Added: 2 years ago
From: SongLive1
Views: 72,905
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (251)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • EVEN IF her voice has lost the power throughout the years, it's not her fault, things like that happen.

    Why do u blame it on her?

  • that's why she is the songbird supreme

  • The most interesting singer in the world today

  • IS THAT A D7? WOAH SHE LAST HIT THAT AT EMOTIONS PERFROAMNCE IN JAPAN.WHAT A HISTORIC WHISTLING ABILITY. LIKE IF YOU BELIEVED SHE GOT THE GIFT AND NO ONE CAN TAKE THAT AWAY FROM HER.

  • My fav part 3.55 - 3.57

  • blown away

  • My most favorite live performance of Mariah on this song.

  • not sure its entirely live....

  • @darrin1701 Look at her lips! Watch closely... Its totally live!! Loves it!

  • @ZbmwM5 oh she uses to do that all the time with live parts and pre recorde "live condition" sections, for instance 90% of the ending of we belong together is pre recorded, you can choose 10 differents ones on you tube the end is always the same, impossible of course

  • @darrin1701 I've heard that ending on a couple, but the majority are definitely live....

  • @darrin1701 Why impossible? It's her voice, the same song, the same notes... She performed this dozens of times, 10 of them may very well be perfectly equal...

  • @darrin1701 Oh, and you'd know, you dumass genius

  • @jbooks888 well I listen to her since the begining and since she almost lost her voice, she had to preserve it, so here in europe most of her perfomances since Charmbracelet album was lipped, in the US she uses pre recorded section "in life condition" , it is well known like for we belong together, the end is always the same, it is impossible, but damn she got an incredible voice even when she's "atone", I really like her, so you don't have to insult me

    who cares anyway bout our comments

  • ive seen all the performances of this song she did and by farrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr this is the Best One yet i love it

  • sHE DID A GOOD JOB HERE.

  • This is the best performance of this song!

  • I Love you.. From The Bottom of my HEART CRT forever.. This is a Phanomal Peformance.. i love you from The Bottom of my Heart CRT forever.. No other singer on this entire Planet, means the world to me like you do..CRT forever

  • I don't care if she's the 1 female artist bla bla, I fell in love with her lyrics and that voice I was like 8 when I became a fan as if I knew about the charts but her success is something extra but I will never get sick of this woman she's just her own >>>

  • Her best performance of this song!

  • i love her

  • I Love you from The bottom of ym heart, Always and forever CRT Forever

  • I love Mariah Carey!!! She has an amazing powerful voice! People need to stop hating on her!!! Number 1 female artist in the world!!!!!!! Go Mimi!! <3

  • @CLjuc87 thank you 1 Billion times agree with you.. She is the best..4ever and always

  • @ILoveMcWhMj4ever

    Anytime. She wouldn't be as famous and well loved... not to mention all the money she is making if she wasn't number one! People dream of being Mariah!! :-)

    Chris L.

  • superb as always mimi!!!

  • This is the most perfect performance. Her voice is FLAWLESS!!!!

  • i don't know if haters still have the stupidity to say something irrelevantly pathetic like SHE CAN'T SING.

  • @malandiaq I KNOW it gets me mad they say it cuz she lip sometimes but hey the world knows she can sing so if she wants to use playback live her alone.

  • @hornyaguilerafan exactly.

  • She is so perfect!!! =D

  • Her ability to access the whistle register hasn't degraded with time, it's her chest voice.

  • 2:43-2:46 is my favorite part

  • OMG 0:04 - 0:24 her voice was so deep and sexy!!! I wish she would do another song kinda like melt away and shes using her lower register! Mrs Cannon for the next album PLEASE!?!?!?1

  • I love the movements she does with her hands to follow notes. (:

    Now when I sing in choir I do it too. LOL xD

  • @ShannonAnne119 Lol...about you doing the hand movements too...I love them too. I think it makes her performances look really unique and she looks cute doing them...lol

  • All hail the queen!

  • WOW! WOW! WOW! She hits the whistle note!! I grew up on Mariah's music and songs. I've so admired her!!

  • omg is that an Eflat7?? it couldnt possibly be Eb6? I thought she was able to reach that note like 20 years ago! That note is a little bit higher than the one in Emotions... but omg! I saw her MTV skit that was a few years back and she could barely reach C7.. now she can hit higher? Is this some accident? Did she accidentally do that?

  • @stevendjie It is Eb7, but I think it was a mistake.

  • @stevendjie no her chest voice is going away which is  make her whistle nicer and high notes clear since when she sings the the lower chords dont vibrate as much

  • @stevendjie I think she has vocal abilities like nobody else, but she needs her vocal rest and sometimes when she performs it suffers from her lack of sleep or vocal rest, or both. she is brilliant tho. peace.

  • Comment removed

  • @TCparaomundo It's an Eb7 (:

  • great simply great

  • dat wuz just beautiful dat whistle with the choir wuz AMAZING i want sombodi 2 say sum stupid bout mariah ima PUT DEY AZZ on blast like dey have no idea

  • I Love you Forever And Always CRt, this is one of my favorites also, Thanks for always being the Best forever and always crt

  • god!!!!!

  • i just want to ask?... are those real diamonds on her mic?.. can anyone answer me...please i just want to know...

  • The high note at 2:54 was lipped... the rest was a little off key but still a good performance. Go Mariah!

  • @rubenator83 not sure about this but be careful cuz this was the same as the one on xfactor UK and u know, no artist could lip on that kind of show

  • i love this song it made me cry once but thats good.i luvs this song

  • EXECELLENT PERFORMANCE!

  • this and the stripped performaces was great.. i think the best live performances of the song...

  • An excellent performance, but still falls second to the Okrah Special.

  • Comment removed

  • lipped!

  • THE PART 0:31 , 0:37 , 0:43 ,0:47 ARE LIPPED. BUT NO PROBLEM BOUT THAT.. SHE CAN DO AND HANDLE IT & NOT OBVIOUS. VERY GOOD PERFORMANCE ..LOVE MC.

  • @henpaul17 LOL, u said it was lipped when it was live. But the first chorus was playback but she did sing on the top of it

  • @henpaul17 Theyre not lipped, its the background music, its the same way for the karaoke version of her song lol. Its supposed to make it sound breathy like it does, notice how she sings with it? its because its supposed to be there.

  • best part 0.00-3.51

  • Now I know what love is.

  • love u mariah

  • she was just perferct ! damn i love her 

  • omg sooo amazingly beautiful wow and those high notes just unbelieveable really im stunned it sounds better then the song love it after all these years she can till sing perfectly amazing

  • She's really fantastic here!!! 4 me it's her best performance of I want to know what love is!!

  • whistle to salp the haters

  • If this doesn't prove she can still sing, nothing can.

    For a woman singing professional for over 20 years, she sounds FANTASTIC.

  • this is the best song of memoirs of an imperfec angel

  • it's like the old mariah..hitting those high notes.....woo hoo

  • MUCH better than the Today Show performance. Good stuff Mariah.

  • Her performance and range of vocals was flawlessly Immaculate!* love her!*

  • BETTER THAN THE ORIGINAL THE WSHISTLES FREAKED ME OUT SO PERFECT

  • This is one of her better performances of IWTKWLI.

  • I love how she sings "In My Life" at 1:41 such control it's really beautiful.

  • She is phenomenal.

  • DAMN...THIS CHICK CAN BLOW...UNBELIEVABLE PIPES. ROCK IT MIMI~

  • love this song :'(

  • This should be the official video for this song. I'm not really a fan of the actual official video. Like someone already posted, this live version sounds better than her studio recording in my opinion. Good job Mariah. Bring this level of performance and realness into your next album.

  • loveeee her at 3:01 gave me chills .. best female singer ever

    i love you Mariah!!!

    GOD BLESS MARIAH!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • LMAO AHAHAHAHA NOW WHAT YU GONE SAY ABOUT HER BITCHES????? AHHHAAAAAA

  • This is how you shut-up the haterz - NAIL the performance !

    LEGENDARY MARIAH!

  • this should be another number one hit, but somehow fans and radio ignore this song, instead it was all about Lady gaga and Justin bierber just a shame for this kind of performance, She still got a BIG VOICE, Whitney not anymore

  • Mariah Carey will perform in Brazil on August 21st. Tickets are on sale at zetcks.com.br.

  • amazing...!!! i love the whistle register...amazing Diva...

  • I love this... dang.. I am bck in love with Mariah

  • I love this performance!

  • now where r the haters????

  • i love you mariah

  • Listen to 2:43 to 2:47. Loved that part. She is very blessed and talented.

  • Mariah Carey is soooo amazing! This was a incredeble performing! I LOVE her voice! The Diva nr. 1

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • So amazing so live, so on-point :)

  • your voise is amazing i wish i were you and you got angels in ur voise and ur very pretty...........  god bless you.........

  • hey hey heey , is perfect *-*

  • i listen to mariah to lift me...she is a gift from God!

  • wow !! this is the best !!

  • She is the best singer on The planet, cant take no One Beat my Hero, I Love her From The Bottom of my heart Always and Forever Love CRT

  • the whistle note is perfect. OMG, she No1.

  • simply amazing, and she looks gorgeous!

  • Watch my cover to this song !!

    Check out on my channel!

    thank you so much !!!

  • Thank you.

  • I Love You Forever. This is My Hero Of all Time, I Love you Forever.. Your The best singer on the planet, Love always CRT

  • so captivating..

  • That's unbelievable! I cannot believe she can hit that high! I used to not really like her voice but this really proves to me how phenomonal she is...

  • i just dont understand why people hate ,mariah `s voice is the best and she smiles all the way to the bank .and people if you aaint got nothing good to say ,shut it.

  • wow she blows the roof off with this song.

  • i really love this performance !!

    this the best performance of this song !

  • I don't know why everyone keeps thinking she messed up on her whistle as the end she did trills to change it up a bit. Fluttering between a couple of notes is a trill. Watch her hand because it's pretty much keeping her beat for her. It was done on purpose to change the song up a bit.

  • SHE DID GUD BUT THERE ONE MISTAKE

  • she really hit the note!! proud of her... love u mariah!!

  • no matter what they say against you mariah, like what you said in your song cant take that away, theres a shine in you that shines brightly, they can try hard but they cant take that away from you..i hope and pray that you will continue to brighten other lives through your own special way, and thats your great music..love you mimi!!!youre number 1 in the philippines..BOBBIE♥♥♥

  • amazing. you are welcome, haters. mariah outstands you all.

  • wow !!

  • That was amaziiiiiiiiing!

  • Beautiful.

  • This is awesome!!! Good job Mariah!!!

  • In my opinion, this is by far the best performance of this song by Mariah. The one on Oprah Show wasn't really that good compare to this.

  • Maybe her back up singers are haters and fuck with her drinks to fuck with her voice lol cuz I notice sometimes her voice is crappier than other times lol. and they tend to smerk when it cracks, look at the fat black bitch lol youll notice what im saying

  • Love this song!!!<3

  • Her melisma is fantastic!!!

    No one could use this singing technique as good as Mariah...

  • now haters,,what are you gonna say about her?,,she is perfect,,,

  • @ctruf true true, this is perfection!!!

  • @ctruf ok i wont front as a mariah carey hater myself i honestly truly cant say shit about this......its kind of perfect

  • @ctruf waaaay over rated!

  • Who said Mariah cant sing???

    Those stupid haters...

    Mariah still can hit low notes, high notes, belted notes, falsetto, melisma n whistle register!!!!!!

    Tats the fact here...

    Maybe the haters will say tat this is lip-synch...

    But lip-synch is not allow in The View..

    Hihi...

    I think the haters are speechless now...

    Mariah 4ever!!

  • skveli!!!!!!!

  • my hero, I Love you so much. Charles

  • lINDA VOU BAIXAR ESSE VIDO AGORA HUAHUHAU

  • love this performance. ican't wait to see her live in dallas 2/18/10 yay me lol

  • Totally live! Yeah the breath at the end is just for show! You can hear her live mic! Go to a show and then youll see she really is the one and only!!!! No one can hit and control those notes they way she can no one! Love you Mariah!!!!

  • no matter what haters says - but one thing to know when my idol mariah carey perform on stage.. she's the only one singer in whole wide world that has a voice of that.. no one like her.. she's one of a kind singer!

  • Mariah is the BEST diva!!!

    Dun care those idiot haters say

  • Comment removed

  • she is still incredible

  • this shit is deep she sings so well... this channel rocks, we are from Brazil in south america and we really just love your videos i really appreciate them from down here...

  • wow her version is actually BETTER MORE GENUINE AND more accurate than the original!

  • God Bless, Love you MIMI

  • live and i love it!!! i knew all she needs was rest and GOD!!! she has a voice of a 100 angels, when she allows god to move,

  • @qutieken Amen to that.. She is a angel.. Best female vocalist to have ever graced this planet. From the time she wrote her first album at age 18 until now. she has surpased every other female in sales, and singles...plus her octave range, and control in unsurpassed.. Best in the world MC

  • @qutieken over rated

  • She definitely does not lip-syncing, you can listen to her breath in the mike.

  • I agree this was live. Other times she might lip, but this is 100% real and even if it's lip who care? We are not ready to things everyday singing too sometimes she get tried and the voice is not ready nothing's wrong with that in my opinion.

  • My hero, Fuck Haters mariah, your the best

  • I love you mariah, and thanks for giving me hope... you are my hero... and Im collecting all your cds rite now... to make ur collection. but i have ur songs on my ipod nano. thank you so much.. Charles R Thornton

  • At least she´s beautiful.

  • she still song htis live, she's beautiful and has a beautiful voice.

    I REPEAT THIS LIVE

  • go the fuck away you ,stop trying to disect her performances.you obviously have horrid ears fro u can't hear properly.

    good day you douche bag moron.

  • Forget the hatters baby, you will always have me as a true friend, you ask anyone, they will tell you, you are my hero, always and forever... charles r thornton

  • If her voice is so strained its not liek she doesnt have the money to get help with it and take some time off to relax!

  • OMGEE I was Watching This In Australia.

    She Is Soo Awesomee

    Nick Cannon IS Soo Lucky

    Wish I Was Him Hehe

  • no its not...hahaha...they all live besides in japan

  • im gonna practice until i can reach that note,

  • WOW. That was a great performance and it actually seemed 100% live!

  • okei...can somebody answer my questions...?

    1.why does mariah have a whistle voice..?is she the only one in the world who has it..?...

    2.whats a "nodule" thing..?is it connected to the whistle voice thingy....?

    ..can someone please answer my questions thanks!!

  • 1) Whistle Register refers to the highest registers that the human voice can produce. Mariah is one of many singers that can sing in that high of a register, but she is the only one that can produce words and a consistent powerful vibrato of those notes. You can wikipedia Whistle Register...

    2) Vocal Nodules affect the vocal chords. they develop because of over straining, shouting, singing of voice, etc, but if you do have them, your voice will sound more hoarse and your vocal range is limited

  • actually she isn't the only one who can producer words and consistent vibrato in whistle register. There's many people who can do it, they're just not famous or widely publicized.

  • @phototgenicposer Whitney and Leona CANNOT use their whistle register. You are mistaken. Mariah never used that as her selling point. Nodules are not tiny in all cases. You are sadly mistaken. They swell for many different reasons and can actually prevent you from using a whole portion of your range. Do your homework, you fool.

  • @phototgenicposer AND you're a singer phototgenicposer, jesus christ, you have a lot of work to do in terms of learning your own craft.

  • oh believe me if they could do high notes they wouldnt be so modest about it...

  • man she can sing i love this song....love you mimi