Added: 3 years ago
From: hiwj2001
Views: 98,289
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (226)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Linda perfeita

  • carinha de vagabunda do caralho

  • She is an amazing artist!!!! I LOVE THIS. 

  • a truly beautiful song with great lyrics. I love this version of the song as well. Madonna sings this just as well as she did on Evita. Superb

  • Her voice kicks ass here, love it!

  • I seriously love her voice in here :)

  • she sings it a third lower than she used to, thats too bad.

  • Spectacular!

  • Wow, Madonna sings this hit superbly, even when on stage... And I didn't know she could play the guitar actually! =)

  • Rasquele mi guera ,que alfin compramos Otra !

  • I do love you madonna

  • I'm so in love with you, Madonna.

  • it's true, it's not the best voice. it's just a good voice, packed inside a whole industry named Madonna. she's done SO MUCH. see you in Belgrade, Madge!

  • un regalo para quienes estuvimos ahi... simplemente espectacular!

  • I'd like to see the bitch who's gonna say she lipsync

  • wow, she sounded perfect.

  • yeah it is

  • She sang SO well in Cardiff. Beautiful. Proud to have been there.

  • this was the most emotional part of a concert i ever been, all the people around me, including myself where crying :( so beautiful

  • what a beautiful song

    and an amazing performance

    plus wonderful audience

  • that was beautiful. the end was my favorite. so sad. so beautiful.

  • simply beautiful. I watched this live last year. I was very moved by this, so was she. Such a superstar, the only woman i have ever really loved, in every way. Tiamo Regina Madonna x

  • see you in August 15th.!!!!!! in Poland!!!!!

  • i love her :'-( I LOVE YOU MADONNA :-***

  • Madonna is the unrivalled queen of pop. amazing vocals

    amazing body

    amazing dancing

    amazing shows

    AMAZING LADY!!!!

    WE WILL LOVE U 4 EVA MADONNA!!!!

  • Shush people, she's singing! I love this song. It always makes me cry though.

  • Eu fui neste dia

    show 1000

  • i was there

  • great performance

  • deep in my herat Im concealing :'(

  • i watched this live when she played London. This was quite emotional, she had tears in her eyes at one point, she looked so beautiful and class-A at 50 years old, just as lovely as she was in her early days. She sung live and was great, despite all the bitchy jibes she gets nower days, she really was amazing.

    Tiamo, Regina Madonna X

  • i saw her in San Diego, the night that Obama won, she was so happy!!! and this song bring tears to my eyes and some other people around me were crying too it was so emotional!

  • I was in Boston on Oct. 15th, the day her divorce was finally confirmed & announced. She was so teary-eyed during songs like this, Borderline, Miles Away, & Devil Wouldn't Recognize You

  • i was there :-)

  • madonna i saw you in concert in vegas your cool as hell

  • so much love.....

  • flawless

  • She's singing this song for her doughter on her 13 birthday.

  • really!!! cause that would be creepy!

  • oh my god soooooooo much better than the oscars 1997 performance. i think her problem in that one was that she let her emotions get the best of her and she was very nervous. here she sounded absolutely flawless and similar to the recorded version

  • i think she sounded better than on the recorded version. this version has a lot more body to it. her voice has become a powerful tool. never used to be though. i think it changed with the re-invention tour. thats when her voice turned the corner.

  • this song is beautiful, but i would have prefered "the power of goodbye" or "take a bow" instead =(

  • gurrr this is madonnas best song ever!

  • MILES AWAY is out now!

  • madonnna i love you

  • Just saw her in Toronto and she sounded flawless :)

  • llorare el 30 de nov cuando escuche esta cancion

  • PRECIOSA ¡¡¡MMMMM

  • so moving... her madgesty

  • No wonder this song won the Oscar for best original song. And Madonna sings it very well.

  • her voice is the best in Cardiff.

  • fu*ck Cardiff

  • i saw her live cardiff opening night,ive been a fan since i was 6 yrs old and was my first time seeing her and when i saw this song i cried my eyes out,it was so powerful and very emotional and lots of the crowd also got emotional when we saw this,she is what the 80s and 90s needed and what the naughties fear to loose she has given us and learnt us so much,inspiring and captivating a true legend who will live eternally

  • Wonderful. Love, love, love it!

  • Madonna, My dear Madonna if only you know what you make all of us feel. I saw her at concert in Zürich on August 2008 !!!

    A guy was just crying when she was signning this beautifull song...It was so deep !!!

    LOVE YOU ...

  • MADONNA YOU ARE THE MOST IMPORTANT THING IM MY LIFE!

    You mean everything to me and I really want to meet you SO bad!! I'm your biggest 13 year old fan!!

  • she looks so beautiful when smiles! this song saved the whole list of songs that she has performed in the tour. I mean it's the most different of all and of course it's beautiful.

  • I liked this part of the concert, she used to joke and say that people leave or go buy a drink when she sings a ballad, but she sang so well and I could hear every word she sang, and it was warm. I loved the Sticky & Sweet Concert. All the Singapore.. Yilin 21 Sept Stade De France Paris. Loved it.

  • someone have a tissue? simply perfect....

  • my all time favourite madonna ballad

  • this woman just gets better!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • and they say MADONNA can't sing.

    love you Madge!!!

  • just brilliant!!!!!!!!

  • I was at this concert & she was amazing

  • ppl always here saying madonna cant sing and now they see she can and theyre denying it by saying "shes getting help" gosh haters, do you have a life?

  • that's very true. She actually can sing live pretty good, and she surprises.

  • Another amazing live performance from Madonna ~ Loved it

  • im surprised she did this song. its been awhile she performed the evita songs. i like the song.

  • she performed Lament in the REINVENTION Tour

  • I agree Melancholio74. I am so glad she did, she did it very well.

  • I saw her in Rome, and this performance made people litteraly cry! It was SO MOVING - and Live for sure

  • i dont' know where you come from. i'm italian and i was in rome last week and it's been an amazing night the stadium was filled up with 60000 people and i was in the golden very close. talking to other fans we realized now she's more emotional than she used to be in the past, she smiled all the time, made us sing, just being carried away by music and audience. she looked like she was happy at last to perform in our contry.

    i tell u this cause it's very important to us: so far, like the ct,

  • she didn't enjoy coming to ita because of the pope and all that shit. but this time she seemed vey relaxed. anyway great performance and definetely live except maybe like a prayer, other parts of some songs like heartbeat...a little prerecorded.veronica still rules.

  • heartbeat was definitely lip synched. like a prayer was live though. i have studied the performance of it enough and can tell that's live. however, not to say there isn't some help making her voice more powerful. give it 2 me was mostly lip synched, had to be, too hard of a dance routine.

  • She sang this beautifully.... Love you Madge.

  • I have seen Madonna 7 times live. She sang most of Drowned World. She sang a majority of Re-Invented (tho a lot of it was (obviously, per the show) lip-synched). She hands-down did ALL of Confessions, and it was unreal. I was on the floor twice for that show- once in the 3rd row and once at the end of the cat-walk; easily the most amazing live performance I've ever seen. Sitting that close, you can tell if it's SINGING or not. She's in amazing shape; of course she can sing AND dance. SHOCKING!

  • she sang all of drowned world live except sky fits heaven and she sang all of reinvention except for vogue and nobody knows me. she sang all of confessions except future lovers and sorry. she usually lips two-three songs on tours. i can tell when she's lip synching always. she's a bit of a sloppy lip syncher on stage and it gives it away.

  • Why is it such a leap of faith to accept that the biggest female star in the world can actually sing quite well sometimes?

    You and this ludicrous prendevillet character should whinge on youutbe videos of singers ACTUALLY lip-syncing.

    God knows there are enough of them.

  • She suddenly becomes a great vocalist because she is sat down rather then diving around.

    She sings this especially well because she underwent intensive vocal training to do Evita, and it is in a good register for her.

    She sings it the same everynight because she is not a fucktard and she has practiced!!!

    Tell me - do you REALLY find it that hard to replicate the same sound over and over, or do you lack controll of your mouth? No...it is quite easy. Now imagine it's what you do for a living.

  • She has vocal chords and a memory. You do not have a musical ear.

    A combination of the above leads you to believe she is lipping.

    You are not stupid but you are wrong.

  • No, they're not.

  • a lot of singers have the same vocals on many shows when they are on tour???????????

  • I'm glad she´s singing this on the tour. I'm looking forward to to hearing it live. :)

  • HA GET OVER IT ITS LIVE. MUPPET oh and brilliant to xxxx

  • well It is live..... I heard her sound heck the song while we were waiting to get in at cardiff.... she sings her slower song better live than the uptempo stuff

  • nah i can tell the difference between the other performances. it must be live

  • BEautifullllllllllll

  • YES SHE IS

  • Prendevillet - I am getting really quite sick of you and your public displays of uttery stupidity on every Madonna video on youtube.

    For the love of Christ - can't you TELL this is live???!!!

    Where is even the slightest scrap of evidence to the contrary???

    And above all: HAVE YOU NOTHING THE FUCK BETTER TO DO WITH YOUR LIFE?

  • You must Love Madonna !!! I DO!

  • Beatiful, excelent job Madonna. Te amo.

  • GO SATAN!

  • good shot, congratulations.

  • i miss madonna singing beautiful ballads that showcases her vibrant alto voice

  • omg, i've got tears in my eyes. What emotional:P

    I saw her 2 sep in Amsterdam. The show was very great, she can really sing. I love her

  • Oh My GOd. At Cardiff, I was right at the front. A truely heartstopping beautiful moment. The Moment of Moments. Amazing. She was SO GOOD

  • Even thou I LOVE Madonna when she does her dance music, but when she stops and hits those ballads, that woman can SING! She may not be a Barbra Streisand or a Celine Dion when it comes to singing, but she sings honestly, and she's GREAT! I got my ticket already!

  • I went to see her yesterday in Holland. The concert was great. She really can sing very good. Especially in this song when the beats and the guitars are off. You really can hear her voice so pure and strong.

  • love her!!!!!!!!

  • Wow! Madonna actually has an amazing voice when she sings in her optimal range, like on this performance! I can't wait to see her in Houston!

  • I Love You!

  • The Ultimate Artist of ALL TIME!!!

  • It's actually so beautiful that I got goosebumps..

  • cannot wait to see her live in ATHENS!!!!

    MADONNA THE greeks adore you!!!!

  • Funny to read comments regarding Madonna's singing ability. I mean come on...this is not a singing contest!

  • Fabulous!

    Go watch her in Lpndon, PAris and Rome!!!! Buy tickets! but HARD CANDY¬!

  • excellent live performance! Madonna has never sounded better.

  • this is the living prove that she sings very good when she is standing still. its obvious that if a person is jumping up and down cant sing properly. I would like to see Mariah carey or C. aguilera sing while dancing like crazy.

  • HA good point they would probably gasping for air if they did the dancing wat madge does lol

  • she sings very good in this. I am very surprised.

  • I dont really like this song (or any from Evita)

    Although her voice is EFFING AMAZING on the Soundtrack.

  • AMAZING!!!!!!!!

  • i must admit i do like this song! and the way she has made it sound folky, I wish she did a spanish guiter version of Take a Bow! nice RnB ballered! that was very poplular with her US audiance! and sits well with the hard cady RnB hip hop sound

  • I agree, I love the Bedtime Stories album.

  • Her voice so amazing so touching!!!

  • stunning

  • HA SHE CAN SING HATERS AND SHE CAN SING LIVE

    and this is not lipsync NO NO NO (not that anyone said that it was)

  • no its not lipsync its totally live. But dont came and tell me she can sing ALL THE TIME. Its very strange how good she sounds in this. She sounds very bad very often..

  • yea....she sings bad often during the concert,that's when she is dancing and singing together

  • yah cuz shes not dancing or playing guitar fast, shes just sitting down, playing it RLLY slowly so she can concentrate on her voice cuz shes always dancing around the stage

  • it´s very strange to see madonna singing almost accappella and completly still. It´s actually the first time. She did it on lament Paradise and mother and father on other tours and she sounded amazing.

  • i was there and i was like WTF she can sing LIVE!!!!

  • Omg her voice is amazing!

  • Her voice sounds absolutely beautiful here, wow, I am impressed.

  • see how good she can sing when she aint jumping all over the stage....love it

  • beautiful

  • The tone of the song fits her voice perfectly and add that she is for once sitting down and therefore fully using her voice 100%.

    I'm impressed and I feel now that I really should get concert tickets.. I'm stunned.

  • Most of the other songs on the tour are sung 100% live as well, only a couple have backing tracks and none are lipped.

  • Beautifylly sung

  • pretty well

  • this song is really beautiful

  • ...and why go only with the comercial hits??.. having wonderful balads like this one with such strong and sincere lyrics. I love it!

    Plus, you forget that it won an Oscar®.

  • nice vocal performance!

  • I wonder what Huwj2001 looks like?

  • i will always love u madonna

  • You Must Love Me has become a musical theatre standard - far more important/famous than any of Madonna's other ballads.

  • The same reason she picked Human Nature, Die Another Day, Borderline among others.

    There's a boxing and a time theme throughout the whole show. The theme is this:

    I'm here to stay and there's nothing wrong with that, no matter how much shit I get for it (age). Nothing's changed. I'll always be Madonna and thank u for staying by my side.

    You Must Love Me is the only ballad that fits. Think about it. You'd think the woman had cancer like Evita the way they keep talking about her being 50.

  • I'm agree with you, I just really like take a bow and other ballads

  • Ah now I am thinking of my dear Eva...this is beautiful! She can sing for sure! My goodness...and the way she played Eva Peron was untouchable. VIVA MADONNA! This is my FAVORITE song of hers. Thank you for posting!!!

  • 2:23 - 2:27....spectacular!!! for all those who say Madonna can't sing for her life, take that, bitches!

  • Fuck, this is making me cry!

    janetmadonnafan4life, u r soooo right, this per4mance rips the '97 Oscars!!!!

  • Dont forget about her new single GIVE IT TO ME. Download and request!

  • oh my fucking god! sooooooooooooooooooooooooo much better than oscar 1997 performance! love it!

  • unbelievable!!!! she sounds beautiful.

  • and all the stupid people who keep say she cannot sing..... SHUT UP PLEASE....

    when she is not dancing and sits down to sing... her voice is clear and nicer then a lot of shitty singers out there today!

  • Yes, she was great in the Re-Invention Tour version of DEEPER and DEEPER, in Paradise (Not For Me) in Confessions Tour, Sooner or Later at the Oscars, Ray of Light in Oprah. She can sing really great! Full of emotion and soul. This tour is gonna be big!

  • Best song of the night for me. Her voice shone like nothing else!

  • This is definitely one the greatest performance ever by the Queen f Pop. Absolutely beautiful and magnificent. I can't wait to see the show in LA!

  • god!!! I love it.

    madonna rocks!

  • one of her best live performances i have EVER heard :O

    x

  • Beautiful

  • can't wait 4 Berlin XXX

  • Gorgeous! Long live the real Queen! I LOVE MADONNA! WOOT!!!

  • My god....she HAS to make a ballads album....tears!!! Her voice is made for them...

  • she soundsssssss greatttttttttttt

  • Iluv mdolla u'are wonderwoman u'are good:-)

  • I WAS THERE!!! WE NEARLY DIED!!!!!!!

  • i love u madonna!!! great song!!!

  • guy, you must love her!

  • Fantastic....I want to go again. Had such a great time in GC with some lovely people...And to have Guy Richie stood behind me was even more spacial. :-)

  • i love you madonna perfect

  • Wonderful beautiful performance. She can definitely sing no matter what the haters say. And thanks to hiwj2001 for getting a great recording with perfect sound and upclose picture. Some of the other videos on youtube of this song you can't really hear her.

  • great !!

    Madonna sing " You Must Love Me " so good!!

  • WOW she looks even better than on the last tour. what a star

  • GOOSE PIMPLES!!!!!

  • i'm crying-

  • absolutely amazing...powerful and so romantic...

  • I love this song, it's really good she is doing it!

  • QUE VOOOOOOOOOZ

  • Probably one of the BEST vocal performances ever by Madonna :-)