Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (452)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Most all of us that stop by Repad's videos do so out of respect for the quality of his work. This is not the place to bad mouth and talk trash to one another - there are plenty of other places to do that if that is what floats ur boat. Listen!

  • best performance EVER on American Idol

  • Haley Reinhart you are perform on stage. 

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Just wanted to say thanks to repad for documenting S10 with such fantastic videos. You've really helped a lot of us Haliens make it through the last year, it's greatly appreciated.

  • jordin sparks version was better...

  • @SuperGodWarrior1 No way. Jordans' was boring. Haley's phrasing is so haunting and real

  • @dblubarry Hmmm, I give the performance to Haleys, since J didn't even move, BUT i liked Jordan's vocals a lot more...

  • @SuperGodWarrior1 I found Sparks' version very boring. Haley has much,much more emotions in her voice. Sparks can sing well, but she's not extraordinary like Haley is. Haley is a rare diamond. Sparks is coal in comparison.

  • It gives me the chills every.single.time.

  • i just can´t believe this

  • i remember seein this on tv for the first time.. i came back to see it again.. and it made me feel something inside.. i guess thats what its like to be touched.. wow.. what a perfromance. giddy up!

  • Swear she looks just like Christina Aguilera in her performance for Bound To You in Burlesque

  • @charmed3prue She sounds just like her too!

  • Everyone always gets their moment on idol and this night was all haley!

  • @stigmatic79 Haley had many moments (HOTRS, Moanin', WIASNB, BATJ (x2), IWHN, YAI, Beautiful, POMH, etc)

  • HALEY.......WOW FACTOR BIG TIME! You have put your mark on" I Who Have Nothing." There is no one else that even comes to close to performing this song the way you do. This young lady put her SOUL into this performance.This song will always belong to you. No words to describe her performance. I am proud of you Haley.

  • And THAT'S why she stayed over Pia and James..

  • she was crying backstage before this performance

  • 1:28 ARMS! Beautiful :_)

  • i just creamed myself

  • Simply Beautiful!! Awesome!

  • did ay one else see the dangly thing behind her throat? -______-

  • @stolen4eighty Sure did. Amazing after all these months we are still scrutinizing her and getting to know Haley intimately : )

  • I have listened to this....so, so many times.

  • she is absolutely gorgeous and sings like a goddess

  • Beautiful performance by Haley !

  • Outstanding performance, and so beautiful! Both the voice and her i mean! damn....

  • I broke the "Like" button on this comment

  • @Drew0722 I guess it leaves me no choice then to dislike it. Damn.

  • Simply Beautiful...

    

  • she has an amazing voice

  • There are singers...and then there are song stylists. Hailey is a song stylist.

    She makes a song hers. And she was the only one of bunch that did that.

    She should have won.

  • 2:04 is that Nikki Reed next to Paul????

  • @LoveHeYa Yes that's Nikki - she seems to have missed the moment.

  • vote for Haley at idolheaded poll - ends sunday - U can only vote once so each makes a difference

  • i tried to see her nails the whole time but couldn't see them but she really sang that well!

  • @LuckyNumbers7 You can see them clearly at the very end of her "I loooovvvveeee yooooouuuuuuuu". In any case, you get a very close view of her beautiful white teeth : )

  • @realfinnatic oh yeah i must have misesd that. yeah she does have very nice nailage.

  • damn thats 'sposed to be ''PierceAbrams''

  • How did she not win?!

    

  • @tg193 It doesn't really matter if she won or didn't, as long as she got signed and shes getting an album is all that matters! Shes way more popular than Scotty and Lauren anways!

  • This was a fabulous performance by Haley. It was the best of the season by any contestant and made her a real contender.

  • Lets see Haley vs the young guy singing Gone. We Haliens know who the true Idol winner is for 2011. Just because a messed up voting system did not declare Haley the winner does not take away from the fact that she is by far the best talent.

    .

  • Jordan Sparks sang this song beautifully, but Haley took it to another level that was outstanding.

  • Haley and the American Idol Concert Tour in Manila is extended for another night and now back to back on September 20 & 21. The Finale of the AI Tour will be in the Philippines! Hope Filipinos will show their love for Haley!!! Happy Birthday World Idol Haley!!!!

  • Haley should have been the American Idol winner

  • Adele should thank this woman :]

  • That echo after she hits that last note is so hauntingly beautiful.

  • this is and will always be the best minute and a half in my life

  • now that's what you call nailage

  • 10 seasons had to pass for Haley to appear in this show, but this moment make it so much worth the wait.

  • Is it odd that everytime I watch this performance, I get goosebumps, I get chills, and I start tearing up? Yes? Okay..

  • @TatianaLerman90434 Me too.

  • Not bad but tom jones is the king of this song

  • @Rowanjamescarreira

    Yes he is, and well he sang it, but Haley is Queen of the song and many perfer Her!

  • I want to wrap you in my arms

  • Me too...Her voice is so amazing, that I cant stop watching her stuff!!!!

  • Emmy nomination for best vocal performance in a variety series...and finally that much deserved win. oh what the hell throw in a grammy, too.

  • Voting has been extended for a few more days. shoot.

    JLO may return to Idol. Shat.

  • THUMBS DOWN FOR ALL TROLLS. USE DROP DOWN BOX NEAR THE THUMB SIGNS AND CLICK IT AS SPAM. DO NOT FEED THE TROLLS. IGNORE THEM. THEY WANT TO PICK A FIGHT.

  • Hot and heavy voting for all contestants tonight at faxo. It's the last night and ends in 2 hours. Witness Haley winning! ...and vote too.

    !!!!!!! go to faxo to watch Haley win 1st place tonight. Put some votes in too. !!!!!!!

  • @seker7 oh! ic.. damn i hate randy == thanks for letting me know anyways :)

  • why was haley in tears 5 minutes earlier?

  • @Musicrocks151 because 'Mad Dawg' Randy had assembled the contestant's on stage (5 min before haley was to perform) to say (basically) that the rest were great and Haley ...wasn't ... still she came back and slayed it hense the great hatred most haleins have for 'In it to win it Jackhole''

  • Isn't there a new release of Haley's today at Amazon?

    YOU ALL ROCK. We are kicking butt on FAXO WALL VOTE. Please keep it up. It ends tomorrow night and we are needing to end with at least 20,000 votes.

  • They went all out on the stage sets on this. You can't beat AI's stage sets. Haley's were the best. Best camera crew ever.

  • She is so cute. Her parents must be soooooo proud of her. From humble beginnings to superstar on her sheer hard work.

  • While Haley had many great performances this season I’m reminded of a comment Simon Cowell once made. Something to the effect of “this is how one song can change your life”… for me this was her defining moment as a performer.

  • She is singing this to the TV audience. No doubt about it.

  • The smile Haley gives @ bout 2:09 IS incredable :))!!

  • Haliens! Check out the full version of the last audition, Baby it's You. I just discovered this little viewed performance. She needs to record this classic.

    watch?v=hytuaTZY3Mg

  • I loved her laid back look. Great looking girl with a 10 body. Oh, and she can sing too.

  • Haley is a movie star here

  • Like I said, the only way to watch HR is in true HD.

  • This girl is my strength and inspiration 

  • This is ABSOLUTELY EPIC - The most AWESOME perf by a singer EVR on AI - Her perf here sets a standard that will prob NEVR b duplicated! Haley changed AI 4EVER!!! Nobody will EVR match Haleys perf on AI NO WAY!!!

  • @beast1022 Haley is the best that is for sure

  • she's awsome beautiful

  • I get chills

    

  • I just covered this song. I hope you can check out my version! Haley Reinhart is such a beast and I would LOVE to duet with her on this!

  • I was looking thru 'old' stuff from earlier in the season - and just now realize who that girl probably is at 2:06 which seemed to always be with Casey in audience during some of Haleys performances Looks to me like Julia Zorrila (who had made to to 24)

  • @seker7 Yes that is Julia Zorrila with Casey. Great smile.

  • hahahaha omg look at Pias face

  • @scott123hawkins where? I don't see her in the crowd in this video..

    I see Nikki Reed & Julie Zurrilla, could you mean one of them?..

  • EPIC!!

  • And THAT, Miss Alaina, is how you sustain a note.

  • I'll say THE BEST PERFORMANCE OF ALL TIME!!!!

    \m/ HALEY!!!

  • Can't help but notice many new names on all the vids. Welcome to the most hapening place on the net. The addiction medications will be dispensed once you have watched each video and read every comment on every thread.

  • I managed to make it an entire 6 hours today without watching this video. Baby steps ... baby steps ... baby steps! :) This is now my favorite all time idol performance without a doubt. GOAT in fact.

  • Woow.... escuchen ese... I love you!!! PrOfUnDo

  • the best interpretation as a cover as this!!! PERFECT!!! FULL OF SOUL AND EMOTIONS! NICE

  • Why oh WHY! is this song NOT on her EP????

  • @seker7 No shit!. I wanted just as bad as you. WOW is the only word to describe this performance!! Well one more too.....EPIC!!

  • @seker7 @seker7 yeah. it's one of the 3 videos of hers that has over 1,000,000 views on YouTube, & one of her best performances of the series with a standing ovation (her 3rd as sadie513 said), along w/ "House of the Rising Sun" & "Benny & The Jets" which were included. I also really liked "Fallin" which was never studio recorded, neither was "Moanin" or "Rhianna."

  • GRAMMY NOMINATION !!!!

  • Oh, and she is absolutely gorgeous, stunning!!  -HookedonHaley-

  • GOD, how in the hell did she not win? -HookedonHaley-

  • Is there anything else happening in the world or the web for that matter? Just wondering cause I seem to be stuck on these true HD Haley pages for the past month... I may need an intervention.

  • @bajadulce HeHeHe!!! I´m in the same situation and i´m from Portugal. I folowed the show from youtube and a month or so after it started to pass on fox life here. Recorded her every perfomance on my tv box. I´m addicted. She´s amazing

  • @bajadulce You will get no one willing to help with that intervention here!

  • @bajadulce it's been a week for me so far, the detox is gonna be torture

  • @bajadulce haha a friend said he may be concerned about my enthusiasm for her. hah

  • @bajadulce me too LOL

  • ^^ @bajadulce ^ ^ am so F###ing glad you asked! - since there is in fact something 'New' happening on the web right now ...Goes by the name of Haley ..... and a little Jazz Club in New Orleans...

    posted by PiercedAbrams (you may know him better as Casey Abrams)

    is 11 minutes of Sublime Pure-fection

    the last 3 minute's will easily blow your mind - I can easily say until you have seen this you ain't seen nothing....

  • Forget the standing ovation - the Audience gave Haley at least Three SCREAMING!Ovations!!

  • Jesus...... nuff said

  • i find it ridiculous that she didn't win. 

  • @prettylittleliarsx33 She might not have won the show but she is about to win top spot in the Idolhead Ed top 13 all time poll and I suspect she will ultimately win the post Idol balttle. DIg it!

  • She should have won, hands down!!! She's got the look, the personality, and VOICE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • its like im not watching american idol because of how good she is

  • Comment removed

  • I don't know why I prefer this than HOTRS.....

  • @XxXArchmageXxX It's ok - the emotion and drama from this performance is without equal EVER on idol. Based on the performances on this particular night no question she wins - hands down. I'm still boiling over the way she was treated by Randy the fatted calf. Haley gave us lots of incredible moments - and it's obvious from all youtube comments, and sales of her EP," that's not the end of this thing. Shindig!"~

  • I'm not a trained musician, but the final note was in perfect tune with the chelos! Incredible talent!! Wal-Mart, here I come!

  • When I get to the end of this - and with the standing ovations- I only focus on Seven Tyler and that "Yeah!" that he give's Haley .. am not looking at the other 2 at all......

  • Comment removed

  • I always liked how when the judges gave Haley a bad review instead of falling down she would come back angry and sing with such force and conviction like saying f*ck you! The judges were wrong tho I think she did great on both songs that week.

  • i love haley Reinhart.. she is beast mode!!

  • I think I am in love with this babe. Wow. Talented, hot, sexy and feisty.

  • She's The Shyt. Doesn't She Have A Record Deal SomeOne Reply Back ?

  • Lauren in an interview said she was gonna sing this... could you imagine ?! we could have missed out on this, smh.

  • @quenquen411 i think God intervened

  • @bluewhale18 loooool, I hear ya

  • Love the calculated pause @:46. Love how she takes Whoaaaa at 1:07 and transitions right into the next verse "I.... I who have nothing" bringing it back down.

  • Such a freaking awesome singer. I don't understand after listening to her, how can anyone be retarded enough to say Haley cannot sing. She sings with the blessing of both God and Satan. Totally otherworldly.

  • The amazing part was that she was in tears five minutes before this. She is a kick-ass woman.

  • @TatianaLerman90434 Why'd she cry

  • @CallieAnn111 watch the Idoloonies Haley interview, they talk about it. plus it's interesting & well done.

    Basically, the judges (or Randy) had just said the best performances of the night so far was a tie between all the contestants except her. This happened right before she had to perform, revealing her outfit pre-maturely as well.

  • @rockxhero oh yeah now i remember

  • 10 people have nothing haahahahaha

  • For those who haven't seen it...there is a five part interview with Haley by Michael Slezak on idoloonies (search that). It is 40 minutes in total and addresses stuff like song selection and arrangements, judges comments, her swan song, and life before idol. I you like Haley you will like it! Michael's week to week commentary during idol and his other interviews are also good. He became a Haley fan and was a critic of the judging throughout the show. Also has an interview with Nigel.

  • GRAMMY NOMINATION !!!

  • Time stands still when you sing.

  • This is her tour de force. Better than AI winner Jordin Sparks'. After getting ripped for 'The Earth Song' (the studio version is actually pretty good, the live performance seems a bit 'shouted'), she really came back strong with this one. Maybe JLO and Randy WERE trying to fire her up. She does seem to perform better when 'under pressure.' Remember her Hollywood Round 3 performance of 'God Bless the Child'? She was THAT close to being elimated after Round 2.

  • I love u too Haley

  • At 1:59 or so Casey is making hand gestures to Haley then laughs - partially visible on the extreme left hand side of the screen. Inside joke?

  • Disappointed she didn't win. She looked shocked when her name wasn't announced for the final 2, heck I would be shocked too with her voice and performance.

  • @bickly777 thank youuu. and i will

  • Wow sounds ALOT better now that I replaced my speakers with TWO that (actually) work !!!!

  • The best performance in idol history right there!

  • Scotty and Lauren were 1 & 2 only because country music nation united behind them to get their first Idol winner since Carrie Underwood. Many country fans were in revolt after Lee DeWyze beat out the better Crystal Bowersox so this is their 'sweet revenge.'

    As Haley said, 'This is a Country year.' It's too bad she and James are paying the price.

  • she should of won

  • i think shes better than scotty!

  • @bandsjohnbern she is better then scotty i hated him i wanted lauren or haley to win

  • 1:06-1:07 the greatest part! oops I broke the replay button

  • FUCKING AMAZING!!

  • Reasons why this was awesome:

    1 - It was Jordin's song in the show. She knew it. She still chose it. Then she slayed it a million times over.

    2 - She listened to Gaga. She brought the drama. Which is probably because..

    3 - She was just in tears 5 minutes before this performance.

    4 - The crowd cheers after her first wail. By the second wail, everyone's lost it. I swear, even JLO's arm is in the air. Look for it.

    5 - She gets her 3rd standing ovation. An Idol first. The haters can eat sh!t.

  • @sadie513 ur comment is mindblowing and just perfect,...thank you! day=made mind=blown

  • @sadie513 FOUND IT :D

  • @sadie513 Actually she claims she didn't know Jordin did the song. But yeah it's awesome :)

  • i'm stuck.. in an endless replay loop.. help..

  • still no record contract for this amazing singer

    how ridiculous is that

    those 2 school country kids get signed but not haley

    the music industry has lost all credibility in my book

  • @bluewhale18 Haley did get signed. Jimmy Iovine signed her to Interscope Records right after she got eliminated,she's already working on her album