there will l always be a gap between generations , and this is proof of it , i thought this was a joke ... start hearing music & figure out how to stop just listening to it
@mellemel1970: Very true. People were exposed to this song when Rita Coolidge sang it on the "Mad Dogs And Englishmen" album by Joe Cocker, then The Carpenters covered it and made it a national hit.
My dad owns a Carpenters CD, and Superstar was on there. I loved it. Watched Juno, heard this when Mark was talking about it... and I was like, dude thats dope, I gotta look it up xD
im watchin juno right now n thouht "i like this song!" :) then when i heard it from the original carpenters im like...this aint it lol so i had to look for it in the credits
Spesso il male di vivere ho incontrato: era il rivo strozzato che gorgoglia,
era l'incartocciarsi della foglia riarsa, era il cavallo stramazzato.
5 Bene non seppi, fuori del prodigio che schiude la divina Indifferenza: era la statua nella sonnolenza del meriggio, e la nuvola, e il falco alto levato.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
ugh it took me forever to figure who sung this song til i saw a trailer today to a horror movied called high tension then i googled it and here i am..love this version..
At least they're keeping the Carpenters' music alive... I prefer the original but this was the first version I heard and it made me go out and buy a Carpenters CD
I remember driving past the Carpenters home in Downey when Karen died. There was a grip of police and repoerters. I was just a kid. I thought to myself, this person must have been bigger that the Osmonds.
haha sure... so why is sonic youth always shooting videos in southern ca.. like the desert , downey and im sure theres a few other locations ... i dunno watching this made me think of that
This cover shows that only Karen Carpenter can sing this song well. In fact, this guy knows it too....that's why he's whispering instead of singing the song. He simply can't do it!
Can someone please explain to me the reasoning behind the bands infatuation with Karen Carpenter. It seems to be reoccuring theme they touch upon on each album pretty much.
have to disagree subsamadhi, Karen Carpenter was recognized AS A REMARKABLE SINGER...anyone who knows "voices" in the music business has stated she is the closest to perfection you will get...I've heard numerous people in the business say this...
do u no how ur mom sounds like when im fucking her so hard in the ass??? u stupid piece of fucking shit this is a good song!!!! AND U SHOULD NO BECAUSE IT SOUNDS JUST LIKE THE WAY U SCREAM WHEN UR DAD SUCKS UR DICK U FUCKING LITTLE KUNT
and you look lyk ur mom on crack in a fatsuit so i'd shut the fukk up yuh dirty skank because if you dont lyk the fkn song yuh dont gotta fkn listen to it!!!
What a mongaloid! Did your parents have to type that comment for you as you can't reach the keyboard in your Steven Hawkings chair? Bless you - a gifted retard.
Haha, half of the people replying don't even know who Sonic MOTHER FUCKING Youth is! If you guys only knew how influential this band was to so many other bands.
uh, yeah we do. see, some of us aren't kids and we remember them from back in the day. they are bunch of rich kids that can afford to sit around and make noise because they don't actually have to produce records with decent songs on them.
a flat 70's mellow gold hit? (sigh) connoisseurs of fine vocalists often rank karen carpenter in the top for her amazing tone quality and incredible control. her voice sounds like butter. and in all her years of touring AND playing drums, never did she sing a flat or sharp note. no, doing a carpenters cover of a burt bachrach song is risky, but they didn't even come close to doing it justice.
Don't get me wrong. I really like the song myself. I was just calling it what it is. Though I highly doubt "connoisseurs of fine vocalists rank karen carpenter in the top for her vocal quality". She was a good singer, but by no means remarkable. By the way, Sonic Youth covers aren't about doing a song justice. You miss the point entirely.
my mother, who loved the carpenters, admitted to me after me playin this song to her.. she said, yea, she didnt really know how to sing. i do like this cover though.
actually, those in the business considered Karen to be an exceptional singer. she was easy to record and never sang flat or sharp. i hate to break it to ya, but your ma didn't know what she was talking about. just saying...
The only thing good about this cover is that it was on the movie "The Frighteners". And it was friggin hilarious... fitted with that balding freak guy perfectly when he was being screamed at by the woman, thus turning the radio on frantically lol.
Stounbjerg, the truly great singers have the whole package. They perfected the craft. Otherwise you lower the standard.Check out Eva Cassidy's "over the rainbow" she died of cancer a bunch of years back. The live cut on U-tube was done when she new she was dying. That's "passion and melancholy" only with a voice only her and Karen Carpenter possessed. She never got a dime. Today it's alot of cosmetics and attitude and love of money but without true talent. They should be poets not singers.
I don't get it. Are you saying SY is a band about money and fame? Because then I would strongly disagree. I'm not saying Karen sings without passion and melancholy, but the sound is just too clean for me. In that way I prefer SY's version and music in general. I haven't listened to "Eva Cassidy", but the most passionate singer i can think of would be Ian Curtis (if you count it as worthy thing to mentioned: he surely knew as well that his life wasn't going in the right direction with his illness
No not at all, as I said in my first comment, I like alot of what the band does. But they're not great singers. Some of the songs are very monotone. And you just can't compare a voice like Carpenters to that. But everything has it's own time. And that time period was about real "Singers". The past couple decades it's more about "statement' etc.
this isn't even close to the best sonic youth song, let alone better than the original. but if it prompts some stupid kids to check out "Death Valley 69" or "Confusion is Sex", then awesome!
honestly anyone who said sonic youth did a better version are just plain stupid, i think it was great they were carpenter fans and decided to cover this song but to say that its better than Karen? thats crazy, just a bunch of dumb hipsters who saw juno and think the version is better v_v
this song was actually in the movie the frightners too so when i saw juno and heard it again i was glad that people started to pick up on how awesome it is.
What an ignorant attitude. I've never seen the film Juno. This version is just better IMO because it is more passionate and melancolic than the original song. It is more raw. But of course if you like a more clean sound that's fine.
wah wah i think its great sonic youth admired karen but this cover doesnt hold a candle to the original and im pretty sure they know that too, and if by "melancholic" you mean horrible sounding with just plain horrible singing then yes i prefer something cleaner and overall more beautiful
this is one of the most hauntingly beautiful love songs ever written and SY s cover just makes it even more heart breaking. first heard it from my first love when i was seventeen and now im nearly 31 and breaking up with my partner of 1i years. still kills me every time. real songs should make you feel summat. and this is just right.
A bit abbreviated, what?
Wormtongue13 3 months ago
Baby baby baby baby oh babyyyy, I loveee you. I really do. <3
eserrette2006 4 months ago
RIP 4000GrausKelvin
thanatosacizis 5 months ago 2
What's up with all these people below me?
TheGreatIndoors1979 6 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
There are countless ways to destroy a beautiful song, this is one of them
ssoko 6 months ago
damn i with this was on itunes
CassandraTheCanadian 7 months ago
there will l always be a gap between generations , and this is proof of it , i thought this was a joke ... start hearing music & figure out how to stop just listening to it
daveponti38 8 months ago
So Soothing,And Comforting Yet It Has That Haunting Edge.I Have Goosebumps(:
ohrocky6464 9 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
curse you youth for damaging this song...............really sucking !
katycasata 9 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
What is this piece of shit!? This is what happens when talentless shits make cover master works of talented people!
NEBESHIKU 10 months ago
They killed it IMO
Harkabba 11 months ago
@luyben12 Tit.
malthus101 11 months ago
Where's the fucking rest of it?
malthus101 11 months ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Superstar is a Leon Russell song...The Carpenter's version was a cover as well...this version here suxx with a capitol S!
whizzkid58 11 months ago
Superstar is a Leon Russell song...The Carpenter's version was a cover as well
whizzkid58 11 months ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
im at a lost of words....
MrAndrewveiga1962 1 year ago
mmmmmmmmmmmm
MsWednesday13 1 year ago
Sonic Youth also has a great original song about Karen Carpenter called; "Tunic (Song for Karen)"
Very haunting as well.
"And I remember mom what you said, you said honey, you look so under fed."
CaptainPillowMusic 1 year ago
A Great song by the Carpenters ,,but sonic youth sing this song amazing...very good cover..
shakys22 1 year ago
A Great song by the Carpenters ,,but sonic youth sing this song amazing...
shakys22 1 year ago
This sucked...this dude can't sing. BAD
biskitlee 1 year ago
@biskitlee yes he can!!!
thehefolomp 1 year ago
Juno - lame. Try High Tension.
dvader7272 1 year ago
@dvader7272
....
I watched the trailer. Terrible.
FALUHSEE 1 year ago
I know The Carpenters made this song famous, but they didn't write it...Leon Russell and Bonnie Bramlett did.
mellemel1970 1 year ago
@mellemel1970: Very true. People were exposed to this song when Rita Coolidge sang it on the "Mad Dogs And Englishmen" album by Joe Cocker, then The Carpenters covered it and made it a national hit.
MattHatter 1 year ago
:D ahhhh love this song! THANKS JUNO!
artchicky 1 year ago
Such a melancholy song. Who knew the Carpenters had darkness to there writing. The speaker of the song is so isolated, delusional and lonely.
mikey42 1 year ago
@mikey42 Is this song about a deranged fan?
titostacos 1 year ago
@titostacos no its not!!!
thehefolomp 1 year ago
yeah...thanks juno! I've heard it before but never found it!!!
milkbreadatfreenetde 1 year ago
why did you cut it short?
dahmeredsback 1 year ago
Flippin awesome switch up!!
poetick31 1 year ago
My dad owns a Carpenters CD, and Superstar was on there. I loved it. Watched Juno, heard this when Mark was talking about it... and I was like, dude thats dope, I gotta look it up xD
ChibiVampie 1 year ago
im watchin juno right now n thouht "i like this song!" :) then when i heard it from the original carpenters im like...this aint it lol so i had to look for it in the credits
demigrl21 1 year ago
They took this song so a whoooole new level.
placeboloverrrrz 1 year ago
amazzzing song!
OMGPinkyStar 1 year ago
just great.
MsValerieee 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this sucks
odd19666 1 year ago
"Superstar" is a 1969 song written by Bonnie Bramlett and Leon Russell not the Carpenters.
TheArtofWalking 1 year ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
EW. WTF IS THIS SHIT? The Carpenters version is a billion times better. >.>
Gizardofmars 1 year ago
@Gizardofmars 'doesn't get it....'
durgAUMurge 1 year ago
kim does play drums
djeeeb3 1 year ago
better than the original
man they're amazing
nmobayed 1 year ago
not only is this song to die for, but kim's dress is amazing....
thenifeelnothing 1 year ago 3
@thenifeelnothing She looks damn good.
nicjazdad 1 year ago
i think that this song is one of their best! I love sonic youth.
whatsonyourbrain 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i didn't like it
rodolfo191 2 years ago
touching.
pandasuicides 2 years ago 3
I die and go to heaven every time I hear this song.
peaceinthemiddleast1 2 years ago 8
Probably the best cover of all-time....in my opinion, Very haunting.
paulsak59 2 years ago 58
genial!
la versin de vevo es una mierda :D
polacomei 2 years ago
graciiaz Juno ¡¡Ez Geniial !!
Monzefull 2 years ago
only 2:18 worth of this gem!?!?!?
where's the entire song?
717mienbao 2 years ago
song fo lanni!!!
killakrazy1 2 years ago
Love this cover better then original.
VinceKrat 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Juno sucks cock
Starvoid7 2 years ago
God I hope so! lol MILF! haha
lambo525 2 years ago
song is hot.
cocteautwin75 2 years ago
Comment removed
thenifeelnothing 2 years ago
song for karen.
howardTdevoto 2 years ago
Spesso il male di vivere ho incontrato: era il rivo strozzato che gorgoglia,
era l'incartocciarsi della foglia riarsa, era il cavallo stramazzato.
5 Bene non seppi, fuori del prodigio che schiude la divina Indifferenza: era la statua nella sonnolenza del meriggio, e la nuvola, e il falco alto levato.
evol1982 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
from Juno
JoeyShot 2 years ago
LOL
FurryOwlet 2 years ago
and?
Dillmanable 2 years ago
and nothing the fucking song was in the movie and there was no need to ask and ? like a moron....
JoeyShot 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This sucks!
myheartakes88 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
ugh it took me forever to figure who sung this song til i saw a trailer today to a horror movied called high tension then i googled it and here i am..love this version..
adamjcantu 2 years ago
I love them in this song better then the original,the original was good ,but this is GREAT!!!
selenagirl14 2 years ago
MMMººº so hot!º
krodelic 2 years ago
Amazing,. No too keen on the abrupt ending tho!
francissweston 2 years ago
I love this tune it is so good.
Baldpoodle 2 years ago
Brilliant cover. The Youth hit the spot on this. Mournful and brilliant.
marmiteboy99 2 years ago 40
@marmiteboy99 Brilliant cover....Really?? Brilliant Cover?!?! You're an ass! You should be banned from listening to the original ever again!
MrGetreal727 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@marmiteboy99 Brilliant cover....Really?? Brilliant Cover?!?! You're an ass! You should be banned from listening to the original ever again!
MrGetreal727 9 months ago
Nice to see yet another band paying tribute, Karen would smile
MasterAceman123456 2 years ago 6
sooo special - i love this
captaincrabtree 2 years ago 5
oops i clicked 1 star :{{
ooooosweetbuttox 2 years ago
I love this version!
quieroterry 2 years ago
i first heard this during the movie juno, i've loved it ever since
jennaaa120108 2 years ago 4
saaaammme,
my favourite song :)
itsbabycakess 2 years ago 3
lol 1:51
Merzbowxnoise 2 years ago
Form what Album is that song?
I love it!
Merzbowxnoise 2 years ago
'If I Were A Carpenter'
xVoodooChildEmmax 2 years ago
This song will never be the same to me.
its sad and true :L:L:L:L
xMellowxYellowx 2 years ago
Amen to that brother.
xbloodybitchx 2 years ago
At least they're keeping the Carpenters' music alive... I prefer the original but this was the first version I heard and it made me go out and buy a Carpenters CD
:]
SteelMagnoliasUpload 2 years ago 4
is that bill gates on the drums .... 1.28... lol
connierep 2 years ago 7
Business at the speed of Sonic Youth
Khimkharmakan 2 years ago
lol i always thought that will the glasses he looked like a cross between gill gates and harry potter
896754 2 years ago
the original is boring to me, that's it.
famAAAs 2 years ago
why doesnt it play the whole song?
bridgeseatpeople 2 years ago 3
I Only Know This Song Because Its In Juno ... Amazing Song Tho i Must Say :O
SherriBourkeRox 2 years ago 2
haha same here!
4everinlove13 2 years ago
ditto lol
DeweyDuck420 2 years ago
I remember driving past the Carpenters home in Downey when Karen died. There was a grip of police and repoerters. I was just a kid. I thought to myself, this person must have been bigger that the Osmonds.
Snotra 2 years ago
haha sure... so why is sonic youth always shooting videos in southern ca.. like the desert , downey and im sure theres a few other locations ... i dunno watching this made me think of that
rickhorror 2 years ago
This is a genius cover. Who knew The Carpenters could sound dark and sexy?
BaudelaireGirl 2 years ago
i like...have a soft spot for sonic youth
109pt2 2 years ago
This cover shows that only Karen Carpenter can sing this song well. In fact, this guy knows it too....that's why he's whispering instead of singing the song. He simply can't do it!
infinera06 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This cover is awful.
endlich1984 2 years ago
i like his ginger hair
wtfshannon 2 years ago
the version of this song makes me want to run a razor across my wrists
jaryn1234 2 years ago
i think this is an amazing cover, i think the lead singer re-created it perfectly
jesikarrrr 2 years ago 5
thurston moore is true love!
kaylastarkiller 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Masquerading the melancholy theme as art....pathetic!!
1lemurian 2 years ago
Can someone please explain to me the reasoning behind the bands infatuation with Karen Carpenter. It seems to be reoccuring theme they touch upon on each album pretty much.
nirvanapnk16 2 years ago
Sonic Youth are infatuated with a lot of people, Madonna being another one. They are just weird people in that way (not saying that in a bad way).
Sollys3 2 years ago
i love how they can turn a carpenters song to a sonic youth song without even trying. truly an original band.
mistahxdaniel 2 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
dude fuck that there original faggots they suck fat cock!
2Pockets0 2 years ago
love this song...alot
lol
lostlove10 3 years ago
have to disagree subsamadhi, Karen Carpenter was recognized AS A REMARKABLE SINGER...anyone who knows "voices" in the music business has stated she is the closest to perfection you will get...I've heard numerous people in the business say this...
SHRINA17 3 years ago
I have to say...I love, love The Carpenters!
I love their version of Superstar, but I really like this version too---I really enjoy it also!
SHRINA17 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
It sound like a diseased dog being put to death by an apathetic shoe salesman.
therightfullking 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
do u no how ur mom sounds like when im fucking her so hard in the ass??? u stupid piece of fucking shit this is a good song!!!! AND U SHOULD NO BECAUSE IT SOUNDS JUST LIKE THE WAY U SCREAM WHEN UR DAD SUCKS UR DICK U FUCKING LITTLE KUNT
BACKSPRING101 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
this is just a reply to therightfullking
BACKSPRING101 2 years ago
you mispelt cunt, just to let you know.i bet thats a little embarrasing.
newellboy2 2 years ago 2
reply to therightfullking:
and you look lyk ur mom on crack in a fatsuit so i'd shut the fukk up yuh dirty skank because if you dont lyk the fkn song yuh dont gotta fkn listen to it!!!
shandell94 2 years ago
What a mongaloid! Did your parents have to type that comment for you as you can't reach the keyboard in your Steven Hawkings chair? Bless you - a gifted retard.
therightfullking 2 years ago 2
that made me LOL
wtfshannon 2 years ago
damn, you suck.
sk8adio42 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
Simple music for simple minded people.
LOL. LONG LIVE IGNORANT SHEEP...
ruleoforder 3 years ago
They do it better than the Carpenters.
dandruff71 3 years ago
hardly.
larissanpw 3 years ago
Agreed.
sschaula 3 years ago
Haha, half of the people replying don't even know who Sonic MOTHER FUCKING Youth is! If you guys only knew how influential this band was to so many other bands.
surfbum5412 3 years ago
uh, yeah we do. see, some of us aren't kids and we remember them from back in the day. they are bunch of rich kids that can afford to sit around and make noise because they don't actually have to produce records with decent songs on them.
larissanpw 3 years ago
I think it is an interesting take on the song, but the lead singer can't quite pull it off.
sgmarshall 2 years ago 3
This is solid gold donkey shit
therightfullking 3 years ago
just great in every way
MikeCarroll17 3 years ago
i really do like this song.....
it is so haunting.
rabblerabble20 3 years ago
lame. it is sad when it sounds cooler then it is good. But that pretty much sums up sonic youth's whole career.
larissanpw 3 years ago
they're covering a flat 70's mellow gold hit. I think that is as far a stretch for their sound as it gets. It still sounds good.
subsamadhi 3 years ago
a flat 70's mellow gold hit? (sigh) connoisseurs of fine vocalists often rank karen carpenter in the top for her amazing tone quality and incredible control. her voice sounds like butter. and in all her years of touring AND playing drums, never did she sing a flat or sharp note. no, doing a carpenters cover of a burt bachrach song is risky, but they didn't even come close to doing it justice.
larissanpw 3 years ago
Don't get me wrong. I really like the song myself. I was just calling it what it is. Though I highly doubt "connoisseurs of fine vocalists rank karen carpenter in the top for her vocal quality". She was a good singer, but by no means remarkable. By the way, Sonic Youth covers aren't about doing a song justice. You miss the point entirely.
subsamadhi 3 years ago
my mother, who loved the carpenters, admitted to me after me playin this song to her.. she said, yea, she didnt really know how to sing. i do like this cover though.
AirThief 3 years ago
actually, those in the business considered Karen to be an exceptional singer. she was easy to record and never sang flat or sharp. i hate to break it to ya, but your ma didn't know what she was talking about. just saying...
larissanpw 3 years ago
(It's not a Burt Bacharach song, It was written by Leon Russell and Bonnie Sheridan)
BlackOnWhiteMedia 3 years ago
the arrangement is by burt bacharach! hello!
larissanpw 3 years ago
The only thing good about this cover is that it was on the movie "The Frighteners". And it was friggin hilarious... fitted with that balding freak guy perfectly when he was being screamed at by the woman, thus turning the radio on frantically lol.
Daracon75 3 years ago
I like old Sonic Youth ('82- '88), but this kind of ironic/clever/hip/wacky/white rendition music makes me weep tears of boredom...
kaptainkrunch 3 years ago
Karen needed to eat more food.
dandruff71 3 years ago
i didnt even now about this song til i heard it on juno
starwinx10 3 years ago 9
lol me too!!!
emoangel1233 3 years ago
me too =))
malkaff 3 years ago
damn is every great song ever produced on that soundtrack?
herrjemischnee 3 years ago
very talented!! i actually never heard this i adore the rendition it's edge and different... thanks for sharing it with me
missfits09 3 years ago
It's so beautiful. It makes me want to cry.
Z281967KUKEN 3 years ago
love this version. carpenters version has such haunting vocals tho. this video is amazing with the footage of her. brings whole new meaning.
lizbethsr08 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Sonic Youth blew the Carpenters OUT
OF THE WATER on this song.
aquarius121995 3 years ago
this video IF COMPARED to carpenters is shit. Sonic Youth blatantly used effects for their cover and frankly i hated it. period.
Lets bring them back to the 70s where technology wasn't that advanced and see how they'll fare next to The Carpenters. :)
FarNeReR 3 years ago 3
haha...your a little dumb...most effects used by sonc youth were made IN the 70s...or atleast their varients orginated....wow...
SethMitchell 3 years ago
I like alot of what this band does, but he's off key on alot of notes on this song.
silkat2 3 years ago
True. He´s all over the place. Thurston Moore can´t sing for shit.
glitch0000 3 years ago
Can't tell if he is, but he sings with such passion and melancoly that i couldn't care less.
Stounbjerg 3 years ago
Stounbjerg, the truly great singers have the whole package. They perfected the craft. Otherwise you lower the standard.Check out Eva Cassidy's "over the rainbow" she died of cancer a bunch of years back. The live cut on U-tube was done when she new she was dying. That's "passion and melancholy" only with a voice only her and Karen Carpenter possessed. She never got a dime. Today it's alot of cosmetics and attitude and love of money but without true talent. They should be poets not singers.
silkat2 3 years ago
I don't get it. Are you saying SY is a band about money and fame? Because then I would strongly disagree. I'm not saying Karen sings without passion and melancholy, but the sound is just too clean for me. In that way I prefer SY's version and music in general. I haven't listened to "Eva Cassidy", but the most passionate singer i can think of would be Ian Curtis (if you count it as worthy thing to mentioned: he surely knew as well that his life wasn't going in the right direction with his illness
Stounbjerg 3 years ago
No not at all, as I said in my first comment, I like alot of what the band does. But they're not great singers. Some of the songs are very monotone. And you just can't compare a voice like Carpenters to that. But everything has it's own time. And that time period was about real "Singers". The past couple decades it's more about "statement' etc.
silkat2 3 years ago
Good call on Ian Curtis. The only person I ever saw with more passion was Mark Eitzel heading American Music Club back in 1992.
momodavy 3 years ago
i prefer tunic
jorourke72 3 years ago
this isn't even close to the best sonic youth song, let alone better than the original. but if it prompts some stupid kids to check out "Death Valley 69" or "Confusion is Sex", then awesome!
BRuggs666 3 years ago
blah blah blah juno hasnt any one of you heard of sonic youth before the stupid movie, i cant believe it
julietavalon 3 years ago
i heard of sonic youth years before juno.
peopleperson111 3 years ago
You'd have to be at least in your LATE 20's to truely know who they where.
killfroggy26 3 years ago
honestly anyone who said sonic youth did a better version are just plain stupid, i think it was great they were carpenter fans and decided to cover this song but to say that its better than Karen? thats crazy, just a bunch of dumb hipsters who saw juno and think the version is better v_v
dylanmartello 3 years ago 3
didnt saw juno. still think this ones better. sorry.
zzzzaszzzz 3 years ago
this song was actually in the movie the frightners too so when i saw juno and heard it again i was glad that people started to pick up on how awesome it is.
originalhulijing 3 years ago
me too, i didn't saw juno and i think this one is greater than the original. sorry[2]
sauloca 3 years ago
Same as me...i have yet to see juno but i think this version is better!
ssugarpluscreamm 3 years ago
What an ignorant attitude. I've never seen the film Juno. This version is just better IMO because it is more passionate and melancolic than the original song. It is more raw. But of course if you like a more clean sound that's fine.
Stounbjerg 3 years ago
wah wah i think its great sonic youth admired karen but this cover doesnt hold a candle to the original and im pretty sure they know that too, and if by "melancholic" you mean horrible sounding with just plain horrible singing then yes i prefer something cleaner and overall more beautiful
dylanmartello 3 years ago 3
I agree, this cover is fine but has nothing on the original.
Zaeon 3 years ago
I like this one better.
Totally agree with Stounbjerg
scarlettmariana 3 years ago
this is one of the most hauntingly beautiful love songs ever written and SY s cover just makes it even more heart breaking. first heard it from my first love when i was seventeen and now im nearly 31 and breaking up with my partner of 1i years. still kills me every time. real songs should make you feel summat. and this is just right.
thedirtyweasel 3 years ago
For some reason, the singer reminds me of Cillian Murphy.. and this song seems like it'd fit right in with his movie, Red Eye.
I loooove it.
theer1ca 3 years ago
ARH SHIT... HE DOES TOO
iliveinabeehive 3 years ago
Someone left his cake out in the rain!
sonicwarrior 3 years ago
lol
originalhulijing 3 years ago
Thanks Juno for this! kinda reminds me of Donovan
lasfinisimas 3 years ago
@lasfinisimas
Yup, thanks Juno. i'd have never heard this song if it weren't for that movie.
rajkiran700 1 year ago 21