Added: 3 years ago
From: TheSkepticsGuide
Views: 64,996
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (163)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • please stop talking and show the video !!! you are lame 

  • When would these hoax making people buy a modern camera with high resolution - these are antique ones ;-) 

  • Oooh, them Aliens sure are smart, you can tell their technology has gotten them far. Peeking into a window completely exposing it's head and face for everyone inside to see. Somebody with less intelligence might be more discreet and not let themselves be seen, but not those smart aliens.

  • What the he'll is that? Hahahaha

  • I really can't take them seriously when one person of the 6 or 7 person team thinks a piece of evidence is real just from seeing a still.

  • Thank you to the Skeptic´s Guide here we can conclude that IT IS A FAKE.... No doube about it.

    STAN ROMANEK has brought to us a real evidence of an Alien. SkepticGU has brought to us another disinformation based on just comments and ideas of their own...

    So WE ALL encourage you, SGU, to search for another "fake" alien evidences, so we can run and see that they are Real, plausibly Real, meanwhile your video is just a fraud of information

  • Comment removed

  • This form of skepticism is primarily a lame bird's nest of squawking opinions dressed up as rational authority. Not saying that Romanek is genuine, only that the "debunking" going on here is not comprehensive, not scientific, utilizes no measurement, but relies on ego-ists getting self ejaculating dopamine squirts every time they can call something "pathetic". So bottom line this is another zealotry dressed as sensibility; pushing want for one's reality without substance, and self aggrandizing

  • what people who are abducted need to do is take a small tracking chip and swallow it so when u go up into space and shit yourself the government can track it around outerspace!

  • I've got a question: If he did in fact fake it, then why did he claim that it would take a Hollywood studio tens of thousands of dollars to make? If he knew it was cheap and easy, why even bother?

  • ALIENS R REAL PERIOD.

  • How do you expect me to believe me that there's intelligent life on other planets when I don't believe that there's intelligent life on THIS planet?

  • whats up with his hed is it a ass

  • cameras are in HD hand have fucking MEGAPIXLES! Do you know what that means? IT MEANS STOP BEING BLURRY. I want to see a fucking alien and there's no excuse not to get one on tape that looks reasonably VISIBLE anymore!

  • Well , well , well !

  • Lol ! - Lol !

  • I beleave but this film by that romanek guy is obviously fake... the thing is that this guy makes money out of this... I saw this on tv before, In that docu he could schow it once but he could not give a copy at the time that would have cost the reporter 5000 Dollars.... This is when i now it is a scam....I say believe but do not believe blindly

  • Anyone see "Alien Planet"? I think if we ever have encounters with aliens, it'll be like that.

  • Crappy Evidence?What about all the NASA space shots of ufo's in space..........how the hell are people gonna fake that shit?You skeptics are the worst pieces of crap out of all of them,uncle toms,you hold the Governments Balls!Ok granted some ppl fake shit,but how do you explain the unexplained?The opening of wormholes(AKA)Spirals and I dont know about anyone else how the fuck we gonna defend our world when were bieng lied to by our own ppl?Who do we trust?Surely not Government or you!

  • @lionpunk1WWE Skeptics do not vehemently deny that there are any life outside earth. However, there is not any INCONTROVERTIBLE evidence of their existence. Space shots of UFOs are not incontrovertible evidence in any way, shape or form. Until good evidence of their existence is available, one cannot say it's a fact that aliens exist. That's science to you.

  • @lionpunk1WWE Argument from authority, ad ignorantiam, ad hominem, confusing currently unexplained with unexplainable, Non-sequitur... just a couple of logical fallacies you blatantly violated, semi in-order, with your statement.

  • @JoNnYShizzle When a Alien probes your asshole out and your Government laughs about it Im gonna say "I TOLD YOU SO"!

  • @lionpunk1WWE When the skeptical society continues to debunk UFO sightings and fake alien videos, such as the one posted, I'm gonna say "Gosh, i'm grateful to have grown up to view life from a logical perspective rather than worry about something so naive."

  • alien to my understanding, from bol

  • i not understand english i speak spanish

  • They would come all this way for a couple of reasons. One, resources. Earth has resources that are current useful for space travel at NASA (gold, precious minerals, precious stones, etc), which might also be useful for some alien life forms technology as well. Two, more resources. We aren't called the water planet for nothing. Seems like water is a precursor to life, so its possible that alien sentient beings would also need water to survive. Three, study the naked half-breed ape-alien.

  • @soldog the truth is of space colonization and federations, our blue planet is a key stopping off point that drags millions of aliens off other space lanes to refuel and take on supplies, the other alternative stop off points are protected by conservation laws that were passed by a UN of the local galaxies, and aliens there of.

    we are a service station for travellers,

    lower forms, animal humans are deemed lesser and not important,

    we are as ants to giants all too often.

  • there coming youll all see lol

  • LOL that guy on the far right looks so much like Glen Beck at 7:20 Ah ha ha ha ha.

    Besides people are ignorant into creating videos regarding another video.

    I mean come on dont you guys ever heard or seen that they have found ancients tablets and in those tablets it looked like they have stone drawings of what it appears flying saucers and man in space suits or big eyed creatures?

    Well whatever the case we are not alone we cant be the only intelligent life in this galaxy.

    Think guys.

  • @AlvaroAndfriends Your comment is the best irony I have read all day. If you were trying to be funny you'd be a riot. "...don't[sic] you guys ever heard...they have stone drawings of ... flying saucers..." .. "Think guys."

    --

    Who is they? How am I supposed to know "they" found stone drawings if you don't know who "they" are?

    --

    Your best evidence for aliens visiting Earth today are stone tablets (that aren't famous because they are shite)? A big-eyed human and a cigar-shaped object?

  • CRAP! stop trying 2 scare me :,(

  • I saw an alien once, it had a big long head with a protruding jaw and concentrated acid for blood.....

    ..... It shit me right up i can tell you, but worse was when the science officer, Ash, turns out to be an android and he tries to stuff the magazine down Ripley's mouth, it's a good film!........ what?

  • I have a picture with a real alien in it holding a boys face in between his arms that looks like me when i was a kid.

  • Romanek video is quite hilarious, I feel bad for his family.

  • But you dont get aliens in the street...? this video is fake lol

  • what people who get abducted need to do is go out and buy a DVR and some camras and put them all over your room and out side and tape your house. When they get you and bring you back you will have proof and you can sell it for lots of money WOW you would be rich and people would belive you.

  • that is so true nice idea

  • @2009wildmonkey1 No, people would STILL say it is a hoax. CGI, a puppet, clever editing etc. Skeptics will not believe until it happens to them or until the president announces that aliens are here.

  • lol xD

  • Comment removed

  • I'm not saying the alien video is real or fake, I haven't seen the whole of it. But what I think is funny is that they are so convinced it is a fake off of one frame of it, when they haven't even seen the video yet. Skeptics can be just as irrational as they claim believers to be.

  • fake

  • Comment removed

  • i believe you, i think i have seen a ufo over my woods so im no sceptic

  • like I say, people won't believe until they see it, just like God

  • @puremana22 u have 2 b a skeptic in order 2 b rational. believing that ur loved one has came back as an ghost or that an alien is going 2 take u to do experiments is a form of mental illness ., this kind of non rational thinking hurts human beings.. it has nthing to do with God . plus y would an alien come all the way 2 earth just 2 look in someones window lmao?

  • @ladiesmanxxxxxxx im just saying people won't believe in anything this big until they see it for them self

  • computerised or a mask either way. if it was real they had a camera and they knew it was coming on that day?

  • they said they heard noises the day before and the day before, and so they set up a camera to see what it was.

  • mate its fake tho. they happen to know which window he looking at?

  • yeh i know its fake, but i was just saying what they said

  • scum

  • Wasn't this documentary supposed to come out last November? Are we ever going to get to see the "real" video?

  • The bashing Steve gives this Billy Myer character really cracks me up! I don't think i've heard him lay it on someone so hard before its fucking halarious.

    Well actually i love to hear him trash the discovery institute too...

  • looks like the o rly owl

  • Hehe, everybody who believes in "aliens" or "gods" or "psychic powers" and crap like that are complete morons!

  • how disrespectful!

    what if i called you a stupid idiot because you believe in gravity?

    you have your beliefs and others have theirs. don't go putting people down like that, bigot!

  • So you find him an ideaological bigot?

  • so you can look at the almost infinite vastnes of space and say with complete certaintity and even prove that there s no life anywhere else on any of the billions of planets out there? thats ludicrous

  • No, life may probably have evolved elsewhere in the universe, the chances are probably not so infitisimaly slim for life to occur on rocks with water and a good temperature and so on..But for that life to evolve in a manner similar to life on earth is some million times less likely, and that there would evolve four-limbed humanoids interested enough and skilled enough to travel here despise the enormous distances an the light-speed-limit, just to play hide and seek? Err, nope..they're fairies: )

  • 100% fake fake fake

  • Anythings possible..

  • no, a prime number of the form 4*k is impossible, it is also impossible to add two positive numbers and get a negative number. Not everything is possible

  • You confuse me. Talking about numbers?

  • no leas esto el 13 de octubre de 1991 un niño llamado nick se tiro a un puente por problemas familiares si ya leiste esto copiar y pegar esto en 5 videos mas hazlo o nick vendra por toasd tu familia y moriran hazme caso yo lo lei y lo hice

  • and your up the ass of a fake god.

  • a little unnecessary, i think

  • Don't be so hard on yourself.

  • If I saw that thing looking in my window it would be laying in the yard spurting green crap out of a .30-06 hole in its head. What a bunch of crap.

  • mi gang ta foq

  • how gay, thanks for wasting 7:46 mins of my life.

  • then why did you keep watching it after a minute?

    you saw the title, didn't it give you a clue on what it was about?

    and don't use "gay" like that.

    that just shows how wide your vocabulary is.

  • looks like the Punisher skull

  • i thought the same thing!

  • it would be fun if he didn´t fake the alien but someone who knew that he would set up a camera did.

  • His last name is not "Reed". He is not a PHD. He is not an M.D. I can't wait till they put him in jail for fraud.

  • Ignorance sure speaks for itself..

  • The reason why they didn't get the video is because the company producing the documentary has exclusive rights on that video.

  • Wow, objectivity on youtube ... a rare find.

  • What the hell was that? I could paint my dog's butt white and he would look more like an alien than that. DAMNIT I want an ALIEN!!!! Maybe Obama will tell us all about them. HAHAHAHAHAHAH!!!!!!

  • Careful what you wish for...

    Woods Footage

    watch?v=ySomFuWtXL4&feature=ch annel_page&fmt=18

    Alien in Home

    watch?v=IAE-OcPhZ_w&feature=ch annel_page&fmt=18

    Alien Artifact

    watch?v=qkwxJ5QnrYs&feature=ch annel_page&fmt=18

    Attempted communication

    watch?v=6nwVNHqWgK0&feature=ch annel&fmt=18

  • Yes, you should all watch the 'Dr' Reed alien saga if you REALLY want to LOL.

    At least he put some effort into it, not some "alien face in the window" crap. He modeled an entire alien WITH brain falling out. (don't worry, he got better).

    And then, he has a 6 minute conversation with someone rubbing a balloon. Now THAT's dedication.

  • You have just exposed your own ignorance jrparri.

    CointelPro has done an effective job I see.

    Google that term... CointelPro.

    I bet you're the type of person who latches onto other people's research or lack thereof rather than You actually doing work for yourself..

    Have you seen the new evidence as of Jan. 2009 for Dr Reed?

    It's kinda hard to get genuine blood and tissue samples from a hoax.

    Art Bell supports Dr. Reed, so does Robert o Dean and Wendelle Stevens.

    jrparri is a 'Not See'.

  • "Genuine" blood and tissue samples that have only been seen by "ufologists". What a shock.

    Oh and btw CointelPro was a dis-information organization, not a "lack of information" organization. They can spread disinformation til the cows come home, but if someone has actual evidence there's nothing they could do about it.

    So that sucks for you. You are really invested huh? So tell me, how much money HAVE you given to these charlatans?

  • even if someone ever catches the real thing we will never find out the real truth!

    just kidding!

    this comment is a real ..aLIEn..!

  • The thing is, if youre always skeptical of everything, aren't you going to miss something the same way as if you believed everything?

  • You're missing the point of being skeptical. Being skeptical does not mean you dismiss everything that seems unusual. It means you take a good, hard look at the claim, and challenge it.

  • o I know that, what I meant was that sometimes looking at something with a certain eye, skeptical or believing, can blind you to something else

  • "o I know that, what I meant was that sometimes looking at something with a certain eye, skeptical or believing, can blind you to something else"

    ... No. A skeptical eye is an eye that looks at everything and dismisses frauds.

  • o I didn't know that

  • so where is the alien autopsy replica clip made in the middle 90s that's better then the original one, and not made in the 2000s?

  • Can you say puppet?

  • 3:27 real????

  • did you even watch the video?

  • "This was a real video. Call it a fake if you like, but we know it was real. 1 star!!!"

    Provide evidence.

  • yes, the video is real, i'm a believer in real videos, hell i worship them day & night, but the camera is more than likely to be a fake,but i'm not sure as i didn't see the camera!

  • I've seen more real videos than you could ever imagine.

    sure, they were real videos of things that were staged fakes, but the VIDEOS were real and DAMMIT THAT'S WHAT COUNTS! :'(

  • Check out this guys favorites list for practicing "Name the Logical Fallacy."

  • crap...

    that video was creepy

    now i wont be able to sleep well for a week

    god damn you fake aliens!!!

  • Excellent!

  • I love the comment by Steve about how this guy has been in the company of aliens for 10 years and never managed to get a clear photo. I've had fish for longer periods and have plenty of great photos.

  • You seriously give credence to the claim?  You saw how easy it was to fake it... God, people are gullible.

  • yes some are gullible.. its not the claim i give credence to - yet, its the 'wise' critics poking fun about energy placements at the end, calling (iforget his name.) 'a kook' its the energy i have interest in, maybe you should watch Bruce Lipton too, its interesting stuff.

    Sorry to be unclear

  • leeburton

    Are you saying the idea of the Metatron Personal Harmonizer holds sway with you?

  • Actually, being skeptical is what makes science work. If we just accepted anecdotal evidence we would be in the dark ages still. Science marches on every second of every day while the fakes hide in the shadows and make unsubstantiated claims. Repeatability is one of the central tenants of science, if no one else can do what you did there is something wrong. "no room for improvement" is a mockery of all that has been accomplished and will be accomplished.

  • the aliens looks like stewie griffin with dark eyes

  • Great Vedio guys! Keep em coming!

  • Great vid. Thanks guys!

  • Hehe Rebecca allways makes me LOL

  • I hope this goes viral...

  • what does viral mean?

  • Hugely popular in a small amount of time.

    Like a virus spreading very rapidly.

  • thanks 4 info

  • Love it!

  • Metatron is the name of an angel in Jewish mythology.

    Alan Rickman played Metatron in the film Dogma.

  • didn't metatron also appear to santana in a dream?

  • Gosh there was a time I used to be freaked out by this sort of stuff. Whether it's ghosts, spontaneous human combustion, alien encounters, bigfoot and even Lochness.

    This is what scares me now: Crossing a busy road when drunk or falling asleep while driving, my powerkite lifting me too high in the air and the line breaks.

  • lol I love the skeptic-created alien video.

    It's almost as great as the pendulum UFO video.

  • oh, sorry, I thought you encouraged debate and discussion, but this is the recruitment page for obsequious sycophants... my bad.

    Great vid guys, you're the best, keep up the good work, you're in my favorites, 5 stars, hi fives, woot, etc.

    meh, red's my favorite colour lol

  • Notice nobody docked you points in your actual argument. Only when you responded, to the counter of your argument, in a defensive manner.

    Keep it above the belt.

  • Perhaps I was disappointed in the original response to my first comment as I was surprised by the belittling and supercilious tone. "quaint" indeed lol.

    However I humbly and graciously accept your point about keeping it above the belt as you were not condescending.

  • I think they were trying to be nice, not harsh.

    There is rarely a good way to say, "you're wrong." It's true though that amoeba can't be said to be any less evolved than humans. One argument would go, "Amoebas have been around for 2 billion years, therefore there evolutionary history trumps ours by some 1.99 billion years." That's not correct either, but  its an interesting thought.

  • Oops, I think amoeba are eukaryotes. That's only 1 billion years old.

  • They are indeed. As are all organisms with their DNA enclosed in a separate membrane within the cell. Including you and me :)

    As opposed to, say bacteria, which are Prokaryotes (spelling?) which have no cell nucleus and hence, their DNA is open to the rest of the cell.

    Or something like that...

  • Haha, Peckman's still pic looks like me in my hockey mask if my neck's bent at a certain angle.

  • Great video!

    5/5 and fav.

  • Suggesetion: More video and less pictures. It looks better if you see the people talking. However, it might be difficult since you guys don't record it in the same place.

  • I do like the new venue, but I don't like being tied to my computer chair. The podcast es muy importante.

  • Isn't it funny how the "aliens" in these types of videos always look like weird humans.

  • Seriously, only a few of the millions of types of animals on earth resemble us. All animals on Earth are directly related to us. How likely is it that a completely unrelated creature looks so similar?

  • My point exactly.

  • Obviously this is a complete hoax, but if there are indeed aliens, I think it's at least reasonable to assume for arguments sake that they could be humanoid in appearance.

    Many scientists believe that for life to be found in space, requires similar conditions as those found on earth, eg, presence of water, similar gravity, etc.

    If the conditions are similar, and we are the pinnacle of evolution thus far on earth, maybe "convergent evolution" would reach a similar result out there.

    Just a thought

  • The notion that humans are the "pinnacle" of evolution is quaint and no longer accepted. We are just one twig on the vast bush of life. We are not "above" anything else. There is no reason to think that technological intelligence would converge on anything resembling a human form.

  • rofl ok. Your response is "quaint" too. You may notice by the structure and words I used that I was speculating, not making assertions. As opposed to your last sentence, which is just plain wrong. Fuck, even sheer accidental chance is "some" reason to think it could happen. But maybe you know best. Thanks for enlightening me...

    Also whilst I don't presume to speak now on your behalf, most people I know are substantially "above", say, amoeba etc.

    Thanks for your insightful response though

  • wow, now I'm wondering if, perchance, you're that skepchic who, in another vid, denies the existence of homeopathy and psychics. I mean most sane people would avoid them like the plague, but I'm pretty sure they exist.

    Then again, I thought people might just be the most advanced form of life on the planet, so what would I know? lol

    Better go whip off a quick email to David Attenborough

  • To clarify - you made an argument for "convergent evolution" which was premised on the notion that humans are the "pinnacle." My point is that your premise is no longer accepted evolutionary thought. Amoeba have just as much evolutionary history behind them as humans. We may be more complex and intelligent, but not more evolved. I said nothing about chance - just that there is no known mechanism for convergence on the human form.

  • ok, I get that you mean we are no longer accepted as the "pinnacle". However to take your point that amoeba have just as much evolutionary history behind them, I'd submit they actually have more. So in terms of e/h we must be the least evolved species as we are about the newest.

    Of course we're getting pedantic now, but you said "There is no reason to think...", not "...there is no known mechanism..". They are in fact substantially different sentences.

    I feel I should clarify also, so cont...

  • I wasn't so much arguing for any theory as just responding conversationally to a point. I think by use of words like "if" and "maybe" it was clear I wasn't trying to push a point.

    Anyway I maintain that for all intents and purposes, by virtue of such things as language, fire, agriculture, tool making, art, music, commerce, law, civilisation etc, we are the most advanced species. Maybe pinnacle of evo's "achievements"? I mean when another species launches a space shuttle, I'll reconsider lol.

  • ok last one. I promise - I hate spamming. It's just difficult to have long and complex discussions in blocks of 500 characters. Perhaps we should make use of another forum if you like. Maybe email me or something? At least then we can make our points fully and effectively rather than trying to expound in a few sentences at a time.

    Basically, where I was being politely conversational to begin, I felt that your "rebuttal" was, well, sort of arrogant. Maybe just terse? I hope you know what I mean.

  • They are quite different sentences, aren't they...

    As for evolution, if "evolve" means in simple terms to change or adapt to exploit new niches or better deal with the environment then to suggest humans are probably more evolved than other species seems reasonable.

    I also agree the Skeptics first response was unnecessarily rude and dismissive. I would have expected better too.

  • It is however not reasonable to assume an alien is going to travel LIGHTYEARS through the universe with advanced tech to look through the window of a barnhouse in Colorado.

  • I agree entirely, hence my first line in my first comment.

  • And the thing is that it's more likely to be thousands or tens of thousands of light years, not just 5 or 6, considering there are only about 40 stars closer than 20 light years from here (not including the Sun or the binary/multiple systems which are very unlikely to sustain stable planetary orbits, i.e. the possibility of life). 5 or 6 I could ALMOST believe, although why they'd do that trip more than once, after seeing the Colorado "specimen" in his natural habitat, I'll never understand.

  • If you have continual contact w/ aliens than get better film equipment! But obviously he isn't in contact sooo...

  • Maybe it is just me but I swear that alien looks just like the skull on the The Punisher's shirt. Anyone else think so?

  • lol

  • One word... More!

  • Excellent work guys! WE NEED MORE VIDEOS!

    Podcast is great, but the videos give the added depth of content that is needed for some of the segments. Keep up the awesome job! You truly are my escape to reality.

  • Great job. You guys are hilarious.

  • It takes forever to download this video. Is it just me, because I have a crappy connection, or is it also the case for other people?

  • just you

  • very well presented. hope to see more.

  • Niice. I want MORE SGU content!!!!

  • SGU!!!! FUCK YEAH! Great video, nice pictures.

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more