why are there still people who are comparing the two phases as there is a competition to see which is best? The Hogarth is 20 years in the band, accept it! The guys released albums in this wonderful time. Who is making comparisons is not concerned with music, with the band, is concerned with a stupid competition. If you do not like Hogarth stay listening to old records and do not bother us!
@vrutoproducciones Must admit I disagree with you there, but fair enough. I personally prefer Hogarth as a frontman. I always wish that Marillion had changed their name when Hogarth came along, that way there'd have been two seperate fan-bases, the original band would indeed have died and been replaced by the totally different style of Hogarth, and quite possibly the new band would've been a lot more successful by escaping the prog-rock stigma that comes with a Tolkeinian name like 'Marillion'!
@vrutoproducciones I hate comments like yours, it's like you would say... when bon scott die ...the spirit of AC/DC dies, in this case it's the same, Brian Jhonson sing his style and AC/DC keeps going, maybe sounds diferent but it's good music, and If does'nt like you...don't hear it !! It's so easy.
I love Marillion with both Fish and H. Each one brought (and brings) something magnificent to the band.
zehnterapril 4 months ago
why are there still people who are comparing the two phases as there is a competition to see which is best? The Hogarth is 20 years in the band, accept it! The guys released albums in this wonderful time. Who is making comparisons is not concerned with music, with the band, is concerned with a stupid competition. If you do not like Hogarth stay listening to old records and do not bother us!
rodilopes 5 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
sorry, i think this song doesn't have the spirit of marillion. When fish left the band marillion died.
vrutoproducciones 7 months ago
@vrutoproducciones Must admit I disagree with you there, but fair enough. I personally prefer Hogarth as a frontman. I always wish that Marillion had changed their name when Hogarth came along, that way there'd have been two seperate fan-bases, the original band would indeed have died and been replaced by the totally different style of Hogarth, and quite possibly the new band would've been a lot more successful by escaping the prog-rock stigma that comes with a Tolkeinian name like 'Marillion'!
Ardensfax 7 months ago
@Ardensfax i agree i like hogarth better.check my music out to thanks.
shafiq1537 1 month ago
@vrutoproducciones Opinions are just that. I think a great many people do not agree with you. Different yes, better or worse?..... no. ;)
JRBL1A1 6 months ago
marillion started when Fish left .
Thanks God he left
rmiladifard 5 months ago
@vrutoproducciones I hate comments like yours, it's like you would say... when bon scott die ...the spirit of AC/DC dies, in this case it's the same, Brian Jhonson sing his style and AC/DC keeps going, maybe sounds diferent but it's good music, and If does'nt like you...don't hear it !! It's so easy.
DynastesEliott 4 months ago
This is "awesome" just brilliant music
margaretburden 7 months ago
aewsome song and video pure artists
jackiechris2 9 months ago
brilliant track
stevewilks99 1 year ago
Great!
nirabalcab 1 year ago
wow, great video. this song is one of the best from marillion. greetings from holland
slooy43 1 year ago
I love marillion with fish but this song is absolutely brilliant .Thanks Ardensfax for this video
grendel306 2 years ago 3
Hey,what a great video,it´s fantastic!!Very good work,great song from my favorite band.
yove381 2 years ago 4
Thanks very much! :-)
Ardensfax 2 years ago
i agree with you completely!you said it.
firestarter66677 2 years ago
Thanks again!
Ardensfax 2 years ago
Thanks! :-) The deserty bits are a reference to where the song was written.
Ardensfax 2 years ago
very moving excellent
electricsky65 2 years ago 2