much as I am very into trees and grew up on them, etc I prefer judy collins version on who knows where the time grows with its haunting ethereal feel and great sonic textures. but, please dont stop putting on stuff like trees, eclection, incredible string band and other good people
I disagree. The rawness, the honest, novel, imaginative approach to this classic folk song is what makes it a masterpiece. Yes, it could be 'produced', 'tidied up', etc etc. But, as it stands, the musical beauty is clear.
Well done Trees, a band that never received the recognition they deserved.
Absolutely ~ that 'rawness' adds something to the emotions of the song.
I first heard the version by Sandy Denny, which is much more 'polished' {and I love it}, but this one is different in a good way, with slight alterations in the lyrics, and a more 'Americanised' feel to the music...
One of the most under rated band ever, its really a shame they didn't have more albums. There style is sick, I think its very much origional
sk8erking4 2 months ago
this isnt on the original lp? i own a copy but i recognize it like i heard it all before..?
TuneDrop 1 year ago
@TuneDrop No, it's an unreleased demo they added onto the CD re-issue.
However, the song was recorded by Sandy Denny in the late 60s, and was on a few of her compilation albums.
SilverWolfMoon 1 year ago
underrated. sounds great
amonduultje 1 year ago
Wow!! That raw blues guitar and drums coming in and those fantastic vocals. A tradtional folk song re-invented. Brilliant.
sunaru1 2 years ago
much as I am very into trees and grew up on them, etc I prefer judy collins version on who knows where the time grows with its haunting ethereal feel and great sonic textures. but, please dont stop putting on stuff like trees, eclection, incredible string band and other good people
puddypuss 3 years ago
Decent music but the vocal track needs a 40% reduction in volume...too distracting in its present form.
TheTickler1717 3 years ago
This was only a demo, so it isn't 'polished'...
SilverWolfMoon 3 years ago
Show me the polished version and i'll try it again.
TheTickler1717 3 years ago
Unfortunately, there isn't one!
This demo was a bonus track on the album re-issue, and it seems they never got the chance to finish it...
SilverWolfMoon 3 years ago
I disagree. The rawness, the honest, novel, imaginative approach to this classic folk song is what makes it a masterpiece. Yes, it could be 'produced', 'tidied up', etc etc. But, as it stands, the musical beauty is clear.
Well done Trees, a band that never received the recognition they deserved.
zensho1 3 years ago 4
Absolutely ~ that 'rawness' adds something to the emotions of the song.
I first heard the version by Sandy Denny, which is much more 'polished' {and I love it}, but this one is different in a good way, with slight alterations in the lyrics, and a more 'Americanised' feel to the music...
SilverWolfMoon 3 years ago
Wow!! That sends shivers down my spine!!!!
zensho1 3 years ago
I couldn't agree with you more, Zensho1. Well said!
knightexpo 2 years ago
Please send details to me as well. Is it possible to still get hold of the bootleg LP and the BBC sessions?
zensho1 3 years ago
Please, where does this com from?
I love Trees' 2 albums from '70 and the bootleg live album, but I never heard anything else from Celia and the guys.
Is there anything else going around?
Love to hear from it.
Stefan, Belgium.
wakkidakki 3 years ago
Hello Stefan,
I've sent you a detailed message about it :)
SilverWolfMoon 3 years ago
Just seen this post! any info you have on Trees would be appreciated.
I have had the 2 albums on vinyl since they first came out & now on CD, but would appreciate anything else that may be out there.
knightexpo 2 years ago
Somewhere ther is the BBC session, after violonist was added.
But, if you have On the Shore and In the Garden of Jane Delawnety, you need nothing else.
On the Shore rivals Unhalfbricking and Lieg and Lief. All three LPs are brilliant.
sunaru1 2 years ago
I just LOVE the banjo..great post Wolfie!! :o)
ou812uc 3 years ago
I promised banjo, and banjo you did get...!
SilverWolfMoon 3 years ago