebangsaan, I behave like one being polarised. So why demolish the dual school system? Im from Sekolah Kebangsaan, yet this polarization still occurred. Why?
Ah, that's where Malaysians ought to think, if it ain't dual school system, what else?
One school system for all will work only in the absence of the inferiority complexed UMNO. Thumbs me down and red, but truth is the truth. We need a change of mindset and government. If it's impossible now, then so be it 3 years from now. May the true Malaysian spirit stay strong and may its flame burns stronger with each passing day. We must live our life that when a foreigner sees Malaysia, they see beautiful diversity and multi-culturism, united not in race, but in justice and equality.
One school system for all? Not good,not good. Malaysia must encourage diversity of thoughts. We must not be too "communistic" in nature. If the Federal Government enforces one school system for ALL, dear unthinking Malaysians, don't you think it's easier for cults like UMNO to spread their propaganda to our young minds? Don't you realize it's already in practice TODAY? Schools aren't use to promote harmony, it's used to brainwash poor non-"Malay" kids to think they're bad and hate their culture
If the saying "bahasa jiwa bangsa" or language is the life of a people, is Dr Khoo and others who share such views asking Malaysian Chinese and Tamils to sacrifice the life essence of their culture? And why a selective call for sacrifice only for non-Malays.
I see this as seeds of aparthied and a subtle move towards eradicating one's language, culture and identity. Like replacement history it is a move towards cultural revisionism and Islamisation of non-Muslims.
kalau one school for all..maknanya kita kene lah tambah pengajaran terhadap mata pelajaran..iaitu bahasa tamil, bahasa mandarain..maka baru adil untuk semua rakyat...
what we want to avoid is this Singaporean style national schools where English is the only priority. COme on, Malaysian Language is for everyone. And is for Malaysians. Yes evryone also can learn Mandarin, Hokkien, Cantonese, Tamil and other languages and it should be up to the choice of the students. French, German perhaps?
But BM is a unity language. I find it hard to accept Malaysians who cant speak BM. One school for all!
we already do have a national secular school. That is the "sekolah kebangsaan". If enrollment numbers for chinese and tamil language schools continue to increase, it merely reflects badly on the national schools.
Truthfully, our national schools don't do well. It sucks. And it has become increasing polarised. I lost my chemistry prize because somebody had better marks than me in BM! How did that work?
It certainly is no fun being called a pendatang at school and a godless one at that.
OF course our school system needs so much work. From top to bottom. We're sending out people who fail job interviews for crying out loud. Kids who can't do their own research and NOT plagiarize (ala parrot like our school) or present projects... these are problems I used to see our students face in my uni days(especially those on handouts given to losers who can't even score a 3.0 but get money to study abroad because of birthright). English alone is hard enough for the TEACHERS. And rural areas
We have a Chinese school,Tamil school and Muslim school,not to forget my favorite school sekolah kebangsaan(multiracial) type school. Whatever school you think your child deserve is best multiracial,are we not going for multiracial ? does it made us better? or otherwise?
One school system that prepares students for globalsed world should be the answer for the betterment of Malaysian as a whole. Only the poiticians prefer vernicular schools and polarisation so that they can use their ethnic influene to become the ellected ones. their selfiishness is the real problem that younger malaysians are facing today.
Btw, with the rise of China in terms of economy, technologies and so on. Mandarin should be a mandatory language to pick up, even for non-chinese student. If our country want to be competent in the future shift of wide usage in Chinese.
One school system yes, but our 3M education system sucks bad. All we produced are generation after generation of students that only aims for how many A(s) they can get.
Well the major shift of education should be focusing on interest development. We do not provide an area for our children to manifest their interest in, all ended up just going to school for the sake of going to school.
The facts that these people all want their own schools shows that they have no desire to assimilate into one but are here merely for exploiting this land
Neil, as a post doctorate fellow in Um, what have u learnt ? Malay scarified the Jawi ? Now, one question to ask, who use the romanise to create the writing for the Malay ?
Can jawi be represented as the language like Chinese and Tamil ? which has a form of writisng invented by their forefathers.
It is racial and religion issue now that combined with religion to polarise the people.
All ASEAN countries should make Esperanto as a language and let other languages to survive, why do we need to use the colonial language as a means of perpaduan, absurb
paksu69 : We need it because English is the language technology. Lastly it is a language that belongs to none of the races in malaysia. So nobody would feel marginalized. Malaysian are so so delicate and easily disturbed by small little things.
paksu69: Certainly, language is for communication. But for historical reasons, the language used when communicating the latest development of human knowledge is English.
Like it, hate it. English is the language of technology. If you don't have good command of this language you will find it hard to follow technological developments (Which in itself uses technical terms not found in everyday English). You may even have difficulties reading the instruction manual of equipment you use.
ye man, this is the age of oneness.. one school system, one bank, one government to efficiently crush the freedom of individuals...dont like it, oh well, your going to do it anyway, or else guns and prison...come on world, join the stupid ass americans in theyr quest for total slavery
longfootbuddy 10 months ago
favoring for 1 school system doesn't mean i'm an Umno supporter, because 1 system is what it takes to bring all races together, just like the US or any other countries.
Berrymore84 1 year ago
@Berrymore84 Agree with you..politician doesn't want 1 school system.. it is easier to divide and manipulate racial issue to secure their seat in the parliament.
myy7911 1 month ago
@myy7911 yeah you couldn't be more right. evil politicians created this gap and now each playing their own race card.
Berrymore84 1 month ago
non-bumis don't have to sacrifice their own mother tongue, it's their culture. they just have to go to national schools, speak good national language and study their own languages there. the main goal is to bring all students together and they must learn to mingle around and respect each other that's all.
Berrymore84 1 year ago
@novelt burn9802 actually got his point there. if non-Malays wish to have equal rights i think it's sensible that they must first assimilate with the bigger community, fair enough. i give you an example, if Malays migrate to China and they dislike the Chinese system yet they ask for equal rights, as a Chinese how would you feel bout that? if you agreed that BM and other languages are equally important then why don't we incorporate all of them into national schools? segregation is unnecessary.
Berrymore84 1 year ago
Why make so much noise-come 2 singapore & experiences d exclusively one system. If u re an Indian even better- Genetically Most competible. Dont worry about racism d President is an Indian & a former Boss of ISA but again dont worry he only detain Malay & Islamic extremist.U er Welcome.
vandomVenom 2 years ago
It is such a shame that the indians and chinese after 52 years of independence, still can't speak malay properly.. yet the want to claim equal rights.. this is so freaking annoying.. If u guys are willing to assimilate more (in terms of language and partly cultural), I would be more than willing to accept equal rights.. Think about it.. think wisely..
burn9802 2 years ago
I'm a malay.. I'm not being a racist here ok, but from my opinion.. as long as the non bumis not willing to sacrifice their language, don't ever dream about equality.. you need to sacrifice something to gain something.. but that's not happening rite now.. you guys only claim unequel here unequel there, but you forget the fact that you guys have sacrificed nothing.. remember, the malays have sacrificed a lot... maybe it's time for u to do the same..
burn9802 2 years ago
We say BM is our official language & english as our international or 2nd language... but yet we have chinese, indian words everywhere & the malays couldnt understand any word. Why? Everyone wants to have equal rights but as long as "communication difficulties" which results to communication breakdown is around...until then we will be a confused lot! I dont like comparing other countries although ours is still the best in the world today to be living in... i still think communication is essential
saracenjedi 2 years ago
of coz... it should just be English & BM...period! As each of us have our own mother tongue. Chinese in any part of the world mostly... i dont mean all... understands chinese language... (either cantonese, mandarin, hokkein...etc) & yet survived well in any countries! Its true what u said miloice! I agree wid u 100%. But why i said that my nephews are in chinese school is bcoz M'sia is a confused country! We dont have a core language.
saracenjedi 2 years ago 2
agreed...
burn9802 2 years ago
Malaysia can be a strong nation on this palnet if the government politic to be more intelligent & fair.You have multiculture,multi brilliant brains,multi religion,multi nature resources to built up this country together with all the races with fair opportunity.Our children is the future of the country,the school & family education is the most important step of their life.The culture is the root of the identity & the value of the nation.Respect & tolerant.Conflict & violence=destroy & hate.
jyjyh1 2 years ago
adakah cina dan india dah melampau lampau memijak kepala melayu?
patut dari merdeka tak payah buat sekolah jenis cina dan india.
sekolah kebangsaan cukup.
PengkritikBebas 2 years ago
Just look forward & built up this country together.Today,the Malay have the goodlife than other races,please stop mention the old folk story!Peace on your mind,hate burn your soul!
jyjyh1 2 years ago
good life apekejadahnye?
kau orang la yg kaye kat malaysia ni.
mane ade melayu kaye raye mcm cine india..
PengkritikBebas 2 years ago
PengkritikBebas:
If you want to trade places with an orang Cina like me, I am happy to do so.
You can have all my "riches" and I will happily take the poverty that you are experiencing.
JayCKat 2 years ago
Not just Tamil and Chinese schools. More Malays are sending their children to private religious schools instead of to cheaper govt schools. The main reason is the government schools failed to provide quality students, especially on religious and moral values. I expect my children to get 'pendidikan', not just 'pelajaran' to score more A's.
weeezeee111 2 years ago
if u notice, most of the time in tertiary education is where all the race are more closer with each other. U will see more harmony in colleges & universities but u wont see this kinda unity in primary/secondary schools. Why do we teach our 5-6 year old to the polarization of race? Our Education system should be responsible for this & only by tackling this issue from the root up... is how the future of Malaysians to be united will be met! Im not sure if this is part of the "social contract" btw
saracenjedi 2 years ago
I suggest we have one school sytem but make the language studies compulsary for the relevant races & open to the malays as well as part of they syllabus. If indians & chinese can learn malay language...why can the malays? right? I am no racist nor am i an ultra malay... but if we teach our children at the early age to be within your own race... then there goes the concept oh muhibbah! (continued next)
saracenjedi 2 years ago
right! i agreed what you said saracenjedi,
if like this i will agreed one school system.lol.. if we learn malay language then if we look for job at other country will be hard..
ts65129 2 years ago
but if malay and indian study chinese language than it will be more easier for them to work in other like taiwan or chinese too.. :)
ts65129 2 years ago
exactly! all my 3 nephews are studying in chinese school now regardless of us being malays. The reason being... communication is the essence of living.... therefore... the more u know, the more u r equipped to be"ready for the world" ! Nothin to lose but everything to gain!
saracenjedi 2 years ago
this is not true, if you want to work in other countries, you need to learn english. however, that's not the main point. the main point is
"Is the chinese and indians ready to become malaysian by learning how to speak malaysian (bahasa malaysia) properly and being intergrated within the country?"
i noticed that 2nd generation chinese in australia can speak with australian accent and identify themselves as proud aussie. but this is not the case in Malaysia.
miloice1 2 years ago
if we want BANGSA MALAYSIA...then it should be SATU BAHASA SATU BANGSA! no point of calling for fairness for all race but the malays are at the losing end. BM is for all & English is for the whole world but when it comes to tamil & chinese language... the malays will be at lost. But other races says that malays has too many privileges & u want the malays to sacrifice that for the sake of fairness but the tamils & chinese cant even sacrifice their language? (continued next...)
saracenjedi 2 years ago
Well said MalaysianAgent. Having a OneSchoolSystem is a fabulous idea. However, the UMNO politicians have a different mindset when they think OneSchoolSystem. Closing down chinese and tamil schools to make SK as the only school will not resolve the problem. SK schools have not produced the brand of "Malaysian Identity" but very oppressed Malays, Chinese and Indians. It starts with home, then the politicians before we even think of change in schools.
MelayuAtasPokok 2 years ago
Lastly, people similar to myself, are bred of the national school system. Do I sound like one that had been racially polarised? To those who say 'Yes', then Im here as a living proof that although Im from a Sekolah Kebangsaan, I behave like one being polarised. So why demolish the dual school system? Im from Sekolah Kebangsaan, yet this polarization still occurred. Why?
Ah, that's where Malaysians ought to think, if it ain't dual school system, what else?
Hint: Race-based politics
MalaysianAgent 2 years ago
One school system for all will work only in the absence of the inferiority complexed UMNO. Thumbs me down and red, but truth is the truth. We need a change of mindset and government. If it's impossible now, then so be it 3 years from now. May the true Malaysian spirit stay strong and may its flame burns stronger with each passing day. We must live our life that when a foreigner sees Malaysia, they see beautiful diversity and multi-culturism, united not in race, but in justice and equality.
TQ
MalaysianAgent 2 years ago
One school system for all? Not good,not good. Malaysia must encourage diversity of thoughts. We must not be too "communistic" in nature. If the Federal Government enforces one school system for ALL, dear unthinking Malaysians, don't you think it's easier for cults like UMNO to spread their propaganda to our young minds? Don't you realize it's already in practice TODAY? Schools aren't use to promote harmony, it's used to brainwash poor non-"Malay" kids to think they're bad and hate their culture
MalaysianAgent 2 years ago
ish in mark fark in mark rabbin sackin sammin
Hogswoth 2 years ago
Isu ini agak menarik.
Tolong sediakan sarikata Bahasa Melayu.
Malaysia tidak membenarkan Penggunaan Bahasa Inggeris.
Diharap dapat siarkan sarikata didalam Bahasa Melayu.Agar semua bangsa dapat faedahnya nanti.
malaysiajews 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I AGREE One School System for all!!
Bcoz we all a malaysian
Bagaimana cara-cara membunuh MELAYU.
1- Sediakan BOM / Pengebom Berani mati.
2- carilah tempat dimana paling ramai dan sentiasa ada orang MELAYU
-pasar malam dan pasar minggu
-Di Akademi Fantasia
-Pesta Lagu Di Jom Heboh
3- letupkan sahaja bom tersebut.Dan lihatlah berapa ramai melayu yang pastinya akan terkorban (mampus)
selamat mencuba!!
malaysiajews 2 years ago
everyone can still use their own mother language.. even my terengganu dialect.. just use one language in teaching.. first malay then english..
ghostblind69 2 years ago
If the saying "bahasa jiwa bangsa" or language is the life of a people, is Dr Khoo and others who share such views asking Malaysian Chinese and Tamils to sacrifice the life essence of their culture? And why a selective call for sacrifice only for non-Malays.
I see this as seeds of aparthied and a subtle move towards eradicating one's language, culture and identity. Like replacement history it is a move towards cultural revisionism and Islamisation of non-Muslims.
makingitnownow 2 years ago
best school system is one that when we come out, we know at least 2 other languages other than our own.
webvideojihadist 3 years ago 2
where's part 2?
mus1402 3 years ago
kalau one school for all..maknanya kita kene lah tambah pengajaran terhadap mata pelajaran..iaitu bahasa tamil, bahasa mandarain..maka baru adil untuk semua rakyat...
mayoryusa 3 years ago
One school teach 4 main language is the BEST!! Still I'm glad that my parents send me to chinese school that mades me able to speak 3 languages. ^^
Astroranagun 3 years ago
u know more languages u get more skills....Let people choose wat school they wanna enrol in!
warsonglord 3 years ago
respect Neil Khor he is giving a non-bias statement
FakeLeader 3 years ago 2
what we want to avoid is this Singaporean style national schools where English is the only priority. COme on, Malaysian Language is for everyone. And is for Malaysians. Yes evryone also can learn Mandarin, Hokkien, Cantonese, Tamil and other languages and it should be up to the choice of the students. French, German perhaps?
But BM is a unity language. I find it hard to accept Malaysians who cant speak BM. One school for all!
FakeLeader 3 years ago
we already do have a national secular school. That is the "sekolah kebangsaan". If enrollment numbers for chinese and tamil language schools continue to increase, it merely reflects badly on the national schools.
Truthfully, our national schools don't do well. It sucks. And it has become increasing polarised. I lost my chemistry prize because somebody had better marks than me in BM! How did that work?
It certainly is no fun being called a pendatang at school and a godless one at that.
JayCKat 3 years ago
OF course our school system needs so much work. From top to bottom. We're sending out people who fail job interviews for crying out loud. Kids who can't do their own research and NOT plagiarize (ala parrot like our school) or present projects... these are problems I used to see our students face in my uni days(especially those on handouts given to losers who can't even score a 3.0 but get money to study abroad because of birthright). English alone is hard enough for the TEACHERS. And rural areas
dizmaldaze 3 years ago
We have a Chinese school,Tamil school and Muslim school,not to forget my favorite school sekolah kebangsaan(multiracial) type school. Whatever school you think your child deserve is best multiracial,are we not going for multiracial ? does it made us better? or otherwise?
DCAPULET 3 years ago
English, B.Malaysia, Mandarin, Tamil why not all languages instead of one language system
michealonghocklye 3 years ago
One school system that prepares students for globalsed world should be the answer for the betterment of Malaysian as a whole. Only the poiticians prefer vernicular schools and polarisation so that they can use their ethnic influene to become the ellected ones. their selfiishness is the real problem that younger malaysians are facing today.
tobeebabee 3 years ago
Btw, with the rise of China in terms of economy, technologies and so on. Mandarin should be a mandatory language to pick up, even for non-chinese student. If our country want to be competent in the future shift of wide usage in Chinese.
long4bliss 3 years ago 2
One school system yes, but our 3M education system sucks bad. All we produced are generation after generation of students that only aims for how many A(s) they can get.
Well the major shift of education should be focusing on interest development. We do not provide an area for our children to manifest their interest in, all ended up just going to school for the sake of going to school.
long4bliss 3 years ago
The facts that these people all want their own schools shows that they have no desire to assimilate into one but are here merely for exploiting this land
Garubolas 3 years ago
Neil, as a post doctorate fellow in Um, what have u learnt ? Malay scarified the Jawi ? Now, one question to ask, who use the romanise to create the writing for the Malay ?
Can jawi be represented as the language like Chinese and Tamil ? which has a form of writisng invented by their forefathers.
It is racial and religion issue now that combined with religion to polarise the people.
paksu69 3 years ago
All ASEAN countries should make Esperanto as a language and let other languages to survive, why do we need to use the colonial language as a means of perpaduan, absurb
paksu69 3 years ago
paksu69 : We need it because English is the language technology. Lastly it is a language that belongs to none of the races in malaysia. So nobody would feel marginalized. Malaysian are so so delicate and easily disturbed by small little things.
JayCKat 3 years ago
JayCKat: language is for communication but not for technology, Chinese use Chinese as their part of technology,what say you ?
paksu69 3 years ago
paksu69: Certainly, language is for communication. But for historical reasons, the language used when communicating the latest development of human knowledge is English.
Like it, hate it. English is the language of technology. If you don't have good command of this language you will find it hard to follow technological developments (Which in itself uses technical terms not found in everyday English). You may even have difficulties reading the instruction manual of equipment you use.
JayCKat 3 years ago
umno led to all this!
pizi87 3 years ago
say no to polarisation of rakyat!
FakeLeader 3 years ago 2